Mandatory arbitration


Mandatory arbitration

Mandatory arbitration is a contract policy that prevents a conflict from receiving judicial attention. In a mandatory arbitration, liability for damages must be determined as a result of an arbitration process before a civil lawsuit can be filed in the court system. In arbitration, neutral arbitrators (often knowledgeable practicing attorneys) are selected and then evidence is presented. The arbitrators then determine the amount of the arbitration award, if any. If the arbitration award is agreed to, that is the end of the matter (and often the arbitration award is thereafter made a court judgment for further enforcement purposes). If there is one of the litigants refuses to accept the arbitration award, a lawsuit may then be filed to have a "trial de novo" (new trial) in a court of law, with liability to be determined by a judge or jury.

Most recently, in the United States, Senators Russ Feingold of Wisconsin and Congressman Hank Johnson of Georgia, together with numerous co-sponsors in both Houses, introduced the Arbitration Fairness Act (S. 1782, H.R. 3010) in the U.S. Congress. The bill would prohibit mandatory pre-dispute binding arbitration in consumer, employment, and franchise disputes. Parties to a dispute would still be able to choose arbitration over court if they wanted to, but individuals would be given a choice in the matter and would not be denied their constitutional right to access the courts and have a jury trial. The bill would overturn the strong presumption in favor of arbitrability that has been erected by decisions of the United States Supreme Court under the rubric of the Federal Arbitration Act, at least as applied to consumer and employment disputes. The bill is supported by the groups such as Public Citizen, Center for Responsible Lending, Consumer Federation of America, Homeowners Against Deficient Dwellings, Home Owners for Better Building, National Association of Consumer Advocates, National Consumer Law Center, National Consumer Coalition for Nursing Home Reform, National Employment Lawyers Association, and American Association for Justice. Opposition to the bill is led by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce's Institute for Legal Reform.

Among other things, the proposed Act states that: "No predispute arbitration agreement shall be valid or enforceable if it requires arbitration of— (1) an employment, consumer, or franchise dispute; or (2) a dispute arising under any statute intended to protect civil rights or to regulate contracts or transactions between parties of unequal bargaining power."


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Arbitration in the United States of America — Arbitration, in the context of United States law, is a form of alternative dispute resolution mdash; specifically, a legal alternative to litigation whereby the parties to a dispute agree to submit their respective positions (through agreement or …   Wikipedia

  • arbitration — ar·bi·tra·tion /ˌär bə trā shən/ n [Latin arbitratio, from arbitrari to judge, arbitrate, from arbiter onlooker, arbitrator]: the process of resolving a dispute (as between labor and management) or a grievance outside of the court system by… …   Law dictionary

  • mandatory law — zwingendes Recht (нем.) = droit impératif (франц.) 1. норма права, зафиксированная в законе или судебном прецеденте (в системе обычного права), которая не может быть исключена соглашением сторон и в любом случае подлежит применению к… …   Glossary of international commercial arbitration

  • Arbitration — Not to be confused with Arbitrage. For Wikipedia s arbitration policy, see Wikipedia:Arbitration/Policy …   Wikipedia

  • arbitration — The procedure available to customers for the settlement of disputes. Brokers and exchange members are required to participate in arbitration to settle disputes. Arbitration is available through the exchanges, the NFA, and the CFTC. The CENTER… …   Financial and business terms

  • mandatory provision — In the context of dispute resolution, a provision of the Arbitration Act 1996 which applies regardless of the parties agreement. Practical Law Dictionary. Glossary of UK, US and international legal terms. www.practicallaw.com. 2010 …   Law dictionary

  • National Arbitration Forum — The National Arbitration Forum (NAF), founded in 1986, provides arbitration and mediation services to businesses, based at its Minneapolis, Minnesota headquarters and offices in New Jersey. The company is one of the United States s largest and… …   Wikipedia

  • non-mandatory provision — In the context of dispute resolution, a provision of the Arbitration Act 1996 which the parties are entitled to contract out of, but which will apply in the absence of any agreement to the contrary. All the provisions of the Act which are not… …   Law dictionary

  • gap-filling law — nachgiebiges (нем.) = ius dispositivum = droit dispositif (франц.) в континентальном праве ссылка на диспозитивные нормы права, обычно зафиксированные в форме позитивного закона, которые регулируют вопросы, не решенные сторонами. Антитеза… …   Glossary of international commercial arbitration

  • ius dispositivum — диспозитивные нормы права. См. gap filling law. Являются антитезой императивным нормам права (mandatory law) …   Glossary of international commercial arbitration