Undue influence

Undue influence

Undue influence (as a term in jurisprudence) is an equitable doctrine that involves one person taking advantage of a position of power over another person. It is where free will to bargain is not possible.

Undue influence in contract law

If undue influence is proved in a contract, in USA law, the contract is voidable by the innocent party, and the remedy is rescission. There are two categories to consider:
* Presumed undue influence
* Actual undue influence

Presumed undue influence

First subgroup

In the first subgroup, the relationship falls in a class of relationships that as a matter of law will raise a presumption of undue influence. Such classes include:
* Parent/child
* Guardian/ward
* Priest/member of parish
* Solicitor/client
* Doctor/patient

In such cases, the onus of proof lies on a doctor, say, to disprove undue influence on a patient.

econd subgroup

The second subgroup covers relationships that do not fall into the first subgroup, but on the facts of case, there was an antecedent relationship between the parties that led to undue influence. The test is one of whether there was a relationship of such trust and confidence that it should give rise to such a presumption (see "Johnson v. Buttress" (1936) 56 CLR 113).

In "Garcia v National Australia Bank" (1998) 194 CLR 395, the High Court of Australia distinguished between cases of actual undue influence and situations where the transaction is set aside because the guarantor does not understand the nature of the transaction. Although there is no presumption of undue influence, a "lender is to be taken to have understood that, as a wife, the surety may repose trust and confidence in her husband in matters of business and therefore to have understood that the husband may not fully and accurately explain the purport and effect of the transaction to his wife; and yet... did not itself take steps to explain the transaction to the wife or find out that a stranger had explained it to her."

Actual undue influence

An innocent party may also seek to have a contract set aside for actual undue influence, where there is no presumption of undue influence, but there is evidence that the power was unbalanced at the time of the signing of the contract.

Undue influence in probate law

"Undue Influence" is the most common ground for will contests and are often accompanied by a capacity challenge. In probate law, it is generally defined as a testator's loss of free agency regarding property disposition through contemporaneous psychological domination by an advisor which results in an excessive benefit to the advisor. It is important to note that "undue influence" is only an issue when the advisor is benefiting, not when advisor is getting a benefit for someone else; in that case it would be considered fraud. In litigation most jurisdictions place the burden of proving undue influence on the party challenging the will.

ee also

* Compare with duress (contract law)

Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • undue influence — n: improper influence that deprives a person of freedom of choice or substitutes another s choice or desire for the person s own compare coercion, duress, necessity ◇ It is a doctrine of equity that a contract, deed, donation, or testamentary… …   Law dictionary

  • undue influence — ˌundue ˈinfluence noun [uncountable] LAW when unfair pressure is put on someone to enter into an agreement: • He was found guilty of misrepresentation and undue influence. * * * undue influence UK US noun [U] LAW ► a situation in which someone… …   Financial and business terms

  • Undue influence — Undue Un*due , a. 1. Not due; not yet owing; as, an undue debt, note, or bond. [1913 Webster] 2. Not right; not lawful or legal; improper; as, an undue proceeding. Bacon. [1913 Webster] 3. Not agreeable to a rule or standard, or to duty;… …   The Collaborative International Dictionary of English

  • undue influence — A species of fraud or constructive fraud whereby means brought to bear upon a person his free agency is destroyed and the will of another person substituted therefor. 25 Am J2d Dur §§ 35, 36. A species of constructive fraud which the court will… …   Ballentine's law dictionary

  • Undue Influence — A situation in which an individual is able to persuade another s decisions due to the relationship between the two parties. In exerting undue influence, the influencing individual is able to gain an advantage. In contract law, a party claiming to …   Investment dictionary

  • undue influence — pernelyg didelė įtaka vartotojui statusas Aprobuotas sritis civilinė teisė ir procesas apibrėžtis Komercinės veiklos subjekto naudojimasis pranašesne padėtimi vartotojo atžvilgiu, darant jam spaudimą, net ir nenaudojant arba negrasinant naudoti… …   Lithuanian dictionary (lietuvių žodynas)

  • undue influence — /ˌʌndju: ɪnfluəns/ noun unfair pressure put on someone to sign a contract ● The salesforce were discouraged from exerting undue influence on prospective buyers …   Marketing dictionary in english

  • undue influence — unfair influence, illegitimate influence of one party on a contract that may deem a contract to be void …   English contemporary dictionary

  • undue influence — noun : such influence over another often presumed from the existence of very close relationships as destroys his free agency in the eye of the law : such influence as prevents a person from exercising his own will and substitutes in its place the …   Useful english dictionary

  • undue influence — noun Law influence by which a person is induced to act otherwise than by their own free will or without adequate attention to the consequences …   English new terms dictionary