Merriespruit tailings dam disaster

The Merriespruit tailings dam disaster occurred on the night of 22 February 1994 when a tailings dam failed and flooded the suburb of Merriespruit, Virginia, Free State, South Africa. Seventeen people were killed.^[1]

Late afternoon on the day of the failure a thunderstorm occurred and about 50 mm of rain fell in 30 minutes. When the dam failed, 600 000 m³ of liquid flowed 4 km. The nearest housed were located 300 m downslope of the dam, when the wave of water and slime reached them it was 2.5 m high.

Seventeen people were killed and there was widespread devastation and environmental damage. Eighty houses were destroyed.^[2]

Background

Once gold is extracted in minute quantities from the mineral pyrite the remaining solid material is waste and is stored in rock dumps or as in the case at the Merriespruit No. 4 facility, tailings dams.^[2]

Method of construction

As is typical with gold tailings in South Africa, the Merriespruit tailing dam was constructed using the "upstream semi-dry paddock" method, where a "daywall" perimeter is constructed and allowed the settle and dry out (typically carried out during the day and supervised) before slurry is placed in the "nightpan" (typically carried out at night without supervision). A penstock is ideally located centrally in the dam and drains water (including stormwater).^[1]

History of the dam

Number 4A in the Harmony Gold Mine tailings complex failed. The dam was designed in the early seventies by the mine's metallurgical manager and a representative from the tailings dam contractor.^[1] The town of Merriespruit, a 250-house suburb of the goldfields town of Virginia, was already established when the No. 4 dam started in 1978. The northern wall of the dam was only 320 m from the nearest houses in Merriespruit.^[2]

In the early years the slurry had a low relative density that led to difficult construction conditions with seep and sloughing on the northern wall. A drained tailings buttress was constructed against the face of the northern wall. A single ringmain around the dam was not used, contrary to current practice. A return water dam that could accept water from the dam itself was not provided.^[1]

In March 1993 an inspection noticed seepage north wall and it was agreed to stop deposition into compartment 4A.^[2] According to the contractor the freeboard at this time was an acceptable 1.0+ m.^[1] The division of compartments 4A and 4B was breached some time before the disaster, resulting in drainage from 4B to 4A.^[2] The extra drainage led to a freeboard of 300 mm.^[2] Despite the termination of daywall construction, excess plant water containing tailings continued to be deposited, with the water decanted by the penstock and the remaining tailings using up the remaining freeboard.^[1]

Piezometers were installed and the water table established, the contractor calculated the stability factor of safety to be 1.34^[1]

The No 4 dam was in an unacceptable condition prior to failure. Contrary to legislative requirements, at the time of failure the dam did not have capacity to maintain a 0.5 m freeboard during a 1 in 100 year 24-hour storm.^[1] Satellite imagery showed that water was ponded against the northern wall in February 1994.^[3]

Eyewitness accounts

An eyewitness reported a strong stream of water entering the town downstream of the dam at 7 o'clock on the evening of the disaster, and that was not the first time this had occurred. One person reported seeing water flowing over the top of the dam wall. When the mining company and contractor arrived at the site that evening one of the contractor's employees found water lapping the top penstock ring, he then removed rings from the two penstock outlets. Another employee saw blocks of tailings toppling from the tailings buttress. Before they could warn the inhabitants of the town they heard a loud bang and a wave of tailings and water flooded the town.^[1]

Inquiry

Separate investigations were carried out by the owner, operator, and the State.

A joint inquest/inquiry was run, with a judge appointed by the Minister of Justice. The State conducted investigations including looking at eyewitness accounts, weather and hydrological data, laboratory and in situ tailings testing, satellite imagery, and overtopping studies using a scale model. The mine and the contractor managing the tailings were found responsible for the disaster. The inquiry led to the introduction of a new Code of Practice for Mine Residue Deposits.^[3]

The judge described the dam as a time bomb waiting to explode.^[2]

The owner, operator and six of their employees were found guilt of negligence and heavy fines were imposed. It was discovered that economic pressure had led to a reduction in personnel related to the tailings dam, the metallurgical manager's direct management of the dam was reduced due to time constraints, and personnel had been promoted to positions that they did not have adequate experience for.^[2]

The South African government appointed the Council for Scientific and Industrial Research to investigate, they confirmed the conclusions reached and as a result the 1995 Draft Code of Practice for the "Design, Operation, and Closure of Tailings Dams" was introduced.^[2]

Consequences

Public awareness of the threat of tailings dams led to community pressure preventing an application for expansion for a tailing dam within 1 km of houses in Fleurhof in 1997. The operator, who is also responsible for the majority of tailings dams in South Africa appointed qualified staff and implemented a hazard-management strategy for every tailings dam.^[2]

Notes

1. ^ ^{a b c d e f g h i} Wagener, 1997
2. ^ ^{a b c d e f g h i j} Niekerk, 2005
3. ^ ^{a b} Strydom, 1999

References

• Wagener, F (1997). "The Merriespruit slimes dam failure: Overview and lessons learnt". SAICE Journal 39 (3): 11–15. 
• Strydom, J; Williams, A (1999). "A review of important and interesting technical finding regards the tailing dam fialure at Merriespruit". SAICE Journal 41 (4): 1–9. 
• Niekerk, H; Viljoen, M (2005). "Causes and consequences of the Merriespruit and other tailings-dam failures". Land Degradation & Development 16: 201–212. doi:10.1002/ldr.681. 

External links

• Overview and colour images from tailings.info