Lon L. Fuller

Lon L. Fuller

Infobox Philosopher
region = Western Philosophy
era = 20th century philosophy
color = lightsteelblue

image_size = 200px
image_caption =
name = Lon L. Fuller
birth = 1902
death = 1978
school_tradition =
main_interests = Legal philosophy
notable_ideas = “Eight Routes of Failure for any Legal System”
influences =
influenced = Ronald Dworkin

box_width = 26em

Lon Luvois Fuller (1902–1978) was a noted legal philosopher, who wrote "The Morality of Law" in 1964, discussing the connection between law and morality. Fuller was professor of Law at Harvard University for many years, and is noted in American law for his contributions to the law of contracts. His debate with H.L.A. Hart in the Harvard Law Review (Vol. 71) was of significant importance for framing the modern conflict between legal positivism and natural law. Fuller was an important influence on Ronald Dworkin, who was one of his students at Harvard Law.

Eight Routes of Failure for any Legal System

# The lack of rules or law, which leads to ad-hoc and inconsistent adjudication.
# Failure to publicize or make known the rules of law.
# Unclear or obscure legislation that is impossible to understand.
# Retroactive legislation.
# Contradictions in the law.
# Demands that are beyond the power of the subjects and the ruled.
# Unstable legislation (ex. daily revisions of laws).
# Divergence between adjudication/administration and legislation.

Fuller presents these problems in his book "The Morality of Law" with an entertaining story about an imaginary king named Rex who attempts to rule but finds he is unable to do so in any meaningful way when any of these conditions are not met. Fuller contends that the purpose of law is to "subject human conduct to the governance of rules". Each of the 8 features which lead to failure form a corresponding principle to avoid such deficiencies which should be respected in legislation. If any of these 8 principles is not present in a system of governance, a system will not be a legal one. The more closely a system is able to adhere to them, the nearer it will be to the ideal, though in reality all systems must make compromises. These principles, Fuller argues, represent the "internal morality of law", and he argues that compliance with them leads to substantively just laws and away from evil ones.

In his review of "The Morality of Law" Hart criticises Fuller's work, saying that these principles are merely ones of efficacy; it is inept, he says, to call them a morality. One could just as well have an inner morality of poisoning as an inner morality of law, but of course we find this idea absurd. A contemporary debate rages, with much "bombast and invective" (Kramer, "Big Bad Wolf", (2005)), between Professor Matthew Kramer and Dr. Nigel Simmonds over the moral value of the rule of law as constituted by Fuller's 8 principles. The former agrees with Hart that it is compatible with great iniquity, arguing that evil regimes would have good prudential reasons for complying with it. The latter contends that adhering to the rule of law has value in and of itself, giving citizens a liberty to act as they please and conform their conduct to the rules and know that if they do so force beyond that which is prescribed will not be used against them by the state. Evil regimes would have every reason to operate outside the rule of law to 'chill' the population into compliance, rather than to use the rule of law for their own ends as Kramer suggests.

ee also

*The Case of the Speluncean Explorers
* Hart-Fuller debate

External links

* [http://oasis.lib.harvard.edu/oasis/deliver/~law00074 Index of Fuller's Papers] from Harvard University Library

Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Lon Fuller — Lon Luvois Fuller (* 15. Juli 1902 in Hereford, Texas; † 8. April 1978) war ein amerikanischer Rechtsphilosoph. Sein rechtsphilosophisches Hauptwerk ist The Morality of Law (1. Aufl. 1964, 2., überarbeitete Aufl. 1969), in dem er – hierbei… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Lon Fuller — Lon L. Fuller Nombre completo Lon Luvois Fuller Nacimiento 15 de junio de 1902 Defunción 8 de abril de 1978, 75 años Género …   Wikipedia Español

  • Fuller (surname) — Fuller is a surname referring to someone who treats cloth or leather with the process called Fulling (synonymous with Tanner) and may refer to:*Alexandra Fuller, British writer *Alfred Fuller (1885 1973), Canadian businessman *Alvan T. Fuller… …   Wikipedia

  • Lon Milo DuQuette — Born 11 July 1948(1948 07 11) Long Beach, California, USA Lon Milo DuQuette, AKA Rabbi Lamed Ben Clifford, is an American writer, lecturer, and occultist, best known as an author who applies humor in the field of Western Hermeticism. Contents …   Wikipedia

  • Fuller — ist ein berufsbezogener englischer Familienname, der sich auf das Walken von Wolle bezieht.[1] Inhaltsverzeichnis A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Hart-Fuller debate — The Hart Fuller debate is an exchange between Lon Fuller and H.L.A. Hart published in the Harvard Law Review in 1958 on morality and law, which demonstrated the divide between the positivist and natural law philosophy. Appearing in 1958 in the… …   Wikipedia

  • J. F. C. Fuller — John Frederick Charles Fuller J.F.C. Fuller Born 1878 Chichester …   Wikipedia

  • Jurisprudence — For the jurisprudence of courts, see Case law. Philosophers of law ask what is law? and what should it be? Jurisprudence is the theory and philosophy of law. Scholars of jurisprudence, or legal theorists (including legal philosophers and social… …   Wikipedia

  • American Society for Political and Legal Philosophy — The American Society for Political and Legal Philosophy, or ASPLP, is a learned society founded in 1955 by political theorist Carl Friedrich. The ASPLP s annual thematic conferences form the foundation for the Nomos series. The ASPLP operates… …   Wikipedia

  • Liste des philosophes politiques et sociaux — La liste des philosophes politiques et sociaux est non exhaustive, et regroupe les philosophes ayant pratiqué la philosophie sociale et la philosophie politique. Principaux Confucius Aristote Platon Thomas Hobbes Nicolas Machiavel Gottfried… …   Wikipédia en Français

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.