Sherwood v. Walker

Sherwood v. Walker

Sherwood v. Walker is the classic case in contract law of mistake, where the parties were mutually mistaken as to the barrenness of a cow. ["Sherwood v. Walker", 66 Mich. 568, 33 N.W. 919 (1887).] [ [http://www.law.pitt.edu/madison/contracts/supplement/sherwood_v_walker.htm U. of Pittsburgh Law School web site] ]

The case is a staple of first year Law School contract law class discussions and text books. [ [http://www.law.berkeley.edu/faculty/rubinfeldd/LS145/sherwood.html U. Of California, Law School at Berkeley web site citing Cooter and Ulen, 1st Edition (1988)] ] [ [http://academic.udayton.edu/caseslawecon/Contracts/sherwood%20v%20walker.pdf U. of Dayton Law School web site] (Adobe needed)] [ [http://jurist.law.pitt.edu/lessons/lesjun98.htm U. of Pittsburgh Law School web site, Jurist section] ]

A case brief

The case has been extensively briefed online. [ [http://lawschool.mikeshecket.com/contracts/sherwoodvwalker.htm Sherwood v. Walker ] ] [ [http://www.4lawschool.com/contracts/sherwood.shtml Sherwood v. Walker ] ] What follows is a summary of the case briefs.

In May 1886, Hiram Walker, a cattle breeder (and grocer and distiller), made a contract with Theodore Sherwood, another farmer and a banker, to sell him a cow. If the cow was barren (or a heifer), it was worth only about $80 - compared to upwards of $1,000 if it were able to breed, give birth to calves and thus produce tons of milk per year. Sherwood purchased an apparently barren heifer, Rose 2nd of Aberlone for 5.5 cents per pound. Before the exchange was completed, Walker discovered the cow was pregnant and refused to complete the sale. Sherwood sued him. The case was heard in 1887 by the Supreme Court of Michigan.

The issue was, (under Michigan contract law) "Can the defendant (Walker) refuse to sell the cow, because the parties did not know that the cow was actually fertile?"

The court held, that if both parties thought the cow was barren (a question for the jury), the contract was voidable on grounds of mutual mistake.

The court reasoned by using the traditional test of the mistake "relating to the substance of the consideration." In other words, because both parties were mistaken, the consideration failed for the cow as she actually was a cow, not a barren animal or heifer.

References

ee also

* Commercial law
* Contract
* Contract law
* Meeting of the minds
* mistake
* Hiram Walker
* "Bell v. Lever Brothers Ltd."
* "Hartog v. Colin & Shields"
* "Smith v. Hughes"


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужно сделать НИР?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Sherwood Rowland — Frank Sherwood Rowland Pour les articles homonymes, voir Rowland. Frank Sherwood Rowland. Franklin Sherwood Rowland, né le 28 juin …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Walker Lake (Northwest Arctic, Alaska) — Infobox lake lake name = Walker Lake image lake = caption lake = image bathymetry = caption bathymetry = location = Northwest Arctic Borough, Alaska USA coords = Coord|67|7|36|N|154|21|47|W|region:US AK type:waterbody… …   Wikipedia

  • Hiram Walker — (4 July 1816 ndash; 12 January 1899) was an American grocer and distiller, and the eponym of the famous distillery in Windsor, Ontario, Canada directly across from Detroit, Michigan. Walker founded the distillery in 1858 in what was then… …   Wikipedia

  • Williams v. Walker-Thomas Furniture Co. — Williams v. Walker Thomas Furniture Co. , 350 F.2d 445 (C.A. D.C. 1965), was a court opinion, written by J. Skelly Wright, that had a definitive discussion of unconscionability as a defense to enforcement of contracts. As a staple of first year… …   Wikipedia

  • Andrew Walker — Andrew W. Walker (* 9. Juni 1979 in Montréal, Québec) ist ein kanadischer Schauspieler. Inhaltsverzeichnis 1 Leben 2 Filmographie 3 Weblinks 4 …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Niel Walker — Niel Alexander McDonald Walker (22 August 1895 10 August 1960) was a British army officer and a cricketer who played in tournaments in India and for Derbyshire. Walker was born at Poona, Maharashtra, India. At the start of World War I he was at… …   Wikipedia

  • Tim Sherwood — Infobox Football biography playername = Tim Sherwood fullname = Timothy Sherwood nickname = height = height|ft=6|in=0 dateofbirth = birth date and age|1969|2|2|df=y cityofbirth = St Albans countryofbirth = England currentclub = clubnumber =… …   Wikipedia

  • Adrian Maxwell Sherwood — (* 1958 in London) ist ein britischer Musikproduzent und hat die Entwicklung des Dub maßgeblich beeinflusst. Seine Karriere begann mit der Zusammenarbeit mit Musikern wie Emperor Rosko, Judge Dread, Johnny Walker und Steve Barnard. Mit siebzehn… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Adrian Sherwood — Adrian Maxwell Sherwood (* 1958 in London) ist ein britischer Musikproduzent und hat die Entwicklung des Dub maßgeblich beeinflusst. Seine Karriere begann mit der Zusammenarbeit mit Musikern wie Emperor Rosko, Judge Dread, Johnny Walker und Steve …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Bobby Sherwood — Robert J. „Bobby“ Sherwood (* 30. Mai 1914 in Indianapolis, Indiana); † 23. Januar 1980 in Auburn, Massachusetts) war ein US amerikanischer Jazzmusiker (Banjo, Gitarre, Trompete und Posaune), Arrangeur und Bigband Leader im Bereich des Swing und… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”