Theodore Theodorsen

Infobox Person
name = Theodore Theodorsen


image_size = 140px
birth_date = birth date|1897|01|8
birth_place = Sandefjord,
Norway flagicon|Norway
death_date = 1978
death_place = Long Island, New York,
United States flagicon|USA
occupation = Aerodynamicist
spouse = Johanne Magdelene Theodorsen
parents = Ole Christian Theodorsen
Andrea Larsen
children = Muriel Gerd-Preutz
Theodore Elliott
John Willman

Theodore Theodorsen (1897 - 1978) was an American theoretical aerodynamicist noted for his work at NACA (the forerunner of NASA) and for his contributions to the study of turbulence.

Early years

Dr. Theodore Theodorsen was born in Sandefjord, Norway on January 8, 1897 to parents Ole Christian Theodorsen, a chief engineer in the Norwegian merchant marine and Andrea Larsen. He was the oldest of six children. Early on he showed exceptional academic promise. At one point Theodore’s father had taken examinations for a merchant marine engineer’s license. He was the only applicant who correctly answered a particularly difficult question. However to his father’s surprise his then twelve year old son was also able to solve the problem. At age sixteen, after finishing compulsory schooling, Theodorsen attended gymnasium (equivalent in the USA to senior high school-junior college) in the nearby town of Larvik. If certain grade levels were attained one would gain a scholarship to university. Norway was then far ahead of most nations in the liberalization of education. Theodorsen’s grades were so outstanding at Larvik that he was admitted to the leading engineering university in Norway. This was the Norwegian Institute of Technology in Trondheim. In those days there were no dormitories; students rented rooms in private homes. Many of the professors in those days were from Germany and England. Therefore a student at the university had to be familiar with all three languages. Theodorsen graduated with the highest grades ever attained at the university. Only in mechanical drawing was his grade less than perfect. In those days anyone who achieved perfect grades would receive the honor of an introduction to the King of Norway.

Fateful Year

In the year 1922 four significant events occurred in Theodorsen’s life: he graduated with a masters degree in mechanical engineering: he married Johanne Magdelene Hoem. Her family was a well known respected family in Trondheim. They were married in the famous Domkirke Cathedral, the largest existing medieval church in Scandinavia and the burial place of St. Olaf. The wedding party was an all-night celebration at the Britannia Hotel with one hundred guests. Also in 1922, Theodorsen was offered a position at the university as an instructor: Lastly it was during that fateful year that one of his students was Lars Onsager who became one of father’s lifelong friends. Onsager also emigrated to the USA and eventually went on to win a Nobel prize in chemistry. After some years as an instructor in Norway Theodorsen, like so many Norwegian engineers, decided to emigrate. Jobs for engineers were few and far between in Norway then. His wife’s family knew a Norwegian sea captain, then retired, living in Baltimore, USA so that became their American destination. As an aside their crossing of the Atlantic Ocean was not uneventful. Attempt #1: Ship had a minor fire so it returned to Norway for four weeks of repair. This young couple were happy to be put up in a hotel at no expense during the ship repair time. Attempt #2: While at sea the US government passed a law that said one could not bring his wife into the USA unless she had her own individual passport. Back they went to Norway. Attempt #3: All went well.

Johns Hopkins University

For some time there were few job prospects in Baltimore. Theodorsen took a job working on the third shift as an oiler at the Sparrows Point electrical generating plant located twenty miles from Baltimore. His luck soon turned. Johns Hopkins University advertised for an instructor in mechanical engineering. He obtained the position. His English was even then grammatically perfect and only slightly accented. He taught at Johns Hopkins for five years during which time his daughter Muriel Gerd-Preutz and son Theodore Elliott were born. Also then in 1928 his university friend from Norway, Lars Onsager, came to the USA and happened to teach at Johns Hopkins for one semester. It was at that time that Onsager suggested to Theodorsen that he obtain a doctorate in Physics. Theodorsen then followed his graduate engineering degree from the Norwegian Institute of Technology with a doctoral degree in physics from Johns Hopkins University. His thesis dealt with thermodynamic and aerodynamic themes that were to permeate much of his later work, which was developed in two parts: 1) shock waves and explosions and 2) combustion and detonation. Through the urging of Dr. Joseph S. Ames, president of Johns Hopkins University and Chairman of the Executive Committee of the National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics (NACA, now NASA), Theodorsen came to NACA in 1929 as an associate physicist. In that year his third child, John Willman, was born in Newport News, Virginia.

National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics

The NACA (forerunner of NASA) facility was located adjoining the Langley Air Force Base near Hampton, Virginia. This was then the only in-house research arm of NACA and had a highly motivated young staff. The work atmosphere was very informal though competitive, with much open stimulating discussion. However, conditions were rather primitive. For example the “library” consisted of one small shelf of books. Theodorsen used as his mainstays his old reliable Hutte Mechanical Engineering Handbook and a set of the 1929 edition of the Handbuch der Physik. Within a short time Theodorsen was made head of the Physical Research Division, the other research divisions being Engine Research and Aerodynamics. Langley NACA was then in the process of expanding its experimental facilities to include a Full Scale Wind Tunnel and a Hydrodynamic Towing Basin for testing flying boat hulls. It happened that the proposed location of the towing basin had formerly been a bombing range. One of Theodorsen’s first activities was the invention of an instrument for detecting buried metals and on its very first use it located a live bomb. The ensuing years were highly productive ones for Theodorsen in a great variety of experimental and theoretical areas as the list of publications arranged chronologically and appended herein discloses. As an overview Theodorsen improved thin airfoil theory by introducing the angle of best streamlining, went on to develop the now classical and elegant theory of arbitrary wing sections, performed the first in-house noise research, worked on fire prevention in aircraft and on means of icing removal and prevention, contributed to the theory of open, closed and partially open wind-tunnel test sections, developed the basic theory of aircraft flutter and its verification, made early measurements of skin friction at transonic and supersonic speeds, developed the use of freon for experimental aeroelastic work, gave damping properties of structures and expanded general propeller theory. During World War 2 Theodorsen was called on for the analysis and troubleshooting of many aircraft problems and to help devise necessary modifications.

Expanding on Significant Themes

Theodorsen’s work is especially significant in that it still plays an important role in current research and technology. The theory of arbitrary airfoils based on conformal mapping developed by Theodorsen, is a model of classical applied mathematics. There is no need to go over this work in any detail as it is now described in many textbooks. It should, however, be pointed out that there are two key concepts that made Theodorsen’s approach different from and a clear improvement on the methods that preceded it such as that of von Mises and von Karman. One was the important use of the complex variable not in the usual form of a polynomial or power series but in the form of an exponential to power series. The equation led directly to the basic boundary value equation which, as an integral equation, represents an exact solution of the problem in terms of the given airfoil data. This solution gave the exact pressure distribution around an airfoil of arbitrary shape. Seldom in aeronautics are solutions “exact”. This is one of the very few. The method has been automated so that complete pressure distributions for a given airfoil section can be obtained in a matter of seconds. The philosophy in Theodorsen’s approach was that an exact formulation is often simpler and preferable to an approximate one and that while approximations are essential in applied mathematics they should be delayed as far as possible. Another topic that merits discussion is Theodorsen’s work on flutter. The approach here is again direct and clean, leading to an explicit exact solution as contrasted with previous implicit and approximate results. This exact flutter solution including results for control surfaces has had a keystone role in the development of flutter methods in the United States. It has enabled an engineering feel for the effects of variables and parameters in complex situations and has been available as a model against which approximate solutions can be compared. Although Theodorsen leaned strongly toward basic theoretical analysis he usually accompanied his work with experimental verification. He was highly innovative in engineering and experimental activities where he always sought a theoretical framework or was guided by physical intuition. He was responsible for proposing a wind tunnel for flutter work which employed a mixture of air and freon with variable pressure to greatly increase the scope of research with aeroelastic models throughout the Mach range and with lower horsepower requirements. The Transonic Dynamics Wind Tunnel now used exclusively for aeroelastic research is based on the same principles. Another unique facility due to Theodorsen was the helicopter rotor tower for aerodynamic and noise research. Ideal propeller dynamics was given a definitive treatment inseveral reports and a book. Theodorsen was the earliest to obtain reliable skin-friction drag data at subsonic, transonic and supersonic speeds. Another significant point is that most of the his contemporary theoretical aerodynamists were located at educational institutions and thus were not involved in practical engineering solutions. Theodorsen, on the other hand, was in addition to his great theoretical contributions an innovative practical engineer which is readily apparent when perusing his work. See attached list of his publications.

Brazil, U.S. Air Force, Republic Aviation and Sikorsky Helicopters

After leaving NACA in 1946 Theodorsen helped to organize and administer the Aeronautical Institute of Brazil (1947-1950). Then he served as Chief Scientist for the U.S. Air Force (1950-1954) during which time he did important work on the structure of turbulence (see below). Theodorsen then became the Chief of Research for the Republic Aviation Corporation (manufacturer of the famous P-47 Thunderbolt fighter plane of WW 2, and after the war the F-84 Thunderjet and the F-105 Thunderchief) a post from which he retired in 1962 when he became an active consultant to the Sikorsky Helicopter Corporation where he specialized in ducted propeller work and helicopter rotors (see patent 2172334 for an example of his work in the field). It was during this time that he proposed an alternative theory of relativity.

Turbulence Theory

A significant development was his contribution to the structure of turbulence in a paper honoring Ludwig Prandtl’s 75th birthday, The universality of turbulence from microphenomena to astrophysics is well known as for example, the hypothesis that the planets have condensed from a gaseous cloud and that the angular momentum of the solar system is a result of the action of viscosity in the nebula. Turbulence remains as the major unsolved domain of fluid mechanics. Theodorsen identified the main turbulence-creating terms in the equations of motion as (q x curl q . curl curl q); he showed that two-dimensional turbulence cannot exist; that vortex lines stretching and bending is the important mechanism and ingredient of turbulence. He also discussed the hierarchy of vortices (Kolmogorov).

Theory of Relativity

Although Theodorsen's life work was in aerodynamics, and he published numerous books and papers in that field, he had other interests. In particular, he wrote a paper, "Relativity and Classical Physics" which sought to show that the results of Einstein's general relativity theory could be obtained without resorting to curved space-time by a modification of Newtonian theory. The paper presents "a successful transformation of the theory of relativity into classical physics... The mathematical entities of the Einstein development have been redefined into rational physical quantities and rearranged in an organized classical framework. Einstein's 'space-time' has been eliminated and replaced by cognitive time." It was published in the Proceedings of the DKNVS Theodorsen Colloquium [Det Kongelige Norske Videnskabers Selskab, "Proceedings of the Theodorsen Colloquium, 1976"] (see "Final Years" below) and on two later occasions [cite book |author=Dowell, E. H.; Theodorsen, Theodore; Garrick, I. E.; Williams, Muriel Theodorsen |title=A Modern view and appreciation of the works of Theodore Theodorsen, physicist and engineer |publisher=American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics |location=New York |year=1992 |pages= |isbn=0-930403-85-1 |oclc= |doi=] [cite journal|title=Relativity and Classical Physics|journal=Galilean Electrodynamics|date=|first=Theodore|last=Theodorsen|coauthors=|year=1995|volume=6|issue=4|pages=63] , but it met with no acceptance.

Final Years

In 1976, [http://www.dknvs.no/indexeng.htm Det Kongelige Norske Videnskabers Selskab] , (The Royal Norwegian Society of Sciences and Letters), held a colloquium in his honor at Trondheim. After a short illness, Dr. Theodorsen passed away in 1978 at the age of eighty one at his home in Centerport, Long Island, New York.

References

* [http://ntrs.nasa.gov/search.jsp?Ns=ArchiveName%7C0&N=0&Ntk=AuthorList&Ntx=mode%20matchall&Ntt=theodorsen List of Publications at NASA]
* [http://scholar.google.com/scholar?as_q=&num=100&btnG=Search+Scholar&as_epq=&as_oq=&as_eq=&as_occt=any&as_sauthors=t-theodorsen&as_publication=&as_ylo=1897&as_yhi=1978&as_allsubj=all&hl=en&lr=&safe=off&as_eq=polyurethane+wood&client=firefox-a List of Publications from Google Scholar]