Quest for the historical Jesus


Quest for the historical Jesus

: "This article is about the history of academic Jesus research. For the book "The Quest of the Historical Jesus: A Critical Study of Its Progress from Reimarus to Wrede", see Albert Schweitzer."

The quest for the historical Jesus is the attempt to use historical rather than religious methods to construct a verifiable biography of Jesus. As originally defined by Albert Schweitzer, the quest began in the 18th century with Hermann Samuel Reimarus, up to William Wrede in the 19th century and Schweitzer himself. The quest is commonly divided into stages, and it continues today among scholars such as the fellows of the Jesus Seminar.

The First Quest

These scholars of what today would be called the "Quest for the Historical Jesus" applied the historical methodologies of their day to distinguish the mythology from the history of Jesus. Reimarus pioneered "the search for the historical Jesus", applying the Rationalism of the Enlightenment Era to claims about Jesus. Although Schweitzer was among the greatest contributors to this quest, he also ended the quest by noting how each scholar's version of Jesus seemed little more than an idealized autobiography of the scholar himself - a criticism suggestive of Ludwig Feuerbach, and still haunts Jesus research to this day.
*Hermann Samuel Reimarus (1694-1768) - credited as the father of the Quest for the Historical Jesus
*Thomas Jefferson (1743–1826) - a US president who considered Jesus' ethics superb and miracles ahistorical: Jefferson Bible
*David Friedrich Strauss (1808-1874) - asserted that the supernatural elements of the gospels could be treated as myth.
*Ernest Renan (1823-1892) - asserted that the biography of Jesus ought to be open to historical investigation just as is the biography of any other man.
*William Wrede (1859-1906) - wrote on the Messianic Secret theme in the Gospel of Mark. He also wrote a crucial study of the Second Epistle to the Thessalonians, which argued for its inauthenticity.
*Albert Schweitzer (1875-1965) - "Schweitzer saw Jesus' ethic as only an "interim ethic" (a way of life good only for the brief period before the cataclysmic end, the eschaton). As such he found it no longer relevant or valid. Acting on his own conclusion, in 1913 Schweitzer abandoned a brilliant career in theology, turned to medicine, and went out to Africa where he founded the famous hospital at Lambaréné out of respect for all forms of life." [http://www.westarinstitute.org/Polebridge/Title/5Gospels/Seven_Pillars/seven_pillars.html]
*Rudolf Bultmann - identified the Signs gospel.
*Martin Dibelius - advocated that form criticism be applied to the New Testament. [http://www.giffordlectures.org/Author.asp?AuthorID=31] Some recent scholars have reasserted Schweitzer's eschatological view of Jesus: see Dale Allison in his 1998 work "Jesus of Nazareth, Milenarian Prophet" and Bart D. Ehrman in 1999 work "Jesus, Apolocyptic Prophet of the New Millennium". Conversely others, such as the Jesus Seminar, have denied the authenticity of Jesus' eschatological message, describing Jesus as a wandering sage.

The Second Quest

Also called the New Quest.
These scholars emphasized the "constraints of history", so that despite uncertainties there were historical data that were usable. Moreover they disputed claims of extreme lateness for the formation of the New Testament and generally accomplished a consensus of approximately year 70 AD, give-or-take a decade or two depending on a specific text. Likewise they emphasized how the redaction of the New Testament resulted from a process over time, so that the New Testament included early textual layers, around which later and later layers crystalized. The form of the Gospel of Thomas was often argued to corroborate the existence of the Q Gospel, whose hypothetical form would resemble it.Hypothesizing about the existence of original source texts became useful for data relevant to the Historical Jesus. These early texts continue to remain hypothetical until future discoveries render proof of their existence.
*Gunther Bornkamm
*Ernst Käsemann
*James M. Robinson
*John A. T. Robinson
*Edward Schillebeeckx

The Third Quest

These scholars tend to focus on the early textual layers of the New Testament for data to reconstruct a biography for the Historical Jesus. Many of these scholars rely on a redactive critique of the hypothetical Q Gospel and on a Greco-Roman "Mediterranean" milieu as opposed to a Jewish milieu and tend to view Jesus as a radical philosopher of Wisdom literature, who strives to destabilize the economic status quo. Some scholars also rely on a critique of non-canonical texts for early textual layers that possibly evidence Jesus.
*Marcus Borg
*John Dominic Crossan
*Robert Funk
*Burton Mack
*Morton Smith

The Jewishness of Jesus is first and foremost. These scholars use the archeology of Israel and the analysis of formative Jewish literature, including the Mishna, Dead Sea Scrolls, New Testament (as a Jewish text) and Josephus, to reconstruct the ancient worldviews of Jews in the 1st-century Roman provinces of Iudaea and Galilaea - and only afterward investigate how Jesus fits in. They tend to view Jesus as a proto-rabbi who announced the Kingdom of Heaven. The focus on Jesus's social environment rather than on Jesus himself is an intentional methodology to increase the influence of verifiable scientific criteria for evaluating Jesus and to reduce the influence of personal subjective criteria.
*David Bivin
*Roy Blizzard
*Raymond E. Brown
*Bruce Chilton
*Haim Cohn
*James H. Charlesworth
*W.D. Davies
*James D. G. Dunn
*Robert Eisenman
*Harvey Falk
*David Flusser
*Paula Fredriksen
*Joachim Jeremias
*Ray Vander Laan
*Robert Lindsey
*John P. Meier
*Ron Moseley
*Jacob Neusner
*Peter Pokorny
*Ray A. Pritz
*Dwight A. Pryor
*E.P. Sanders
*Shmuel Safrai
*David Stern
*Geza Vermes
*Marvin R. Wilson
*Ben Witherington
*N. T. Wright
*Brad H. Young

* Members of the [http://www.jerusalemschool.org/ Jerusalem School] (a consortium of Israeli Christian and Jewish scholars: periodical [http://www.jerusalemperspective.com/Default.aspx?tabid=35 Jerusalem Perspective] )

See also

* Cultural and historical background of Jesus
* Historical Jesus
* Historicity of Jesus
* Jesus as myth
* Historicity of Muhammad


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Quest of the Historical Jesus, The — The title of Albert Schweitzer [[➝ Schweitzer, Albert]] s work (ET1910 and 2000) which traced the course of investigation by (mostly) German scholars into the presentation of Jesus in the gospels. The starting point was in the late 18th cent. and …   Dictionary of the Bible

  • The Quest of the Historical Muhammad (Jeffery) — For other uses, see The Quest of the Historical Muhammad. The Quest of the Historical Muhammad is a writing authored by Arthur Jeffery.HistoryIt is inspired by 1906 German work named Von Reimarus zu Wrede by Albert Schweitzer. In 1910, William… …   Wikipedia

  • The Quest of the Historical Muhammad (Peters) — For other uses, see The Quest of the Historical Muhammad The Quest of the Historical Muhammad is often referenced essay by Francis Edwards Peters, published in August 1991 in the International Journal of Middle East Studies [Peters, F. E. The… …   Wikipedia

  • Historical Jesus — The historical Jesus is Jesus of Nazareth as reconstructed by historians using historical methods. These historical methods use critical analysis of gospel texts as the primary source for the biography of Jesus, along with non biblical sources to …   Wikipedia

  • Jesus myth theory — The Resurrection of Christ by Noel Coypel (1700). Jesus myth theorists see this as one of a number of stories about dying and rising gods. Description The …   Wikipedia

  • Jesus Seminar — The Jesus Seminar is a group of about 150 individuals including scholars with advanced degrees in biblical studies, religious studies or related fields as well as published authors who are notable in the field of religion founded in 1985 by the… …   Wikipedia

  • Jesus myth hypothesis — Jesus myth links here. For a comparison between Jesus Christ and pagan mythology see Jesus Christ and comparative mythology. The Jesus myth hypothesis, also referred to as the Jesus myth theory , the Christ myth or the Jesus myth is an argument… …   Wikipedia

  • Jesus — This article is about Jesus of Nazareth. For other uses, see Jesus (disambiguation). Jesus …   Wikipedia

  • The Bible and history — Part of a series on The Bible …   Wikipedia

  • Jésus de l'histoire — Quêtes du Jésus historique Cet article fait partie de la série Bible Contenus …   Wikipédia en Français


Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.