Black Box Voting

Black Box Voting

Black Box Voting signifies voting on voting machines which do not disclose how they operate such as with closed source or proprietary operations. The term, as described by Dr. Arnold Urken of Stephens Institute of Technology, comes from the technical jargon use of the term black box, a device or system or object when it is viewed primarily in terms of its input and output characteristics. Dr. Urken's group at Stevens Institute was one of the first Independent Testing Authorities for voting machines.

The term was coined by David Allen, publisher, technical consultant and co-writer to author and activist Bev Harris, who popularized the term in her book with that title and runs the [] website. Allen's formal definition is found on page 4 of the original edition of the book: "Any voting system in which the mechanisms for recording and/or tabulating the vote are hidden from the voter, and/or the mechanism lacks a tangible record of the vote cast." [ [ Black Box Voting: Ballot Tampering in the 21st Century] ]

A national nonprofit elections watchdog group by the name "Black Box Voting" was founded by Bev Harris, author of the book Black Box Voting: Ballot-Tampering in the 21st Century. [ [ Black Box Voting: Ballot Tampering in the 21st Century] ] . The author donated the book rights to the nonprofit group, and it is available online for free.

About black box voting systems

Both optical scan systems which interpret paper ballots and Direct Recording Electronic (DRE) systems can be black box systems. The determination is whether the public is allowed to examine the source code and hardware. Though source code may be available to voting system testing authorities and state or county election officials it can still be considered "black box" if it is not available to the public. Even with some open source systems, which allow examination of the source code, access to firmware, which controls the hardware, is not available.

Even if the source code is made public, significant challenges remain in the areas of authenticating that the code running systems in the field matches the publicly released code, and it is still possible to find attack vectors for open source systems.

In the U.S. presidential election, 2004, about 80% of voting was done on optical scan and DRE voting systems using trade secret proprietary software.Fact|date=July 2007 As of February, 2006, that figure had climbed to 95%, with 80% of all votes in America were counted by only two companies, Diebold Election Systems and Election Systems & Software (ES&S). Neither company releases their source code to the public, and thus all voting on these systems is "black box" voting. [] However, these figures apply to population, not number of jurisdictions. As of 2007, approximately 0.41% of all jurisdictions (0.19% of all registered voters [ [ Voting Equipment Summary By Type] , as of 11/07/2006. Election Data Services] ) still counted ballots by hand. These jurisdictions each serve small populations, the overall figures, based on population, favor optical scan and DRE voting.

Legislation has been introduced in the United States Congress to ban black box voting by requiring public release of source codes, including hardware and firmware information. One such bill, entitled the Voter Confidence and Increased Accessibility Act of 2007 - HR 811, was introduced by Congressman Rush D. Holt, Jr..This bill was changed in committee, and has dropped all requirements for public disclosure of the source codes, and for the first time, codifies the concept of black box voting into federal law by requiring protection of secret voting machine codes, and taking the unprecedented step of requiring nondisclosure agreements for even the limited set of "qualified experts" allowed to look at the code.

See also

* Electoral fraud
* Hacking Democracy
* Open Voting Consortium
* Voting machine
* Voter Verified Paper Audit Trail

Related organizations

* [ Black Box Voting - nonprofit citizen watchdog site]
* [ Election Defense Alliance - collaborative nonprofit organization to help build and coordinate a comprehensive, cohesive national strategy for the election integrity movement]
* [ Open Voting Consortium site on open source voting systems]
* [ Verified Voting - lobbying group for paper trails]

Research, Articles, and Advocacy

* [ Princeton Security Analysis of the Diebold AccuVote-TS Voting Machine]
* [ Evidence Shows that the Vote may have been Hacked] , Thom Hartmann, [ Common Dreams] , November 2004
* [ How the Ohio election was rigged for Bush.] , Bob Fitrakis, [] November 2004
* [ USA Today: More problems arise with 'black-box voting'] , Andrew Kantor, June 2004
* [ How Elections Should Be Conducted] , Eric Jaffa, [ MoveLeft Media] , March 2004
* [ Black Box Voting: Death of a patriot] ,Bob Fitrakis, [] ("Describes the untimely March, 2004 death of an influential advocate of a verified voting paper trail.")
* [ Diebold, electronic voting and the vast right-wing conspiracy] , Bob Fitrakis, [] Februaru 2004
* [ 20 Amazing Facts About Voting In The United States]
* [ No Paper Trail Left Behind: The Theft of the 2004 Presidential Election, by Dennis Loo, Ph.D]


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Black box voting — Als E Voting oder Electronic Voting bezeichnet man alle Formen von elektronischen Wahlen. Dazu gehört der Einsatz von Wahlcomputern im Wahllokal aber auch Internetwahlen vom heimischen PC. Inhaltsverzeichnis 1 Formen des E Votings 2 Formen des… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Box — describes a variety of containers and receptacles. When no specific shape is described, a typical rectangular box may be expected. Nevertheless, a box may have a horizontal cross section that is square, elongated, round or oval; sloped or domed… …   Wikipedia

  • Black — infobox color textcolor=white title=Black hex=000000 symbolism = lack, evil, darkness, bad luck, crime, mystery, silence, concealment, elegance, execution, end, chaos, death, and secrecy r=0|g=0|b=0 c=0|m=0|y=0|k=100 h= |s= |v=0 spelling=Color… …   Wikipedia

  • Black Sheep (1996 film) — Infobox Film name = Black Sheep caption = Black Sheep Poster director = Penelope Spheeris producer = Lorne Michaels writer = Fred Wolf starring = Chris Farley David Spade Gary Busey Tim Matheson music = cinematography = editing = distributor =… …   Wikipedia

  • Comparison of instant runoff voting to other voting systems — This article is a comparison of various voting systems with Instant runoff voting (IRV), also called the Alternative Vote , preferential voting and ranked choice voting. Contents 1 Categories 2 Voting system criteria 3 Voting system results …   Wikipedia

  • New Zealand voting method referendum, 2011 — 2009  ← 26 November 2011 (with election) …   Wikipedia

  • Electronic voting in Canada — It is a common misconception that there is no electronic voting in Canada. While the federal elections still use paper ballots, electronic voting technology has been used since at least the 1990s at the municipal level in some cities, and there… …   Wikipedia

  • Bev Harris — Bev Merton Harris is an American writer, activist, and founder of Black Box Voting Inc., a national nonpartisan, nonprofit elections watchdog group. She helped popularize the term Black Box Voting, while authoring a book of that title.She first… …   Wikipedia

  • Hursti Hack — Three voting machines hacking tests have been performed by Finnish Computer expert Harri Hursti for the nonprofit elections watchdog group Black Box Voting [ [ Black Box Voting site] ] and the producers of the HBO… …   Wikipedia

  • United States presidential election, 2004 timeline — The following is a timeline of events during the 2004 U.S. presidential election:2002* May 31 Vermont Governor Howard B. Dean III forms a presidential exploratory committee. * December 1 John F. Kerry, U.S. senator from Massachusetts announces… …   Wikipedia