Leslie Herron

Sir Leslie James Herron, KBE, CMG (May 22 1902 - May 3 1973) was a prominent Australian barrister, judge, chief justice and lieutenant governor of New South Wales. Biographer Martha Rutledge describes him as being “interested, interesting and with a lively sense of humour”, but that he “conducted his court with consideration, dignity and mercy”. [ADB]

Early years

Herron was born on 22 May 1902 in the Sydney suburb of Mosman, to Henry Herron and Emily Ethel (nee Downie). Leslie was the second of six siblings. He was educated at the Church of England Preparatory School, Mosman, at the Sydney Grammar School and at the University of Sydney. He obtained an LL.B in 1924 with second class honours. Herron played first-grade rugby union in the position of “breakaway” for the Sydney club Western Suburbs Football Club between 1922 to 1925.

Herron was admitted to the New South Wales bar on 28 August 1925 and practiced in common law on the “Northern Circuit” of New South Wales. He married Andree Lorna on 6 January 1930 at St James Anglican Church in the centre of Sydney on 6 January 1930. He took silk as a Kings Counsel (KC) in 20 December 1939.

Judicial career

Herron was appointed as an acting judge of the District Court of New South Wales in February 1939. The District Court is a middle ranking court in New South Wales and at the time was a civil court. On 10 February 1941, Herron was appointed as a judge of the Supreme Court of New South Wales, the state’s highest ranking court.

Herron served as a royal commissioner in the 1958 Royal Commission of Inquiry into statements made by the Auditor-General in his annual report for the year 30 June 1958 concerning the Minister for Housing, the Honourable Abram Landa. [cite web|accessdate=2007-05-21 |url=http://www.records.nsw.gov.au/cguide/c2/com&inq7.htm#E10E82
title=Royal Commission of Inquiry into statements made by the Auditor-General in his annual report for the year 30 June 1958 concerning the Minister for Housing, the Honourable Abram Landa, 1958
work=Concise Guide to the State Archives (Commissions - Cor) : Commissions and Inquiries
publisher=State Records, New South Wales] In 1961, Herron became the chairman of the Law Reform Committee.

From March 1962, Herron served as acting chief justice of the Supreme Court of New South Wales due to the illness of the then chief justice Doc Evatt. On Evatt’s resignation, Herron was permanently appointed as chief justice on 25 October 1962. [ADB] Herron was to serve as chief justice during a time of structural change in the Supreme Court. In 1965, the New South Wales Government established the Court of Appeal to replace the Full Court of the Supreme Court. This new court was to be the first court of its kind in Australia. The government however appointed a junior judge of the court, Justice Wallace, to be the first president of the new Court of Appeal. This made Wallace the second most senior judge of the Supreme Court. This appointment was resented by some of the other judges of the court and led to a schism in the bench, which was not fixed until Justice Sugerman replaced Wallace upon his retirement. It led to certain judges refusing to sit with other judges which created its own tensions. [Slattery, paragraph 58]

Notable cases

One of the legally significant cases Herron was involved with was "R v Cuthbert". [(1967) 86 WN (Pt. 1) (NSW) 272 ] This case laid out the rationale upon which a society inflicts punishment upon offenders when they contravene the law and commit a criminal offence. Herron said at 274:'The function of the criminal law and the purposes of punishment cannot be found in any single explanation, for it depends both upon the nature and type of offence and the offender. But all purposes may be reduced under the single heading of the protection of society, the protection of the community from crime. The sentence should be such as, having regard to all proved circumstances, seems at the same time to accord with the general moral sense of the community and to be likely to be a sufficient deterrent both to the prisoner and others: per Jordan CJ, "R. v. Geddes". [(1936) 36 SR (NSW) 554] Courts have not infrequently attempted further analysis of the several aspects of punishment ("Reg v. Goodrich"), [(1952) 70 WN (NSW) 42] where retribution, deterrence and reformation are said to be its threefold purposes. In reality they are but the means employed by the Court for the attainment of the single purpose of the protection of society'. [cite web|accessdate=2007-05-21
title=Chapter Five: The Argument Against Mandatory Sentencing
author=Ruth McColl SC |url=http://www.samuelgriffith.org.au/papers/html/volume%2012/v12chap5.htm
work=Proceedings of the Twelfth Conference of The Samuel Griffith Society
date=10-12 November 2000] Herron also presided in the trial of notorious Sydney identity Darcy Duggan. Duggan and William Cecil Mears were convicted by Herron for a bungled hold-up of the Commonwealth Bank at Ultimo in Sydney. Mears shot the bank manage Leslie Nalder, and both Duggan and Mears were charged with wounding with intent to murder. Herron sentenced both to death, but both sentences were commuted. [cite news|accessdate=2007-05-21| title=Larrikin thief's last gamble marks his grave |author=Stephen Gibbs
work=Sydney Morning Herald|date=6 November 2002
url= http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2002/11/05/1036308311457.html] Duggan and Mears were eventually paroled.

Herron was involved in hearing the criminal charges against Charles Ivan le Gallien. Le Gallien was sentenced to life imprisonment for murder. Herron received a death threat as a result of this trial, and was given police protection as a result. [ADB]

Civic activities

Herron was heavily involved in civic activities in Australia. Herron was the president of the Australian Golf Club between 1944 and 1973. He was the president of the New South Wales Rugby Union between 1943 and 1956. He was elected as the first chairman of the Australian Rugby Football Union was that body was first started on 25 November 1949. [cite web
title=History of the ARU
publisher=Australian Rugby Website |accessdate=2007-05-21|url=http://www.rugby.com.au/about_the_aru/history_of_the_aru/history_of_the_aru,183.html] . He subsequently in 1957 was chairman of the International Rugby Football Board which is based in London. He was president of the New South Wales Amateur Swimming Association between 1949 and 1964. He was chairman of the Sydney Cricket Ground Trust between 1970 to 1972. Herron was the founding vice-president of Australian Neurological Foundation (now called the Brain Foundation) established in 1970. Herron was involved with fundraising for St Vincent's Hospital at Sydney, the Mater Misericordiae hospital in North Sydney, the National Heart Foundation, the Freedom from Hunger Campaign, the Central Methodist Mission, the Salvation Army and the Bush Children's Hostels Foundation of New South Wales. He was president of the New South Wales branch of the St John Ambulance Association. He was also a member of the New South Wales Olympic Council. [ADB]

Honours

New South Wales Rugby Union established the Sir Leslie Herron Scholarship in 2004 to support young players in the competition. [cite web|accessdate=2007-05-21|title=Sir Leslie Herron Scholarship
publisher=NSW Rugby Website |url=http://www.nswrugby.com.au/MediaExtranet/News/2004/November/SirLeslieHerronScholarship.aspx] . Herron was appointed a knight of the Order of St John in 1964 for his work in the St Johns Ambulance. He was named 'Father of the Year' by the Australian Father Day Council in 1963. [cite web|accessdate=2007-05-21|url=http://www.fatheroftheyear.com.au/content/view/15/41/
title=History of the Award|work=Australian Father of the Year] . He was appointed C.M.G. in 1964 and K.B.E. in 1966, and in 1972 received the second honorary LL.D awarded by the University of New South Wales. [cite web|accessdate=2007-05-21
url=http://www.lawlink.nsw.gov.au/lawlink/supreme_court/ll_sc.nsf/pages/SCO_cjherron
title=The Honourable Sir Leslie James Herron, K.B.E., C.M.G., K.St.J.
publisher=Supreme Court New South Wales]

Later years

Upon reaching the mandatory retirement age for judges in 1972, Herron remarked that he had reached 'the age of statutory senility' as he was no longer considered competent to work as a judge. Herron worked on a legal aid scheme and was the Administrator of the New South Wales government in the absence of the governor Sir Roden Cutler on an official visit to the United Kingdom between 11 April 1973 and until the date of his death on 3 May 1973 in St Vincent's Hospital, Darlinghurst. [cite book| accessdate=2007-05-21
title=Parliamentary Record: Legislative Council and Legislative Assembly (1824 – 2003)
edition=1st Edition, Volume VII
url=http://www.parliament.nsw.gov.au/prod/parlment/members.nsf/0/E40E428435AC95A84A25684800178F37/$File/Parliamentary%20Record%20(Volume%20VII).pdf
format=PDF] .

References

Footnotes

ources

*cite web|accessdate=2007-05-21|url=http://www.adb.online.anu.edu.au/biogs/A140508b.htm
author=Martha Rutledge|title=Herron, Sir Leslie James (1902 - 1973)
work=Australian Dictionary of Biography|publisher=Australian National University, Melbourne University Press |date=1996|pages=Volume 14, pages 441-442

*

* cite web|accessdate=2007-05-21
title=Address to the Judges of the Supreme Court
author=Hon Justice Slattery
url=http://www.forbessociety.org.au/documents/slattery.pdf
format=PDF

Persondata
NAME=Herron, Leslie James
ALTERNATIVE NAMES=
SHORT DESCRIPTION=Australian barrister, judge, chief justice and lieutenant governor of New South Wales
DATE OF BIRTH=22 May 1902
PLACE OF BIRTH=Mosman, New South Wales, Australia
DATE OF DEATH=3 May 1973
PLACE OF DEATH=Darlinghurst, New South Wales