Division of a question


Division of a question

A motion for division of a question, in parliamentary procedure, is used to split a motion into a set of motions.

Explanation and Use

Division of a question (RONR)
Class Incidental motion
In order when another has the floor? No
Requires second? Yes
Debatable? No
May be reconsidered? No
Amendable? Yes
Vote required: Majority

Robert's Rules of Order Newly Revised (RONR)

This motion is applicable when each of the different parts, although relating to a single subject, is capable of standing as a complete proposition without the others.[1] The motion is made by saying, for instance, "I move to divide the resolution so as to consider separately...."[2]

A motion to divide the question is not required when a single motion seeks approval of a series of propositions or resolutions on different subjects. Any member may obtain separate discussion and voting on any of the unrelated propositions or resolutions by making a demand for separate consideration, at any time before the unified motion is put to a vote. [3]

Legislative Use

In the British House of Commons, a formal motion is not required to divide the question; since 1888, the Speaker has held that a question consisting of two or more propositions, each of which is able to stand on its own, can be divided on the objection of any Member of Parliament.[4]

History

The concept of a division of a question dates back to at least 1640, when the Lex Parliamentaria noted, "If a Question upon a Debate contains more Parts than one, and Members seem to be for one Part, and not for the other; it may be moved, that the same may be divided into two, or more Questions: as Dec. 2, 1640, the Debate about the Election of two Knights was divided into two Questions."[5]

Related Motions

Consideration by Paragraph, Consider by Parts, or Consider Seriatim are names for a similar motion whereby a complex motion is broken up to be deliberated part by part. Each part is considered tentatively and amended as necessary, then the whole motion is considered and voted on as a whole. This differs from the motion to divide a question which splits the motion into two or more independent motions that are taken up in sequence. Each new motion is deliberated and voted upon before taking up the next part.

The motion division of the question is not to be confused with division of the assembly, which is a call for a rising vote.


References

  1. ^ Robert, Henry M. (2000). Robert's Rules of Order Newly Revised (10th ed. ed.). pp. 261.  (RONR)
  2. ^ RONR (10th ed.), Sample Forms Used in Making Motions, p. 35
  3. ^ RONR (10th ed.) p. 265
  4. ^ May, Erskine (1989). Erskine May: Parliamentary Practice (21st ed.). Butterworths. pp. 335–6. ISBN 0406114714. 
  5. ^ Petyt, George. Lex Parliamentaria. pp. 169. 



Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • division — [ divizjɔ̃ ] n. f. • 1120; lat. divisio, onis 1 ♦ Action de diviser; état de ce qui est divisé (rare en emploi concret).⇒ dis ; tomie. Division d un corps en plusieurs parties. ⇒ bipartition, coupure, déchirement, fission, fractionnement,… …   Encyclopédie Universelle

  • DIVISION CELLULAIRE — La capacité à croître et à se diviser est une propriété fondamentale du monde vivant dont la cellule est l’unité de base. Le processus de multiplication cellulaire présente deux caractéristiques majeures: il s’agit d’un phénomène de reproduction… …   Encyclopédie Universelle

  • Division — may refer to: Contents 1 Mathematics 2 Science 3 Society 4 …   Wikipedia

  • Division of the assembly — In parliamentary procedure, a division of the assembly (also division of the house or simply division) is a voting method in which the members of the assembly take a rising vote (stand up) or go to different parts of the chamber, literally… …   Wikipedia

  • DIVISION — s. f. Séparation réelle ou fictive, partage. La division des parties d un corps. La division d un régiment en bataillons, d un bataillon en compagnies. Les experts déclarèrent que l immeuble n était pas susceptible de division. La division d un… …   Dictionnaire de l'Academie Francaise, 7eme edition (1835)

  • DIVISION — n. f. Action de diviser ou Résultat de cette action. La division des parties d’un corps. La division d’un régiment en bataillons, d’un bataillon en compagnies. Les experts déclarèrent que l’immeuble n’était pas susceptible de division. Division… …   Dictionnaire de l'Academie Francaise, 8eme edition (1935)

  • division — (di vi zion ; en vers, de quatre syllabes) s. f. 1°   Opération par laquelle on réduit un corps solide en parties plus ou moins ténues. •   On trouve, dans l art et dans la nature, des divisions qui vont infiniment plus loin qu on ne peut l… …   Dictionnaire de la Langue Française d'Émile Littré

  • Division (vote) — Division of the house is a parliamentary mechanism which calls for a rising vote, wherein the members of the house literally divide into groups indicating a vote in favour of or in opposition to a motion on the floor. This was the method used to… …   Wikipedia

  • Question Jurassienne — En Suisse la question jurassienne est liée au conflit entre le Peuple Jurassien et le Canton de Berne qui se manifesta par de nombreux évènements conflictuels tant culturels, religieux et sociaux qui se déroulèrent dès l annexion de l ancien… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Division (mathématiques) — Division Pour les articles homonymes, voir division (homonymie). La division est une loi de composition qui à deux nombres associe le produit du premier par l inverse du second. Si un nombre est non nul, la fonction division par ce nombre est la… …   Wikipédia en Français