- Thermodynamic versus kinetic reaction control
Thermodynamic reaction control or kinetic reaction control in a
chemical reactioncan decide the composition in a reaction product when competing reactions lead to different products under different reaction conditions. The distinction is relevant when product A forms faster (kinetics) than product B (The activation energyfor A is lower than that of B) but B is a more stable (thermodynamics) product than A.
Reactions are considered to take place under thermodynamic reaction control when the reverse reaction is rapid and the
Chemical equilibriumestablishes itself quickly. In this way the thermodynamically more stable product is always favoured. Thermodynamic reaction control takes place with vigorous reaction conditions or when the reaction is allowed to continue over a long time to give a slow reaction time to reach equilibrium.
In kinetic reaction control, the forward reaction is much faster than the reverse reaction. As a result, the reaction favours the product with the lowest activation energy and goes forth regardless of relative product stabilities. Kinetic control is favoured with mild and low temperature conditions.
Diels-Alder reactionof cyclopentadienewith furanserves as an example. At room temperaturekinetic reaction control prevails and the less stable endo isomer2 is the main reaction product. At 81°C and long reaction time the chemical equilibrium can assert itself and the thermodynamically stable exo isomer1 is formed.
protonationof an enolate ionthe kinetic product is the enoland the thermodynamic product is a ketone.
carbohydrate acetalisationchoice of acetone precursor determines reaction outcome.
electrophilic additionreaction of hydrogen bromideto 1,3-butadieneat 60°C leads predominantly to the thermodynamically stable 1,4 adduct 1-bromo-2-butene but decreasing the reaction temperature to -60°C favours the kinetic 1,2 product 3-bromo-1-butene.
* Organic Chemistry, 3rd ed., M. A. Foxe & J. K. Whitesell, Jones & Bartlett, 2004 ISBN 0-7637-2197-2
* A Guidebook to Mechanism in Organic Chemistry, 6th Edition, Peter Sykes, Pearson Prentice Hall, 1986. ISBN 0-582-44695-3
Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.