Multipurpose Applied Physics Lattice Experiment

For other senses of "maple", see Maple (disambiguation).

The Multipurpose Applied Physics Lattice Experiment (MAPLE) dedicated isotope-production facility was a project jointly undertaken by AECL and MDS Nordion. It was intended to include two identical reactors, as well as the isotope-processing facilities necessary to produce a large portion of the world's medical isotopes, especially Molybdenum-99, medical Cobalt-60, Xenon-133, Iodine-131 and Iodine-125. An operational license for the MAPLE 1 reactor was granted in 1999, and the reactor went critical for the first time soon after. However, problems with the reactor, most notably a positive power co-efficient of reactivity, led to the cancellation of the project in 2008.

History

Background

With the completion of the NRX reactor in 1947, AECL's Chalk River Laboratories possessed the world's most powerful research reactor. While the large neutron fluxes available in the reactor led to advances in such fields as condensed matter physics and neutron spectroscopy, many experiments were carried out involving the production of new isotopes. The field of nuclear medicine developed when it was realized that some of these artificially created isotopes could be used to diagnose and treat many diseases, especially cancers.

Pioneering medical work done in the late 40's and early 50's established Cobalt-60 as a useful isotope, as the relatively high-energy gamma rays produced when it undergoes beta decay are able to penetrate the skin of the patient, and deliver a greater portion of the dose directly to the tumor. The high neutron efficiency of the NRX's heavy water-moderated design, coupled with the high neutron flux of the reactor, made it relatively inexpensive for AECL to produce medical-grade Cobalt 60. For example, the cost of the entire unit used to perform the first Cobalt-60 treatment was about $50,000. By way of contrast, it would cost $50,000,000 just to produce enough radium (which had been previously used as a therapy source) to perform the same procedure.^[1]

With this promising start, AECL came to be a major world supplier of medical isotopes, using both the NRX reactor, and the NRU reactor, which came on-line in 1957. However, as these reactors began to age, it became clear that a new facility would be needed to continue the production of medical isotopes.

Beginnings

In the late 80's, AECL began to acknowledge that continued isotope production would require the construction of a new reactor to replace capacity lost by the closing of the NRX in 1992, and the planned closing of the NRU early in the new millennium. As a result, it was decided to build a new facility dedicated to the production of medical isotopes on-site at Chalk River Laboratories. As the result of an understanding between AECL and its daughter company, MDS Nordion, that such a facility was required when Nordion was spun off in 1991, design work for the reactor was undertaken during the first half of the decade.

The design that resulted involved a facility with two identical reactors, each capable of supplying 100% of the world's medical isotope demand. The second reactor would function primarily as a back-up, to ensure that the supply of isotopes would not be interrupted by maintenance, or unplanned shutdowns. This is made necessary by the nature of medical isotopes; many have short half-lives, and must be used within a few days of production. With treatments being constantly carried out around the globe, an uninterruptible supply was essential.

A formal agreement was signed to begin the project in August, 1996. Following a year-long environmental assessment, construction began in December, 1997.^[2]

There has been some local opposition to the use of highly-enriched uranium (HEU) in the reactor,^[3] as well as from activists in the United States who fear that the uranium could be stolen by terrorists and used to fabricate a bomb.^[4]

Current status

Construction of the two reactors was completed by May 2000. An operational license was granted in August 1999 for the MAPLE I reactor, and extended to include the MAPLE II reactor in June 2000. Commissioning testing was begun immediately, with the MAPLE I achieving its first sustained reaction in February 2000, and MAPLE II following in October 2003. However, during testing, it was noted that some of the emergency shut-off rods in the MAPLE I reactor could fail to deploy in certain demanding situations. This failure was ascribed to workmanship and design issues, and related to fine metal particles accumulating in the control rods' housing and interfering with their free movement.^{[citation needed]} In addition, testing found that the reactors have a positive power co-efficient of reactivity (PCR), which was in disagreement with the prediction of the modelling, and was a significant barrier to commissioning.^[5]

Consequently significant efforts were made to resolve the outstanding issues, but progress towards commissioning the reactors was markedly slowed.^[6][7] During the subsequent eight-year-long delay in the start of commercial production, the project significantly overran its budgeted cost. Disputes over responsibility for the overruns between AECL and MDS Nordion added a further layer of complexity to the process. After considerable negotiation, AECL assumed full responsibility for the reactor in a settlement.^[8]

The MAPLE facility was granted an extension on its operating license on October 25, 2007, which would permit operations until October 31, 2011.^[9] This (final) submission envisioned that the MAPLE 1 reactor would be operational in late 2008.^[10] However, on May 16, 2008, AECL released a statement announcing that the MAPLE program had been terminated, as it had become "no longer feasible to complete the commissioning and start-up of the reactors".^[11] In this statement, AECL indicated that they would move to further extend the licence of the operating NRU reactor to continue the production of medical isotopes. The statement left unclear what long-term direction AECL would take for its medical isotope production business.

Design

^[12]

Legacy

References

1. ^ "CBC Archives". CBC News. http://archives.cbc.ca/400d.asp?id=1-75-346-1855-20&wm6=1. 
2. ^ http://anes.fiu.edu/Pro/s4ma1.pdf
3. ^ Website of local group opposed to HEU in MAPLE
4. ^ 2/19/99 Letter from American group concerned about HEU use in MAPLE
5. ^ North Renfrew Times: AECL scraps Maple project
6. ^ Press release of an agreement with INVAP for numerical modelling work
7. ^ Index of AECL submissions to the CNSC for licensing, and the subsequent decisions.
8. ^ PR Newswire report of AELC-MDS Nordion Settlement (in brief)
9. ^ Release confirming licence extension.
10. ^ October 2007 AECL submission to the CNSC, see Slide 8 on Page 4.
11. ^ Globe and Mail article describing the announcement to cancel the MAPLE reactor (subscription required)
12. ^ How the MAPLE Reactors Work

External links

• Article on early cobalt therapy
• http://www.aecl.ca/NewsRoom/News/Press-2008/080516.htm
• Magnus, B. (2008). "Over budget, overdue and, perhaps, overdesigned". Canadian Medical Association Journal 178: 813. doi:10.1503/cmaj.080320.