Argument from degree


Argument from degree

The argument from degrees or the degrees of perfection argument is an argument for the existence of God first proposed by Thomas Aquinas as one of the five ways to prove God in his "Summa Theologica". It is based on ontological and theological notions of perfection. [cite encyclopedia | first=Simon | last=Blackburn | title=Degrees of perfection argument | encyclopedia=Oxford Dictionary of Philosophy | publisher=Oxford University Press | id=ISBN 0-19-283134-8] Contemporary Thomist scholars are often in disagreement on the metaphysical justification for this proof.

Aquinas's original formulation

Syllogistic form

A syllogistic form collected by Robert J. Schihl follows:quote
# Objects have properties to greater or lesser extents.
# If an object has a property to a lesser extent, then there exists some other object that has the property to the maximum possible degree.
# So there is an entity that has all properties to the maximum possible degree.
# Hence God exists. [ [http://www.regent.edu/acad/schcom/phd/com707/aquinas.html Aquinas'/Anselm's Arguments in Syllogistic Form ] ]

Rebuttals

A common argument is that it is not evident that simply because we can conceive of an object with some property in a greater degree, that such an object exists. Richard Dawkins has argued that, for instance, the existence of the property "smelliness" should not be taken as proof that a "most smelly possible being," or "pre-eminently peerless stinker" in Dawkins' words, actually exists. [ [http://www.huffingtonpost.com/richard-dawkins/why-there-almost-certainl_b_32164.html?p=22 Richard Dawkins: Why There Almost Certainly Is No God - The Huffington Post ] ] It is worth noting in this context that the specific claim that "fire is the greatest heat" is either meaningless or false in the context of modern science, depending on interpretation. Moreover, even if every perfection is actually embodied in some being, it is not clear that all perfections must be embodied in "the same" being, nor is this necessarily possible.

Notes


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Argument from nonbelief — Part of a series on Atheism …   Wikipedia

  • Argument from morality — The argument from morality is one of many arguments for the existence of God. It comes in different forms, all aiming to support the claim that God exists with observations about morality. Its counterpoint is generally the Problem of evil.… …   Wikipedia

  • Argument from consciousness — The argument from consciousness is an argument for the existence of God based on consciousness.Philosophical summary of the argumentThe argument may be stated in inductive or deductive form [Both these are following J. P Moreland The Argument… …   Wikipedia

  • Argument from ignorance — The argument from ignorance, also known as argumentum ad ignorantiam ( appeal to ignorance [ [http://philosophy.lander.edu/logic/ignorance.html Argumentum ad Ignorantiam ] ] ) or argument by lack of imagination, is a logical fallacy in which it… …   Wikipedia

  • Argument from poor design — The dysteleological argument or argument from poor design is an argument against the existence of God, specifically against the existence of a creator God (in the sense of a God that directly created all species of life). It is based on the… …   Wikipedia

  • Argument — This article is about the subject as it is studied in logic and philosophy. For other uses, see Argument (disambiguation). In philosophy and logic, an argument is an attempt to persuade someone of something, by giving reasons or evidence for… …   Wikipedia

  • Degree of a field extension — In mathematics, more specifically field theory, the degree of a field extension is a rough measure of the size of the extension. The concept plays an important role in many parts of mathematics, including algebra and number theory indeed in any… …   Wikipedia

  • Teleological argument — A teleological or design argument[1][2][3] is an argument for the existence of God. The argument is based on an interpretation of teleology wherein purpose and intelligent design appear to exist in Nature beyond the scope of any such human… …   Wikipedia

  • Psychology (The separation of) from philosophy — The separation of psychology from philosophy Studies in the sciences of mind 1815–1879 Edward S.Reed THE IMPOSSIBLE SCIENCE Traditional metaphysics The consensus of European opinion during and immediately after the Napoleonic era was that… …   History of philosophy

  • Cosmological argument — The cosmological argument is an argument for the existence of a First Cause (or instead, an Uncaused cause) to the universe, and by extension is often used as an argument for the existence of an unconditioned or supreme being, usually then… …   Wikipedia


Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.