Boldt Decision


Boldt Decision

"United States v. Washington", 384 F.Supp. 312 (W.D. Wash. 1974) better known as the "Boldt Decision", was a controversial 1974 court case which affirmed the right of most of the tribes in the U.S. state of Washington to continue to harvest salmon. Many opponents of this case couch it as a "grant" of rights to the tribes. More accurately, the decision was simply affirming that when the Tribes released their interest in the millions of acres of land in Washington State through a series of treaties signed in 1854 and 1855, they reserved the right to continue fishing. For example, the (1854) includes the following language: "The right of taking fish, at all usual and accustomed grounds and stations, is further secured to said Indians in common with all citizens of the Territory." Most of the treaties negotiated by Territorial Governor Isaac Stevens included this, or very similar, language.

To interpret this article of these treaties, United States District Court Judge Boldt looked at the minutes of the treaty negotiations to determine the meaning of "in common with" as the United States described it to the Tribes, and determined that the United States intended for there to be an equal sharing of the fish resource between the Tribes and the settlers.

Of this, Judge Boldt wrote: "By dictionary definition and as intended and used in the Indian treaties and in this decision, 'in common with' means sharing equally the opportunity to take fish…therefore, non-treaty fishermen shall have the opportunity to take up to 50% of the harvestable number of fish…and treaty right fishermen shall have the opportunity to take up to the same percentage."

The decision was the culmination of years of State of Washington limitation of treaty fishing by the Tribes, resulting in the United States suing the State of Washington to force the state to comply with the treaties. It was immediately met with shock and outrage by non-Native fishermen, but the ruling has held for more than 30 years.

Today, the Tribes of Washington State are equal partner with the State of Washington in both harvest and management of the fishery resource. The Tribes have spent hundreds of millions of dollars since the Boldt Decision in efforts to protect and enhance the salmon, shellfish and hunting resources of the State.

See also

* Sohappy v. Smith: a similar case in Oregon

External links

* [http://www.nwifc.org/aboutus/documents/BoldtDecision8.5x11layoutforweb.pdf Boldt Decision]
* [http://www.historylink.org/essays/output.cfm?file_id=5282 Federal Judge George Boldt issues historic ruling affirming Native American treaty fishing rights on February 12, 1974.] Article from historylink.org.
* [http://kohary.com/env/bill_020799.html 25 years after the Boldt Decision: The fish tale that changed history.] Article from Seattle Times.


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Boldt (Disambiguation) — Boldt may refer to*George Boldt (1851 1916), Prussian born entrepreneur *Gerhardt Boldt (1918 1981), German officer and author *Paul Boldt (1885 1921), German poet *Laurence Boldt, author *Sidney Boldt Christmas (*1924), Swedish sailor *Harry… …   Wikipedia

  • Duwamish (tribe) — infobox ethnic group group = Duwamish caption = poptime =About 253 (1854); about 400 enrolled members (1991), about 500 (2004). [(1) Gibbs ( [1877] , 1967) (1.1) D Wamish on the Lake Fork of the D Wamish River, 152; Sa ma mish (Sammamish) and S… …   Wikipedia

  • Duwamish tribe — Duwamish Duwamish territory shown highlighted in green. Orange blocks are modern Indian Reservations Total population About 253 (1854); about 400 enrolled members (1991), about 500 (2004).[1] …   Wikipedia

  • Puget Sound environmental issues — articleissues POV = December 2007 copyedit = January 2007 citationstyle = October 2008The environmental health of Puget Sound, Washington has a diverse and complex history related to a long, involved relationship with marine and freshwater… …   Wikipedia

  • Treaty of Point Elliott — The Treaty of Point Elliott of 1855, or the Point Elliott Treaty, [The treaty is entitled and listed in catalogs and archives as the Treaty of Point Elliott, 1855 .] is the lands settlement treaty between the United States government and the… …   Wikipedia

  • Robert Satiacum — Robert (Bob) Satiacum (1929–1991) was Puyallup tribal leader, and an advocate of native treaty fishing rights.Satiacum first came to the public attention in 1954, when he was arrested for illegally fishing in the Puyallup River in Tacoma,… …   Wikipedia

  • Duwamish — Traditionelles Stammesgebiet der Duwamish und heutige Reservationen im Nordwesten der USA (orange) Die Duwamish sind ein im Westen des US Bundesstaats Washington lebender indianischer Stamm. Sie sprechen einen Dialekt der südwestlichen Küsten… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Küsten-Salish — Sprachgruppen des Küsten Salish Als Küsten Salish wird eine Gruppe von indianischen Ethnien bezeichnet, die an der Pazifikküste Nordamerikas in British Columbia, Washington und Oregon lebt. Sie gehört sprachlich zur Familie des Salish, kulturell… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Muckleshoot — Die Muckleshoot sind ein im US Bundesstaat Washington lebender indianischer Stamm, der sich als Muckleshoot Indian Tribe bezeichnet. Dessen Angehörige sprechen einen Dialekt der südwestlichen Küsten Salish und leben am Puget Sound und den… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Sauk-Suiattle — Die Sauk Suiattle (früher auch Sah Ku Me Hu) sind ein im Nordwesten des US Bundesstaat Washington lebender indianischer Stamm, der früher zu den Upper Skagit gehörte. Sie lebten am Sauk und Suiattle River, Nebenflüssen des Skagit Rivers. Die Sauk …   Deutsch Wikipedia


Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.