Interaction information


Interaction information

The interaction information (McGill 1954) or co-information (Bell 2003) is one of several generalizations of the mutual information, and expresses the amount information (redundancy or synergy) bound up in a set of variables, "beyond" that which is present in any subset of those variables. Unlike the mutual information, the interaction information can be either positive or negative. This confusing property has likely retarded its wider adoption as an information measure in machine learning and cognitive science.

The Three-Variable Case

For three variables {X,Y,Z}, the interaction information I(X;Y;Z) is given by

:egin{matrix}I(X;Y;Z) & = & I(X;Y|Z)-I(X;Y) \ & = & I(X;Z|Y)-I(X;Z) \ & = & I(Y;Z|X)-I(Y;Z) end{matrix}

where, for example, I(X;Y) is the mutual information between variables X and Y, and I(X;Y|Z) is the conditional mutual information between variables X and Y given Z. Formally,

:egin{matrix}I(X;Y|Z) & = & H(X|Z) + H(Y|Z) - H(X,Y|Z) \ & = & H(X|Z)-H(X|Y,Z)end{matrix}

For the three-variable case, the interaction information I(X;Y;Z) is the difference between the information shared by {Y,X} when Z has been fixed and when Z has not been fixed. (See also Fano's 1961 textbook.) Interaction information measures the influence of a variable Z on the amount of information shared between {Y,X}. Because the term I(X;Y|Z) can be zero — for example, when thedependency between {X,Y} is due entirely to the influence of a common cause Z, the interaction information can be negative as well as positive. Negative interaction information indicates that variable Z inhibits (i.e., "accounts for" or "explains" some of) the correlation between {Y,X}, whereas positive interaction information indicates that variable Z facilitates or enhances the correlation between {Y,X}.

Example of Negative Interaction Information

Negative interaction information seems much more natural than positive interaction information in the sense that such "explanatory" effects are typical of common-cause structures. For example, clouds cause rain and also block the sun; therefore, the correlation between rain and darkness is partly accounted for by the presence of clouds, I(rain;dark|cloud) leq I(rain;dark). The result is negative interaction information I(rain;dark;cloud).

Example of Positive Interaction Information

) since once output X is known, the value on input Y completely determines the value on input Z. Since I(Y;Z|X)>I(Y;Z), the result is positive interaction information I(X;Y;Z). It may seem that this example relies on a peculiar ordering of X,Y,Z to obtain the positive interaction, but the symmetry of the definition for I(X;Y;Z) indicates that the same positive interaction information results regardless of which variable we consider as the "interloper" or conditioning variable. For example, input Y and output X are also independent until input Z is fixed, at which time they are totally dependent (obviously), and we have the same positive interaction information as before, I(X;Y;Z)=I(X;Y|Z)-I(X;Y).

literature (e.g., Pearl 1988}. Pearl's example is auto diagnostics: A car's engine can fail to start (X) due either to a dead battery (Y) or due to a blocked fuel pump (Z). Ordinarily, we assume that battery death and fuel pump blockage are independent events, because of the essential modularity of such automotive systems. Thus, in the absence of other information, knowing whether or not the battery is dead gives us no information about whether or not the fuel pump is blocked. However, if we happen to know that the car fails to start (i.e., we fix common effect X), this information induces a dependency between the two causes "battery death" and "fuel blockage". Thus, knowing that the car fails to start, if an inspection shows the battery to be in good health, we can conclude that the fuel pump must be blocked.

"Battery death" and "fuel blockage" are thus dependent, conditional on their common effect "car starting". What the foregoing discussion indicates is that the obvious directionality in the common-effect graph belies a deep informational symmetry: If conditioning on a common effectincreases the dependency between its two parent causes, then conditioning on one of the causes must create the same increase in dependency between the second cause and the common effect. In Pearl's automotive example, if conditioning on "car starts" induces I(X;Y;Z) bits of dependency between the two causes "battery dead" and "fuel blocked", then conditioning on"fuel blocked" must induce I(X;Y;Z) bits of dependency between "battery dead" and "car starts". This may seem odd because "battery dead" and "car starts" are already governed by the implication "battery dead" ightarrow "car doesn't start". However, these variables are still not totally correlated because the converse is not true. Conditioning on "fuel blocked" removes the major alternate cause of failure to start, and strengthens the converse relation and therefore the association between "battery dead" and "car starts". A paper by Tsujishita (1995) focuses in greater depth on the third-order mutual information.

The Four-Variable Case

One can recursively define the "n"-dimensional interaction information in terms of the (n-1)-dimensional interaction information. For example, the four-dimensional interaction information can be defined as

:egin{matrix}I(W;X;Y;Z) & = & I(X;Y;Z|W)-I(X;Y;Z) \ & = & I(X;Y|Z,W)-I(X;Y|W)-I(X;Y|Z)+I(X;Y)end{matrix}

or, equivalently,

:egin{matrix}I(W;X;Y;Z)& = & H(W)+H(X)+H(Y)+H(Z) \ & - & H(W,X)-H(W,Y)-H(W,Z)-H(X,Y)-H(X,Z)-H(Y,Z) \ & + & H(W,X,Y)+H(W,X,Z)+H(W,Y,Z)+H(X,Y,Z)-H(W,X,Y,Z) end{matrix}

The "n"-Variable Case

It is possible to extend all of these results to an arbitrary number of dimensions. The general expression for interaction information on variable set mathcal{V}={X_{1},X_{2},ldots ,X_{n}} in terms of the marginal entropies is given by Jakulin & Bratko (2003).

:I(mathcal{V})equiv -sum_{mathcal{T}subseteq mathcal{V(-1)^{leftvertmathcal{V} ightvert -leftvert mathcal{T} ightvert}H(mathcal{T})

which is an alternating (inclusion-exclusion) sum over all subsets mathcal{T}subseteq mathcal{V}, where leftvert mathcal{V} ightvert =n. Notethat this is the information-theoretic analog to the Kirkwood approximation.

Difficulties Interpreting Interaction Information

The possible negativity of interaction information can be the source of some confusion (Bell 2003). As an example of this confusion, consider a set of eight independent binary variables {X_{1},X_{2},X_{3},X_{4},X_{5},X_{6},X_{7},X_{8}}. Agglomerate these variables as follows:

:egin{matrix}Y_{1} &=&{X_{1},X_{2},X_{3},X_{4},X_{5},X_{6},X_{7}} \Y_{2} &=&{X_{4},X_{5},X_{6},X_{7}} \Y_{3} &=&{X_{5},X_{6},X_{7},X_{8}} end{matrix}

Because the Y_{i}'s overlap each other (are redundant) on the three binary variables {X_{5},X_{6},X_{7}}, we would expect the interaction information I(Y_{1};Y_{2};Y_{3}) to equal -3 bits, which it does. However, considernow the agglomerated variables

:egin{matrix}Y_{1} &=&{X_{1},X_{2},X_{3},X_{4},X_{5},X_{6},X_{7}} \Y_{2} &=&{X_{4},X_{5},X_{6},X_{7}} \Y_{3} &=&{X_{5},X_{6},X_{7},X_{8}} \Y_{4} &=&{X_{7},X_{8}}end{matrix}

These are the same variables as before with the addition of Y_{4}={X_{7},X_{8}}. Because the Y_{i}'s now overlap each other (are redundant) on only one binary variable {X_{7}}, we would expect the interaction information I(Y_{1};Y_{2};Y_{3};Y_{4}) to equal -1 bit. However, I(Y_{1};Y_{2};Y_{3};Y_{4}) in this case is actually equal to +1 bit,indicating a synergy rather than a redundancy. This is correct in the sense that

:egin{matrix}I(Y_{1};Y_{2};Y_{3};Y_{4}) & = & I(Y_{1};Y_{2};Y_{3}|Y_{4})-I(Y_{1};Y_{2};Y_{3}) \ & = & -2+3 \ & = & 1end{matrix}

but it remains difficult to interpret.

Uses of Interaction Information

Jakulin and Bratko (2003b) provide a machine learning algorithm which uses interaction information.

Killian, Kravitz and Gilson (2007) use mutual information expansion to extract entropy estimates from molecular simulations.

References

* Bell, A J (2003), ‘The co-information lattice’ [http://www.rni.org/bell/nara4.pdf]

* Fano, R M (1961), "Transmission of Information: A Statistical Theory of Communications", MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.

* Garner W R (1962). "Uncertainty and Structure as Psychological Concepts", JohnWiley & Sons, New York.

* Han T S (1978). Nonnegative entropy measures of multivariate symmetric correlations, "Information and Control" 36, 133-156.

* Han T S (1980). Multiple mutual informations and multiple interactions in frequency data, "Information and Control" 46, 26-45.

* Jakulin A & Bratko I (2003a). Analyzing Attribute Dependencies, in N Lavraquad{c}, D Gamberger, L Todorovski & H Blockeel, eds, "Proceedings of the 7th European Conference on Principles and Practice of Knowledge Discovery in Databases", Springer, Cavtat-Dubrovnik, Croatia, pp. 229-240.

* Jakulin A & Bratko I (2003b). Quantifying and visualizing attribute interactions [http://arxiv.org/abs/cs/0308002v1] .

* McGill W J (1954). Multivariate information transmission, "Psychometrika" 19, 97-116.

* Nemenman I (2004). Information theory, multivariate dependence, and genetic network inference [http://arxiv.org/abs/q-bio.QM/0406015] .

* Pearl, J (1988), "Probabilistic Reasoning in Intelligent Systems: Networks of Plausible Inference", Morgan Kaufmann, San Mateo, CA.

* Tsujishita, T (1995), ‘On triple mutual information’, "Advances in applied mathematics" 16, 269-–274.

* Killian B J, Kravitz J Y & Gilson M K (2007) Extraction of configurational entropy from molecular simulations via an expansion approximation. "J. Chem. Phys.", 127, 024107.


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Information visualization — the interdisciplinary study of the visual representation of large scale collections of non numerical information, such as files and lines of code in software systems [S.G. Eick (1994). Graphically displaying text . In: Journal of Computational… …   Wikipedia

  • Information theory and measure theory — Measures in information theory = Many of the formulas in information theory have separate versions for continuous and discrete cases, i.e. integrals for the continuous case and sums for the discrete case. These versions can often be generalized… …   Wikipedia

  • Interaction Design — oder IxD (dt.: Interaktionsgestaltung) bezieht sich auf die Gestaltung der Funktion, des Verhaltens und der endgültigen Ausgestaltung von Produkten und Systemen. Auch die Gestaltung von Interaktionsprozessen innerhalb einer Organisation werden… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Information overload — refers to excess amounts of information being provided, making the processing and absorbing tasks very difficult for the individual because we cannot see the validity behind the information (Yang, 2003 [Yang, C.C. (2003) Decision Support Systems …   Wikipedia

  • Interaction design — (IxD) is the discipline of defining the behavior of products and systems that a user can interact with. The practice typically centers around complex technology systems such as software, mobile devices, and other electronic devices. However, it… …   Wikipedia

  • Information Awareness Office — seal The Information Awareness Office (IAO) was established by the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) in January 2002 to bring together several DARPA projects focused on applying surveillance and information technology to track and …   Wikipedia

  • Information forensics — is the science of investigation into systemic processes that produce information. Systemic processes utilize primarily computing and communication technologies to capture, treat, store and transmit data. Manual processes complement technology… …   Wikipedia

  • Interaction sociale — Interaction (sciences sociales) Pour les articles homonymes, voir Interaction. Une interaction est un échange d information, d affects ou d énergie entre deux agents au sein d un système. C est une action réciproque qui suppose l entrée en… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Intéraction sociale — Interaction (sciences sociales) Pour les articles homonymes, voir Interaction. Une interaction est un échange d information, d affects ou d énergie entre deux agents au sein d un système. C est une action réciproque qui suppose l entrée en… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Information communication technology — Information and Communications Technology or technologies (ICT) is an umbrella term that includes all technologies for the manipulation and communication of information. The term is sometimes used in preference to Information Technology (IT),… …   Wikipedia