Gustav Radbruch


Gustav Radbruch

Gustav Radbruch (November 21, 1878 - November 23, 1949) was a German law professor and political figure.

Life

Born at Lübeck, Radbruch studied law in Munich, Leipzig and Berlin. He passed his first bar exam ("Staatsexamen") in Berlin in 1901, and the following year he received his doctorate with a dissertation on "The Theory of adequate Causation." This was followed in 1903 by his qualification to teach criminal law in Heidelberg. In 1904, he was appointed Professor of Criminal and Trial Law and Legal Philosophy in Heidelberg. In 1914 he accepted a call to a professorship in Königsberg, and in 1914 he accepted one at Kiel.

Radbruch was a member of the Social Democratic Party of Germany (SPD), and held a seat in the Reichstag from 1920 to 1924. In 1921-22 and throughout 1923, he was Justice Minister in the cabinets of Joseph Wirth and Gustav Stresemann. During his time in office, a number of important laws were implemented, such as those giving women access to the justice system, and, after the assassination of Walter Rathenau, the Law for the Protection of the Republic.

In 1926, Radbruch accepted a renewed call to lecture at Heidelberg. After the Nazi seizure of power in 1933, Radbruch was dismissed from his civil service post, as the universities were public entities. During the Nazi period, he devoted himself primarily to cultural-historical work. Immediately after the end of the Second World War in 1945, he resumed his teaching activities, but died at Heidelberg in 1949 without being able to complete his planned updated edition of his textbook on legal philosophy.

Work

Radbruch's legal philosophy derived from Neokantianism, which assumes that a categorical cleavage exists between "is" ("Sein") and "ought" ("Sollen"). According to this view, "Should" can never be derived from "Being." Indicative of the Heidelberg school of Neokantianism to which Radbruch subscribed was that it interpolated the value-related cultural studies between the explanatory sciences (Being) and philosophical teachings of values (Should).

In relation to the law, this triadism shows itself in the subfields of legal sociology, legal philosophy and legal dogma. Legal dogma assumes a place in between. It posits itself in opposition to positive law, as the latter depicts itself in social reality and methodologically in the objective "should-have" sense of law, which reveals itself through value-related interpretation.

The core of Radbruch's legal philosophy consists of his tenets the concept of law and the idea of law. The idea of law is defined through a triad of justice, utility and security. Radbruch thereby had the idea of utility or usefuleness spring forth from an analysis of the idea of justice. Upon this notion was based the Radsbrucian formula, which is still vigorously debated today. The concept of law, for Radbruch, is "nothing other than the given fact, which has the sense to serve the idea of law."

Hotly disputed is the question whether Radbruch was a legal positivist before 1933 and executed an about-face in his thinking due to the advent of Nazism, or whether he continued to develop, under the impression of Nazi crimes, the relativistic values-teaching he had already been advocating before 1933.

The problem of the controversy between the spirit and the letter of the law, in Germany, has been brought back to public attention due to the trials of former East German soldiers who guarded the Berlin Wall--the so-called necessity of following orders. Radbruch's theories are posited against the positivist "pure legal tenets" represented by Hans Kelsen and, to some extent, also from Georg Jellinek.

In sum, Radbruch's formula argues that where statutory law is incompatible with the requirements of justice "to an intolerable degree", or where statutory law was obviously designed in a way that deliberately negates "the equality that is the core of all justice", statutory law must be disregarded by a judge in favour of the justice principle. Since its first publication in 1946 the principle has been accepted by Germany's Federal Constitutional Court in a variety of cases. Many people partially blame the older German legal tradition of legal positivism for the ease with which Hitler obtain power in an outwardly "legal" manner, rather than by means of a coup. Arguably, the shift to a concept of natural law ought to act as a safeguard against dictatorship, an untrammeled State power and the abrogation of civil rights.


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Gustav Radbruch — (vor 1921) Gustav Radbruch (* 21. November 1878 in Lübeck; † 23. November 1949 in Heidelberg) war Reichsjustizminister in der Weimarer Republik und gilt als einer der einflussreichsten Rechtsphilosophen des 20. Jahrhunderts. Daneben genoss… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Gustav Radbruch — né le 21 novembre 1878 à Lübeck et décédé le 23 novembre 1949 à Heidelberg est un homme politique et un philosophe de droit allemand. Il est ministre de la Justice pendant la République de Weimar. Il participe en 1928 au premier cours… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Gustav Radbruch — Archivo:Gustav Radbruch.jpg GUSTAV RADBRUCH (1878 1950) Nació en la ciudad de Lübeck (Alemania). Fue Profesor en Heidelberg, Koenisberg y Kiel. De 1920 a 1924, miembro del Reichstag y ministro de Justicia con Wirth y con Stresemann. Desde 1925,… …   Wikipedia Español

  • Radbruch'sche Formel — Gustav Radbruch (1878–1949), 1902 Als Radbruchsche Formel wird eine erstmals 1946 formulierte These des deutschen Rechtsphilosophen Gustav Radbruch bezeichnet. Dieser These zufolge hat sich ein Richter im Konflikt zwischen dem positiven… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Radbruch’sche Formel — Gustav Radbruch (1878–1949), 1902 Als Radbruchsche Formel wird eine erstmals 1946 formulierte These des deutschen Rechtsphilosophen Gustav Radbruch bezeichnet. Dieser These zufolge hat sich ein Richter im Konflikt zwischen dem positiven… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Radbruch (Begriffsklärung) — Radbruch ist der Name einer Gemeinde im Landkreis Lüneburg in Niedersachsen, siehe Radbruch und ist der Name von folgenden Personen Gustav Radbruch (1878–1949), deutscher Rechtsgelehrter und politiker Heinrich Radbrock (gest. 1536), letzter Abt… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Gustav Stresemann — Gustav Stresemann, 1925 Gustav Stresemann (* 10. Mai 1878 in Berlin; † 3. Oktober 1929 ebenda) war ein deutscher Politiker (zuerst Nationalliberale Partei, später DVP). Seine Karriere be …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Gustav Stresemann — « Stresemann » redirige ici. Pour l ornithologue, voir Erwin Stresemann. Gustav Stresemann …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Gustav Stresemann — Infobox Chancellor name=Gustav Stresemann order=Chancellor of Germany term start =August 13 term end =November 23, 1923 predecessor =Wilhelm Cuno successor =Wilhelm Marx birth date =birth date|1878|5|10|mf=y death date =death date and… …   Wikipedia

  • Radbruch, Gustav — (1878 1949)    professor and Justice Minister; one of Germany s renowned constitutional theorists. Born to a wealthy middle class family in Lübeck, he published poetry while still in Gymnasium, but studied law at the behest of his father. He… …   Historical dictionary of Weimar Republik


Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.