Difference feminism

Difference feminism

Difference feminism is a philosophy that stresses that men and women are ontologically different versions of the human being.[citation needed] Many Catholics adhere to and have written on the philosophy, though the philosophy is not specifically Catholic.[citation needed]

Although the title "difference feminism" is a relatively recent addition to the feminist movement, the philosophies of gender relations undergirding this category have their roots as far back as the early Greeks.[1] Forms of difference feminism often stress a fundamental biological, emotional, psychological or spiritual difference between the sexes.


Reverse gender polarity

Reverse gender polarity is the form of difference feminism that asserts that women, per se, are superior to men. It developed as the opposite of traditional gender polarity that asserts that men, per se, are superior to women. Traditional polarity was espoused beginning with Aristotle[2].

Reverse gender polarity, however, began in the medieval era with the exaltation of feminine virtue by authors like Heinrich Cornelius Agrippa and Lucrezia Marinelli.[3] It became prominent again in second-wave feminism with women like psychologist Carol Gilligan.

Gender complementarity

Fractional gender complementarity

Fractional gender complementarity argues that men and women complement one another as separate parts that together make up a composite whole. This form of difference feminism was most prominent in the Cult of True Womanhood developed in reaction to other forms of feminism in the 19th century. It originally developed from a neoplatonic unisex theory that one sexless soul was incarnated into two different bodies: male and female. The two, when added together, were to have formed a single mind.[4]

Difference feminism has been criticized for claiming that the sexes differ in their style of reasoning by evolutionary psychologist Steven Pinker. "If difference feminism is true," he writes, "it would disqualify women from becoming constitutional lawyers, Supreme Court justices, and moral philosophers, who make their living by reasoning about rights and justice." He also notes that many studies have not found significant differences between men and women in their moral reasoning.[5]

Integral gender complementarity

Integral gender complementarity argues that men and women are each integral, whole beings unto themselves whose result when put together is greater than the sum of their parts. Michele M. Schumacher, for example, believes that there is "one (human) nature, two modes of expression... Together they form a communion of persons..."to exist mutually one for the other" " [6]

The metaphysical foundation of this theory was developed by Dietrich von Hildebrand[7] and Edith Stein,[8] and later by Personalists like Emmanuel Mounier and Jacques Maritain.[9] More recently, the theory was espoused by Pope John Paul II as a foundation for a new feminism.[10]

In regards to differences in emotions, styles or reasoning, those who follow integral complementary assert that the differences are not divisional - that women only feel or reason one way and men another. Rather, they claim the characteristic differences can be found in tendencies and inclinations rather than finite generalizations. For example, author Janne Haaland-Matlary asserts that it "is far more profound than simple biological reductionism...or... social constructivism."[11] A woman may use her "feminine genius" in practically every profession and vocation.

Pope John Paul II asserted that the challenge facing most societies "is that of upholding, indeed strengthening, woman's role in the family while at the same time making it possible for her to use all her talents and exercise all her rights in building up society."[12] For feminists who believe in integral complementary, like the new feminists, biology is not "destiny", but it is essentially important.

See also


  1. ^ Allen, Prudence, RSM. The Concept of Woman: The Aristotelian Revolution 750BC - AD 1250. Montreal: Eden Press, 1985
  2. ^ Allen, The Concept of Woman. p. 89-126
  3. ^ Allen, "Man-Woman Complementarity", p.3
  4. ^ Allen, "Man-Woman Complementarity". p.3-5
  5. ^ Steven Pinker, The Blank Slate, Chapter on Gender p. 342.
  6. ^ Schumacher, Michele M. "The Nature of Nature in Feminism, Old and New: From Dualism to Complementary Unity". p.17-51 in "Women in Christ; Toward a New Feminism". William B. Eerdmans Publishing Company. Grand Rapids, Michigan. 2003. p. 45
  7. ^ Von Hildebrand, Dietrich. Marriage: the Mystery of Faithful Love. Manchester, New Hampshire: Sophia Institute Press, 1991. p. 53-55; Von Hildebrand, Dietrich. Man and Woman: Love and the Meaning of Intimacy. Manchester, New Hampshire: Sophia Institute Press, 1992, p. 91
  8. ^ Stein, Edith. "Letter to Sister Callista Koph" in Self-Portrait in Letters: 1916-1942. Washington DC: ICS Publications, 1993. Stein, Edith. Essays on Woman.
  9. ^ Allen, "Man-Woman Complementarity". p.5-18
  10. ^ John Paul II, "Letter to Women" in The Genius of Women (Washington DC: United States Catholic Conference, 1997)
  11. ^ Haaland-Matlary, Janne. "Men and Women in Family, Society and Politics". L'Osservatore Romano. Vatican. January 12, 2005. p. 6-7. http://www.catholicculture.org/docs/doc_view.cfm?recnum=6309&longdesc
  12. ^ John Paul II, "Welcome to Gertrude Mongella, Secretary General of the Fourth World Council on Women", May 1995. No 8, as included in "The Genius of Women".

Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • feminism —    Early Spanish feminism was weak and conservative, although socialist and anarchist feminism was important between 1920 and 1930. The greatest reforms concerning women s emancipation were introduced in the 1931 constitution, which stipulated… …   Encyclopedia of contemporary Spanish culture

  • feminism — feminist, n., adj. feministic, adj. /fem euh niz euhm/, n. 1. the doctrine advocating social, political, and all other rights of women equal to those of men. 2. (sometimes cap.) an organized movement for the attainment of such rights for women. 3 …   Universalium

  • feminism — in China has been intricately intertwined with both philosophy and political ideology. As early as the Zhou dynasty, men and women were associated respectively with notions of yang and yin in a philosophy that organized the world into polarized… …   Encyclopedia of Contemporary Chinese Culture

  • feminism — feminism, feminist A social movement , having its origins in eighteenth century England, which seeks to achieve equality between the sexes by extension of rights for women. In the 1890s the term referred specifically to the women and men who… …   Dictionary of sociology

  • Feminism — Feminists redirects here. For other uses, see Feminists (disambiguation). See also: feminist movement and feminism in the United States …   Wikipedia

  • feminism / feminine —    by Victoria Grace   Baudrillard has been an arch critic of feminism, of movements for women s liberation and sexual liberation, and yet he would be (and has been) the first to say that there have been some genuine and problematic… …   The Baudrillard dictionary

  • feminism —    by Felicity J. Colman   Deleuze did not advocate feminism as the movement has historically come to be known. Yet in his writings one message that is continually relayed is: Do not ever smugly assume that you have reached the limit edges, or… …   The Deleuze dictionary

  • feminism —    by Felicity J. Colman   Deleuze did not advocate feminism as the movement has historically come to be known. Yet in his writings one message that is continually relayed is: Do not ever smugly assume that you have reached the limit edges, or… …   The Deleuze dictionary

  • difference — Although increasingly employed with reference to ethnic, class, and age divisions within social groups, the term ‘difference’ was initially used by ‘second wave’ feminist writers, who defined the term politically, seeing it as a polarity both… …   Dictionary of sociology

  • feminism — The approach to social life, philosophy, and ethics that commits itself to correcting biases leading to the subordination of women or the disparagement of women s particular experience. Contemporary feminist ethics is sensitive to the gender bias …   Philosophy dictionary