Committee of the Whole


Committee of the Whole

A Committee of the Whole is a device in which a legislative body or other deliberative assembly is considered one large committee. All members of the legislative body are members of such a committee. This is usually done for the purposes of discussion and debate of the details of bills and other main motions.

Contents

Australia

In the House of Representatives, the equivalent device is termed the "Main Committee", and is used for uncontroversial matters. It is slightly different from most Committees of the Whole in that it generally meets separately from the House and has its own committee room, and can be as small as the Speaker, a member of the Government and a member of the Opposition. This device is rather new, having been introduced only in 1994.

Canada

In the Canadian House of Commons, a Committee of the Whole is when all the MPs sit in the chamber in one large committee. The committee is chaired by the deputy speaker or the deputy chair of committees. It uses committee rules rather than House procedures.

In the past, the Committee of the Whole considered a majority of bills, with few bills being sent to parliamentary committees. The increased workload of MPs has led to a decline in this use of the Committee of the Whole. Now the Committee of the Whole is used mostly for monetary bills and on rare occasions to expedite the passage of other legislation.[1]

On June 11th 2008, Prime Minister Stephen Harper formally apologized in the House of Commons for the government's role in the Canadian residential school system. A Committee of the Whole was used, so that aboriginal leaders (who were not Members of Parliament) could be allowed to respond to the apology on the floor of the House. [2]

Hong Kong

In the Legislative Council of Hong Kong, when the debate of the second reading resumes, members debate the general merits and principles of the bill. At the committee stage, the Legislative Council becomes 'a Committee of the whole Council' and goes through the bill clause by clause, making amendments where necessary. After the bill has passed through Committee with or without amendments, it proceeds to the third reading for passage by the Council.

United Kingdom

In the United Kingdom House of Commons, the Committee of the Whole House is used instead of a standing committee for the clause-by-clause debate of important or contentious bills. The sitting is presided over by the Chairman of Ways and Means, rather than the Speaker of the House.

In the United Kingdom House of Lords, the Committee of the Whole House examines the majority of bills.

United States

United States Congress

In the United States House of Representatives, the Committee of the Whole is a device in which the House of Representatives is considered one large Congressional committee. The presiding officer is chosen by the Speaker of the House and is normally a member of the majority party who does not hold the chair of a standing committee.

The United States Senate used the Committee of the Whole as a parliamentary device for 197 years from the 1st Congress in 1789 and ceased using it in 1986 during the 99th Congress.

Non-legislative use and variants

Robert's Rules of Order states that the committee of the whole is suitable to large assemblies. The procedure is invoked by a motion to commit to the committee of the whole, or simply to go into a committee of the whole. The only motions in order in a committee of the whole are those to adopt a proposal for inclusion in the committee's report; to amend; to "rise and report"; as well as certain incidental motions and requests.

Variants of the committee of the whole are the quasi committee of the whole and to consider informally. The difference between a committee of the whole and a quasi committee of the whole is that in the latter, the presiding officer of the assembly remains in the chair and presides. Informal consideration simply removes the normal limitations on the number of times members can speak in debate.[3]

The Standard Code of Parliamentary Procedure rejects both the committee of the whole and quasi committee of the whole procedures as being outdated, and instead recommends the motion to consider informally in their place.

References

  1. ^ Jackson and Jackson, Politics in Canada, p. 320
  2. ^ Toronto Star, Jun 13, 2008 "NDP aide's Commons sense saved the day"
  3. ^ Robert, Henry M. (2000). Robert's Rules of Order Newly Revised, 10th ed., p. 513

Reading

J.R. Odgers, Australian Senate Practice (11th edition), Department of the Senate, Canberra, Chapter 14.


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • committee of the whole — committee of the whole: the whole membership of a legislative house (as the House of Representatives) sitting as a committee and operating under informal parliamentary rules – called also Committee of the Whole House on the State of the Union;… …   Law dictionary

  • Committee of the whole — Whole Whole, n. 1. The entire thing; the entire assemblage of parts; totality; all of a thing, without defect or exception; a thing complete in itself. [1913 Webster] This not the whole of life to live, Nor all of death to die. J. Montgomery.… …   The Collaborative International Dictionary of English

  • committee of the whole — ☆ committee of the whole n. a committee comprising all the members of a legislative body, etc. under more informal rules than those used in a regular session …   English World dictionary

  • committee of the whole — or committee of the whole house : a committee consisting of the whole membership of a legislative house and operating with its own chairman under informal and flexible rules for the purpose of considering a particular measure or some special… …   Useful english dictionary

  • committee of the whole — commit′tee of the whole′ n. gov a committee composed of all the members of a legislative body, meeting under relaxed rules in order to expedite business • Etymology: 1745–55 …   From formal English to slang

  • committee of the whole — Date: 1775 the whole membership of a legislative house sitting as a committee and operating under informal rules …   New Collegiate Dictionary

  • committee of the whole — the entire membership of a legislative body, sitting in a deliberative rather than a legislative capacity, for informal debate and preliminary consideration of matters awaiting legislative action. [1745 55] * * * …   Universalium

  • Committee of the whole house — Committee Com*mit tee, n. [Cf. OF. comit[ e] company, and LL. comitatus jurisdiction or territory of a count, county, assize, army. The word was apparently influenced by the verb commit, but not directly formed from it. Cf. {County}.] One or more …   The Collaborative International Dictionary of English

  • Committee of the Whole (short story) — Committee of the Whole Author Frank Herbert Country  United States Language …   Wikipedia

  • Committee of the whole House — ► Committee of the whole House the whole House of Commons when sitting as a committee. Main Entry: ↑committee …   English terms dictionary


Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.