Sic et Non


Sic et Non

"Sic et Non", an early scholastic text whose title translates from Latin as "Yes and No," was written by Peter Abelard. In the work, Abélard juxtaposes apparently contradictory quotations from the Church Fathers on many of the traditional topics of Christian theology. In the Prologue, Abélard outlines rules for reconciling these contradictions, the most important of which is noting the multiple significations of a single word. However, Abélard does not himself apply these rules in the body of the "Sic et non", which has led scholars to conclude that the work was meant as an exercise book for students in applying dialectic (logic) to theology.

Recensions and Dating of the "Sic et non"

There are eleven surviving full and partial manuscripts of the "Sic et non". These are:
*Zürich, Zentralbibliothek, Car. C. 162, fols. 23-38v (siglum Z)
*Tours, Bibliothèque Municipale, 85, fols. 106rb-118v (siglum T)
*Montecassino, Archivio dell'Abbadia, 174, pp. 277-451 (siglum C)
*Einsiedeln, Stiftsbibliothek, 300, pp. 1-74 (siglum E)
*Brescia, Biblioteca Quiriniana, A.V. 21, fols. 14-64v (siglum B)
*Douai, Bibliothèque Municipale, 357, fols. 140-155v (siglum D)
*London, British Museum, Royal 11 A v, fols. 73-98v (siglum L)
*München, Bayerische Staatsbibliothek, Clm. 18926, fols. 14v-105v (siglum M)
*Cambridge, University Library, Kk 3.24, fols. 67v-159 (siglum K)
*Avranches, Bibliothèque Municipale, 12, fols. 132-207 (siglum A)
*Cambridge, Corpus Christi College, 165, pp. 1-355 (siglum k)

There is also one surviving manuscript containing solely q. 117:
*Turin, Biblioteca Nazionale, MS E. v. 9 (749) (siglum S).

An examination of these manuscripts demonstrates the existence of successive drafts of the "Sic et non".
*Z is the earliest known recension of the "Sic et non", which, according to Constant Mews, dates to 1121. Parallels between Z and Abelard's other works from this period show that Z is not an abbreviation of the TCEBS recension of the "Sic et non", as Boyer and McKeon believed.
*TCEB and S belong to the next earliest recension of the "Sic et non", which dates to 1121-1126.
*DL belong to an intermediate recension of the "Sic et non", which likewise dates to the period 1121-1126.
*MKAk belong to the latest recension of the "Sic et non", which dates to the period 1127-1132.

Bibliography

*Peter Abelard. [http://individual.utoronto.ca/pking/resources/abelard/Sic_et_non.txt "Sic et non"] . Full Latin text provided by Peter King.
*Peter Abelard. "Sic et non: A Critical Edition". Ed. Blanche B. Boyer and Richard McKeon. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1976.
*Barrow, Julia. “Tractatus magistri Petri Abaielardi de sacramento altaris.” "Traditio" 40 (1985): 328-36.
*Buytaert, E. M. General introduction to "Petri Abaelardi opera theologica". CCCM 11. Turnholt 1969. p. xiii.
*Mews, Constant. General introduction to "Petri Abaelardi opera theologica". CCCM 13. Turnholt 1987. p. 21 and p. 51.


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Sic et Non — (lat. „so und [so] nicht“, so viel wie „Ja und Nein“) ist der Titel einer grundlegenden scholastischen Abhandlung aus den Jahren 1122/1123 von Pierre Abaelard einer in Darmstadt erscheinenden Zeitschrift, siehe Sic et non (Zeitschrift) …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Sic et non — (lat. „so und [so] nicht“, so viel wie „Ja und Nein“) ist der Titel einer grundlegenden scholastischen Abhandlung aus den Jahren 1122/1123 von Pierre Abaelard einer in Darmstadt erscheinenden Zeitschrift, siehe Sic et non (Zeitschrift) Diese… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • SIC ET NON — (лат. – так и не так) да и нет. Обозначение схоластического метода, созданного в основном Абеляром. При решении любого вопроса мы должны сначала выслушать авторитетов, говорящих за , и авторитетов, выступающих против , и, наконец, принять решение …   Философская энциклопедия

  • sic et non —   [lateinisch »so und nicht so«, »ja und nein«], Formel für das die scholastische Philosophie kennzeichnende methodische Schema der Quaestiones und Disputationen. Bei jeder Frage werden zuerst die dafür , dann die dagegensprechenden Autoritäten… …   Universal-Lexikon

  • sic et non — …   Useful english dictionary

  • Sic vos non vobis — (lat.), »so (schafft, arbeitet) ihr, (aber) nicht für euch«, ein vom jüngern Donatus (»Vita Vergilii«, 17) überliefertes Wort Vergils …   Meyers Großes Konversations-Lexikon

  • SIC VOS NON VOBIS — Bathylle (poète) Pour les articles homonymes, voir Bathylle. Bathylle, mauvais poète latin, contemporain de Virgile, s attribuait les vers du cygne de Mantoue : c est pour le confondre que Virgile composa cet hémistiche célèbre en le défiant …   Wikipédia en Français

  • sic — (izg. sȋk) uzv. DEFINICIJA znak kojim se upozorava na kakvu grešku u tekstu ili na kakav važan podatak; »tako (stoji u originalu)« SINTAGMA sic erat in fatis (izg. sic ȅrat ȉn fȃtis) tako je bilo suđeno; sic itur ad astra (izg. sic ȋtur ȁd ȁstra) …   Hrvatski jezični portal

  • SIC Internacional — Création 15 septembre 1997 Slogan Portugal mais perto de si Langue Portugais Pays …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Sic 'Em Friday — and Sic emation are blocks of programming on MTV2. Each block is dedicated to airing outrageous shows, either of the live action or animated variety. How it startedAs 2005 began, most of MTV2 s programming continued moving with the general trend… …   Wikipedia


We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.