- Georgian Affair
The Georgian Affair of 1922 ( _ru. Грузинское дело) was a political conflict within the Soviet leadership about the way in which social and political transformation was to be achieved in the
Georgian SSR. The dispute over Georgia, which arose shortly after the forcible Sovietization of the country and peaked in the latter part of 1922, involved local Georgian Bolshevikleaders, led by Filipp Makharadzeand Budu Mdivani, on one hand, and their de factosuperiors from the Russian SFSR, particularly Joseph Stalinand Sergo Ordzhonikidze, on the other hand. The content of this dispute was complex, involving the Georgians’ desire to preserve autonomy from Moscowand the differing interpretations of Bolshevik nationality policies, and especially those specific to Georgia. One of the main points at issue was Moscow’s decision to amalgamate Georgia, Armenia and Azerbaijan into Transcaucasian SFSR, a move that was staunchly opposed by the Georgian leaders who urged for their republic a full-member status within the Soviet Union.
The affair was a critical episode in the power struggle surrounding the sick
Vladimir Leninwhose support Georgians sought to obtain. The dispute ended with the victory of the Stalin-Ordzhonikidze line and resulted in the fall of the Georgian moderate Communist government. It also contributed to a final break between Lenin and Stalin, and inspired Lenin’s last major writings.Smith, Jeremy (May, 1998), The Georgian Affair of 1922. Policy Failure, Personality Clash or Power Struggle? " Europe-Asia Studies", Vol. 50, No. 3, pp. 519-544.]
The Soviet rule in Georgia was established by the Soviet
Red Armyduring the February-March 1921 military campaign that was largely engineered by the two influential Georgia-born Soviet Russian officials, Joseph Stalin, then People's Commissarfor Nationalities for the RSFSR, and Sergo Ordzhonikidze, head of the Transcaucasian Regional Committee ("Zaikkraikom") of the Russian Communist Party. Disagreements among the Bolsheviks about the fate of Georgia preceded the Red Army invasion. While Stalin and Ordzhonikidze urged the immediate Sovietization of independent Georgia led by the Menshevik-dominated government, Trotsky favored "a certain preparatory period of work inside Georgia, in order to develop the uprising and later come to its aid." Lenin was unsure about the outcome of the Georgian campaign, fearful of the international consequences and the possible crisis with Kemalist Turkey. Lenin finally gave his consent, on February 14, 1921, to the intervention in Georgia, but later repeatedly complained about the lack of precise and consistent information from the Caucasus.Suny, Ronald Grigor (1994), "The Making of the Georgian Nation: 2nd edition", pp. 210-212. Indiana University Press, ISBN 0-253-20915-3] Well aware of widespread opposition to the newly established Soviet rule, Lenin favored a reconciliatory policy with Georgian intelligentsia and peasants who remained hostile to the militarily imposed regime. However, many Communists found difficult to abandon the methods exploited against their opposition during the Russian Civil Warand make adjustment to the more flexible policy. For moderates like Filipp MakharadzeLenin’s approach was a reasonable way to secure for Soviet power a broad base of support. They advocated tolerance toward the Menshevik opposition, greater democracy within the party, gradual land reform, and above all, respect for national sensitivities and Georgia’s sovereignty from Moscow. Communists like Ordzhonikidze and Stalin pursued more hardliner policy; they sought to completely eliminate political opposition and centralize party control over the newly Sovietized republics.Knight, Ami W. (1993), "Beria: Stalin's First Lieutenant", p . 26-27. Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey, ISBN 0691010935]
"National deviationism" vs. "Great Russian nationalism"
Conflict soon broke out between the moderate and hardliner Georgian Bolshevik leaders. The dispute was preceded by Stalin’s ban on formation of the national Red Army of Georgia, and subordination of all local workers’ organizations and
trade unions to the Bolshevik party committees. Dissatisfied by the Soviet Georgian government’s moderate treatment of the political opposition and its desire to retain sovereignty from Moscow, Stalin arrived in Tbilisi, capital of Georgia, in early July 1921. After summoning a workers' assembly, Stalin delivered a speech outlining a program aimed at elimination of local nationalism, but was booed by the crowd and received hostile silence from his colleagues. Lang, David Marshall (1962). "A Modern History of Georgia", p. 238. London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson.] Within the days that followed, Stalin removed the Georgian Revolutionary committeechief Makharadze for inadequate firmness and replaced him with Budu Mdivani, ordering local leaders to "crush the hydra of nationalism." Makharadze’s supporters, including the Georgian Chekachief Kote Tsintsadzeand his lieutenants, were also sacked and replaced with more ruthless officers Kvantaliani, Atabekov, and Lavrentiy Beria.
Within less than a year, however, Stalin was in open conflict with Mdivani, and his associates. One of the most important points at issue was the question of Georgia’s status in the projected union of Soviet republics. While Moscow’s envoys, led by Sergo Ordzhonikidze and strongly backed by Stalin, insisted that all three
Transcaucasian republics – Armenia, Azerbaijan, and Georgia – join the Soviet Uniontogether as one federative republic, the Georgians wanted their country to retain an individual identity and enter the union as a full member rather than as part of a single Transcaucasian SFSR. Stalin and his henchmen accused the local Georgian Communists of selfish nationalism and labeled them as "national deviationists". On their part, the Georgians responded with charges of "Great Russian chauvinism". Lenin suddenly upheld Stalin’s position and expressed his strong support for the political and economic integration of the Transcaucasian republics, informing the Georgian leaders that he rejected their criticism of Moscow’s bullying tactics.
The conflict peaked in November 1922, when Ordzhonikidze resorted to physical violence with a member of the Mdivani group and struck him during a verbal confrontation. [Kort, M (2001), "The Soviet Colossus", p.154. M.E. Sharpe, ISBN 0765603969] The Georgian leaders complained to Lenin and presented a long list of abuses, including the notorious incident involving Ordzhonikidze.
Lenin was no longer able to overlook the bitterness of the conflict in Georgia and unleashed his criticism upon Ordzhonikidze. In late November 1922, he dispatched the
VeChekachief Dzerzhinsky to Tbilisi to investigate the matter. Dzerzhinsky sympathized with Stalin and Ordzhonikidze and, hence, tried to give Lenin a significantly smoothened picture of their activities in his report. However, Lenin's doubts about the conduct of Stalin and his allies around the Georgian question mounted. He was also afraid of negative outcry that might ensue abroad and in other Soviet republics. In late December 1922, Lenin accepted that both Ordzhonikidze and Stalin were guilty of the imposition of Great Russian nationalism upon non-Russian nationalities.Thatcher, Ian D. (2003), "Trotsky", p. 122. Routledge, ISBN 0415232503] He now considered Stalin and his forceful centralizing policy increasingly dangerous and decided to dissociate himself at once from his protégé.
Nevertheless, Lenin’s misgivings over the Georgian problem were not fundamental, and as his health deteriorated, the Georgian leaders were left without any major ally, watching Georgia being pressed into the Transcaucasian federation that signed a treaty with the
Russian SFSR, Ukraine and Belarus, joining them all in a new Soviet Union on December 30, 1922. [Lieven, Dominic C. B.; Perrie Maureen; Suny, Ronald Grigor (ed., 2006), "The Cambridge History of Russia", p. 175.]
The end of the affair
On March 5, 1923, Lenin broke off personal relations with Stalin. He attempted to enlist
Leon Trotskyto take over the Georgian problem, and began preparing three notes and a speech, where he would announce to the Party Congress that Stalin would be removed as Secretary General. [McNeal, Robert H. (1959), Lenins Attack on Stalin: Review and Reappraisal, American Slavic and East European Review, 18 (3): 295-314] However, on March 9, 1923 Lenin suffered a third stroke, which would eventually lead to his death. Trotsky declined to confront Stalin on the issue probably due to his long-held prejudice against Georgia as a Menshevik stronghold, At the 12th Party Congress in April 1923, the Georgian Communists found themselves isolated. With Lenin’s notes suppressed, every word uttered from the platform against Georgian or Ukrainian nationalism was greeted with stormy applause, while the mildest allusion to Great Russian chauvinism was received in stony silence. [Lang (1962), p. 243.]
Thus, Lenin’s illness, Stalin’s increasing influence in the party and his assent toward full power, coupled with the sidelining of Leon Trotsky led to the marginalization of the decentralist forces within the Georgian Communist party.Cornell, Svante E. (2002), [http://www.silkroadstudies.org/new/inside/publications/0419dissertation.pdf "Autonomy and Conflict: Ethnoterritoriality and Separatism in the South Caucasus – Case in Georgia"] , pp. 141-144. Department of Peace and Conflict Research, University of Uppsala, ISBN 91-506-1600-5]
The affair held back the careers of the Georgian
Old Bolsheviks, but Ordzhonikidze’s reputation also suffered and was soon recalled from the Caucasus. Mdivani and his associates were removed to minor posts, but they were not actively molested until the late 1920s. Most of them were later executed during the Great Purgeof the 1930s. Another major consequence of the defeat of Georgian "national deviationists" was the intensification of political repressions in Georgia, leading to an armed rebellion in August 1924 and the ensuing Red Terrorwhich took several thousands of lives.
*cite journal | author=Jones, Stephen F. | title= The Establishment of Soviet Power in Transcaucasia: The Case of Georgia 1921-1928 | journal=
Soviet Studies| month=October | year=1988 | volume=40, No. 4 | pages=616–639 | url=http://links.jstor.org/sici?sici=0038-5859%28198810%2940%3A4%3C616%3ATEOSPI%3E2.0.CO%3B2-C&size=LARGE | issue= 4
*Ogden, Dennis George (1978), "National Communism in Georgia: 1921-1923", The
University of Michigan(doctoral dissertation)
Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.
Look at other dictionaries:
Georgian wine — Georgia is the oldest wine producing region of Europe, if not the world.Fact|date=July 2008 Because of this, it is often referred to as The birth place of wine or The cradle of wine making .Fact|date=July 2008 The fertile valleys of the South… … Wikipedia
Mingrelian Affair — The Mingrelian Affair, or Mingrelian Case (Russian: Мингрельское дело, mingrel’skoe delo; Georgian: მეგრელთა საქმე, megrelt’a sak’me) was a series of criminal cases fabricated in 1951 and 1952 in order to accuse several members of the Georgian… … Wikipedia
Nazino affair — Map of the Nazino area The Nazino affair was the mass deportation of 6,000 people, 4,000 of whom died, on Nazino Island (Russian: Остров Назино) in the Soviet Union in 1933. The small, isolated Western Siberian island is located about 800 km… … Wikipedia
Joseph Stalin — Stalin redirects here. For other uses, see Stalin (disambiguation). Joseph Stalin Russian: Иосиф Виссарионович Сталин Georgian: იოსებ ბესარიონის ძე სტალინი … Wikipedia
Red Army invasion of Georgia — Infobox Military Conflict conflict=Red Army invasion of Georgia caption=The Transcaucasus Campaign of 1921. date=1921 place=South Caucasus (Transcaucasus) result=Soviet Turkish victory; establishment of the Georgian SSR combatant1= combatant2=… … Wikipedia
Khrushchev Thaw — The Khrushchev Thaw (or Khrushchev s Thaw; in Russian Khrushchovskaya Ottepel or simply Ottepel; Russian: Хрущёвская оттепель, Russian pronunciation: [xruɕˈɕovskəjɐ ˈotʲɪpʲelʲ]) refers to the period from the mid 1950s to the early 1960s,… … Wikipedia
Polikarp Mdivani — Polikarp Budu Mdivani ( ka. პოლიკარპე [ბუდუ] მდივანი; ru. Поликарп Гургенович [Буду] Мдивани, Polikarp Gurgenovich [Budu] Mdivani ) (1877 – July 19, 1937) was a veteran Georgian Bolshevik and Soviet government official energetically involved in… … Wikipedia
Nadezhda Alliluyeva — Grave at Novodevichy Cemetery under protective covering … Wikipedia
Filipp Makharadze — Filipp Makaradze (Georgian: ფილიპე მახარაძე, Russian: Филипп Махарадзе) (1868–1941) was a Bolshevik revolutionary and government official. Life Born in the village of Shemokmedi (Guria, Georgia), he studied at the Theological Seminary in Tbilisi… … Wikipedia
Eastern Bloc — Map of the Eastern Bloc … Wikipedia