Operation Scherhorn

Pavel Sudoplatov, the Intelligence Services official who executed the operation.

Operation Scherhorn (in English sources) or Operation Berezino (original Russian codename), Operation Beresino (in East German sources) was a secret deception operation performed by the NKVD against the Nazi secret services in August 1944 – May 1945. It was proposed by Joseph Stalin, drafted by Mikhail Maklyarsky and executed by Pavel Sudoplatov and his NKVD subordinates assisted by ethnic German antifascists and communists.^{[note 1]}

The main objective of Operation Berezino was to create an illusion of a large German armed group operating behind the front line, and to deplete Nazi intelligence resources through capture and extermination of their field operatives sent to assist these nonexistent troops. The NKVD set up a fake German "resistance pocket" under "command" of lieutenant-colonel Heinrich Scherhorn, a real German prisoner of war forced to cooperate with the Soviets. The German response, Otto Skorzeny's Operation Freischütz (Operation Poacher in post-war English sources^{[note 2]}) developed according to Soviet expectations. The German commandos sent by Skorzeny were routinely arrested and forced to take part in the Soviet funkspiel. German support gradually faded, but the German command maintained radio contact with "Group Scherhorn" until May 1945.

Background

According to Pavel Sudoplatov, Operation Berezino was conceived by the NKVD officers Victor Ilyin and Mikhail Maklyarsky as an extension of Operation Monastyr (1941-1944). In 1941 NKVD operative Alexander Demyanov (Soviet codename Heyne, German codename Max), wearing a persona of a disgruntled bohemian socialite, established contact with the German resident in Moscow. The NKVD used this opportunity to expose the undercover network of the Abwehr in the Soviet Union. In December 1941 Demyanov "defected" to the German side and showed up at the Abwehr field office in Smolensk. Three months later he returned to Moscow as a trusted German agent. His apartment became a death trap for scores of genuine German agents but he retained the trust of his German superiors. In the middle of 1942 Demyanov's control officer Willie Fischer expanded the operation into a strategic level disinformation campaign. For more than two years Demyanov supplied Reinhard Gehlen with carefully scripted "military plans". According to Sudoplatov, the German success in repealing the Soviet Rzhev offensive were, in part, influenced by correct information fed to Gehlen through Demyanov.^[1]

According to Sudoplatov, Joseph Stalin personally monitored the progress of Operation Monastyr. The NKVD men engaged in it were highly rewarded but Stalin himself was dissatisfied with the limited scope of the operation. Shortly before the beginning of Operation Bagration he summonned Victor Abakumov, Vsevolod Merkulov, Fyodor Kuznetsov and Sudoplatov^{[note 3]} and issued a direct written order to launch a new disinformation campaign. Stalin's instructions, recorded by Sergei Shtemenko, shifted the objective towards methodical physical destruction of German special forces and their intelligence capacity. Sudoplatov had to set up a believable "German camp" behind the advancing Soviet troops and call the German command for help. Stalin reasoned that the Germans would expend their best commandos in futile rescue missions. As a side benefit, the fake "camp" would divert German airlift resources from supporting the real pockets of resistance.^[1]

Planning

The new operation, codenamed Berezino, was drafted by colonel Mikhail Maklyarsky and approved by Stalin, Lavrenty Beria and Vyacheslav Molotov. NKVD officers Nahum Eitingon, Willie Fischer, Mikhail Maklyarsky, Alexander Demyanov, Yakov Serebryansky departed to Belarus with a group of ethnic German antifascists. More pro-Soviet Germans, earlier engaged in mopping up Polish and Lithuanian forest brothers, joined them at the base camp some 100 kilometers east of Minsk.^[2] The NKVD men screened groups of German prisoners of war captured during Operation Bagration and picked lieutenant-colonel Heinrich Scherhorn as the "front" for their operation. Scherhorn, former commander of the guards' regiment of the 286th Security Division was taken prisoner in June 1944. According to NKVD veteran Igor Schors, the choice was sealed by the connection between the Scherhorn family and Hitler: in the early 1930s Scherhorn's father made substantial donations to the Nazi Party.^[3] Scherhorn and his radio operator agreed to play the Soviet game.^{[note 4]} German communist Gustav Rebele assumed the role of Scherhorn's aide, watching his "commander" day and night.^[2]

The active phase of Berezino began on August 18, 1944^{[note 5]} with a wireless message from Max to German command. Max reported that Scherhorn's detachment of 2,500 men was encircled by the Soviets in the swamps near the Berezina River. According to German sources, colonel Hans-Heinrich Worgitzky^{[note 6]} of OKH Counterintelligence suspected a Soviet funkspiel and refused to commit his men to rescue "Scherhorn". Gehlen intervened and demanded full support to "Scherhorn" which he thought would ideally fit Otto Skorzeny's plan of guerilla action behind the front line.^[4] OKW Chief of Staff Alfred Jodl instructed Skorzeny to begin the rescue operation.^[5]

First casualties

According to German communist Karl Kleinjung, in the beginning of September Eitingon announced the first success: the German command confirmed departure of a group of four or five commandos. The Soviets mustered a "welcome party" dressed in battered Nazi field uniforms. Some, like Kleinjung, were ethnic Germans, others were NKVD men who did not speak the language. Between 01:00 and 02:00 September 16^[6] a Heinkel He 111 made two runs over the designated drop zone, releasing supply containers and paratroopers. According to the official site of the SVR there were three radio operators;^[6] according to Kleinjung there were two SS commandos, one of them a radio operator, and two agents of Baltic descent.^{[note 7]} The latter two were quietly subdued by NKVD, while the two SS men were cordially welcomed and escorted to Scherhorn's tent. After the meeting the guests were arrested by the NKVD and forced to cooperate in the funkspiel. They reported their safe landing over their own wireless set, persuading the German command that the operation proceeded as planned. They were followed by three more commando teams; according to Kleinjung, the NKVD intercepted all three without arousing suspicion.^[2]

Otto Skorzeny, too, wrote about four airborne SS teams. All were dressed in Soviet field uniforms, armed with Soviet handguns and stripped of any personal items that could give away their identities. The first one (Einsatz P) disappeared before the commandos or the aircraft crew could confirm landing. The second one (Einsatz S) made radio contact with Skorzeny after four days of silence. They reported that they safely reached their objective; Scherhorn himself spoke to German command over the wireless. The third team (Einsatz M) disappeared without trace. The fourth one (Einsatz P) reported that they landed far off the drop zone and had to reach it on foot, wandering through the forests infested with NKVD and Soviet deserters. The contact was soon lost. Three weeks later Einsatz P safely crossed the front line in Lithuania, reporting horrors of Soviet atrocities on their way.^[7]

Spy games

"Scherhorn" reported that a rapid breakthrough was made impossible by a large number of wounded. The German command suggested airlifting the wounded to the German rear, which, according to Kleinjung, would have exposed the Soviet ploy. Skorzeny sent an engineer to manage construction of the runway.^{[note 8]} The Soviets responded with staging a believable night fight between "Group Scherhorn" and "Soviet troops" at the very same moment when two transport planes arrived over the properly illuminated airfield. One of the pilots attempted landing despite the commotion on the ground, but immediately before the touchdown the NKVD men extinguished the runway lights, forcing both planes to abandon their mission.^[2] Skorzeny received reports that the runway was permanently disabled by a Soviet air raid.

According to Russian sources, execution of this air raid was indeed planned by colonel Ivan Fyodorov of the 4th Air Army. Before this night attack could materialize, the NKVD changed their minds and decided to use Fyodorov as a pawn in their game with Skorzeny. Fyodorov had to defect to "Scherhorn", fly to Germany with one of Skorzeny's planes, and operate there as a double agent. Fyodorov, one of the few Soviet recipients of the Nazi Iron Cross, was well known to the Luftwaffe and the Abwehr,^{[note 9]} and could have indeed been a perfect double agent had it not been for his explosive, outspoken personality.^[8]

Instead of openly approaching Fyodorov, the NKVD set up a mock ambush. NKVD men impersonating Belarussian nationalists and Russian monarchists^{[note 10]} kidnapped Fyodorov, took him to their camp in the forest and pressed him to change sides. The recruiters soon realized that Fyodorov was not fit for the job. Major Kopirovsky, author of the failed proposal, suggested liquidating Fyodorov, but Demyanov overruled him. Fyodorov was allowed to "flee" from the camp and return to the Air Force.^[8]

Agony

Skorzeny and chief of the FHO^{[note 11]} Reinhard Gehlen remained confident in the existence and combat-worthiness of the 2,000-strong group. According to Kleinjung, they instructed Scherhorn to split it: one half had to march 250 kilometers north, to the Latvian-Lithuanian border, another to the south. According to Skorzeny, both detachments were to march north, with the smaller SS vanguard clearing the way for Scherhorn's main force. Scherhorn suggested that their march might bring them in contact with Polish population, and Skorzeny sent him his ethnic Polish agents. They also fell into Sudoplatov's hands and exposed the German network in Poland.^[9]

The Germans continuously supplied "Scherhorn" with necessary food and materiel, drawing down the scarce resources of Kampfgeschwader 200. According to the official site of the SVR, the Germans sent a total of 39 flights and dropped a total of 22 commandos with 13 wireless sets.^[6] This, according to Kleinjung, created a logistical problem for the NKVD: their once compact team snowballed into a large formation. All German radio operators remained with the group to maintain radio contact with their German controllers, and the number of their NKVD guards and attending personnel grew accordingly.^[2]

By January 1945 air supplies dwindled: the front line moved too far west, the Luftwaffe could not afford wasting precious fuel on a remote Army camp. Group Scherhorn increased their radio activity, flooding the German command with pleas for help. To motivate the German command, "Scherhorn" proposed a brisk march towards the Daugavpils area where the ice was thick enough for transport airplanes. Gehlen developed a fixation on the success of the "Scherhorn Raid". On February 20, 1945 he took over the operation from Skorzeny and declared it a matter of prestige that had to be supported at all costs.^[10] In March, however, Skorzeny spoke against Gehlen's single-handed management and Gehlen reluctantly backed off.^[4] Heinrich Scherhorn remained a national hero and on March 23, 1945 was awarded the colonel's rank and the Knight's Cross.^[2][11]

According to the official site of the SVR, the German command communicated with "Scherhorn" until May 5, 1945;^[6] according to Kleinjung and Skorzeny, "Scherhorn" remained in contact with the command until May 8.^[12]

Aftermath

Admiral Raeder

After the end of the war Sudoplatov used Heinrich Scherhorn to recruit captive Admiral Erich Raeder and his wife. The attempt failed: according to Sudoplatov, Scherhorn and Raeder were "incompatible with each other". Scherhorn and his group were held prisoners in a camp near Moscow and were repatriated in the early 1950s. Sudoplatov was arrested in the wake of the execution of Lavrenty Beria, and served 15 years in prison. He was cleared of criminal charges in 1992.^[1]

Alexander Demyanov (Max) retired from the NKVD after one unsuccessful post-war mission in France. According to Sudoplatov, Gehlen offered Max for sale to the Americans, but by this time the real Alexander Demyanov was out of his reach. He worked as an engineer at the Mosfilm studios and died in Moscow in 1975. Mikhail Maklyarsky also worked for the movie industry as a screenwriter. Neither they, nor any of the NKVD officers engaged in Operation Berezino were ever rewarded for it.^[1]

Reinhard Gehlen founded the Bundesnachrichtendienst, the West German secret service, and headed it until 1968. Karl Kleinjung, one of the ethnic Germans attendants at Camp Scherhorn, quickly rose through the East German bureaucracy and became the head of the First Directorate (HA I) of the Stasi. In 1997 he was indicted in the murders of civilians on the Inner German border and was acquitted in court.

Sources

Footnotes

1. ^ The official site of the SVR names Pavel Sudoplatov the head of the operation; Nahum Eitingon, Mikhail Maklyarsky and Georgy Mordvinov his deputies in charge of Operation Scherhorn; and Willie Fischer as the chief of wireless communications.
2. ^ Operation Poacher was used, for example, in the original 1950 edition of Skorzeny's memoirs, - Skorzeny, pp. 173 and 182.
3. ^ According to Sudoplatov, at this time he was completely unaware of the planned Operation Bagration.
4. ^ Kleinjung: "Scherhorn war sichtlich erfreut, Deutsche zu sehen und sich mit ihnen unterhalten zu können ... Er und einige andere, darunter auch der Funker, gerieten in Gefangenschaft. In zahlreichen Gesprächen wurden sie zur Zusammenarbeit bewegt und erklärten sich zu einem einzigartigen Funkspiel mit dem deutschen Generalstab bereit."
5. ^ Date stated on the official SVR site. Kleinjung provides a different date, August 19.
6. ^ First Deputy to the President of the Bundesnachrichtendienst (Reinhard Gehlen) in 1957-1967.
7. ^ Kleinjung: "Agenten des deutschen Geheimdienstes, die aus Litauen, Lettland und Estland kamen." - "Agents of the German secret service from Lituania, Latvia and Estonia" (sic).
8. ^ Soviet and East German sources do not mention the arrival of this engineer or his team. Shmorgun, pp. 208-212, names a number of German officers flown to "Scherhorn" to supervise evacuation by air.
9. ^ Fyodorov and Stepan Suprun received their Iron Crosses from Hermann Göring for their performance at an air show held in Berlin in June 1941, two weeks before the outbreak of Operation Barbarossa.
10. ^ The "monarchists" were "loaned" from Operation Prestol, another NKVD operation unfolding in the same area - Shmorgun, pp. 221-223.
11. ^ Abteilung Fremde Heere Ost (Eastern Intelligence Section) of Oberkommando des Heeres.

References

1. ^ ^{a b c d} Sudoplatov.
2. ^ ^{a b c d e f} Kleinjung.
3. ^ Ovchinnikova, Lyudmila (2002). Podpolnaya yavka v centre Moskvy (in Russian). Trud, January 18, 2002 (reproduced on the official site of the Federal Security Service).
4. ^ ^{a b} Von Zolling, Hoehne pt. 2.
5. ^ Skorzeny, p. 173.
6. ^ ^{a b c d} SVR. Операция "Березино" (Operacia Beresino, in Russian). Official site of the Foreign Intelligence Service.
7. ^ Skorzeny, pp. 175-176.
8. ^ ^{a b} Shmorgun, pp. 208-225.
9. ^ Sudoplatov; Biddiscombe, p. 103.
10. ^ Von Zolling and Hoenhe cite Gehlen's speech: "Mit Übernahme der Verantwortung durch Generalstab des Heeres ist es erforderlich, die Aktion auch als Prestigefrage zu betrachten und sie mit allen Mitteln zu beenden."
11. ^ Sevin, Dieter (1989). Operation Scherhorn. Military Review. 
12. ^ Kleinjung; Skorzeny, p. 182.

• Шерхорн,_Генрих

Bibliography

• Biddiscombe, Perry (2006). The SS hunter battalions: the hidden history of the Nazi resistance movement 1944-45. Tempus. ISBN 0752439383.
• Karl Kleinjung (2003).Nichts gewesen außer Spesen. Operation Beresina (in German). Verband Deutscher in der Résistance, in den Streitkräften der Antihitlerkoalition und der Bewegung "Freies Deutschland" e.V.
• Shmorgun, Vladimir (2005). Krasny Sokol (in Russian). Moscow: Golos Press. ISBN 5711700812.
• Skorzeny, Otto (1950). Secret missions: war memoirs of the most dangerous man in Europe. Dutton. pp. 173-182.
• Stephan, Robert W. (2004). Stalin's secret war: Soviet counterintelligence against the Nazis, 1941-1945. University Press of Kansas. ISBN 0700612793. pp. 175-181.
• Sudoplatov, Pavel (1995). Special tasks: the memoirs of an unwanted witness, a Soviet spymaster. Little, Brown. ISBN 0316821152.
• Von Zolling, Hermann and Hoenhe, Hans (1971). Pullach intern. Die Geschichte des Bundesnachrichtendienstes (in German, pt. 2). Der Spiegel, March 22, 1971.

External links

• Parallel analysis of Kleinjung's and Skorzeny's accounts (in German).
• Kessler, Michael B.. "Deception: A Neglected Force Multiplier". GlobalSecurity.org. http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/library/report/1989/KMB.htm. Retrieved August 16, 2010.