- Portrayal of women in comics
Womenhave been portrayed in comic bookssince the medium's beginning, with their portrayals often the subject of controversy. Sociologistswith an interest in gender rolesand stereotypinghave outlined the role of women as both supporting characters and as potential leaders struggling to be accepted as equals. Another point of study has been the depiction of women in comics, in which, as in other forms of popular culture, body types are unrealistically portrayedFact|date=July 2008.
Golden Age of comic books
There was a time when more girls read comics than boys. [Robbins, Trina. "From Girls to Grrrlz: A History of Women's Comics from Teens to Zines" (San Francisco: Chronicle Books, 1999), p. 7; ISBN 0756781205] One of the first books geared to these readers was "
Archie Comics", starring a group of all-American teens— Archie Andrews, Jughead Jones, and Veronica Lodge—who had debuted in " Pep Comics" #22.
During the 1930s-1940s period that fans and historians call the
Golden Age of comic books, a time during which the medium evolved from comic strips, women who were not superheroeswere primarily portrayed three ways: as career girls, romance-story heroines, or perky teenagers. [Robbins, Ibid.]
Career-oriented girls included such characters as
Nellie the Nurse, Tessie the Typist, and Millie the Model, each of whom appeared in comic books geared toward female readers using the types of jobs that non-wartime women of the era typically worked: nurse, secretary, and actress/model. Teachers were also sometimes portrayed.
The second role was evident in the very popular romance genre, pioneered by
Joe Simonand Jack Kirby. A woman in those stories could be the good girl or the bad girl. A good girl gets her heart broken while the bad girl breaks all the boys’ hearts. A good girl could also be happily married while a bad girl who tries to be good but can’t give up her wild side and goes back to being bad.
The third role was as a perky teenager. This is embodied by characters such as those in titles such as Betty and Veronica. The lead characters were both boy crazed and completely fun loving teenagers. Betty and Veronica spent all their time fighting over who would get to date Archie. Josie and her band, the Pussycats, always managed to find their way into some sort of adventure but emerged unscathed. [
List of superheroines"
* The first known female superhero is writer-artist
Fletcher Hanks's minor character Fantomah, [ [http://www.toonopedia.com/fantomah.htm Don Markstein's Toonopedia: Fantomah] ] an ageless, ancient Egyptian woman in the modern day who could transform into a skull-faced creature with superpowers to fight evil; she debuted in Fiction House's "Jungle Comics" #2 (Feb. 1940), credited to the pseudonymous "Barclay Flagg".
Another seminal superheroine is
Invisible Scarlet O'Neil, a non-costumed character who fought crime and wartime saboteurs using the superpower of invisibility; she debuted in the eponymous syndicated newspaper comic stripby Russell Stammon June 3 1940. A superpowered female antihero, the Black Widow—a costumed emissary of Satanwho killed evildoers in order to send them to Hell—debuted in "Mystic Comics" #4 (Aug. 1940), from Timely Comics, the 1940s predecessor of Marvel Comics. The superpowered Nelvana of the Northern Lightsdebuted in Canadian publisher Hillborough Studio's "Triumph-Adventure Comics" #1 (Aug. 1941).
The first widely recognizable female superhero is "
Wonder Woman", from All-American Publications, one of three companies that would merge to form DC Comics. In an October 25 1940, interview conducted by former student Olive Byrne (under the pseudonym 'Olive Richard') and published in " Family Circle", titled "Don't Laugh at the Comics", William Moulton Marstondescribed what he saw as the great educational potential of comic books (a follow up article was published two years later in 1942. [Richard, Olive. " [http://www.wonderwoman-online.com/articles/fc-marston.html Our Women Are Our Future] ."] ) This article caught the attention of comics publisher Max Gaines, who hired Marston as an educational consultant for National Periodicals and All-American Publications, two of the companies that would merge to form the future DC Comics. At that time, Marston decided to develop a new superhero. In the early 1940s the DC line was dominated by superpowered male characters such as the Green Lantern, Batman, and its flagship character, Superman. According to the Fall 2001 issue of the Boston Universityalumni magazine, it was his wife Elizabeth's idea to create a female superhero:
Marston introduced the idea to
Max Gaines, cofounder (along with Jack Liebowitz) of All-American Publications. Given the go-ahead, Marston developed "Wonder Woman" with Elizabeth (whom Marston believed to be a model of that era's unconventional, liberated woman). [' [http://www.bu.edu/alumni/bostonia/2001/fall/wonderwoman/ Who Was Wonder Woman?] ] In creating Wonder Woman, Marston was also inspired by Olive Byrne, who lived with the couple in a polygamous/polyamorous relationship. [Les Daniels, "Wonder Woman: The Complete History," (DC Comics, 2000), pp. 28-30.] Marston's pseudonym, Charles Moulton, combined his own and Gaines' middle names.
Marston was also the creator of a systolic blood-pressure measuring apparatus, which was crucial to the development of the polygraph (lie detector). Marston's experience with polygraphs convinced him that women were more honest and reliable than men, and could work more efficiently.
In a 1943 issue of "
The American Scholar", Marston wrote:
Some of Marston Moulton's early stories included Wonder Woman as president of the United States ["Wonder Woman" #7 (Winter 1943)] and as a modern-day
Incan Sun God, ["The Secret City of the Incas", "Sensation Comics" #18 (June 1943)] both non-traditional roles for women. Despite such portrayals of women in leadership roles, however, editor Sheldon Mayerwas disturbed by the recurring bondage imagery. [Daniels, Ibid.. p. 6] One issue dealt with Wonder Woman losing control because her bracelets had broken; she was driven mad because the bracelets represented restraint, and stated "power without self-control tears a girl to pieces". ["The Unbound Amazon", "Sensation Comics" #19 (June 1943)]
As superheroes began to fade out of fashion in the post-
World War IIera, comic book publishers scrambled to explore new types of stories, characters, and audiences. In an attempt to appeal to young female readers, comics companies began introducing some of the first significant superheroines since Wonder Woman. These new female leads would include Timely's Blonde Phantom, Golden Girl, Miss America, Namora, Sun Girl, and Venus; Fox Comics' revival of Quality Comics' Phantom Lady; and DC's Black Canary.
The jungle girl archetype also made her transition from pulp fiction to comic books, with such examples from the 1940s and 1950s as
Jann of the Jungle, Nyoka the Jungle Girl, and Sheena, Queen of the Jungle. Such heroines would later be criticized for wearing skimpy clothing.
Batman, the Phantom and other non-superpowered heroes, female costumed crimefighters were among the early comics characters. The Woman in Red, [ [http://www.toonopedia.com/womanred.htm Don Markstein's Tonnopedia: The Woman in Red] and [http://www.comics.org/details.lasso?id=675 Grand Comics Database: "Thrilling Comics" #2] ] introduced in Standard Comics' "Thrilling Comics" #2 (March 1940), was a police officerwith a dual identity. Lady Luck, debuted in the Sunday- newspapercomic-book insert "The Spirit Section" on June 2 1940. The tough-fighting Miss Fury, [ [http://www.toonopedia.com/missfury.htm Don Markstein's Toonopedia: Miss Fury] ] debuted in the eponymous comic strip by female cartoonist Tarpé Millson April 6 1941, and the equally formidable Phantom Ladywas introduced in Quality Comics"Police Comics" #1 (Aug. 1941). Harvey Comicshad the motorcycle-riding Black Cat, [ [http://www.toonopedia.com/blackcat.htmon Markstein's Toonopedia: Black Cat] and [http://www.comics.org/details.lasso?id=1572 Grand Comics Database: "Pocket Comics" #1] ] introduced in "Pocket Comics" #1 (also Aug. 1941).
One publisher in particular,
Fiction House, featured several progressive heroines such as the jungle queen Sheena. As Trina Robbins, in "The Great Women Superheroes" (Kitchen Sink Press, 1996, ISBN 0-87816-481-2), wrote:
The Spirit and femme fatales
During World War II, women assumed jobs formerly occupied by men, becoming truck drivers, stevedores, and welders. Many women refused to give up their newfound freedom, creating a massive crisis in formerly naturalized definitions of masculinity and feminity.
femme fatale(prevalent in The Spiritcomic book) exemplified this crisis-a strong, sexually aggressive woman who refused to stay in her traditional "proper" place. [Thomas Andrae, "Carl Barks and the Disney Comic Book: Unmasking the Myth of Modernity", University Press of Mississippi, 2006, ISBN 1578068584, p. 95]
In the Spirit's many adventures, the femme fatale was a character that sought revenge usually through blackmail or exploitation. One such adventure includes Broadway Lily, who attempts to exploit political tensions between the Spirit's confidant, Commissioner Dolan, and the Mayor. A doctored photograph of Dolan and Broadway Lily is given to the Mayor with the intention of forcing Dolan to resign. The Spirit discovers that Broadway Lily was bitter that the Commissioner arrested her lover, Foxy Dan, and wanted to exact revenge. ["The Spirit Section" (
August 29 1943)] When women turn away from feminine wiles to commit violent crime, however, the Spirit finds himself shocked. The Spirit comments about how women in organized crime are doing what men generally do. The response he gets is: "Didn’t you ever hear of the manpower shortage, handsome?" ["The Spirit Section": "Woman Crooks" (Sept. 12, 1943)]
The Silver Age of Comic Books
Between 1961 and 1963, one of the top two comic book genres was romance comics. Many influences from this genre overlapped in the superhero comics of the era. Although superhero titles would eventually become the leading
genre, DC Comics’ Young Romancewould end its thirty-year run in 1977. [Trina Robbins, From Girls to Grrrlz: a History of Women’s Comics from Teens to Zines, p.77, Diane Pub Co, 1999, ISBN 0756781205 ]
During this time frame, the comics of the
Silver Age of Comic Bookspublished by Marvel and DC were different enough that if you liked one, you were liable not to like the other. If you wanted the classic feel of the original 1940’s superheroes, you were a DC partisan. If you wanted fast action mixed with the emotional angst reflecting a world where social unrest was slowly coming to a boil, you were more likely to read the Marvel offerings [ Foreword, Doom Patrol Archives, Volume 2, pp.5-6, Roy Thomas, writer, ISBN 978-1401201500, 2004 ]
After the implementation of the
Comics Code, DC Comics implemented its own in-house Editorial Policy Code regarding the portrayal of women, which stated, "The inclusion of females in stories is specifically discouraged. Women, when used in plot structure, should be secondary in importance, and should be drawn realistically, without exaggeration of feminine physical qualities". [Uslan, Michael. "Batman in the Fifties" (2002) Introduction, p.5. ISBN 1-56389-810-1, 2002 ]
Most of DC's Silver Age superheroes each had a major female supporting character. These included two career women:
journalist Lois Lane, who worked at "The Daily Planet" with Superman's alter ego, Clark Kent; and aircraft manufacturer Carol Ferris, the boss of Green Lantern's alter ego, Hal Jordan. Iris Westwas the on-again, off-again girlfriend of the Flash's alter ego, Barry Allen. Batman's supporting cast, beginning in the 1950s, occasionally included journalist Vicki Valeand heiress Kathy Kane, whose alter ego was the motorcycle-riding masked crimefighter Batwoman. With a tip of her cowl to the Harvey Comicscharacter the Black Cat, who preceded her by 15 years as a superheroine on a motorcycle, Batwoman used weapons as well, although hers included powder puffs, charm bracelets, perfume, a hair net, a compact mirror, and a shoulder bag utility case with matching bolo strap. [Uslan, Introduction]
Her first appearance, in 1956, was greeted with thugs retorting, "Ha-ha! What can she do?" and, referring the Batman, Robin and Batwoman, "There's only two of them. The girl doesn’t count". As for the heroes themselves, Robin tells Batman, "A girl saving you? It’s ridiculous!", while Batman tells Batwoman, "This is no place for a girl" and Batwoman herself sighs, "How could any woman ever equal the great Batman?" ["Detective Comics" #233 (July 1956)]
In 1964, Batman editor
Julius Schwartzintroduced a modernized Batman to fans. This "New Look" Batman not only had a revamped Batcave, a souped-up Batmobile, and new Bat-gadgets, but a new love interest: Police officer Patricia (Pat) Powell. ["Batman" #165 (Aug 1964)] The daughter of police detective Mike "Bulldog" Powell, she wins the Gotham City Police Academy's annual award for top-ranking cadet in Academics, Physical, Firearms, and Overall. Award-presenter Batman is shocked that such an award is going to a woman. He is even more shocked when Powell shares a secret with him that she has a crush on Bruce Wayne, Batman's secret civilian identity. Allowed to work with Batman on her first case, she gets distracted by a tobacco package with the initials BW and starts to daydream about Bruce Wayne Like many other female characters of DC's early years, she does not know that the man she loves is the secret identity of a famous superhero.
Of the women of DC's Silver Age, Carol Ferris in "
Green Lantern" was unique in that she was Hal Jordan's boss. Despite his best efforts to date her, Carol firmly rejects his advances and adapts a business-first mentality. [Carol Ferris: "You heard what dad said. I've got to satisfy his faith in me—and that means that during the next two years, I'll have absolutely no time for romance! I'm your boss Hal Jordan and that's orders."—"Showcase" #22 (Sept. 1959), "The Menace of the Runaway Missile", pp. 8-9, writer John Broome]
She later assumed the role of a superheroine. Women from the Planet Zamaron (in their language meaning Land of Lovely Women) notice Ferris resembles their fallen Queen. ["Green Lantern" #16 (Oct. 1962), "The Secret Life of Star Sapphire", p.3, writer
Gardner Fox] The Zamaronians give Carol the identity of Star Sapphireand convince her to fight Green Lantern. Despite this new identity, the influence of the romance genre carries over into their battles. A strategy is devised in which Star Sapphire will weaken Green Lantern to such an extent that she will propose marriage to him. ["Green Lantern" #26 (Jan. 1964), "Star Sapphire Unmasks Green Lantern", p. 9, writer Gardner Fox] While recharging the ring, Star Sapphire unmasks Green Lantern, and he promises to marry her. With his power ring, Green Lantern reads her mind and discovers that she is Ferris. He erases her memory of what occurred so that he can put off marriage.
DC's Doom Patrol had many similarities to Marvel's X-Men. Its leader was in a wheelchair, its members were seen as outcasts, and there was an attractive female, Rita Farr (Elasti-Girl), who added an edge of romantic tension. She was involved solely with her future husband, Steve Dayton (
Mento), who wanted her to leave the team. ["Doom Patrol" #91 (Nov. 1964), "Mento - The Man Who Split the Doom Patrol", writer Arnold Drake]
Atlas Comicsbecame Marvel Comicsin 1961, many brand new women superheroes were introduced. The first female superhero from Marvel Comics was the Invisible Girl, aka Susan Storm, charter member of the Fantastic Four. These superheroes were given a strong supporting role but were often maligned. The Wasp (Janet Van Dyne) was an early example. She would have to endure the tone of the fatherly Giant-Man(Henry Pym), who would ignore her romantic advances. Although these characters would develop and become cornerstones of the Marvel Universe, their early treatment would resemble a struggle to be recognized as equals.
The Fantastic Four's early adventures in the Silver Age had the feel of the Romance Genre. The Invisible Girl is central to this. An instant attraction occurs when she meets Prince Namor, the
Sub-Mariner. [ Fantastic Four # 4, "The Coming of the Sub-Mariner", p.21, Stan Lee, Writer (1962) ] He immediately asks for her hand in marriage, with the agreement that he will not attack the human race. When she reluctantly agrees, Namor becomes insulted, as he feels that she is sacrificing herself. An attack by the rest of the Fantastic Four, results in Namor fleeing the scene.
Despite this confrontation, the romance element is evident when the Invisible Girl’s brother, the
Human Torch, aka Johnny Storm, finds a photograph of the Sub-Mariner on a bookshelf. [ Fantastic Four # 6, "Captives of the Deadly Duo", Stan Lee, Writer (1962) ] Both struggle to get the picture when the Human Torch decides to burn the picture.
After this confrontation, Namor enters the Baxter Building and the Human Torch attempts to attack him. The Invisible Girl stands in front of Namor and tries to protect him from the attack. The romantic tension between the two would come to define the image of the Invisible Woman during Marvel’s early years.
Another example of the romance genre's influence would include
Marvel Girl(aka Jean Grey) of the X-Men. In the early days of the X-Men, Jean Grey is the object of two members of the X-Men's affection. In issue #25, the Betty and Veronica portrayal plays a role reversal. Cyclops (aka Scott Summers) and Warren Worthington III (aka The Angel) both have feelings for Jean Grey after she goes off to college.
When Thor was introduced in
Journey Into Mystery, his civilian alter ego was Dr. Don Blake. Don Blake developed a crush on his nurse, Jane Foster (comics). Like the women of the Golden Age, Foster was categorized into the category of a career girl. This crush would create tension between the relationship of Thor, and his father Odin.
The tension would continue between father and son. Eventually, a decision was made by Odin to turn Jane Foster into an immortal. Stan Lee had introduced another plot twist. Before she could become immortal, Jane Foster would need to pass a test to prove her worthy of being an immortal. Jane Foster had shown fear and in effect, failed her test. [ Thor # 136, ”To Become an Immortal”, pp.9-11, Stan Lee, 1967 ] The result of Jane Foster being refused for godhood created another Betty and Veronica scenario. In the same issue, Odin would attempt to have Thor forget about Jane Foster by re-introducing him to the goddess Sif.
The most noticeable example of women playing a supporting role is the women involved in the life of Marvel’s flagship character –
Spider-Man(aka Peter Parker). Spider-Man’s first appearance in Amazing Fantasy # 15 features the most important woman in his life enduring a traumatizing moment. His Aunt May witnesses the murder of her husband, Peter's beloved Uncle Ben. Throughout the rest of the Silver Age of Comic Books, Aunt May would be constantly sick. Spider-Man (as Peter Parker) would work for the Daily Bugleas a way to help ends meet. Parker's going to college would lead to guilt about his Aunt May.
; Peter Parker: "You're a great guy Parker. Worrying about getting your own apartment, buying a new cycle, thinking only of number one. - While the woman who's devoted her life to you does without her medicine because she can't afford a new bottle." [ The Amazing Spider-Man # 42, p. 20, Stan Lee, writer, 1965 ]
After Aunt May, the next woman in the Spider-Man mythos would be an employee of the "Daily Bugle"-
Betty Brant. She is the receptionist for J. Jonah Jameson, publisher of the Daily Bugle. A big part of Peter Parker’s identity is that he is not liked in school, but Betty respects Peter and sees him as more than just a bookworm.Fact|date=February 2007 Like all the other women in Spider-Man’s life, Brant's personal tragedy would have an impact on his life. Betty’s tragedy would be that her brother, Bennett Brantwas accidentally murdered during a fight with Spider-Man and Doctor Octopus, and she blamed Spider-Man. This event would dramatically alter Peter and Betty’s friendship. [The Amazing Spider-Man # 11, Stan Lee, writer, 1963]
It would also be in the Silver Age that Peter Parker would meet another important woman in his life –
Mary Jane Watson[The Amazing Spider-Man # 40, Stan Lee, writer, 1965] Mary Jane is the niece of Aunt May’s best friend, Anna Watson. Although her personal relationship with Parker would not develop until the tail end of the Bronze Age of Comic Books, she was part of the Amazing Spider-Man's supporting cast. Her presence would make Gwen Stacy, another woman in his life, jealous. One of the first examples was evident when Peter's friends throw a party for Flash Thompson, who was going to Vietnam.
Peter enters the party with Mary Jane and starts to talk to Gwen. This behaviour is also recognized by another partygoer, Betty Brant. The dynamic between Gwen and Mary Jane is reminiscent of the very popular romance genre. One is the good girl while the other is the bad girl. At the party, Gwen and Mary Jane were supposed to give out burgers to the partygoers but try to outdance each other.
The Bronze Age of Comic Books
The Bronze Age of Comics reflected many of the feminist tensions of the era. One of the examples, from the Bronze Age, where women are seen for their strength is in the works of
Steve Gerber. The characters of Beverly Switzlerin the Howard the Ducktitle and Jennifer Kalein the Man-Thingtitle play a very strong supporting role. In the first issue of Howard the Duck, Beverly prevents Howard from committing suicide. The friendship with Beverly is what helps Howard the Duck cope with being on Earth. Jennifer Kale is the only human that has any psychic link with the Man-Thing. [Adventure into Fear 14, The Demon Plague, p.8, Writer, Steve Gerber, Artist, Val Mayerik, Marvel Comics Group]
Despite their strong roles, both are still portrayed as victims and as sex objects. Beverly makes ends meet by posing as a nude model. Her beauty seems to lead her into various problems, as she is kidnapped by
Dr. Bong, a character who knew Bev as a teenager and was obsessed with her. His obsession leads him to wanting to marry her. Beverly marries Dr. Bong in exchange for Howard’s life. The result is that Howard the Duck is turned into a human as a punishment for trying to rescue her. In another adventure, Beverly is kidnapped by a shiek who wants to enslave her, and Howard must try to rescue her once more. [Howard the Duck Annual 1, Steve Gerber, Writer, Marvel Comics Group ] Jennifer Kalefinds trouble in her first appearance in comics. She steals an enchanted book, and accidentally summons demons from another world. [Adventure into Fear 11, Night of the Nether-Spawn, pp. 2-4, Writer, Steve Gerber, Artist, Rich Buckler, Marvel Comics Group] The released demon chases Jennifer to a movie theatre where the Man-Thing comes to her rescue. The Man-Thing and the demon resume their fight in the swamp where Jennifer burns the enchanted book and the demon disappears. Jennifer is apologetic to the Man-Thing for her behaviour.
When Jennifer’s grandfather discovers that she has a psychic link with the Man-Thing, Jennifer is still portrayed as a victim. The two are kidnapped by
Dakimh the Enchanterand brought to the world Sandt where the Man-Thing must fight Mongu the Gladiator so that both can be freed or else they will die. [Adventure into Fear 14, The Demon Plague, p.8, Writer, Steve Gerber, Artist, Val Mayerik, Marvel Comics Group]
In the 1980s, under writer-artist
John Byrne, Susan Richards found new uses for her powers and developed an assertive self-confidence to use her powers more aggressively. She changed her alias from the Invisible Girl to the Invisible Woman. ["Fantastic Four" #283, 1985 ]
One of the first women from the history of Marvel would undergo a huge transformation in the Bronze Age of Comics. Jean Grey aka Marvel Girl would not only become romantically involved with Cyclops, but would have to deal with the advances of Wolverine. [ Classic X-Men #1, Chris Claremont, 1986 ] The Betty and Veronica situation that occurred with Cyclops and Angel during the Silver Age had now carried on to Cyclops and Wolverine in the Bronze Age. Despite these romantic issues, Jean Grey was transformed into the omnipotent Phoenix. [ X-Men #101,Chris Claremont, 1986 ] In an era that represented the Women's Liberation Movement, this transformation reflected the changes of society.
Throughout most of the Silver and Bronze Age, women in comics were not given leadership positions. Men (led by characters such as Mr. Fantastic,
Captain America, and Cyclops) chaired teams such as the Avengers, Fantastic Four, and the X-Men. In the Bronze Age and early Modern Age, characters such as Invisible Woman and the Wasp would chair the Fantastic Four and the Avengers, respectively. Fact|date=February 2007
Bronze Age of Comic Booksrepresented a change for the X-Men. The forming of a new group representing various nationalities of the world would mark a turning point in the history of the team. Storm aka Ororo Munroe, would be the first relevant African-American superheroine of the era. She was the first black female, to play either a major or supporting role in the big two comic book houses, Marvel Comicsand DC Comics. One of her defining moments would be eventually succeeding Cyclops as leader of the X-Men during the early years of the Modern Age of Comics. [ Uncanny X-Men #201, Chris Claremont, writer, 1985 ] This was unique because Storm was a visible minority and would join Monica Rambeau, aka the second Captain Marvel (who chaired the Avengers) as minorities in leadership positions.
The Modern Age of Comic Books
Due to the fan–based nature of the comic book industry, many of the readers feel, either directly or indirectly, that they are involved in a social practice. [ By Jeffrey A. Brown, Black Superheroes: Milestone Comics and Their Fans, p. 129, 2001, University Press of Mississippi, ISBN 15780628291 ] The attachment to the titles and the characters obtains a life all its own. There is a sense of social contact with the books and the characters themselves. [ By Jeffrey A. Brown, Black Superheroes: Milestone Comics and Their Fans, p. 129, 2001, University Press of Mississippi, ISBN 15780628291 ] By adopting these properties, a unique relationship for the reader develops. Due to this relationship, the context in which women are presented in comic books can have various effects.
This portrayal would be put to the test in the Modern Age. While there were many examples of strong, female characters getting their own titles, including Ghost from
Dark Horse Comics, " Strangers in Paradise" from Terry Moore, " 9 Chickweed Lane", "Birds of Prey" and the newly invented Supergirlat DC Comics, it was not uncommon that sex was used to sell comics as well. In the 2000s, Frank Cho’s " Liberty Meadows" was a key example of having strong female roles but blending it with skimpy outfits and the occasional nudity.
Bad Girl Trend
The creation of sexualised female characters was very common with independent publishers, leading some to dub it "
bad girl art". The most infamous example of this type was in " Team Youngblood" #14, published by Image Comicsin the mid-1990s. The character Riptide poses nude for a men's magazineand is dismissed from Team Youngblood. Image Comics continued to set the trend with its very popular " Gen¹³", in which many of the characters appeared in bikinis or in skimpy clothing holding guns. Other bad girl characters from Image include Voodoo and Witchblade(later part of the Top Cowimprint).
The decade would continue with other sexually suggestive characters from the independents including
Barb Wire(from Dark Horse Comics), Lady Death(from Chaos! Comics), Lady Rawhide (from Topps Comics), Mantra (from Malibu Ultraverse), and Vampirella(from Harris Comics). Even a popular brand like DC Comics’ Vertigo imprint started to capitalize on the trend. Books such as Codename: Knockout and Vamps were published in the 1990’s. By the time the speculator market crashed, most of these “bad girl” comics met their end.
The trend towards sexually suggestive characters was also felt at Marvel Comics. In the early 1990s, characters such as the Invisible Woman (see Fantastic Four # 375) and the
Scarlet Witch(see Scarlet Witch #1) started wearing revealing outfits. She-Hulk was also doing a nude jump rope issue in The Sensational She-Hulk#40. It is worth noting that the first truly sexually suggestive character in the Marvel Comics mythos appeared in the Bronze Age of Comic Booksin the form of the White Queen, Emma Frost. The White Queen appeared in the X-Men during the Dark Phoenixsaga and her lingerie-like outfits and dominant personality became her trademarks, which she carried on even as a superhero and member of the X-Men.
During the Modern Age of Comics, an issue that has gained attention in society is body image. Many images of women in popular culture have been accused of altering what people perceive as appropriate body typesFact|date=July 2008. The learned body image that develops is deeply tied to gender identity. The range of eating disorders and body image that are developed come from what people believe to be the cultural ideal. [Margaret L. Andersen and Howard F. Taylor, Sociology: The Essentials, Third Edition, p. 275, Thomson Wadsworth, 2005 ]
An example of a character with an imperfectFact|date=July 2008 body type but still has a fan following is Francine from
Strangers in Paradise. Francine has a round face and a small collection of fat underneath the chin, while appearing as slightly overweight. Her stomach is not flat and does not display any discernible muscle tone. She is what Trina Robbins describes as “pleasingly plump” and is very far from the stereotypes of exaggerated female forms. [Trina Robbins, From Girls to Grrrlz: a History of Women’s Comics from Teens to Zines, p. 139, Diane Pub Co, 1999, ISBN 0756781205 ]
Another example of body image in comics is in a flashback tale set in Smallville. Set in Clark Kent’s high school days, Clark sees others laughing at an overweight girl that is called “Marge the Barge” because she does not have a date for the homecoming dance. Clark Kent decides to reject Lana Lang’s offer to be his date for the homecoming dance, and asks out Marge the Barge. [ACTION COMICS #791, “The Invitation”, Benjamin Raab, DC Comics, July 2002 ]
She actually rejects him because she feels he is asking her out due to pity. She tells him that after the dance, she will be long gone. Clark interprets this as suicide and is concerned. Upon seeing her standing on the edge of the bridge in town, he screams at her to not jump. After a discussion, Clark finds out the she will be long gone due to early admissions to college. [ACTION COMICS #791, “The Invitation”, Benjamin Raab, DC Comics, July 2002 ]
After getting to know each other, Clark takes her to homecoming. With some help from Lana Lang, the Homecoming vote is rigged and Clark and Marge become Homecoming King and Queen. Once the event is over, Marge goes home and is hit by a drunk driver on the same bridge where she talked to Clark. The driver was a drunk teenager who was bitter that he was not made Homecoming King. Clark assumed that because she was overweight, that she was suicidal, and once he got to know her, he found that she was a likeable person. [ACTION COMICS #791, “The Invitation”, Benjamin Raab, DC Comics, July 2002 ]
The excess of exaggeratedFact|date=July 2008 comic-book women has been satirized on occasion within the medium. Writer-artist
Jhonen Vasquezfeatured a tall, blonde, buxom, scantily clad, dumb superheroine in the alternative presscomic "Squee!" #2, with the storyline addressing her ability to stand up straight with an improbably tiny waist and overlarge chest. After a poke to the forehead, she tips over and her superhero career comes to an end as her spine snaps from the weight.
In 2002, writer
Steve Gerber's " Howard the Duck" miniseriesfor Marvel Comics' mature-reader imprint Marvel MAXapproached the topic of scantily clad superheroines, within a larger satirical framework. Issue #2 featured nudity, as Beverly's bare chest was visible in the shower. In issue #3, Howard and his human companion Beverly Switzlerrun across a woman police officer who has acquired the "Doucheblade", a parody of Image Comics' Witchblade, which transforms the officer into a superheroine whose chest expand and whose clothes disappear.
In the 21st Century, the roles of many women have changed. Roles and choices such as single parenting, same-sex relationships, and positions of power in the workplace have come to define many women in modern society. These roles have found their way into the comic books of the 21st Century as well. Lesbian relationships were initially featured in underground and in alternative titles, such as Julie Doucet's "Dirty Plotte", before entering the mainstream with
Image Comics' Gen¹³and Marvel Comics' " Exiles" #34 (Nov. 2003).
Lesbianism has become increasingly common in modern comic books. Many characters, such as Quasar/Captain Marvel,
Batwomanand Renee Montoyaare portrayed as lesbians despite their previous incarnations being heterosexual. Marvel Comics' Exiles is a team of mutants from alternate-realityuniverses. Each member of the loose-knit group is attempting to find his or her way back home by repairing "broken chains of time". One of the characters was an alternate version of Mariko Yashida, known in her universe as the superpowered mutant Sunfire. She and her teammate Nocturne end up on a version of Earth where most of the characters are plagued by the Legacy Virus. ["Exiles" #34 (Nov. 2003)] In this alternate Earth, Mary Jane Watsonhas Spider-Man's powers and abilities. The two characters are romantically linked and kiss each other. While Nocturne speaks with the alternate-Earth version of Hank McCoy, Watson and Yashida are seen sharing a bed in a post-coital scene, with Watson saying she'd always known Yashida was gay. The current version of " Batman and the Outsiders" includes a lesbian relationship between Thunder and Grace Choi.
Single parenthood starts to become a prevalent issue in this age with both Marvel and DC. Jessica Jones, the wife of
Luke Cage, aka Power Man, leaves the United States with their baby, out of fear for the events of the Civil War. [New Avengers 22, New Avengers Disassembled: Part Two, Brian Michael Bendis, Writer, Marvel Comics Group, 2006] Jones goes to Torontowith her child, while Luke Cage fights with Captain America’s “Secret Avengers”, in opposition to the Superhero Registration Act. DC’s Birds of Prey series also tackles the issue of single parenting. The Black Canarygives up being a hero to take care of her newly adopted daughter. “It’s more important for me to be faithful to you, and that means getting you away from all the costumes and crazies. See, the mistake mom was afraid I’d repeat was that I wouldn’t spend enough time with my own kid.” [Birds of Prey 100, “Keepsakes”, Tony Bedard and Gail Simone, p. 50, DC Comics, January 2007 ] Longtime DC villain/hero Catwomanalso became a single mother beginning in the One Year Latercontinuity, though she is eventually forced to give up her daughter due to the danger of her lifestyle.
In 1999, a new website was launched entitled
Women in Refrigerators. It featured a list of female comic book characters who had been injured, killed, or depowered within various superhero comic books and sought to analyze why these plot devices were used disproportionately on female characters.
In 2007, Sideshow Collectibles produced a 14.25-inch "comiquette" statuette designed by
Adam Hughesshowing Mary Jane hand-washing Peter Parker's Spider-Mancostume. [cite news
last = Hughes
first = Adam
title = ADAM HUGHES ON THE MARY JANE STATUE
work = NEWSARAMA
url = http://forum.newsarama.com/showthread.php?t=113690 ] The statuette has received criticism for MJ's ostensibly highly-sexualized and objectifying pose. [cite news
last = Graves
first = Neil
title = MARY JANE IS SPIDEY 'SENSUOUS'
New York Post
May 16, 2007
url = http://www.nypost.com/seven/05162007/news/nationalnews/mary_jane_is_spidey_sensuous_nationalnews_neil_graves.htm ] cite news
last = Arpe
first = Malene
title = No plumber's butt for Spidey?
Toronto Star Newspapers Ltd.
May 17, 2007
url = http://www.thestar.com/article/214778 ]
Good girl art
Bad girl art
*Woman in Refrigerator syndrome
9 Chickweed Lane
Silver Age of Comic Books
Bronze Age of Comic Books
Modern Age of Comic Books
List of women warriors in folklore, literature, and popular culture
* Walker, Douglas J. (EDT) Cognitive Technology: essays on the transformation of thought and society, 2004, McFarland and Company, ISBN 0786419741
Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.