Coups d'état in Argentina

In Argentina there were six coups d'état during the 20th century: in 1930, 1943, 1955, 1962, 1966 and 1976. The first four established interim dictatorships, while the last ones established dictatorship of permanent type on the model of a bureaucratic-authoritarian State. The latter imposed a Dirty War in the line of State terrorism, in which human rights were systematically violated and there were tens of thousands of forced disappearances.

In the 53 years since the first military coup in 1930 until the last dictatorship fell in 1983, the military ruled the country for 25 years, imposing 14 dictators under the title of "president", one every 1.7 years on average. In that period, the democratically elected government experiences (radicals, peronists and radical-developmentalists) were interrumpted by coups.

The Coup of September 6, 1930

Main article: Infamous Decade

General José Félix Uriburu started a series of coups and military dictatorship that would extend until 1983.

The military coup of September 6, 1930 was led by General José Félix Uriburu and overthrew president Hipólito Yrigoyen of the Radical Civic Union, who had been democratically elected to exercise his second term in 1928. Paradoxically, General Uriburu had been one of the organizers of the Revolution of the Park, a civic-military uprising that give rise to the Radical Civic Union.

On September 10, Uriburu was recognized "interim" president of the Nation by the Supreme Court by the agreement that led to the doctrine of de facto governments and that would be used to legitimize all other military coups.^[1]

Following a trend which was repeated in future coups, Uriburu appointed a civilian as head of the Ministry of Economy, José S. Pérez, who had links with the large landowners and the more conservative factions.^[2]

The military leadership established a fascist government and, for drafting the first proclamation, appointed the writer Leopoldo Lugones. Lugones had joined the fascist cause in 1924 by giving a speech called "The Hour of the Sword", where he declared the deterioration of democracy, its instability and its evolution towards demagoguery. One of Uriburu's first initiatives was to establish an illegal repressive state structure, creating a "special section" of the police which could be used to systematically torture his opponents and which was the first such police division to use the picana, originally for cattle, against its victims.^[3]

When Uriburu was unable to shore up the necessary political support to fully establish his fascist political regime, he called elections, but decided to prohibit the participation of the Radical Civic Union. The reinstituation of democracy was false, restricted and controlled by the Armed Forces. This electoral fraud gave rise to a period of conservative, corrupt governments which was dubbed the "Infamous Decade".^[4][5] On February 20 of 1932, General José Félix Uriburu handed over power to General Agustín P. Justo, the true force behind the coup who, although involved in the coup, wanted a democratic and limited government.

The Coup of June 4, 1943

Main article: Revolution of '43

Generals Arturo Rawson, Pedro Pablo Ramírez and Edelmiro Farrell, the three consecutive dictators of the Revolution of '43.

The Revolution of '43 which startedd with a coup d'état by the military on June 4, 1943, was distinct from the other Argentian coups in the following ways:

• Ramón Castillo, the toppled president, was part of the conservative regime which ruled during the "Infamous Decade" and which originated in the coup of 1930 and was supported by fraudulent general elections, repression and corruption.^[4]
• It was the only military coup that unfolded in the midst of a world war.
• It didn't establish relationship with the important landowners and businessmen.
• Its outbreak was influenced by the pressure that the US was putting on Argentina to drop its position of neutrality with respect to World War II, con el fin de afectar los intereses británicos en el país y reemplazar a Gran Bretaña como poder económico dominante en la Argentina.
• It was the only coup in Argentina which was executed purely by the military and with popular support.^[6]

• It was a true revolution in the sense that it toppled the conservative government with its fraudulent elections, established in 1930, and had the intention of being permanent.

• Just like all the other institutional breakdowns in Argentina, it was very damaging to democracy. Although eliminating the "patriotic election rigging" of the previous decade, it continued with the line of harmful leaders in government.

The Revolution of '43 was a confusing political process during which various groups, many of whom had never played a role in Argentina's history, vied for power. The coup itself was not executed to permanently establish control, so it was a transitory dictatorship that followed.

All of the military groups fighting for power during the Revolution of '43 were markedly anti-communist and maintained strong ties to the Catholic Church which reestablished its presence (absent since the 19th century), especially in the area of education. Internal fighting unleashed two more coups, meaning there were three dictators succeeding each other in power and carrying the title of "president": Arturo Rawson, Pedro Pablo Ramírez y Edelmiro Farrell.^[7] During this period, the Argentinian unions, mainly the socialists and the syndicalists as well as a few communists, formed an alliance with a group of young army officials led by the Colonel Juan Perón. This alliance constituted the successful nationalist labor movement which prevailed by winning popular support from the working class and which was given the name "peronism". This period was characterized by extreme polarization of the social classes and led to the formation of a large social block that was strongly antiperonist and made up mostly of the middle class and upper class.^[8]

Economically, the Revolution of '43 saw the continuation of the policy of Import Substitution Industrialization.

The dictatorship ended with a call for democratic elections which were held on February 24, 1946, which all the sections of society accepted as perfect. Juan Domingo Perón won the elections and assumed the presidency on May 1, 1946. Perón would later be overthrown by the military in 1955 before finished his second term.

The Coup of September 16, 1955

Main article: Revolución Libertadora

Generals Eduardo Lonardi and Pedro Eugenio Aramburu, the successive dictators of the Revolución Libertadora.

The so-called Revolución Libertadora was a transitional military dictatorship, brought about by a coup d'état which overthrew the president Juan Domingo Perón and lasted between September 16 and September 23 of 1955. On the last day of this period, the leader of the insurrection was sworn in as president and congress was dissolved. On the following day, he designated Admiral Isaac Rojas as vice president.

During the Revolución Libertadora, the military government created a Civilian Advisory Board composed in large part of the political parties the Radical Civic Union, the Socialist Party, the National Democratic Party, the Christian Democratic Party, and the Democratic Progressive Party.^[9]

The group behind the coup was divided in two parts: a Catholic-nationalist part led by General Eduardo Lonardi, who took charge of the government initially, and a liberal-conservative part led by General Pedro Eugenio Aramburu and Admiral Isaac Rojas. The latter group ended up gaining power and executing another coup, replacing Lonardi with Aramburu as president.^[10]

The dictatorship in power imposed a ban on Peron's Justicialist Party and began the persecution of its sympathizers, policies which it maintained for the following 18 years. The government also took over the unions. In actions that were unprecedented in the modern history of Argentina, it shot its opponents, sometimes in public and sometimes clandestinely.

The government assigned civilians to run the Ministry of Economy, which was run successively by Eugenio Folcini, Eugenio A. Blanco, Roberto Verrier and Adalberto Krieger Vasena, who pursued policies favorable to the most well-off and economically powerful sectors of society.^[11]

One of most significant institutional measures taken by the military dictatorship was to send out a proclamation abolishing, ipso facto, the then national constitution, known as the Constitution of 1949, and replacing it with the text from Argentina's Constitution of 1853. Esta medida sería luego avalada por una Convención Constituyente elegida con proscripciones, que sesionó bajo el régimen militar y le agregó el artículo 14 bis.

In 1958, the government of the Revolución Libertadora held a limited form of elections, overseen by the Armed Forces, in which the Peronist party was banned. The elections were won by the Intransigent Radical Civic Union (UCRI), a group from the fractured Radical Civic Union, led by Arturo Frondizi, who had established a pact with Perón in order to attract the decisive Peronist vote. President Fondizi was, in turn, overthrown by the military four years later.

The Coup of March 29, 1962

Main article: José María Guido

José María Guido, the only civilian dictator in the series of Argentinian coups d'état.

The military coup of March 29, 1962 was unique in that, after overthrowing Arturo Frondizi (of the UCRI), it was not a member of the military who took power, but rather a civilian.^[12]

Frondizi endured repeated protests and military insurrections during his rule, during which even the Minister of the Economy (Álvaro Alsogaray) opposed him. These events ended in the coup of March 29, 1962, led by General Raúl Poggi.

The event that led to the coup was the sweeping vicotry of Peronism in the elections held eleven days before and in which ten of the fourteen then-existent provinces, including the strategic Province of Buenos Aires where the textile union leader Andrés Framini won. Peronism has been banned by the government of the Revolución Libertadora but Frondizi had allowed it in the elections, although he continued to prohibit Juan Perón from returning to the country and from running as a candidate. Frondizi immediately moved to establish his power in the provinces in which Peronist parties had won, but the coup proved to be unstoppable.

After the military uprising of March 29, 1962, President Frondizi, who had been arrested by the military and was been held at Isla Martín García, refused to resign saying "I will not commit suicide, I will not resign and I will not leave the country".^[13] This led to turmoil, threats and negotiations which exhausted the leaders of the insurrection who went to bed that night before formally assuming power. On the morning of March 30, the leader of the insurrection General Raúl Poggi went to the Casa Rosada (where the office of the president is located) to take charge of the government and was surprised to find that there were journalists telling him that a civilian, José María Guido, had been sworn in president that morning in the palace of the Supreme Court.^[14] Guido was a senator from the UCRI who was temporarily presiding over the senate, due to the resignation of Vicepresident Alejandro Gómez. The night of the coup, some lawyers associated with the Supreme Court, one of whom was Horacio Oyhanarte, decided that the downfall of Frondizi had led to the case of a leaderless government and proposed to Guido that, since he was next in line of succession, he assume the presidency, which he did on the morning of March 30.

The military leaders of the coup, who were surprised, skeptical and angry, ended up reluctantly accepting the situation and called Guido to the Casa Rosada to inform him that he would be recognized as the president, provided that he promised committed in writing to execute certain policies stipulated by the Armed Forces, the first of which was to annul the elections won by the Peronist factions. Guido accepted the military impositions, signed an act affirming this support and only then was he allowed to be given the title "president", but with the obligation of bringing the National Congress to a close and taking control of the provinces.

Guido upheld the military orders he had been given, annulling the elections, shutting down the National Congress, reinstating the ban on Peronism, taking control of the provinces and designating a right-wing economic team which included such figures as Federico Pinedo and José Alfredo Martínez de Hoz.

In 1963, there were more elections called in which Peronist factions were banned and which were won by Arturo Illia of the Radical Civic Union of the People (UCRP). After Illia, most votes were cast for None of the Above which Peronists took advantage of as a form of protest. President Illia assumed power on October 12, 1963 and would later be overthrown by a military coup on June 28, 1966.

The Coup of June 28, 1966

Main articles: Revolución Argentina and Juan Carlos Onganía

Generals Juan Carlos Onganía, Marcelo Levingston and Alejandro Lanusse, the three successive dictators of the self-styled "Argentine Revolution".

On June 28, 1966, a military uprising led by General Juan Carlos Onganía overthrew President Arturo Illia (of the UCRP). The coup gave rise to a dictatorship which called itself the "Argentine Revolution", which didn't claim to be a provisional government, as was the case with the previous coups, but rather established itself as a permanent government. At the time, there were many similar permanent military dictatorships coming to power in various Latin American countries (e.g. Brazil, Chile, Uruguay, Bolivia, Paraguay, etc.) and they was analyzed in detail by the political scientist Guillermo O'Donnell who gave them the name "bureaucratic-authoritarian state" (EBA).^[15]

The "Argentine Revolution" issued a statute in 1966 which held a superior judicial position to the constitution and, in 1972, introduced constitutional reforms. This was another action that distinguished this dictatorship from the previous ones. In general, the dictatorship adopted a fascist-Catholic-anticommunist ideology and was supported openly by the United States as well as by European countries.^[16]

The deep political and social conflict generated during the "Argentine Revolution" and the infighting between the many military divisions led to two internal coups, with three dictators succeeding each other in power: Juan Carlos Onganía (1966–1970), Marcelo Levingston (1970–1971) y Alejandro Agustín Lanusse (1971–1973).

On the economic front, the dictatorship handed over the Ministry of Economy to the most conservative-liberal sectors of the civilian popultaion, which was epitomized by Adalberto Krieger Vasena, who had already served as minister under the "Revolución Libertadora". However, during the dictatorship of Levingston, a nationalist-developmentalist group of the Armed Forces became dominant and named Aldo Ferrer of the Intransigent Radical Civic Union as Minister of the Economy.García Lupo, Rogelio (1971). Mercenarios y monopolios. Buenos Aires: Achaval Solo. </ref>^[17]

Threatened by a growing popular insurrection, the government organized an election to exit power in which Peronist parties were allowed (although Perón's candidacy was banned). The election took place in 1973 and the Peronist candidate Héctor J. Cámpora won with 49.53% of the votes. He assumed power on May 25, 1973.

Cámpora then resigned in order to allow free elections to take place. Juan Perón won with 62% of the votes, but died less than a year after being elected. The Peronist government, which was subsequently led by the vice president María Estela Martínez de Perón, was overthrown by a military coup in 1976.

Coup of March 24, 1976

Main articles: National Reorganization Process and Dirty War

Trial of the Juntas (1985), in which many of the dictators of the "National Reorganization Process" were sentenced.

On March 24, 1976, a new military uprising overthrew the president María Estela Martínez de Perón and established a permanent dictatorship (a bureaucratic-authoritarian state), calling itself the "National Reorganization Process". The country was governed by a military junta mad up of three members of the military, uno por cada fuerza. This junta appointed a functionary with the title "President" and with executive and legislative power.

Similar to the previous dictatorship, the military junta passed a statute and two acts which were higher on the judicial hierarchy than the constitution.^[18]

The National Reorganization Process consisted of four successive military juntas:

• 1976-1980: Jorge Rafael Videla, Emilio Eduardo Massera and Orlando Ramón Agosti
• 1980-1981: Roberto Eduardo Viola, Armando Lambruschini and Omar Domingo Rubens Graffigna
• 1981-1982: Leopoldo Fortunato Galtieri, Jorge Isaac Anaya and Basilio Lami Dozo
• 1982-1983: Cristino Nicolaides, Rubén Franco and Augusto Jorge Hughes

During these periods, the juntas appointed the military members Jorge Rafael Videla, Roberto Eduardo Viola, Leopoldo Fortunato Galtieri and Reynaldo Benito Bignone, respectively, as de facto presidents. Among these, Bignone was the only one not belonging to the junta.

The National Reorganization Process began the Dirty War, a type of state terrorism which massively violated human rights and led to the disappearance of tens of thousands of opponents.

Internationally, the Argentinian dictatorship, along with the human rights violations, had the active support of the government of the United States (except during the Jimmy Carter administration) and was tolerated by the European countries, the Soviet Union and the Catholic Church, without whose inaction it would have been difficult for the dictatorship to sustain itself. Also, during that time, military dictatorships were established in all the countries in the Southern Cone of South America (Argentina, Brazil, Bolivia, Chile, Paraguay, Perú and Uruguay) with the support from the US. These countries, along with the US, jointly coordinated the repression, by means of an international terrorist organization called Operation Condor^{[citation needed]}.

In economic matters, the dictatorship formally handed over the Ministry of the Economy to the most conservative business associations which promoted economic policies which were openly de-industrialist and neoliberal, and with a maximum expansion of the foreign debt.

Videla, the military leader who lasted the longest in power, together with President Isabel Perón and Massera, in 1975. One year later, President Perón would be deposed by the coup of 1976, started by Videla.

In 1982, the military government entered into the Falklands War against the United Kingdom in an event of which the causes continue to be unclear. The defeat inflicted in this war sparked the fall of the third military junta and, a few months later, the fourth junta called elections for October 30, 1983. Raúl Alfonsín of the Radical Civic Union won the elections and assumed power on December 10, 1983.

The military leaders were tried and convicted, many of them being imprisoned after long and complex processes.

The "National Reorganization Process" was the last dictatorship. Even though there were various military insurrections between 1987 and 1990, called the "Carapintadas", none of them succeeded in toppling the democratic government.

General Notes

The coups d'état in Argentina generated a series of specific political-judicial problems:

• The "de facto government doctrine" of the Supreme Court;^[19]
• The validity and fate of the so-called "decree laws" and other regulations passed by the military governments, once the dictatorships had ended;^[19]
• The punishment of those involved in the coups.

It is also possible to see a escalation in the repressive violence and a decline in respect for legal norms in each of the coups. In particular, whereas the first four coups d'état (1930, 1943, 1955, 1962) were defined as "provisional governments" and acted with the intention of calling democratic elections within a short time period, the two last coups (1966 and 1976) brought to power military dictatorships which were permanent and adhered to the idea of the bureaucratic-authoritarian state, described by Guillermo O'Donnell.

An important element of the coups d'état in Argentina is regarding the economic policies and the attitude of the big world powers towards these policies. Firstly, the economic teams formed by the military government tended to be made of the same figures, mainly coming from the conservative-liberal sections of society, leading some to say that the Armed Forces behaved as a political party of the upper classes.^[20][21] Secondly, in almost all the coups, the hegemonic world powers participated directly, either in the coup itself or in the protection of those involved in the coup afterwards.^[22]

The coups that took place in Argentina, especially those starting from the 1960s, were part of a widespread trend in the Latin America in which there were many military coups, most of which were supported or promoted by the United States through the operations of the School of the Americas, located in Panama and through the US doctrine of National Security.^[20]

During the 1994 amendment of the Argentine Constitution, the doctrine of de facto governments and methods of preventing them from establishing themselves in future coups d'état were discussed at length. The result was the adoption of the first paragraph of article 36 of the National Constitution, also known as the "defense of democracy and defense of constitutional order":

 

See also

• Military dictatorship
• Military junta
• History of Argentina
• 1976 Argentine coup d'état

References

1. ^ Historia Integral Argentina, vol. 7, pp. 88-89
2. ^ Mallorquín, Carlos. "Textos para el estudio del pensamiento de Raúl Prebisch". In Cinta de Moebio, Universidad de Chile, 2006. http://redalyc.uaemex.mx/redalyc/pdf/101/10102503.pdf. Retrieved 18 December 2007. 
3. ^ Jorge Aulicino. "Factors in determining the suicide of Leopoldo Lugones (Spanish)". In diario Clarín, 18 February 1998. http://www.clarin.com/diario/1998/02/18/e-04201d.htm. Retrieved 18 December 2007. 
4. ^ ^{a b} Torres, José Luis (1973). Buenos Aires: Freeland. ed. La Década Infame [1945]. 
5. ^ Sanguinetti, Horacio (1977). Buenos Aires: La Bastilla. ed. La democracia ficta. 1930-1938. ISBN. 
6. ^ "If Argentina can be effectively dominated, the State Department's control over the Western Hemisphere will be total. This will simultaneously help to mitigate the possible risk of Russian and European influence in Latin America and also separate Argentina from what is supposed to be our sphere of influence." (translated) David Kelly, quoted in Escudé, Carlos; Cisneros, Andrés (2000). "La campaña del embajador Braden y la consolidación del poder de Perón". In Historia de las Relaciones Exteriores Argentinas, CARI. http://www.argentina-rree.com/13/13-004a.htm. Retrieved 18 December 2007. 
7. ^ TRONCOSO, Oscar A. (1976). "La revolución del 4 de junio de 1943". El peronismo en el poder. Buenos Aires: CEAL. 
8. ^ Luna, Félix (1971). El 45. Buenos Aires: Sudamericana. ISBN 84-499-7474-7. 
9. ^ Norberto Galaso. "La Revolución Libertadora". http://www.galeon.com/elortiba/pdf/revoluc-libertadora.pdf. Retrieved 18 de diciembre de 2007. 
10. ^ Lonardi, Marta (1980). Mi padre y la revolución del 55. Buenos Aires : Ediciones Cuenca de Plata. 
11. ^ Alain Rouquié (1983). Poder Militar y Sociedad Política en la Argentina, II (1943-1973). Buenos Aires : Emecé. pp. 131–132. "El Plan Prebisch demuestra que los obreros aumentaron su ingreso real en un 37% a expensas de los productores agropecuarios y de las clases medias. La 'ciencia' económica legitimaba así la vindicta social de los propietarios y de los privilegiados" 
12. ^ Carlos Floria and César García Belsunce: Historia Política de la Argentina Contemporánea (1880-1983). Alianza Universidad, Buenos Aires 1989 p. 184
13. ^ This sentence was said by Arturo Frondizi on March 27, 1962, two days before the coup. It has become one the famous quotes of Argentinian history. El argentino dice, ONI
14. ^ "While General Poggi believed he had the reigns the country within his grasp, the provisional president of the Senate, José María Guido, was been sworn in as the President of the Republic before the Supreme Court ... The maneuver took the military powers, the union powers and the whole society be surprise".
15. ^ O'Donnell, 1982
16. ^ Revista Atlántida. "Historia secreta de la revolución". Revista Atlántida, 1966 [en Mágicas Ruinas]. http://www.magicasruinas.com.ar/revistero/esto/revdesto319.htm. Retrieved December 18, 2007. 
17. ^ "Un interregno: Levingston-Ferrer", en Portantiero, Juan Carlos (1977), "Economía y política en la crisis argentina: 1958-1973", Revista Mexicana de Sociología 39 (2 (Apr. - Jun., 1977)): 531–565 
18. ^ Escuelas ONI, El golpe: la legalización del terrorismo de Estado. Estatuto y Actas (The Coup: Legalization of State Terrorism. Statutes and Acts.
19. ^ ^{a b} Pelizzari, Julio Alberto (2003). "La Constitución Nacional ante el quebranto del Estado de derecho. Nulidad insanable de los actos de fuerza contra el orden institucional y el sistema democrático (art. 36, primer párrafo, de la Constitución Nacional)". In Provincia de Tierra del Fuego. Ushuaia, Argentina: Jornadas en Homenaje al 150º Aniversario de la Constitución Nacional desde la más joven de las Provincias Argentinas, 25 y 26 de Septiembre de 2003. http://www.justierradelfuego.gov.ar/Jornadas/Pelizzari.htm. Retrieved 2007. 
20. ^ ^{a b} Azpiazu, D; Khavisse, M; Basualdo, E. (1988). El nuevo poder económico (The New Economic Power). Buenos Aires: Hyspamérica. 
21. ^ Scenna, Miguel Ángel (1980). Los militares. Buenos Aires: Editorial de Belgrano. 
22. ^ Lula da Silva, Luiz Inácio (2007). "Lula: EEUU ha tenido gran participación en golpes de Estado en América Latina". In TeleSUR. Caracas, Venezuela: TeleSUR. http://www.telesurtv.net/secciones/noticias/nota/index.php?ckl=12883. Retrieved 2007. "Los golpes militares que acontecieron en toda América Latina: Chile, Argentina, Uruguay y Brasil, apenas para dar algunos ejemplos, contaron con una gran participación de la política externa de EEUU (The military coups which happened in all Latin America: Chile, Argentina, Uruguay and Brazil, to name a few, relied on the significant participation of the United States' foreign policies)" 

Bibliography

• Odena, Isidro J. (1977). Libertadores y desarrollistas. Buenos Aires: La Bastilla.
• O' Donnel, Guillermo (1982). El Estado burocrático autoritario. Buenos Aires: de Belgrano.
• Potash, Robert A. (1981). El ejército y la política en la Argentina: 1928-1945. Buenos Aires: Sudamericana.
• Potash, Robert A. (1994). El Ejército y la política en la Argentina: 1962-1973. De la caída de Frondizi a la restauración peronista, Primera Parte: 1962-1966, Buenos Aires: Sudamericana. ISBN 950-07-0939-2.
• Potash, Robert A. (1994). El ejército y la política en Argentina: 1962-1973. Segunda Parte, Buenos Aires: Sudamericana. ISBN 950-07-0973-2.
• Rouquié, Alain (1983). Poder Militar y Sociedad Política en la Argentina, II (1943-1973), Buenos Aires: Emecé.
• Scenna, Miguel Angel (1980). Los militares. Buenos Aires: Belgrano.
• Several authors (1976). Historia Integral Argentina. Buenos Aires: Centro Editor de América Latina.