The Forgotten Soldier

The Forgotten Soldier

"The Forgotten Soldier" is presented as an autobiographical account by a veteran under the name Guy Sajer of World War II as experienced on Germany's Eastern front. The historical accuracy of Sajer's autobiographical work has been questioned, with proponents on both sides.

The book, in reference to the autobiographical soldier's ambiguous relationship to war and its passions, has been called "the account of a disastrous love affair with war and with the army that, of all modern armies, most loved war", being written with the "admiration of a semi-outsider" (an Alsatian in a German unit). [" [http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,904688-1,00.html Up the Down Steppes] " - "Time", Monday, 25 January 1971]

A movie adaption of The Forgotten Soldier is currently in production. Paul Verhoeven is attached to direct the film. cite web |url=http://www.screendaily.com/ScreenDailyArticle.aspx?intStoryID=39936&strSearch=forgotten%20soldier&strCallingPage=ScreenDailySearchSite.aspx |title= 3

Controversy

The accuracy of the book has been disputed by historians. Some details in the book are cited as incorrect (such as reference to subunits of the Großdeutschland Division that never existed) while other details are simply not verifiable (while the names of some officers don't appear on official rolls in the Bundesarchiv, these records are far from complete). The inaccuracies which have been cited may have very well been a result of poor memory or as possibly due to mistranslations from the original French text, to English (or from French to German to English).

In defense of the book, there are many very accurate references in the book, such as bunkers on otherwise unknown beaches which exist to this day, and descriptions of towns and terrain which would be unknown to someone unless they had actually been there. One of the more compelling arguments is a reference to and accurate description of a ship called the "Pretoria" (later named the "GUNUNG DJATI"), which the author places in Hel on March 28th or 29th of 1945. This ship was in fact purchased by the Kriegsmarine at the start of the war and used to evacuate areas around the Baltic at this precise time. The ships logs record leaving Hel at 9:00 AM on the morning of the 30th. And finally, the comrade of the author ("Halls") who is referred throughout the book has been identified, contacted, and has verified Guy Sajer's account.Fact|date=April 2007

See the external links below for summaries of the opposition to the notion that the book is factual.

Some commentators have suggested that given the controversy surrounding the historical accuracy of the book, "The Forgotten Soldier" shouldn't be taken as an historical book of the Großdeutschland but rather a book about Guy Sajer's experiences during the Second World War. This has also been the advice of the author since, as he says, he did not try to write a history book, but a book of his own experiences.

Despite the recent critique from mostly U.S. military historians, it is still considered to be a genuine autobiography by the U.S. Army Command and General Staff College and has remained on their recommended reading list for World War II. [ [http://www-cgsc.army.mil/carl/resources/csi/berlin/berlin.asp#World%20War%20II Historical Bibliography No. 8: Military Classics ] ] Apart from being recommended in the United States, it is a recommended read for insights in the personal experience of war in many armies around the world.

External links

* [http://www.warfarehq.com/index.php?page=articles/wargame_articles/forgotten_soldier.shtml Two articles presenting reasons to doubt the accuracy of the book]
* [http://members.shaw.ca/grossdeutschland/sajer.htm LANDSER article on The Forgotten Soldier controversy]

References


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем сделать НИР

Look at other dictionaries:

  • The Good Soldier — for other uses, see The Good Soldier (disambiguation) The Good Soldier   Author(s) Ford Madox Ford …   Wikipedia

  • Monument to the Unknown Soldier, Sofia — Monument to the Unknown Soldier Паметник на Незнайния воин Bulgaria Monument to the Unknown Soldier …   Wikipedia

  • The Summoner — (2007) is the first novel in the Chronicles of the Necromancer series by Gail Z. Martin. The story follows Prince Martris ( Tris ) Drayke and his companions on a quest to take back their kingdom after it is seized by Tris s older brother. With so …   Wikipedia

  • The Two Kings' Children — is a German fairy tale collected by the Brothers Grimm in Grimm s Fairy Tales , tale number 113.Jacob and Wilheim Grimm, Household Tales , [http://www.surlalunefairytales.com/authors/grimms/113twokingschildren.html The Two Kings Children ] ] It… …   Wikipedia

  • The Culpepper Cattle Co. — The Culpepper Cattle Co. Promotional poster for The Culpepper Cattle Co. Directed by Dick Richards …   Wikipedia

  • The Whole Truth (TV series) — The Whole Truth Genre Drama Starring Rob Morrow Maura Tierney …   Wikipedia

  • Ride of the Valkyries — The Ride of the Valkyries ( de. Walkürenritt), is the popular term for the beginning of Act III of Die Walküre by Richard Wagner. The main theme of the ride, the leitmotif labelled Walkürenritt was first written down by the composer on 23 July… …   Wikipedia

  • The Life and Extraordinary Adventures of Private Ivan Chonkin — infobox Book | name = The Life and Extraordinary Adventures of Private Ivan Chonkin title orig = Жизнь и необычайные приключения солдата Ивана Чонкина translator = image caption = author = Vladimir Voinovich illustrator = cover artist = country …   Wikipedia

  • The Holocaust — Holocaust and Shoah redirect here. For other uses, see Holocaust (disambiguation) and Shoah (disambiguation). Selection on …   Wikipedia

  • The War Game — For the Doctor Who serial, see The War Games. Infobox Film name = The War Game amg id = 1:53327 imdb id = 0059894 writer = Peter Watkins starring = Michael Aspel Peter Graham director = Peter Watkins distributor = BBC released = 1 November 1965… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”