Buridan's ass


Buridan's ass

Buridan's ass is a figurative description of a man of indecision. It refers to a paradoxical situation wherein an ass, placed exactly in the middle between two stacks of hay of equal size and quality, will starve to death since it cannot make any rational decision to start eating one rather than the other. The paradox is named after the 14th century French philosopher Jean Buridan.

Discussion

The paradox was not originated by Buridan himself. It is first found in Aristotle's "De Caelo", where Aristotle mentions an example of a man who remains unmoved because he is as hungry as he is thirsty and is positioned exactly between food and drink. Buridan nowhere discusses this specific problem but its relevance is that he did advocate a moral determinism whereby, save for ignorance or impediment, a human faced by alternative courses of action must always choose the greater good. Buridan allowed that the will could delay the choice to more fully assess the possible outcomes of the choice. Later writers satirised this view in terms of an ass who, confronted by two equally desirable and accessible bales of hay, must necessarily starve while pondering a decision.

Some proponents of hard determinism have granted the unpleasantness of the scenario, but have denied that it illustrates a true paradox, as such, since one does not contradict oneself in suggesting that a man might die between two equally plausible routes of action. For example, Baruch Spinoza in his "Ethics", suggests that a person who sees two options as truly equally compelling cannot be fully rational: Quotation| [I] t may be objected, if man does not act from free will, what will happen if the incentives to action are equally balanced, as in the case of Buridan's ass? [In reply,] I am quite ready to admit, that a man placed in the equilibrium described (namely, as perceiving nothing but hunger and thirst, a certain food and a certain drink, each equally distant from him) would die of hunger and thirst. If I am asked, whether such an one should not rather be considered an ass than a man; I answer, that I do not know, neither do I know how a man should be considered, who hangs himself, or how we should consider children, fools, madmen, &c.|Baruch Spinoza|Ethics, Book 2, Scholium

Other writers have opted to deny the validity of the illustration. A typical counter-argument is that rationality as described in the paradox is so limited as to be a straw man of the real thing, which does allow the consideration of meta-arguments. In other words, it's entirely rational to recognize that both choices are equally good and arbitrarily pick one instead of starving. This counter-argument is sometimes used as an attempted justification for faith. The argument is that, like the starving ass, we must make a choice in order to avoid being frozen in endless doubt. Other counter-arguments exist.

Buridan's ass sometimes finds mention in electrical engineering. Specifically, in digital logic, an analog-to-digital converter must convert a continuous voltage value into either a 0 or a 1. The voltage value represents the position of the ass, and the values 0 and 1 represent the bales of hay. Like the situation of the starving ass, there exists an input on which the converter cannot make a proper decision, resulting in a metastable state. Having the converter make an arbitrary choice in ambiguous situations does not solve the problem, as the boundary between ambiguous values and unambiguous values introduces another binary decision with its own metastable state. In the ass illustration, the ass cannot decide whether or not to choose arbitrarily and so starves to death.

In popular culture

*The Devo song "Freedom of Choice" refers to this paradox (but substitutes a dog for a donkey).
*In an episode of "Boy Meets World", Shawn's college philosophy professor poses this paradox, also substituting a dog.
*In the Doctor Who novel "The Eight Doctors", the fifth and eighth Doctors use the principle to confuse a Raston Warrior Robot.

ee also

*Catch-22
*Hobson's choice
*Morton's fork
*Metastability in electronics
*Dining philosophers problem
*Spontaneous symmetry breaking

External links

* [http://www.pnas.org/content/105/31/10635.full Competing interactions create functionality through frustration] , Vassiliy Lubchenko, PNAS August 5, 2008 vol. 105 no. 31 10635-10636

References

* Zupko, Jack (2003) "John Buridan. Portrait of a Fourteenth-Century Arts Master". Notre Dame, Indiana: University of Notre Dame Press. "(cf. pp. 258, 400n71)"


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • buridan's ass — ˈbyu̇rədənz , dənz noun Usage: usually capitalized B Etymology: after Jean Buridan died ab1358 French philosopher, who is reputed to have posed the problem : a hypothetical dilemma in which a person is postulated as presented with two equally… …   Useful english dictionary

  • Buridan's ass — The creature who, placed midway between two identical bales of hay, starved to death, since there was no reason for moving one way rather than the other. The ass is not referred to in the Sophismata of Buridan, but was probably an example used to …   Philosophy dictionary

  • Buridan's ass — noun a) The hypothetical donkey who is placed precisely midway between two sources of food and/or water. The National Peace Council was, I will not say a Buridans Ass, but a kind of eunuch organisation, unable to take a decision one way or… …   Wiktionary

  • Buridan, Jean — born 1300, Béthune?, France died 1358 French philosopher, logician, and scientific theorist. He studied under William of Ockham at the University of Paris and later taught there. According to his modified version of determinism, though one must… …   Universalium

  • BURIDAN, JEAN —    a scholastic doctor of the 14th century, born in Artois, and famous as the reputed author, though there is no evidence of it in his works, of the puzzle of the hungry and thirsty ass, called after him Buridan s Ass, between a bottle of hay and …   The Nuttall Encyclopaedia

  • Jean Buridan —     Jean Buridan     † Catholic Encyclopedia ► Jean Buridan     French scholastic philosopher of the fourteenth century, b. at Béthune, in the district of Atois towards the end of the thirteenth century; date of death unknown. He studied at the… …   Catholic encyclopedia

  • Jean Buridan — (in Latin, Johannes Buridanus; ca. 1295 ndash; 1358) was a French priest who sowed the seeds of the Copernican revolution in Europe. Although he was one of the most famous and influential philosophers of the late Middle Ages, he is today among… …   Wikipedia

  • Donkey — For other uses, see Donkey (disambiguation). Donkey Conservation status Domesticated Scientific classific …   Wikipedia

  • Buridans Esel — Karikatur aus dem 19. Jahrhundert zur US Politik. Die Regierung muss wirtschaftliche einbußen hinnehmen, weil sie sich nicht entscheiden kann, einen Kanal durch Panama oder durch Nicaragua zu bauen. Buridans Esel ist philosophisches Gleichnis:… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • List of philosophy topics (A-C) — 110th century philosophy 11th century philosophy 12th century philosophy 13th century philosophy 14th century philosophy 15th century philosophy 16th century philosophy 17th century philosophy 18th century philosophy 19th century philosophy220th… …   Wikipedia