Sociological positivism

Sociological positivism

:"This article describes the term 'positivism' as used in social sciences, especially within the science of sociology. For other meanings of this word, see positivism."

In sociology, anthropology, and other social sciences, the term positivism is closely connected to naturalism and can be traced back to the philosophical thinking of Auguste Comte in the 19th century. In Comte's view, positivism is an approach.

Structural anthropologist Edmund Leach described "positivism" during the 1966 Henry Myers Lecture as follows:

:"Positivism" is the view that serious scientific inquiry should not search for ultimate causes deriving from some outside source but must confine itself to the study of relations existing between facts which are directly accessible to observation.


Positivists are guided by five principles:
# Unity of scientific method - logic of inquiry is the same across all sciences (social and natural)
# The goal of inquiry is to explain and predict. Most positivists would also say that the ultimate goal is to develop the law of general understanding, by discovering necessary and sufficient conditions for any phenomenon (creating a perfect model of it). If the law is known, we can manipulate the conditions to produce the predicted result.
# Scientific knowledge is testable. Research can be proved only by empirical means, not argumentations. Research should be mostly inductive, i.e. inductive logic is used to develop statements that can be tested (theory leads to hypothesis which in turn leads to discovery and/or study of evidence). Research should be observable with human senses (arguments are not enough, belief is out of question). Positivists should prove their research using logic of confirmation.
# Science does not equal common sense. Researchers must be careful not to let common sense bias their research.
# Relation of theory to practice – science should be as value-free as possible, and the ultimate goal of science is to produce knowledge, regardless of politics, morals, values, etc. involved in the research. Science should be judged by logic, and ideally produce Universal conditionals::* For all conditions of X, if X has property P and P=Q, then X has property Q.:* Statements must be true for all times and places.

Positivistic assumptions about the real world

# Nature is orderly; there is an underlying causality and pattern.
# We can know nature (discover and understand causes, patterns, etc.).
# Knowledge is always preferable to ignorance.Fact|date=January 2008
# Natural phenomena have natural causes.
# Knowledge comes through sensory experience.

Positivists' self-critique

Positivists have themselves raised questions and doubts about positivism, questioning whether anyone can follow the ideal described above. The most often raised points are:
* Forms of controlled inquiry – there is a narrower range of possibilities for social science study compared to natural science study. Issues of ethics, control and of experimenters involuntarily influencing their subjects limit how we can experiment on humans. It is also difficult to test some predictions other than in time.
* Knowledge is a social variable – knowing one is a subject of a study changes one's behaviour and results can modify the future (self-fulfilling prophecy).
* Generalisations are limited – because of the complexity of culture and history, it is impossible to create statements that are true for all times and places.
* Subjectivity and value orientation – Research is often subjective. Researchers always have their own motives, goals, ethics and values, some deeply unconscious, and it is thus impossible to be a completely objective observer.

Contemporary thinking

Today, although many sociologists would agree that a scientific method is an important part of sociology, orthodox positivism is rare. Social scientists realize that one cannot identify laws that would hold true in all cases when human behaviour is concerned, and that while the behaviour of groups may at times be predicted in terms of probability, it is much harder to explain the behaviour of each individual. In some quarters of contemporary sociology, positivism has been replaced by a contrary view, antipositivism.

Many sociologists today operate somewhere between positivism and antipositivism, usually called postpositivism. Sociologists taking this intermediate position argue that human behavior is more complex than animal behavior or the movements of planets. Others reject positivism as a fundamental misunderstanding of social reality, that it is ahistorical, depoliticized, and an inappropriate application of theoretical concepts. A similar distinction is often made in the critique of analytic philosophy made by continental philosophers. Some argue humans have free will, imagination and irrationality, so that our behavior is at best difficult to explain by rigid "laws of society".

See also

* Logical positivism
* Positivist calendar
* postpositivism
* Interpretive sociology
* Verstehen

Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Sociological naturalism — is a theory that states that the natural world and social world are roughly identical and governed by similar principles. Sociological naturalism, in sociological texts simply referred to as naturalism, can be traced back to the philosophical… …   Wikipedia

  • Positivism (disambiguation) — Positivism is a philosophy that states that the only authentic knowledge is scientific knowledge.Positivism may also refer to:* Legal positivism, a school of thought in jurisprudence and the philosophy of law * Logical positivism, a school of… …   Wikipedia

  • Positivism — is the philosophy that the only authentic knowledge is knowledge that is based on actual sense experience. Such knowledge can only come from affirmation of theories through strict scientific method. Metaphysical speculation is avoided. Though the …   Wikipedia

  • positivism — The acknowledged founder of positivism or ‘the positive philosophy’ was the French philosopher and social scientist Auguste Comte (1798 1857). Comte is also accredited with the invention of the term ‘sociology’ to describe his proposed science of …   Dictionary of sociology

  • Sociological theory — Sociological theories are complex theoretical frameworks that sociologists use to explain and analyze variously how social action, social processes, and social structures work. Sociological theories are sometimes called social theories , though… …   Wikipedia

  • Sociological paradigm — Sociological paradigms (or frameworks) are specific points of view used by social scientists in social research. Sociological paradigms are particular paradigms that employ the sociological perspective and the sociological imagination. A… …   Wikipedia

  • Logical positivism — (also known as logical empiricism, scientific philosophy, and neo positivism) is a philosophy that combines empiricism the idea that observational evidence is indispensable for knowledge with a version of rationalism incorporating mathematical… …   Wikipedia

  • Comte and positivism — Robert Brown COMTE’S AIMS The chief aim of all of Auguste Comte’s publications, and the constant mission of his entire working life, was the improvement of human character through the perfecting of human society. He was convinced that the… …   History of philosophy

  • The Sociological Imagination — infobox Book | name = The Sociological Imagination orig title = translator = author = C. Wright Mills cover artist = country = language = series = genre = publisher = Oxford University Press release date = 1959 media type = pages = 256 isbn =… …   Wikipedia

  • neo-positivism — A movement in early twentieth century American sociology which blended together the three themes of quantification, behaviourism , and positivist epistemology. Its principal proponents were Franklin H. Giddings and George A. Lundberg , although… …   Dictionary of sociology

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.