They Were Not Silent

They Were Not Silent

Infobox Film
name = They Were Not Silent: The Jewish Labor Movement and the Holocaust

image_size =
caption =
director = Roland Millman
producer = Roland Millman
writer =
narrator =
starring =
music =
cinematography =
editing =
distributor =
released = 1998
runtime = 30 min.
country =
language = English
budget =
preceded_by =
followed_by =
website =
amg_id =
imdb_id =

"They were Not Silent" is a documentary about the Jewish Labor Committee's anti-Nazi movement in America before, during and after World War II. The film features rare archival footage and photographs along with interviews with labor veterans, Holocaust survivors and scholars. It explores how the international Jewry worked to help Jews and non-Jews in Germany, Poland and elsewhere in Europe.
The JLC's role has changed over the years. A trade unionist who has focused on JLC history, Kenneth Burt, says he hopes that the documentary will encourage new interest in the organization.


As Hitler was coming to power in Germany in the 1930s, most Americans, struggling with the Great Depression, were preoccupied with their own concerns. Many had an isolationist attitude towards foreign affairs. But many Jewish trade-unionists took notice of the troubling goings-on in Germany, and established the Jewish Labor Committee in New York City in early 1934 to respond to the rise of Nazism. Many of its members were Jewish immigrants who still spoke Yiddish and remained intensely connected to the Eastern European from which they or their parents emigrated. These concerned individuals united to fight against Nazi anti-Semitism for their friends and relatives across the ocean, as well as other potential victims of the Nazis.

“When Hitler came to power most people had one of two feelings,” explains one member of the JLC. Most Americans were either apathetic to German politics because of domestic issues, or they thought that “Hitler was a clown—he’s going to take over power and everyone is going to see he’s a blooming idiot.’”

The founding president of the JLC, B.C. Vladeck, was celebrated as a passionate orator who could rally a crowd with his enthusiasm. As Hitler ascended to power, Vladeck told audiences, “A great silence is descending upon Europe — a silence, like a sinister shroud of death. The instruments of torture that Hitler has prepared for the Jews have been turned on the labor unionists.”

As the JLC grew in size and influence it worked tirelessly to challenge Nazi power. Even before the war began, Jewish leaders worked to send an anti-Nazi message to the American public, especially but not only the American trade union movement, and organized boycotts against German-made goods. United in the struggle, mothers and little old ladies held giant cardboard signs to picket stores selling products that were produced under the Third Reich.

In 1936, the organization petitioned against the United State's participation in the upcoming Olympic games in Germany. When the campaign failed and American athletes traveled across the ocean to compete, the JLC organized the “Counter-Olympics” at Randall’s Island in New York City. Amateur athletes from across the country participated and, perhaps more importantly, the event received extensive nationwide press coverage.

The JLC also were able to help a number of Jews and non-Jews to escape from Europe, and aided a number of anti-Nazi the underground resistance movements there. At the same time that apathetic, isolationist and anti-war Americans were saying things like “Let the Germans fight their battle, they mean nothing to us,” the JLC was busy arranging for aid to get those who would eventually be part of the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising.

Even after the Holocaust was over, the JLC continued to help displaced Jews, sending aid to survivors in refugee camps across the globe, and helping relocate people to the U.S., Canada, Israel and Australia.

The enormous loss of life and destruction of Jewish communities throughout Europe during the Holocaust that came despite the JLC’s best efforts left many members of the JLC feeing dejected. One of the academics interviewed in the movie laments in retrospect that it was “too little, too late,” but takes some solace from the fact that “nonetheless, it was an expression of fraternity and solidarity.”



cite web
last = Schuster
first =Joshua
title = Film details Jewish Laborers' efforts against the Nazis
publisher = The Jewish News Weekly
date = April 22 1999
url =
accessdate = July 25

cite web
last = Malmgreen
first =Gail
title = Labor and the Holocaust: The Jewish Labor Committee and the anti-Nazi Struggle
publisher = New York University
url =
format =
doi =
accessdate = July 25

ee also

*General Jewish Labor Union
*Jewish Labor Committee

External links

* [ They Were Not Silent website]
* [ Jewish Labor Committee official website]
* [ LABOR AND THE HOLOCAUST: The Jewish Labor Committee and the Anti-Nazi Struggle]
* [ Director of the Film's Website]
* [ Production Company Website]
* [ Keith Crane, Composer of the film]

Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Silent Sentinels — The Silent Sentinels were a group of women in favor of women s suffrage organized by Alice Paul to protest in front of the White House during Woodrow Wilson s presidency. The protests started January 10, 1917 and lasted until June 1919 when the… …   Wikipedia

  • Silent Alarm — Studio album by Bloc Party R …   Wikipedia

  • Silent Hill (film) — Silent Hill Promotional poster Directed by Christophe Gans Produced by …   Wikipedia

  • Silent e — is a writing convention in English spelling. A silent letter e at the end of a word often signals a specific pronunciation of the preceding vowel letter, as in the difference between rid /ˈrɪd/ and ride /ˈraɪd/. This orthographic pattern followed …   Wikipedia

  • Not on the Lips — (Pas sur la bouche) Theatrical release poster Directed by Alain Resnais Produced by …   Wikipedia

  • Not On Your Nellie — Series 1 DVD cover Format Comedy Created by Roy Bottomley Tom Brennand …   Wikipedia

  • Silent key — refers to an amateur radio operator who is deceased. [ [ ARRL Silent Key submission guidelines.] Retrieved 10 August 2007] The term can be abbreviated SK , especially in morse code.… …   Wikipedia

  • Silent film — A silent film is a film with no synchronized recorded sound, especially spoken dialogue. The idea of combining motion pictures with recorded sound is nearly as old as film itself, but because of the technical challenges involved, synchronized… …   Wikipedia

  • Silent Hill Homecoming — Infobox VG |title = Silent Hill Homecoming caption = Boxart for Silent Hill Homecoming developer = Konami Digital Entertainment Double Helix Games publisher = Konami distributor = designer = series = Silent Hill engine = released =… …   Wikipedia

  • Silent Valley National Park — Infobox Indian Jurisdiction native name=Silent Valley National Park other name = type= National Park iucn category = II latd = 11|longd=76 latm = 08|longm=28| locator position=left inset inset map size = 75px inset map x = 175px inset map y =… …   Wikipedia