- 1947–1948 Civil War in Mandatory Palestine
Infobox Military Conflict
conflict=Civil War in Palestine (1947-1948)
1948 Palestine war
date=30 November 1947 - 14 May 1948
British Mandate of Palestine
caption=Jewish soldiers defending
1948 Palestinian exodusand Israeli Declaration of Independencewhich lead to the start of the 1948 Arab-Israeli War.
Jewsof Palestine( Haganah, Palmach, Irgun, Lehi)
Arabsof Palestine( Army of Holy War, Arab Liberation Army)
United Kingdommilitary forces in Palestine
Yigael Yadin, Lt-Gnl Yigal Allon, Menachem Begin
Abd al-Qadir al-Husayni, Fawzi al-Qawuqji
strength1=A few thousands beginning of December to 35,000 on 14 May
strength2=A few tens of thousands
strength3=Around 70,000 beginning of December to total withdrawal on 14 May
casualties1=1/4 : 895Yoav Gelber (2006), p.85] 15/5 : ~ 2000 [
Benny Morris, "The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem Revisited, 2004, p.35.]
casualties2=1/4 : 991
casualties3=1/4 : 123
notes= The 1947-1948 Civil War in the Mandatory Palestine lasted from 30 November 1947, with the
United Nationsvote in favour of the termination of the British Mandate of Palestineand the UN Partition Plan, to 14 May 1948, with the termination of the British Mandate itself.
This period constitutes the first phase of the
1948 Palestine war, during which the Jewish and Arab communities of Palestine clashed, while the British, who supposedly had the obligation to maintain order, organized their withdrawal and intervened only on an occasional basis.
The next phase of the conflict was the
1948 Arab-Israeli Warwhich began on the 15 May 1948, on the termination of the British Mandate of Palestine and the creation of the State of Israel, when the conflict in Palestinebecame an outright war between the new State of Israel and its Arab neighbours.
In the immediate aftermath of the
United Nations' approval of the Partition plan, the explosions of joy amongst the Jewish community were counterbalanced by the expression of discontent amongst the Arab community. Soon after, violence broke out and became more and more prevalent. Murders, reprisals, and counter-reprisals came fast on each other's heels, resulting in dozens of victims killed on both sides in the process. The sanguinary impasse persisted as no force intervened to put a stop to the escalating cycles of violence.
During the first two months of the war, around 1,000 people were killed and 2,000 people injured. [Special UN commission (16 April 1948), § II.5] By the end of March, the figure had risen to 2,000 dead and 4,000 wounded. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.85] These figures correspond to an average of more than 100 deaths and 200 casualties per week; in a population of 2,000,000.
From January onwards, operations became increasingly militarized, with the intervention of a number of
Arab Liberation Armyregiments inside Palestine, each active in a variety of distinct sectors around the different coastal towns. They consolidated their presence in Galileeand Samaria. [Yoav Gelber (2006), pp.51-56] Abd al-Qadir al-Husaynicame from Egypt with several hundred men of the Army of Holy War. Having recruited a few thousands of volunteers, al-Husayni organised the blockade of the 100,000 Jewish residents of Jerusalem. [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), chap.7, pp.131-153] To counter this, the Yishuv authorities tried to supply the city with convoys of up to 100 armoured vehicles, but the operation became more and more impractical as the number of casualties in the relief convoys surged. By March, Al-Hussayni's tactic had paid off. Almost all of Haganah's armoured vehicles had been destroyed, the blockade was in full operation, and hundreds of Haganah members who had tried to bring supplies into the city were killed. [Benny Morris (2003), p.163] The situation for those who dwelt in the Jewish settlements in the highly-isolated Negevand North of Galilee was even more critical.
While the Jewish population had received strict orders requiring them to hold their ground everywhere at all costs, [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), p.163] the Arab population was more affected by the general conditions of insecurity to which the country was exposed. Up to 100,000 Palestinians, from the urban upper and middle classes in Haifa, Jaffa and Jerusalem, or Jewish-dominated areas, evacuated abroad or to Arab centres eastwards. [Benny Morris (2003), p.67]
This situation caused the
USAto withdraw their support for the Partition plan, thus encouraging the Arab Leagueto believe that the Palestinians, reinforced by the Arab Liberation Army, could put an end to partition. The British, on the other hand, decided on the 7 February 1948, to support the annexation of the Arab part of Palestine by Transjordan. [Henry Laurens (2005), p.83]
Although a certain level of doubt took hold amongst
Yishuvsupporters, their apparent defeats were due more to their wait-and-see policy than to weakness. Ben-Gurionreorganised Haganahand made conscription obligatory. Every Jewish man and woman in the country had to receive military training. Thanks to funds raised by Golda Meirfrom sympathisers in the United States, and Stalin's decision to support for the Zionist cause, the Jewish representatives of Palestine were able to sign very important armament contracts in the East. Other Haganahagents recuperated stockpiles from the Second World War, which helped improve equip the army's equipment and logistics. Operation Balak allowed arms and other equipment to be transported for the first time by the end of March.
Yigal Yadinwith the responsibility to come up with a plan in preparation for the announced intervention of the Arab states. The result of his analysis was Plan Dalet, which was put in place from the start of April onwards. The adoption of Plan Dalet marked the second stage of the war, in which Haganah passed from the defensive to the offensive.
The first operation, named Nachshon, consisted of lifting the blockade on
Jerusalem. 1500 men from Haganah's Givati brigade and Palmach's Harel brigade conducted sorties to free up the route to the city between 5 April and 20 April. The operation was successful, and enough foodstuffs to last 2 months were trucked into to Jerusalem for distribution to the Jewish population. [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), pp.369-381] The success of the operation was assisted by the death of Al-Hassayni in combat. During this time, and independently of Haganah or the framework of Plan Dalet, irregular troops from Irgunand Lehi formations massacred a substantial number of Arabs at Deir Yassin, an event which, though publicly deplored and criticized by the principal Jewish authorities, had a deep impact on the morale of the Palestinian population.
At the same time, the first large-scale operation of the
Arab Liberation Armyended in a "débâcle", having been roundly defeated at Mishmar Ha'emek [Benny Morris (2003), pp.242-243] m coinciding with the loss of their Druzeallies through defection. [Benny Morris (2003), p.242]
Within the framework of the establishment of Jewish territorial continuity foreseen by
Plan Dalet, the forces of Haganah, Palmachand Irgunintended to conquer mixed zones. Palestinian society was shaken. Tiberias, Haifa, Safed, Beisan, Jaffaand Acrefell, resulting in the flight of more than 250,000 Palestinians. [Henry Laurens (2005), pp.85-86]
The British had, at that time, essentially withdrawn their troops. The situation pushed the leaders of the neighbouring Arab states to intervene, but their preparation was not finalised, and they could not assemble sufficient forces to turn the tide of the war. The majority of Palestinian hopes lay with the
Arab Legionof Transjordan's monarch, King Abdullah I, but he had no intention of creating a Palestinian-run state, since he hoped to annex as much of the territory of the British Mandate of Palestineas he could. He was playing a double-game, being just as much in contact with the Jewish authorities as with the Arab League.
In preparation for the offensive,
Haganahsuccessfully launched Operations Yiftah [Benny Morris (2003), pp.248-252] and Ben-'Ami [Benny Morris (2003), pp.252-254] to secure the Jewish settlements of Galilee, and Operation Kilshon, which created a united front around Jerusalem. The inconclusive meeting between Golda Meirand Abdullah I, followed by the attack of Kfar Etzion on the 13 May by the Arab Legionled to predictions that the battle for Jerusalem would be merciless.
On 14 May 1948,
David Ben-Guriondeclared the independence of the state of Israeland the 1948 Palestine warentered its second phase with the intervention of the Arab state armies and the beginning of the 1948 Arab-Israeli War.
Under the control of a British administration since 1920, the area of Palestine found itself the object of a battle between Jewish Zionist nationalists and Palestinian Arab nationalists, who opposed one another just as much as they both opposed the British 'occupation.'
The Palestinian backlash culminated in the
1936–1939 Arab revolt in Palestine. Directed by Palestinian nationalists, the rebels opposed Zionism, the British presence in Palestine and Palestinian politicians who called for pan-Arabic nationalism at the same time. Both the British and the Zionist organisations of the time opposed the revolt; nonetheless, the Palestinian nationalists did obtain from the British a drastic reduction of Jewish immigration, legislated by the 1939 White Paper. However, the consequences of the unsuccessful uprising were heavy. Nearly 5000 Arabs and 500 Jews died; the various paramilitary Zionist organisations were reinforced, and the majority of the members of the Palestinian political elite exiled themselves, such as Mohammad Amin al-Husayni, chief of the Arab High Committee, who took refuge in Nazi Germany, where he would help to recruit Muslims for the Waffen-SS.
World War IIand the horrors of The Holocaust, the Zionist movementattracted sympathy. In Palestine, right-wing Zionist groups fought against the British occupation. The Palestinian nationalists reorganized themselves, but their organisation remained inferior to that of the Zionists. Nevertheless, the weakening of the colonial British Empire reinforced Arabic countries and the Arab Leaguefor the future war against newly-founded Israel.
with the support of the big global powers, but not that of Britain nor the Arabic nations.
Beginning of the Civil War (30 November 1947 - 1 April 1948)
In the aftermath of the adoption of the United Nations' partition plan, the manifestations of joy of the Jewish community were counterbalanced by protests by Arabs throughout the country [Extracts from Time Magazine of that time [http://www.time.com/time/archive/preview/0,10987,934119,00.html] ] and after the 1 December, the
Arab Higher Committeeenacted a general strikethat lasted three days. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.17]
A 'wind of violence' [This expression is taken from Ilan Pappé (2000), p.111] rapidly took hold of the country, foreboding civil war between the two communities. [Benny Morris (2003), p.65]
Rise of violence
s. Attacks against traffic, for instance, turned into ambushes as one bloody attack led to another.
Irgunand Lehifollowed a strategy of placing bombs in crowded markets and bus-stops. [B. Morris, 2004, 'The Birth of the Palestinian refugee problem revisited', p. 66] As on 30 December, in Haifa, when members of the clandestine militant Zionist group, Irgun, threw two bombs at a crowd of Arab workers who were queueing in front of a refinery, killing 6 of them and injuring 42. An angry crowd killed 39 Jewish people in revenge, until British soldiers reestablished calm. [Efraïm Karsh (2002), p.30 ] [" The Palestine Post" of 31 December 1947 : [http://jic.tau.ac.il/Default/Skins/PalestineP/Client.asp?Enter=true&Skin=PalestineP&AW=1143352970859&AppName=2 Archives of the newspaper] ] In reprisals, some soldiers from the strike force, Palmachand the Carmeli brigade, attacked the village of Balad ash-Sheikhand Hawassa. According to different historians, this attack led to between 21 and 70 deaths. [Benny Morris (2003), p.101]
On the 22 February 1948, supporters of
Mohammad Amin al-Husayniorganised, with the help of certain British deserters, three attacks against the Jewish community. Using car bombs aimed at the headquarters of the pro-Zionist " Jerusalem Post", the Ben Yehuda St. market and the backyard of the Jewish Agency's offices, they killed 22, 53 and 13 Jewish people respectively, and injured hundreds. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.24 ] [Efraïm Karsh (2002), p.36] In retaliation, Lehiput a landmineon the railroad track in Rehovoton which a train from Cairoto Haifawas travelling, killing 28 British soldiers and injuring 35. ["The Times", 1 March 1948] This would be copied on the 31 March, close to Caesarea Maritima, which would lead to the death of forty people, injuring 60, who were, for the most part, Arab civilians. [Newspapers of the time: " The Palestine Post", 1st April 1948 and " The Times", on the same day, attribute the incident to Lehi.]
Between December 1947 and January 1948, it was estimated that around 1,000 people were killed and 2,000 injured. [ [http://domino.un.org/UNISPAL.NSF/181c4bf00c44e5fd85256cef0073c426/fdf734eb76c39d6385256c4c004cdba7!OpenDocument Special UN report] by the United Nations Special Commission (16 April 1948)] , § II.5] By the end of March, a report stated that 2,000 had been killed and 4,000 injured. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.85] These figures correspond to an average of over 100 deaths and 200 injuries per week, all of this in a country with 2,000,000 inhabitants.
War of the roads and blockade of Jerusalem
Geographic situation of the Jewish zones
The possibility of evacuating these difficult to defend zones was considered, but the policy of
Haganahwas set by David Ben-Gurion. He stated that 'what the Jewish people have has to be conserved. No Jewish person should abandon his or her house, farm, kibbutzor job without authorisation. Every outpost, every colony, whether it is isolated or not, must be occupied as though it were Tel Avivitself. [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), p.163] No Jewish settlement was evacuated until the invasion of May 1948. Only a dozen kibbutzim in Galilee as well as those of Gush Etzion sent women and children into the safer interior zones. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.8]
Ben Gurion gave instructions that the settlements of Negev be reinforced in number of men and goods, [Efraïm Karsh (2002), p.34] in particular the kibbutzim of
Kfar Daromand Yad Mordechai(both north of Gaza,) Revivim(south of Beersheba) and Kfar Etzion. Conscious of the danger that weighed upon Negev, the supreme command of Haganahassigned a whole Palmachbattalion there. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.28]
Jerusalem and the great difficulty of accessing the city became even more critical to its Jewish population, who made up one sixth of the total of Yishuv settlers. The route from
Tel Avivto Jerusalem was long and precipitous, which, after leaving the Jewish zone at Hulda, went through the [http://www.rc.net/wcc/israel/latrun.htm foothills of Latrun] . Then, the 28 kilometre route between Bab al-Wadand Jerusalem took no less than 3 hours, [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), p.214] and the route passed the vicinity of the Arab villages of Saris, Qaluniya, Al-Qastaland Deir Yassin. [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), pp.122-123]
Abd al-Qadir al-Husayni's strategy
Abd al-Qadir al-Husayniarrived in Jerusalem with the intent to surround and besiege its Jewish community. [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), chap.7, pp.131-153] He moved to Surif, a village to the southwest of Jerusalem, with his supporters - around a hundred fighters who were trained in Syriabefore the war and who served as officers in his army, Jihad al-Muqadas, or Army of the Holy War. He was joined by a hundred or so young villagers and Arab veterans of the British Army. [Yoav Gelber (2006), pp.36-37] His militia soon had several thousand men, [Efraïm Karsh (2002), p.27] and it moved its training quarters to Bir Zeit, a town near Ramallah. Its zone of influence extended up to Lyddaand Ramleh, [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.37] where Hasan Salama- a veteran of the 1936–1939 Arab revolt in Palestine- commanded 1,000 men and co-ordinated, with al-Husayni, a plan of disruption and harassment of road traffic. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.26] [Efraïm Karsh (2002), p.26]
On the 10 December, the first organized attack occurred when ten members of a convoy between
Bethlehemand Kfar Etzionwere killed. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.26]
On the 14 January, Abd al-Qadir himself commanded and took part in an attack against Kfar Etzion, in which 1,000 Palestinian Arab combatants were involved. The attack was a failure, and 200 of al-Husayni's men died. Nonetheless, the attack did not come without losses of Jewish lives: a detachment of 35
Palmachmen who sought to reinforce the establishment were ambushed and killed. [Efraïm Karsh (2002), p.38]
On 25 January, a large scale attack took place in the Arab village of
al-Qastal. Due to an appeal by al-Husayni, many people from several Arab-majority villages situated in the northeast of Jerusalemjoined the attack, although others did not, for fear of reprisals. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.27] The campaign for control over the roads became increasingly militaristic in nature, and became a focal point of the Arab war effort. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.27] After 22 March, supply convoys to Jerusalem stopped, due to a convoy of around thirty vehicles having been destroyed in the gorges of Bab-el-Oued. [Pierre Razoux (2006), p.66]
On 27 March, an important supply convoy from
Kfar Etzionwas taken in an ambush in southern Jerusalem. They were forced to surrender all of their arms, ammunition and vehicles to al-Husayni's forces. The Jews of Jerusalem requested the assistance of the United Kingdomafter 24 hours of combat. According to a British report, the situation in Jerusalem, where a food rationing system was already in application, risked becoming desperate after 15 May. [Efraïm Karsh (2002), p.40]
The situation in other areas of the country was as critical as the one of Jerusalem. The settlements of Negev were utterly isolated, due to the impossibility of using the Southern coastal road, which passed through zones densely populated by Arabs. [Efraïm Karsh (2002), p.40] On 27 March, a convoy of supplies (the Yehiam convoy [Benny Morris (2003), p.163] ) that was intended for the isolated
kibbutzim north-west of Galilee was attacked in the vicinity of Nahariya. In the ensuing battle, 42-47 Haganahcombatants and around a hundred fighters of the Arab Liberation Armywere killed, and all vehicles involved were destroyed. [Pierre Razoux (2006), p.66] [Efraïm Karsh (2002), p.40] [Benny Morris (2003), p.254]
Death toll and analysis
In the last week of March alone, the losses underwent by Haganah were particularly heavy: they lost three large convoys in ambushes, more than 100 soldiers and their fleet of armoured vehicles. [Benny Morris (2003), p.163]
All in all, West Jerusalem was gradually 'choked;' the settlements of Galilee could not be reached in any other way but via the valley of
Jordanand the road of Nahariya, both dominated by Arab villages. Haifa could not be joined to Tel-Aviv by the coastal road due to the chain of Arab villages at the Northern part of it. In the south, the four settlements of the Etzion Bloc were besieged and the pipeline that supplied them with water regularly sabotaged. [Benny Morris (2003), p.163]
This situation, the need to prepare the settlements for the foreseen attack of the Arab states in May, and the earlier projected departure date of the British pushed Haganah to the offensive and to apply the Daleth plan from April onwards.
Intervention of foreign forces in Palestine
, p.185] Furthermore, the authorities felt that they had lost enough men already in the conflict.
The British either could not or did not want to impede the intervention of foreign forces into Palestine. [This policy would change; at the end of the mandate, the High Commissioner,
Alan Cunningham, opposed the deployment of Arab Legiontroops into the territory and threatened the Arab states with RAF intervention if they grouped their forces around the border or crossed it. (Yoav Gelber (2006), p.115) ] According to a special report by the UN Special Commission on Palestine [United Nations Special Commission (16 avril 1948), § II.7] :
:* During the night of 20-21 January, a troop composed of 700 Syrians in battle dress, equipped well and in control of mechanised transport, enters Palestine 'via
Transjordan.':* On 27 January, 'a band of 300 men from outside Palestine, was established in the area of Safedin Galileeand was probably responsible for the intensive heavy weapon and mortar attacks the following week against the settlement of Yechiam.':* In the night of 29 January-30 January, a batallion commanded by commanded by Fawzi al-Qawuqjithat consisted of 950 men in 19 vehicles was deployed by the Arab Liberation Armyand entered Palestine 'via Adam Bridgeand dispersed itself around the villages of Nablus, Jeninand Tulkarem.'
This description corresponds to the entry of
Arab Liberation Armytroops between 10 January and the start of March [Yoav Gelber (2006), pp.51-56] :
:* The Second regiment of
Yarmouk, under the orders of Adib Shishakli[Shishakli would seize the power in Syria between October 29, 1951 and February 25, 1954 (Henry Laurens (2005), pp.115-116)] entered Galileevia Lebanonon the night of 11-12 January. The batallion passed through Safedand then settled in the village of Sasa. A third of the regiment's fighters were Palestinian, and a quarter were Syrian.:* The 1st Yarmouk regiment, commanded by Muhammad Tzafa, entered Palestine on the night of 20-21 January, via the Bridge of Damia from Jordanand disperses around Samaria, where it established its HQ, in the Northern Samarian city of Tubas. The regiment is composed chiefly of Palestinians and Iraqis. :* The Hittin regiment, commanded by Madlul Abbas, settled in the west of Samaria with its headquarters in Tulkarem.:* The Hussein ibn Aliregiment provided reinforcement in Haifa, Jaffa, Jerusalemand several other cities. :* The Qadassia regiment were reserves based in Jab'a. Fawzi al-Qawuqji, Field Commander of the Arab Liberation Army, arrived, according to himself, on the 4 March, with the rest of the logistics and around 100 Bosniak volunteers in Jab'a, a small village on the route between Nablusand Jenin. He established a headquarters there and a training centre for Palestinian volunteers. Alan Cunningham, the British High Commissionerin Palestine, thoroughly protested against the incursions and the fact that 'no serious effort is being made to stop incursions'. The only reaction came from Alec Kirkbride, who complained to Ernest Bevinabout Cunningham's 'hostile tone and threats'. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.51]
The British and the information service of Yishuv expected an offensive for 15 February, but it would not take place, seemingly because the Mufti troops were not ready. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.55]
In March, an
Iraqi regiment of the Arab Liberation Army came to reinforce the Palestinian troops of Salamehin the area around Lyddaand Ramleh, whilst Al-Hussayni started a headquarters in Bir Zeit, 10 km to the north of Ramallah. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.56] At the same time, a number of North African troops, principally Libyans, and hundreds of members of the Muslim Brotherhoodentered Palestine. In March, an initial regiment arrived in Gazaand certain militants amongst them reached Jaffa.
Morale of the fighters
The Arab combatants' initial victories reinforced morale amongst them. [United Nations Special Commission (16 april 1948), § II.7.3] The
Arab Higher Committeewas confident and decided to prevent the set-up of the UN-backed partition plan. In an announcement made to the Secretary-General on the 6 February, they declared [United Nations Special Commission (16 april 1948), § II.6] :
cquote|The Palestinian Arabs consider any attempt by Jewish people or by whatever power or group of power to establish a Jewish state in an Arab territory to be an act of aggression that will be resisted by force [...]
The prestige of the
United Nationswould be better served by abandoning this plan and by not imposing such an injustice [...]
The Palestinian Arabs make a grave declaration before the UN, before
Godand before history that they will never submit to any power that comes to Palestine to impose a partition. The only way to establish a partition is to get rid of them all: men, women, and children."
At the beginning of February 1948, the morale of the Jewish leaders was not high: 'distress and despair arose clearly from the notes taken at the meetings of the Mapai party.' [ Ilan Pappé (2000), p.113] 'The attacks against the Jewish settlements and main roads worsened the direction of the Jewish people, who underestimated the intensity of the Arab reaction. [ Ilan Pappé (2000), p.113, quoting Milstein, Milhemet, vol.2, p.47] The situation of the 100,000 Jewish people situated in
Jerusalemwas precarious, and supplies to the city, already slim in number, were likely to be stopped. Nonetheless, despite the setbacks suffered, the Jewish forces, in particular Haganah, remained superior in number and quality to those of the Arab forces. [Henry Laurens (2005), p.83]
The First Wave of Palestinian Refugees
The high morale of the Arab fighters and politicians was not shared by the Palestinian civilian population. The UN Palestine Commission reported 'Panic continues to increase, however, throughout the Arab middle classes, and there is a steady exodus of those who can afford to leave the country. [United Nations Special Commission (16 avril 1948), § II.7.3] 'From December 1947 to January 1948, around 70,000 Arabs fled, [Ilan Pappé (2000), p.125] and, by the end of March, that number had grown to around 100,000. [Benny Morris (2003), p.67]
These people were part of the first wave, chiefly voluntary, of Palestinian refugees of the conflict. Mostly the middle and upper classes fled, including the majority of the families of local governors and representatives of the
Arab Higher Committee. [Benny Morris (2003), p.67] Non-Palestinian Arabs also fled in large numbers. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.77] Most of them did not abandon the hope of returning to Palestine once the hostilities had ended. [Ibid.]
Policies of foreign powers
Many decisions were made abroad that had an important influence over the outcome of the conflict.
Britain and the Jordanian choice
Britain did not want a Palestinian state led by the
Mufti, and opted unofficially instead, on 7 February 1948, to support the annexation of the Arab part of Palestine by Abdullah I of Jordan. [Henry Laurens (2005), p.83] At a meeting in London between the commander of Transjordan's Arab Legion, Glubb Pasha, and Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs, Ernest Bevin, the two parties agreed that they would facilitate the entry of the Arab Legion into Palestine on 15 May and that the Arab part of Palestine be occupied by it. However, they held that the Arab Legion not enter the vicinity of Jerusalem or the Jewish state itself. [Henry Laurens (2005), p.83] This option did not envisage a Palestinian Arab state. Although the ambitions of King Abdullah are known, it is not apparent to what extent the authorities of Yishuv, the Arab Higher Committeeor the Arab Leagueknew of this decision.
The American U-turn
In Mid-March, after the increasing disorder in Palestine and faced with the fear, later judged unfounded, of an Arab petrol embargo, [Henry Laurens (2005), p.84] the American administration announces the possible withdrawal of its support for the UN's partition plan and for the dispatching of an international force to guarantee its implementation. The US, instead, suggested that Palestine be put under UN supervision. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.71 ] [Benny Morris (2003), p.13] On the 1 April, the
UN Security Councilvoted on the American proposal of a convocation of a special assembly intended to reconsider the Palestinian problem, a proposal for which the Soviets abstained from voting. [ [http://indaily.net/?p=1299 See the entry at April 1, 1948] ] This U-turn from the Americans causes concern and debate amongst Yishuv authorities, who could not, after the withdrawal of British troops, afford to face the Arab troops without the support of the USA. In this context, Elie Sasson, the director of the Arab section of Jewish Agency, and several other personalities, ended up convincing David Ben-Gurionand Golda Meyerson to advance a diplomatic initiative towards the Arabs. The job of negotiation was delegated to Joshua Palmon, who was prohibited from limiting the Haganah's liberty of action but was authorised to declare that 'the Jewish people were ready with a truce.' [Yoav Gelber (2006), pp.71-73]
The logistical support of the Eastern bloc
In the context of the embargo imposed upon Palestinian belligerents - Jewish and Arab alike - and the dire lack of goods in Palestine, Stalin's decision to not adhere to the embargo and support the country by exporting
Czechoslovakian goods played a role in the war that was differently appreciated. [See [http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Probl%C3%A9matique_du_mat%C3%A9riel_lors_de_la_guerre_de_Palestine_de_1948 here] ]
Motivations advanced as regards to
Stalin's choice include his support towards the UN Partition plan and his interest in financially aiding Czechoslovakia to lessen their financial frustration after having been refused Marshall Planassistance. [For a discussion of the motivation of Czech aide, check [http://www.ivry.cnrs.fr/receo/janvier1974/KRAMMER.htm L'aide militaire tchèque à Israël, 1948] ]
The extent of this support and the concrete role that it played is up for debate. Figures advanced by historians tend to vary. Yoav Gelber spoke of 'small deliveries from Czechoslovakia arriving by air [...] from April 1948 onwards [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.14] ' whereas various historians have argued that there was an unbalanced level of support in favour of
Yishuv, given that the Palestinian Arabs did not benefit from an equivalent level of Soviet support. [See for example the résumé of an article by Arnold Krammer [http://www.ivry.cnrs.fr/receo/janvier1974/KRAMMER.htm L'aide militaire tchèque à Israël, 1948] .] In any case, the embargo that was extended to all Arab states in May 1948 by the UN Security Council caused great problems to them. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.13] [ [http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/UN/unres46.html 17 April 1948 resolution] ]
Arab leaders' refusal of direct involvement
Despite what one may be led to think by their bellicose declarations, the Arab leaders 'did what they possibly could to avoid being directly involved [This term is important. Pappé underlined that they were not ready 'to have their own troops intervene' in the conflict, but that they would rather follow other solutions, such as delegating the task to a voluntary force, like the Arab Liberation Army, that they financed.] ' in support for the Palestinian cause. [Ilan Pappé (2000), p.146]
Arab Leaguesummit of October 1947, in Aley, the Iraqi general, Ismail Safwat, painted a realist picture of the situation. He underlined the better organisation and greater financial support of the Jewish people in comparison to the Palestinians. He recommended the immediate deployment of the Arab armies at the Palestinian borders, the dispatching of weapons and ammunition to the Palestinians, and the contribution of a million pounds of financial aid to them. His proposals were rejected, other than the suggestion to send financial support, which was not followed up on. Nonetheless, a techno-military committee was established to coordinate assistance to the Palestinians. Based in Cairo, it was directed by Sawfat, who was supported by Lebanese and Syrian officers and representatives of the Higher Arab Committee. A Transjordian delegate was also appointed, but he did not participate in meetings.
At the December 1947 Cairo summit, under pressure by public opinion, the Arab leaders decided to create a military command that united all the heads of all the major Arab states, headed by Safwat. They still ignored his calls for financial and military aid, preferring to defer any decision until the end of the Mandate [Ilan Pappé (2000), p.147] , but, nevertheless, decide to form the
Arab Liberation Army, which would go into action in the following weeks. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.5]
On the night of 20-21 January 1948, around 700 armed Syrians entered Palestine via Transjordan. [ [http://domino.un.org/UNISPAL.nsf/eed216406b50bf6485256ce10072f637/d3bc8aaa0231aae0802564ad003974d2!OpenDocument UN Security Council 270th meeting report] ]
In February 1948, Safwat reiterated his demands, but they fell on deaf ears: the Arab governments hoped that the Palestinians, aided by the Arab Liberation Army, could manage on their own until the International community renounced the partition plan. [Ilan Pappé (2000), p.147]
The Arms Problem
Whereas the Arab states had state armies and official structures that guaranteed a steady flow of weapons, ammunition and materials, the other protagonists of the conflict did not. The Palestinian Arabs and the Jews' situation was more delicate, since, during the British mandate, the authorities always prohibited the possession of weapons, and confiscated all that they found. Consequently, neither had heavy weaponry or the advantages that recognised, established states have, and their forces had to be clandestine.
Arab Liberation Armywas, in theory, financed and equipped by the Arab League. A budget of one million pounds sterling had been promised to them, [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), p.137] due to the insistence of Ismail Safwat. In reality, though, funding never arrived, and only Syriatruly supported the Arab volunteers in concrete terms. On the ground, logistics were completely neglected, and their leader, Fawzi al-Qawuqji, envisaged that his troops survive only on the expenses accorded to them by the Palestinian population. [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), p.305]
The situation that the
Army of the Holy Warand the Palestinian forces were in was worse. They could not rely on any form of foreign support and had to get by on the funds that Mohammad Amin al-Husaynicould raise. The troops' armament was limited to what the fighters already had. To make things even worse, they had to be content with arms bought on the black marketor pillaged from British warehouses, and, as a result, did not really have enough arms to wage war. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.38]
The situation in which Jewish fighters found themselves in was better than that of the Palestinian Arabs, since they benefitted from a number of clandestine factories that manufactured light weapons and ammunition. However, they had far less than what was necessary to carry out a war: in November, only one out of every three Jewish combatants was armed, rising to two out of three within Palmach. [Efraïm Karsh (2002), p.25]
However, for Ben-Gurion, the problem was not essentially having the capacity of waging war, but of constructing an army that was worthy to be a state army. The importance that he accorded to this is illustrated by the practice of combining the cabinet posts of
Prime Ministerand Minister for Defence, a practice that he initiated and that many of his successors follow. [Pierre Razoux (2006), p.96, p.575]
To arm and equip this army, he sent agents to Europe and to the USA, thence came the essential support in terms of light arms and munitions, which began to arrive at the start of April. From June, onwards, there was also a flow of heavy arms.
Until March, Haganah suffered a lack of arms similar to that of the Army of Holy War. From April onwards, it was armed better than the Palestinians, but, after 15 May, during the first weeks of the
Arab-Israeli War, the arms advantage leant in favour of the Arab states. From June, after the first truce, the advantage leant clearly towards the Israelis. This situation's changing was due to the contacts made in November 1947 and afterwards.
The Jewish armament movement was helped out after the Yishuv agents obtained a supply of
Aviaplanes from Czechoslovakia[Walid Khalidi, "Before Their Diaspora", Institute for Palestine Studies, Washington DC, 1991, p.316 rapporté par http://www.canpalnet-ottawa.org/canpalissafahel.html] ] and, later on in the conflict, Supermarine Spitfires, machine guns and munitions. [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), et pp.108-109] In the stockpiles left over from World War II, they procured all the necessary equipment, vehicles and logistics needed for an army. In France, they procured armoured vehicles despite the ongoing embargo. [Pierre Razoux (2006), p.79 et p.523] Jewish agents also bought machines to manufacture arms and munitions, forming the foundations of the Israeli armament industry. [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), pp.109-113]
In the USA, they bought a number of bombardiers and aeroplanes, which allowed for the transporting of arms purchased in Europe. Operation Balak was put in place to bring these arms and munitions to Israel by the end of March. [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), pp.375-376] Some ships were also leased out from various European ports so that these goods could be transported by the 15 May. To finance all of this,
Golda Meirmanaged, by the end of December, to collect twenty-five million dollars through a fundraising campaign set about in the USA to capitalise on American sympathisers to the Zionist cause. [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), Chap.12] Out of the 129 million US dollars raised between October 1947 and March 1949 for the Zionist cause, more than 78 million dollars, over 60%, were used to buy arms and munition. [Benny Morris (2003), p.240]
Reorganisation of Haganah
After 'having gotten the Jews of Palestine and of elsewhere to do everything that they could, personally and financially, to help
Yishuv,' Ben-Gurion's second greatest achievement was his having successfully transformed Haganah from being a clandestine paramilitaryorganization into a true army. [Ilan Pappé (2000), p.79] Ben-Gurion appointed Israel Galilito the position of head of the High Command counsel of Haganah and divided Haganah into 6 infantrybrigades, numbered 1 to 6, allotting a precise theatre of operation to each one. Yaakov Dori was named Chief of Staff, but it was Yigal Yadin who assumed the responsibility on the ground as chief of Operations. Palmach, commanded by Yigal Allon, was divided into 3 elite brigades, numbered 10-12, and constituted the mobile force of Haganah. [Efraïm Karsh (2002), p.31]
On 19 November 1947, obligatory
conscriptionis instituted and all men and women received military training. [Ilan Pappé (2000), p.80]
"From November 1947, the Haganah, (...) began to change from a territorial militia into a regular army. (...) Few of the units had been well trained by December. (...) By March-April, it fielded still under-equipped battalion and brigades. By April-May, the Haganah was conducting brigade size offensive. [Benny Morris (2003), pp.16-17]
Plan Daletwas finalised on 10 March 1948, under the direction of Yigal Yadin. 75 pages long, it laid down the rules and the objects that were to be followed by Haganah during the second phase of the war. Its principal objective was to secure Yishuv's uninterrupted territorial connections, particularly in response to the war of the roads carried out by Al-Hussayni and in preparation for the Arab states' declared intervention. Plan Dalet caused quite a controversy amongst historians. Some see it as an offensive plan that approves of ethnic cleansing, and the conquering of as much of Palestine as possible, [ [http://www.acj.org/w_khalidi.htm] Dead link|date=March 2008] whereas others think that the plan was primarily defensive and military in nature and a preparation against invasion. [ [http://www.mideastweb.org/pland.htm Plan D - Master Defense Plan of the Hagana ] ]
Haganah on the offensive (1 April 1948 - 15 May 1948)
The second phase of the war, which began in April, marked a huge change in direction, as Haganah moved to the offensive.
In this stage, Arab forces were composed of around 10,000 men among which between 3,000 and 5,000 foreign volunteers serving in the
Arab Liberation Army. [ Benny Morris, in the "Birth revisited", 2003, p.34] .] [ Yoav Gelber, "Palestine 1948", 2006, p.51.] [ Ilan Pappe, "The ethnic cleansing of Palestine", 2006, p.44.] Haganahand Palmachforces were steadily increasing. In March, they aligned around 15,000 men [ David Tal, "War in Palestine 1948", 2004, p.362.] and in May around 30,000 who were better equipped, trained and organized. [ Benny Morris, in the "Birth revisited", 2003, p.16.] [ Yoav Gelber, "Palestine 1948", 2006, p.73.] [ Ilan Pappe, "The ethnic cleansing of Palestine", 2006, p.44 gives the number of 50,000 with 30,000 fighting forces.]
The armed Palestinian groups were roundly defeated, Yishuv took control of some of the principal routes that linked the Jewish settlements, and as a consequence,
Jerusalemwas able to receive supplies again. Palestinian society collapsed. Many mixed cities were taken by the Haganah as well as Jaffa. A massive exodus was triggered.
Operation Nachshon, 5-20 April
At the end of March, 1948, Hussayni's troops prevented supply convoys from reaching Jerusalem. The city was besieged and the Jewish population was forced to adhere to a rationing system. As the first operation of
Plan Daleth, Ben-Gurion decided to launch the Nachshon operation to open up the town and provide supplies to Jerusalem. [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), p.369]
Between 5-20 April 1500 men from the Guivati and Harel brigades took control of the road to Jerusalem [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), p.372] and allowed 3 or 4 convoys to get to the city. [
Benny Morris(Benny Morris (2003), p.236) speaks of 3 resupply convoys but Lapierre and Collins (Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), p.456) speak of a fourth convoy of 300 lorries that left Kfar Biou on the dawn of the 20th April]
The operation was a military success. All the Arab villages that blocked the route were either taken or destroyed, and the Jewish forces were victorious in all their engagements. Nonetheless, not all the objectives of the operation were achieved, since only 1800 tonnes of the 3,000 envisaged were transported to the town, and two months of severe rationing had to be assumed. [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), p.457]
Abd al-Qadir al-Husayniwas killed during the night of 7-8 April, in the middle of the battles taking place in Al-Qastal. The loss of this charismatic Palestinian leader 'disrupted the Arab strategy and organisation in the area of Jerusalem.' [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), p.455] His successor, Emil Ghuri, changed tactics: instead of provoking a series of ambushes throughout the route, he had a huge road block erected at Bab-el-Oued, and Jerusalem was once again isolated as a consequence. [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), p.456]
The Nachshon operation exposed the bad military organisation of the Palestinian paramilitary groups. Due to lack of logistics, particularly food and ammunition, they were incapable of maintaining engagements that were more than a few hours away from their permanent bases. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.89]
Faced with these events, the
Arab Higher Committeeasked Alan Cunningham to allow the return of the Mufti, the only person capable of redressing the situation. Despite obtaining permission, the Mufti did not get to Jerusalem. His declining prestige cleared the way for the expansion of the influence of the Arab Liberation Army and of Fawzi al-Kawukji in the Jerusalem area. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.89]
Deir Yassin massacre
Deir Yassinis a village located 5 kilometres west of Jerusalem. On 9 April 1948, independently of the Nachshon operation but with the agreement of the Haganah, around 120 Irgunand Lehiattacked the village of Deir Yassin. They massacred between 100 and 120 inhabitants of the village, mostly civilians. [Yoav Gelber, "Palestine 1948", [http://www.ee.bgu.ac.il/~censor/katz-directory/05-12-14gelber-palestine-1948-appendix-II-what-happened-in-deir-yassin-english.pdf Appendix II] ]
This massacre led to indignation from the international community, the more so since the press of the time reported that the death toll was 254. Ben-Gurion roundly condemned it [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.317] , as did the principal Jewish authorities:
Haganah, the Great Rabbinate and the Jewish Agency for Israel, who sent a letter of condemnation, apology and condolence to King Abdullah I. [Benny Morris (2003), p.239]
According to Morris, "the most important immediate effect of the atrocity and the media campaign that followed it was how one started to report the fear felt in Palestinian towns and villages, and, later, the panicked fleeing from them." [Benny Morris (2003), p.239]
Another important repercussion was within the Arab population of neighbouring Arab states, which, once again, increased its pressure on the representatives of these states to intervene and come to the aid of the Palestinians. [Benny Morris (2003), p.239] [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), p.528]
On the 13 April, in revenge, a medical convoy that was driving towards Jerusalem's Hadassah of Mount Scopus hospital was attacked by Arabs, killing 80 Jewish doctors and patients. A few British soldiers tried to intervene to stop this massacre, but without success. [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), pp.429-442]
The Battle of Mishmar HaEmek (4 April - 15 April 1948)
On 4 April, the Arab Liberation Army launched an attack on the kibbutz with the support of artillery cannons. The attack was fought off by the members of the kibbutz, who were supported by Haganah soldiers. The artillery fire that had almost totally destroyed the kibbutz was stopped by a British column, who arrived on the scene by order of General MacMillan, and, on 7 April,
Fawzi Al-Qawuqjiaccepted a 24-hour ceasefire, but required that the kibbutz be surrendered. The inhabitants of the kibbutz evacuated their children, and, after having consulted Tel-Aviv, refused to surrender. [Benny Morris (2003), p.240] [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), p.426]
On the 8 or 9 April, Haganah prepared a counter-offensive, with accordance to
Plan Dalet. Yitzhak Sadehwas put in charge of operations, with the order to 'clean out' the region. The battle lasted until the 15 April. Sadeh's men besieged all the villages around the kibbutz, and the Arab Liberation Armyhad to retreat to its bases in Jabba. The majority of the inhabitants of the region fled, but those who did not were either imprisoned or expelled to Jenin. The villages were plundered by some kibbutznikim and razed to the ground with explosives. [Benny Morris (2003), pp.242-243]
According to Morris, the Arab Liberation Army soldiers were demoralised by reports of the
Deir Yassin massacreand the death of Abd al-Qadir al-Husayni. Throughout battle, they had generally been forced to withdraw and to abandon the people of the villages. [Benny Morris (2003), p.242] Dominique Lapierreand Larry Collinsreport that Joshua Palmon, head of a unit of 6 men, failed to seize invaluable pieces of artillery, and they depict the events as a débâcle for which Fawzi Al-Qawuqjioffered extravagant excuses, declaring in particular that the Jewish forces has 120 tanks, six squadrons of fighter and bomber aeroplanes and that they were supported by a regiment of gentile Russian volunteers. [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), p.427]
When the battle finished,
Palmachforces continued 'cleaning' operations until the 19 April, destroying several villages and forcing those who inhabited them to flee. Some villages were also evacuated under the instruction of Arab authorities. [Benny Morris (2003), pp.243-244]
Irgunengaged in several operations in the region, razing a number of villages and killing some of their inhabitants, as did some detachments from the Golani and Alexandroni brigades. [Benny Morris (2003), p.244]
= The Battle of Ramat Yohanan and the Defection of the Druzim =
Following the 'fiasco' [This word is from
Yoav Gelber(Yoav Gelber (2006), p.93)] of Mishmar HaEmek, Fawzi Al-Qawuqji ordered the Druzeregiment of the Arab Liberation Armyinto action, to carry out diversion operations. Druze soldiers took position in several Arab villages 12 kilometres to the east of Haifa, [Shafa 'Amr, Khirbet Kasayir et Hawsha] whence they occasionally attacked traffic and Jewish settlements, including Ramat Yohanan. [Benny Morris (2003), p.244]
The Kibbutznikim and the Haganah soldiers that supported them forced back their attacks with ease, and razed the villages from which they launched their attacks in retaliation. Having run out of ammunition, the Druzim withdrew to their base in Shafa'amr, with one hundred casualties. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.93] [Benny Morris (2003), p.245]
The Druzim had already made contact on several occasions with Yishuv agents, and, following their defeat at Ramat Yohanan, the Druze officers, without the knowledge of their officer, offered to defect and to join the ranks of Haganah. This proposition was discussed with
Yigael Yadin, who refused the proposal but suggested that they could help to carry out sabotage operations behind the backs of the Arabs and to influence their comrades into deserting the army. By the start of May, 212 Wahab soldiers deserted, Taking into account the attitude of his men, Wahab met with Jewish liaison officers on the 9 May and agreed to cooperate with Haganah. The two parties avoided clashes, and Wahab created a neutral enclave in the centre of Galilee. Wahab's army did not respond to calls for it to help fight Haganah's occupation of Acre, and avoided being present whilst Haganah occupied the police fortress of Shafa'amr during its evacuation by the British. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.93]
The position that the Druzim took influenced their fate after the war. Given the good relationship between the Druzim and Yishuv from 1930 onwards despite their collaboration with the Arab Higher Council and the
Arab League, Ben-Gurion insisted that the Druzim, as well as the Circassiansand the Maronitesbenefit from a different position to that of the other Arabs. [Yoav Gelber (2006), pp.225-226]
The siege of mixed localities
In the context of Plan Dalet, mixed urban centres, or those on the borders of the Jewish state, were attacked and besieged by Jewish forces.
Tiberiaswas attacked on 10 April and fell six days later; Haifafell on 23 April, after only one day of combat ( Operation Bi'ur Hametz), and Jaffawas attacked on 27 April but fell only after the British abandoned it ( Operation Hametz). Safedand Beisanfell on 11 May and 13 May respectively, within the framework of Operation Yitfah, and Acre fell on 17 May, within the framework of Operation Ben Ami.
The Arab inhabitants of these towns fled or were expelled en masse. In these 6 cities, only 13,000 of the total of 177,000 Arab inhabitants remained by the end of May. This phenomenon ricocheted also in the suburbs and the majority of the zone's Arab villages.
Operation Yiftah (20 April-24 May)
The Finger of Galilee, a zone in North-West
Galilee, between the Lake Tiberias and Metula, was the Jewish-controlled area that was the most distant and isolated from the area most densely populated by Jewish people, the coastal plain. The presence of the Lebanese border to the North, the Syrian border to East and the Arab presence in the rest of Galilee made it a probable target for intervention of the Arab armies [Yoav Gelber (2006), pp.134-135] . Within the framework of the Dalet plan, Yigal Yadinentrusted Yigal Allon, commander of the Palmach, with the responsibility of managing Operation Yiftah, whose objectives were to control all the aforementioned area and consolidate it ahead of the Arab attack that was planned for 15 May. [Benny Morris (2003), p.248]
Allon was in charge of two undermanned Palmach battalions, which had to face the populace of
Safedand several dozen Arab villages. The situation was made more problematic by the presence of the British, although they began their evacuation of the area. According to his analysis, it was essential that they empty the zone of any Arab presence to completely protect themselves; the exodus would also encumber the roads that the Arab forces would have to penetrate. [Benny Morris (2003), pp.248-250]
On 20 April, Allon launched a campaign that mixed propaganda, attacks, seizing control of strongholds that the British had abandoned, and destroying conquered Arab villages. On 1 May, a counter-offensive was launched by Arab militiamen against Jewish settlements but was ultimately unsuccessful. On 11 May,
Safedfell, and the operation finished on 24 May after the villages of the valley of Hula were burnt down. Syrian forces' planned offensive in the area failed and, by the end of June, the zone covering everywhere from Tiberias to Metula, encorporating Safed, was emptied of all its Arab population. [Benny Morris (2003), pp.249-252]
Meeting of Golda Meir and King Abdullah I of Jordan (10 May)
On 10 May,
Golda Meirand Ezra Danin secretly went to Aman, to the palace of King Abdullah to discuss the situation with him. The situation that Abdullah found himself in was difficult. On one hand, his personal ambitions, the promises made by the Yishuvin November 1947 and the British approval of these promises pushed him to consider annexing the Arab part of Palestinewithout intervening against the future state of Israel. On the other hand, the pressure exerted by his people in reaction to the massacre of Deir Yassin, combined with their feelings with regard to the Palestinian exodus and his agreements with other members of the Arab Leaguepushed him to be more strongly involved in the war against Israel. [Ilan Pappé (2000), p.167] He also found himself in a position of power, having the benefit of military support from not only the Arab League, but the British. In his diary, Ben-Gurion wrote about Golda Meir's reaction to the meeting:
cquote|We met [on 10 May] amicably. He was very worried and looks terrible. He did not deny that there had been talk and understanding between us about a desirable arrangement, namely that he would take the Arab part [of Palestine] . (...) But Abdullah had said that he could now, on 10 May, only offer the Jews "autonomy" within an enlarged Hashemite kingdom. He added that while he was not interested in invading the areas allocated for Jewish statehood, the situation was volatile. But he voiced the hope that Jordan and the Yishuv would conclude a peace agreement once the dust had settled. ["War Diary 1948-1949", ed. Elhanan Orren and Gershon Rivlin, Israël Defence Ministry Press, Tel Aviv, 1982, p.409]
Historical analyses of the motivations and conclusions of this meeting are disparate.
According to Dominique Lapierre and Larry Collins - as well as Israeli historiographers [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), pp.525-530] - the intention behind the Yishuv's negotiation was to obtain a peace treaty and avoid an attack by Arab forces. At that time, the balance of power was not favourable for them, but Meir did not manage to convince the King.
According to Morris, [Benny Morris (1881), p.221] Abdullah 'reconsidered the promises that he made in November to not be opposed to the partition plan,' but left Meir with the impression that he would make peace with the Jewish state once the civil war had finished.
Avi Shlaim [Henry Laurens (2005), p.83] spoke of a 'tacit' agreement to prevent the division of Palestine with the Palestinians, arguing the idea that there was a collusion between the Hashemite Kingdom and Yishuv. The historian
Yoav Gelber, however, rejected this idea and devoted an entire work to dismounting it. [Both theses are developed in Avi Shlaim, "Collusion Across the Jordan : King Abdullah, the Zionist movement and the Partition of Palestine", Columbia University Press, 1988 and in Yoav Gelber, "Israeli-Jordanian dialogue, 1948-1953 : cooperation, conspiracy or collusion", Sussex Academic Press, 2004.]
Pierre Razoux indicated that 'the majority of experts consider it probable' that Ben-Gurion and King Abdullah had an understanding over dividing Palestine, and that only the pressure from the Arab states on Abdullah constrained him from following up on his promise. According to Razoux, this idea explains the attitude of the British, who, following this plan, would thereby fulfill the promises made by
Arthur Balfourto the Yishuv and the Hashemite empire at the same time. He states that the presence of Arab Legion troops, before 15 May, near strategic positions held by the British is in this way easy to understand... [Pierre Razoux (2006), p.523]
Ilan Pappé [Ilan Pappé (2000), pp.168-169] stressed that neither Abdullah's ministers, nor the Arab world itself, seemed to be privy to the discussions held between him and the Yishuv, even if his ambitions on Palestine were widely known. He also stated that Sir
Alec Kirkbrideand Glubb Pasha thought at the time that, at the very least, Azzam Pasha, the Secretary of the Arab League, must have known about Abdullah's double game.
It is certain, on the other hand, that Golda Meir and King Abdullah did not come to an agreement on the status of Jerusalem. On 13 May, the Arab Legion took
Kfar Etzion, [Efraïm Karsh (2002), p.51] strategically located halfway along the road between Hebron and Jerusalem. On 17 May, Abdullah ordered Glubb Pasha, commander of the Arab Legion, to launch an attack against the Holy City.
The Fall of Gush Etzion (12-13 May)
Kfar Etzion is a group of four settlements established on the strategic route between Hebron and Jerusalem, right in the middle of Arab territory. It had 400 inhabitants at the end of 1947. After the adoption of the partition plan, it was the object of Arab attacks. Ben Gurion reinforced it on 7 December, protecting it with a Palmach division, but on 8 January, he authorised the evacuation of the women and children of the settlements.
After 26 March, the last date on which a supply convoy successfully reached it, despite heavy losses of life, the defenders were completely isolated.
On 12 May,
Arab Legionunits started to attack the settlements. The motivations advanced include their desire to protect one of their last supply convoys before the embargo took effect, which had to travel down the road by Kfar Etzion. Another theory is that the block of settlements obstructed the deployment of the Legion in the area around Hebron, whose attack was one of Abdullah's principal objectives. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.95] External defences fell quickly, and, on the 13 May, the first kibbutz was captured, and those who were taken prisoner were massacred; only four survived. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.96] [ [http://www.kfar-etzion.co.il/English_history_KE.htm Official site of the kibbutz] ] Of the 131 defenders, 127, including 21 women, were killed, or massacred after they surrendered. [ Benny Morris, "The road to Jerusalem", p.139.] The other three establishments surrendered, and the kibbutzim were first plundered, then razed to the ground.
The events that took place at Kfar Etzion made apparent the limitations of the policy prohibiting evacuation. Although it was effective during civil war, when facing militias, isolated Jewish settlements could not resist the fire power of a regular army, and an evacuation could have made it possible to avoid the captivity or death of those who defended the settlements. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.96]
According to Yoav Gelber, the fall and massacre of Kfar Eztion influenced Ben-Gurion's decision to engage the Arab Legion on its way to Jerusalem, although the Haganah General Staff were divided about whether the Legion should be challenged inside Jerusalem itself as such a move could harm the Jews in the city. Ben Gurion left the final decision to Shaltiel. The battle for Jerusalem was thus set in motion. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.96]
Operation Kilshon ("Pitchfork") (13-18 May)
Haganahintended to capture the Old City during the final days of the Mandate.Benny Morris (2002), pp. 155-156.] Its attacks on the seam between East and West Jerusalem from 13-18 May (known as Operation Kilshon) were planned as the initial phase of this conquest.
Jerusalem, the British held several strategically-located security zones named "Bevingrads", at its centre. The city's radio station, telephone exchange and government hospital were located there, along with a number of barracks and the fashionable Notre Dame country inn, which dominated the city. [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), p.576] One of the main objectives of Operation Kilshon was to take control of these zones of strategic importance whilst the British withdrew. On 13 May the Haganah extended its control of the Old City's Jewish Quarter and on 14th (having obtained the precise schedule of the evacuation with British complicity) took control of the Bevingrads, including the central post office and the Russian Church compound at 04:00. [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), pp.580-582] Having taken the Arab troops by surprise, they were unable to offer any resistance. [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), pp.575-576]
A secondary objective of Operation Kilshon was to simultaneously create a continuous frontline between the various isolated Jewish localities. For this aim, Brigadier General David Shaltiel, Haganah's former envoy to Europe, was deployed along with a troop of 400 Haganah soldiers and 600 militia soldiers. Emil Ghuri, the new leader of the Army of the Holy War, also envisaged taking these districts and mobilised 600 soldiers for the mission, but prepared no specific operation.
The secondary aim was also successful. In the North of the city, Jewish forces seized Arab-populated Sheikh Jarrah, made a connection with
Mount Scopus, and took the villages surrounding the American settlement. In the South, they ensured the connection of the German and Greek settlements with Talpiot and Ramat Rahel, after having taken the Allenby barracks. A Palmach unit even re-established contact with the Jewish district in the Old City via the Zion Gate. [According to this [http://daat.ac.il/daat/english/history/lapidot/27.htm Israeli site] with confirmation from this map [http://www.passia.org/palestine_facts/MAPS/images/jer_maps/UNPartition.html from the Passia organisation] ]
The irregular Arabic forces were rendered impotent and yielded to panic, calling the situation hopeless and announcing the imminent fall of the city. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.140]
Operation Ben'Ami (13-22 May)
Within the framework of
Plan Dalet, Yigal Yadinintended to make a breakthrough in the west of Galilee, wherein a number of isolated Jewish settlements were situated. This zone, which covers the land from Acre all the way to the Lebanese border, was allocated to the Arabs by the Partition plan, but was on the road through which Lebanese forces intended to enter into Palestine. [Yoav Gelber (2006), pp.134-135 Although the last (the Lebanese) ultimately would not engage in combat]
The command of this operation was entrusted to Moshe Carmel, head of the Carmeli brigade. It consisted of two phases: the first began on the evening of 13 May, when a column of Haganah's armoured vehicles and lorries advanced along the coast with no resistance. The forces of the Arab Liberation Army fled without entering battle, and the first phase of the operation finished when Acre was taken on 18 May. In the second phase, from the 19 May to the 21 May, troops went as far as the Yehi'am kibbutz by the Lebanese border, connecting it and conquering and destroying a number of Arab villages on the way. [Benny Morris (2003), pp.252-254)]
Main wave of the Palestinian Exodus
Haganah's move to offensive operations during the second phase of the war was accompanied by a huge exodus that involved 300,000 Arab refugees, not to forget the 100,000 of the First wave. The term 'Palestinian exodus' is often used to refer to both these and two subsequent waves. These two waves gained a considerable amount of press interest and were widely relayed in the press of the time, more so than most other Palestine-related events. [See, for example, in the New York Times archives : [http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/nytimes/96593062.html?did=96593062&FMT=ABS&FMTS=AI&date=May+3%2C+1948&author=&pub=New+York+Times++(1857-Current+file)&desc=DESPAIR+IS+VOICED+BY+ARAB+REFUGEES : Despair is voiced by arab refugees] ]
The causes of and responsibility for this exodus are highly controversial topics amongst commentators on the conflict and even historians who specialise in this era. Amongst the various possible causes, some attribute the exodus mainly to Arab authorities' instructions to escape, whereas others feel that a policy of expulsion had been organised by the
Yishuvauthorities and implemented by Haganah. Others yet reject these two assumptions and see the exodus as the cumulative effect of all the civil war's consequences.
Preparations made by the Arab League
During the last meeting of the Arab League in February 1948, the Arab leaders expressed their convictions in the capacity of the
Arab Liberation Armyto help the Palestinians and to force the international community to give up on the UN-backed partition plan. [Ilan Pappé (2000), p.147] The following summit took place in Cairo on 10 April, with the situation having clearly developed with the death of Al-Hussayni and the debacle at Mishmar Ha'emek.
Once again, Ismail Safwat called for the immediate deployment of the Arab state armies at the borders of Palestine, and for the need to go beyond the established policy of participating in little more than small-scale raids towards taking part in large-scale operations. For the first time, the Arab leaders discussed the possibility of intervening in Palestine. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.120]
Syriaand Lebanondeclared themselves ready to intervene immediately, but King Abdullah refused to let the Arab Legionforces intervene immediately in favour of the Palestinians, a move which irritated the Secretary-Generalof the League, who declared that Abdallah only cedes to the British diktat.
Nonetheless, Abdullah declared himself ready to send the Legion to assist the Palestinian cause after 15 May. In response, Syria insisted that the Egyptian army also take part, and, in spite of the opposition of Egypt's prime minister, King Farkouk responded favourably to the Syrian request, but due to his aim of curbing the Jordanians' hegemonic goals rather than his desire to help the Palestinians. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.120]
Later on, following the visit of several Palestinian dignitaries in
Amman, and despite the opposition of Syria and the Mufti, Hadj Amin Al-Hussayni, Azzam Pasha accepted Abdullah's proposition and sent Ismail Safwat to Ammanto organise a coordination between the Arab Liberation Armyand Jordan's Arab Legion. It was decided that command over the operations would be reserved for King Abdullah, and that the Iraqis would deploy a brigade in Transjordan to prepare for intervention on 15 May. [Yoav Gelber (2006), pp.122-123]
On 26 April, the 'intention to occupy Palestine' was officially announced at the Transjordanian parliament and the Jewish people were 'invited to place themselves beneath King Abdullah's jurisdiction.' The intention to spare their lives was also promised. Yishuv perceived this declaration as being one of war and encourages the Western world to pressure the King, through diplomatic means, to prevent his intervention. [Yoav Gelber (2006), pp.124-125]
On 30 April, Jordanians, Egyptians and Iraqis disputed the command of Abdullah. Abdullah received the honorary title of
Commander-in-Chief, whilst the Iraqi general, Aldine Nur Mahmud, was named Chief of Staff. Despite this show of unity, it was agreed that each army would act independent of each other in the theatre of operations. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.127]
On 4 May, the Iraqi task force arrived at
Mafraq. It was composed of a regiment of armoured tanks, a regiment of mechanised infantry, and twenty-four artillery weapons, and included 1500 men. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.126] The Egyptians formed two brigades, deploying around 700 men into the Sinai. [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.128] The Syrians could not put together a better force, whereas the Lebanese announced that they could not take part in military operations on 10 May.
It was only two days before, on 8 May, that the British Foreign Office was certain of the Arab invasion. Whereas British analysts considered that all Arab armies, except the Arab Legion, were not prepared for the engagements to come, [Yoav Gelber (2006), p.126; p.132] the Egyptian officers claimed that their advance would be 'a parade with the least risk,' and that their army 'would be in Tel-Aviv after just two weeks.'
The state of preparation of the army was such that they did not even have maps of Palestine. [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), pp.453-454] At the time, the final plans of invasion had not even been established yet. British leaders tried in vain to make the Arab leaders reconsider their decision, [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), p.133] and Ismail Safwat resigned in indifference, but the Arab states seemed resolute. On 15 May 1948, the
Arab Leagueannounced officially that it would intervene in Palestine to guarantee the security and right to self-determination of the inhabitants of Palestine in an independent state. [ [http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/History/arab_invasion.html Arab League Declaration, May 15 1948] from jewishvirtuallibrary.com, retrieved September 26 2007] Azzam Pasha declared on Cairo radio: 'This will be a war of extermination and a momentous massacre which will be spoken of like the Mongolian massacres and the Crusades.' [Dominique Lapierre et Larry Collins (1971), p.132; Benny Morris, "Righteous Victims", p. 219; Sachar, 1979, p. 333]
Results and aftermath
Benny Morris, the result of these five and a half months of fighting was a "decisive Jewish victory". On one side, the "Palestinian Arab military power was crushed" and most of the population was fleeing or had been driven out. On the other side, the "Haganah transformed from a militia into an army" and succeeded "in consolidating its hold on a continuous strip of territory embracing the Coastal Plain, the Jezreel Valley, and the Jordan Valley". The Yishuv proved it had the capability to defend itself, persuading the United States and the remaining of the world to support it and the "victory over the Palestinian Arabs gave the Haganah the experience and self-confidence [...] to confront [...] the invading armies of the Arab states. Benny Morris, "1948, p.179.]
On 14 May 1948,
David Ben-Guriondeclared the independence of the state of Israeland the 1948 Palestine warentered its second phase with the intervention of the Arab state armies and the beginning of the 1948 Arab-Israeli War.
;Main sources of the article
Yoav Gelber, "Palestine 1948", Sussex Academic Press, Brighton, 2006, ISBN 1845190750
Ilan Pappé, "La guerre de 1948 en Palestine", La fabrique éditions, 2000, ISBN 226404036X
* Efraïm Karsh, "The Arab-Israeli Conflict - The Palestine War 1948", Osprey Publishing, 2002, ISBN 1841763721
* Alain Gresh and Dominique Vidal, "Palestine 47, un partage avorté", Editions Complexe, 1994, ISBN 2870275218.
Dominique Lapierreand Larry Collins, "O Jérusalem", Robert Laffont, 1971, ISBN 2266106988
Benny Morris, "The Road to Jerusalem: Glubb Pasha, Palestine and the Jews", I.B.Tauris, 2002, ISBN 1860649890
Benny Morris, "The Birth Of The Palestinian Refugee Problem Revisited", Cambridge University Press, 2003, ISBN 0521009677
Benny Morris, "Histoire revisitée du conflit arabo-sioniste", Editions complexe, 2003, ISBN 2870279388
Benny Morris, "1948: A History of the First Arab-Israeli War", Yale University Press, 2008.
* Bickerton, Ian and Hill, Maria (2003). "Contested Spaces: The Arab-Israeli Conflict". McGraw-Hill. ISBN 0074712179
* Eugène Rogan,
Avi Shlaimet al., "La guerre de Palestine 1948 : derrière le mythe", Autrement, 2002, ISBN 2746702401
Henry Laurens, "Paix et guerre au Moyen-Orient", Armand Colin, Paris, 2005, ISBN 2200269773
* Pierre Razoux, "Tsahal, nouvelle histoire de l'armée israélienne", Perrin, 2006, ISBN 226202328X
;Other sources used in the article
* Jon and David Kimche, "A clash of destinies, The Arab-Jewish War and the founding of the state of Israel", Praeger, New-York, 1960,
Yitzhak Rabin, "Mémoires", Buchet/Chastel, 1980,
* Ahron Bregman, "Israel's Wars: A History Since 1947", 2002, London: Routledge. ISBN 0415287162
;Other sources on the topic
Uri Milstein, "History of Israel's War of Independence: A Nation Girds for War", vol.1, University Press of America, 1996, ISBN 0761803726
Uri Milstein, "History of Israel's War of Independence: The First Month", vol.2, University Press of America, 1997, ISBN 0761807217
Uri Milstein, "History of Israel's War of Independence: The First Invasion", vol.3, University Press of America, 1999, ISBN 0761807691
Uri Milstein, "History of Israel's War of Independence: Out of Crisis Came Decision", vol.4, University Press of America, 1999, ISBN 0761814892
* Salim Tamari, "Jérusalem 1948 : Les faubourgs arabes et leur destin durant la guerre", Institut des études palestiniennes, 2002, ISBN 9953900191
* Plan Daleth from [http://www.mideastweb.org/pland.htm mideastweb.org]
* United Nations Special Commission, First special Report to the Security Council : The Problem of Security in Palestine, 16 April 1948, [http://domino.un.org/UNISPAL.NSF/181c4bf00c44e5fd85256cef0073c426/fdf734eb76c39d6385256c4c004cdba7!OpenDocument from the United Nations website] .
* [http://www.palestineremembered.com/ Palestine remembered] Palestinian view.
* [http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/History/1948toc.html Jewish Virtual Library] Jewish view.
* Elie Chouraqui, "Ô Jérusalem, 2006.
Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.
Look at other dictionaries:
Lebanese Civil War — The Martyr s Square statue in Beirut, 1982, during the civil war Date 13 A … Wikipedia
1948 Arab–Israeli War — 1948 Arab Israeli War Part of 1948 Palestine war Ca … Wikipedia
Palestine Liberation Organization — P.L.O. and PLO redirect here. For Pot Limit Omaha, a variant of Poker, see Omaha hold em#Pot limit Omaha. Palestine Liberation Organization منظمة التحرير الفلسطينية Leader Mahmo … Wikipedia
1947 Jerusalem riots — The 1947 Jerusalem Riots occurred following the vote in the UN General Assembly in favour of the 1947 UN Partition Plan on 29 November 1947. The Arab Higher Committee declared a three day strike and public protest to begin on 2 December 1947, in… … Wikipedia
1948 — This article is about the year 1948. Millennium: 2nd millennium Centuries: 19th century – 20th century – 21st century Decades: 1910s 1920s 1930s – 1940s – 1950s … Wikipedia
1948 Palestine war — The 1948 Palestine war refers to the events that happened in Palestine between the vote on the partition plan of Palestine on November 30, 1947, to the end of the first Arab Israeli war on July 20, 1949. [This corresponds to the signature of the… … Wikipedia
PALESTINE LIBERATION ORGANIZATION — (PLO), Palestinian organization founded in May 1964 at a Palestinian Congress held in East Jerusalem (then under Jordanian rule) following intensive efforts of Ahmad al Shuqeiri, until then the representative of the Palestinian Arabs in the… … Encyclopedia of Judaism
Palestine — /pal euh stuyn / for 1, 2; /pal euh steen / for 3, n. 1. Also called Holy Land. Biblical name, Canaan. an ancient country in SW Asia, on the E coast of the Mediterranean. 2. a former British mandate (1923 48) comprising part of this country,… … Universalium
Palestine — For other uses, see Palestine (disambiguation) … Wikipedia
Palestine Police Force — The Palestine Police Force was a British colonial police service established in Palestine on 1 July, 1920,Sinclair, 2006.] when High Commissioner Herbert Samuel s civil administration took over responsibility for security from General Allenby s… … Wikipedia