- An Inconvenient Truth
name = An Inconvenient Truth
caption = Promotional poster for "An Inconvenient Truth"
Davis Guggenheim Al Gore
Lawrence Bender Scott Z. Burns Laurie David Lesley Chilcott(co-producer)
Jay Cassidy Dan Swietlik
released = May 24, 2006
runtime = 94 min.
language = English
budget = US$+1,000,000 [ [http://grist.org/news/maindish/2007/03/06/bender/index.html "On a Bender: A chat with "Inconvenient Truth" co-producer and Hollywood bigwig Lawrence Bender"] . Grist.org. Retrieved March 7, 2007.]
gross = US$49,047,567
website = http://www.climatecrisis.net/
amg_id = 1:342290
imdb_id = 0497116
"An Inconvenient Truth" is an American
documentary filmabout global warming, presented by former United States Vice President Al Goreand directed by Davis Guggenheim. [cite web |url=http://www.oscar.com/oscarnight/winners/?pn=detail&nominee=AnInconvenientTruthDocumentaryFeatureNominee
title=Winner: Documentary Feature, "An Inconvenient Truth" |accessdate=2007-03-18
date=February 25, 2007
publisher=Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences] The film premiered at the
2006 Sundance Film Festivaland opened in New Yorkand Los Angeleson May 24, 2006. The film was released on DVDby Paramount Home Entertainment on November 21, 2006. A companion book by Gore, "", reached #1 on the paperback nonfiction New York Times bestsellerlist on July 2, 2006. [cite news
title=New York Times Bestsellers: Paperback Nonfiction |url=http://www.nytimes.com/2006/07/02/books/bestseller/0702bestpapernonfiction.html?ex=1174363200&en=aa0e9c76ef010f5a&ei=5070
The New York Times
accessdate=2007-03-17] The documentary won
Academy Awards for Best Documentary Feature and for Best Original Song.
Earning $49 million at the
box officeworldwide, "An Inconvenient Truth" is the fourth-highest-grossing documentary film to date in the United States(in nominal dollars, from 1982 to the present), after " Fahrenheit 9/11", " March of the Penguins" and " Sicko". [cite web
title=Documentary 1982–Present (film rankings by lifetime gross)
publisher=Box Office Mojo]
"An Inconvenient Truth" focuses on Al Gore and his travels in support of his efforts to educate the public about the severity of the climate crisis. Gore says, "I've been trying to tell this story for a long time and I feel as if I've failed to get the message across." The film closely follows a Keynote presentation (dubbed "the slide show") that Gore presented throughout the world. It intersperses Gore's exploration of data and predictions regarding
climate changeand its potential for disaster with Gore's life story.
It weaves in events that changed his world view, including his college education with early climate expert
Roger Revelleat Harvard University, his sister's death from lung cancer, and his young son's near-fatal car accident. Throughout the film, Gore makes comments regarding his loss to George W. Bushin the 2000 United States presidential election. For comic effect, Gore also uses a clip from the " Futurama" episode " Crimes of the Hot" to explain global warming.
In the slide show Gore reviews the
scientific opinion on climate change, discusses the politics and economics of global warming, and describes the consequences he believes global climate change will produce if the amount of human-generated greenhouse gasesis not significantly reduced in the very near future. A centerpoint of the film is his examination of the annual temperature and CO2 levels for the past 650,000 years in Antarctic ice core samples.
The film includes segments intended to refute critics who say that global warming is unproven or that warming will be insignificant. For example, Gore discusses the possibility of the collapse of a major
ice sheetin Greenlandor in West Antarctica, either of which could raise global sea levels by approximately 20 feet (6 m), flooding coastal areas and producing 100 million refugees. Melt water from Greenland, because of its lower salinity, could then halt the currents that keep northern Europe warm and quickly trigger dramatic local cooling there. The documentary ends with Gore arguing that if appropriate actions are taken soon, the effects of global warming can be successfully reversed by releasing less CO2 and planting more vegetation to consume existing CO2. Gore calls upon his viewers to learn how they can help him in these efforts.
Gore's book of the same title was published concurrently with the theatrical release of the documentary. The book contains additional information, scientific analysis, and Gore's commentary on the issues presented in the documentary. A 2007 documentary entitled "An Update with Former Vice President Al Gore" features Gore discussing additional information that came to light after the film was completed, such as
Hurricane Katrina, coral reefdepletion, glacial earthquake activity on the Greenland ice sheet, wildfires, and trapped methane gas release associated with permafrostmelting. [http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0978403/ An Update with Former Vice-President Al Gore (2006) (V) ] ]
The film's thesis is that global warming is real, potentially catastrophic, and human-caused. Gore presents specific data that supports the thesis, including:
Keeling curve, measuring CO2 from the Mauna Loa Observatory.
*The retreat of numerous glaciers is shown in before-and-after photographs (see
Retreat of glaciers since 1850).
*A study by researchers at the
PhysicsInstitute at the University of Bernand the European Project for Ice Coring in Antarcticapresenting data from Antarctic ice coresshowing carbon dioxide concentrations higher than at any time during the past 650,000 years. [cite journal |last=Siegenthaler |first=Urs |coauthors=Stocker, Thomas F.; et al. |year=2005 |month=November 25 |title=Stable Carbon Cycle–Climate Relationship During the Late Pleistocene (abstract) |journal=Science |volume=310 |issue=5752 |pages=1313–1317 |url=http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/short/310/5752/1313 |accessdate=2008-06-13 |pmid=16311332 |doi=10.1126/science.1120130 ]
Temperature record since 1880showing that the ten hottest years ever measured in this atmospheric record have all occurred in the last fourteen years.
*A 2004 survey by
Naomi Oreskesof 928 peer-reviewed scientific articles on global climate change published between 1993 and 2003. The survey, published as an editorial in the journal "Science", found that every article either supported the human-caused global warming consensus or did not comment on it. [cite journal |last=Oreskes |first=Naomi |authorlink=Naomi Oreskes |year=2004 |month=December 3 |title=Beyond the Ivory Tower: The Scientific Consensus on Climate Change |journal=Science |volume=306 |issue=5702 |pages=1686 |url=http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/306/5702/1686 |accessdate=2007-03-18 |doi=10.1126/science.1103618 ]
Associated Presscontacted more than 100 climate researchers and questioned them about the film's veracity. All 19 climate scientists who had seen the movie said that Gore conveyed the science correctly. [cite news |first=Seth |last=Borenstein
title=Scientists OK Gore's Movie for Accuracy
date=June 27, 2006
accessdate= 2007-03-18] Professor Brian Soden, however, expressed concern about the coverage of topics for which there was not a scientific consensus, indicating "I thought the use of imagery from Hurricane Katrina was inappropriate and unnecessary in this regard, as there are plenty of disturbing impacts associated with global warming for which there is much greater scientific consensus."
In contrast, the
U.S. Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works, at the time chaired by Senator Jim Inhofe(R-OK) issued a press release criticizing this article. [cite web
title=AP Incorrectly Claims Scientists Praise Gore’s Movie
U.S. Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works
date=June 27, 2006
accessdate= 2007-03-18] Inhofe's statement that "global warming is the greatest hoax ever perpetrated on the American people"cite news |first=Zachary |last=Coile |title=Senator fights the tide, calls warming by humans a hoax |url=http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/c/a/2006/10/11/MNGEJLMT8A1.DTL |publisher=San Francisco Chronicle |date=October 11, 2006 |accessdate=2007-03-18 ] appears in the film. The majority of climate researchers have rejected Inhofe's views.
Eric Steig, a climate scientist writing on
RealClimate, lauded the film's science as "remarkably up to date, with reference to some of the very latest research." [cite web
title=Al Gore’s movie
date=May 10, 2006
Michael Shermer, scientific author and founder of The Skeptics Society, wrote in " Scientific American" that a lecture that Gore gave "shocked me out of my doubting stance". [cite news
first=Shermer |last=Michael |authorlink=Michael Shermer
title= The Flipping Point: How the evidence for anthropogenic global warming has converged to cause this environmental skeptic to make a cognitive flip
According to Gore, he became interested in global warming when he took a course at
Harvard Universitywith Professor Roger Revelle, one of the first scientists to measure carbon dioxidein the atmosphere. [cite web | last=Voynar | first=Kim | title=Sundance: "An Inconvenient Truth" Q & A - Al Gore on fire! No, really. | work=Cinematical | date=2006-01-26 | url=http://www.cinematical.com/2006/01/26/sundance-an-inconvenient-truth-q-and-a-al-gore-on-fire-no-rea/ ] Later, when Gore was in Congress, he initiated the first congressional hearing on the subject. [cite web | last=Remnick | first=David | title=The Talk of the Town | work=New Yorker | date=2006-04-14 | url=http://www.newyorker.com/talk/content/articles/060424ta_talk_remnick ] Gore's 1992 book, " Earth in the Balance", dealing with a number of environmental topics, reached the New York Times bestseller list.
As Vice President during the
Clinton Administration, Gore pushed for the implementation of a carbon taxto modify incentives to reduce fossil fuel consumption causing fossil fuel to last longer and thereby decrease emission of greenhouse gases in the short term but not long term; it was partially implemented in 1993. He helped broker the 1997 Kyoto Protocol, an international treaty designed to curb greenhouse gasemissions. However, it was not ratified in the United Statesafter a 95 to 0 vote in the Senate. The primary objections stemmed from the exemptions the treaty gives to Chinaand India, whose industrial base and carbon footprint are growing rapidly, and fears that the exemptions would lead to further trade imbalances and offshoring arrangement with those countries.
Gore also supported the funding of a satellite called Triana, to increase awareness of environmental issues and to take the first direct measurements of how much sunlight is reflected from the Earth. During his 2000 Presidential Campaign, Gore ran, in part, on a pledge to ratify the
After his defeat in the 2000 presidential election by
George W. Bush, Gore returned his focus to the topic. He edited and adapted a slide show presentation he had compiled years earlier, and began featuring the slide show in Power Point presentations on global warming across the U.S. and around the world. At the time of the film, Gore estimated he had shown the presentation more than one thousand times.
Laurie Davidand Lawrence Bendersaw Gore's slide show in New York Cityafter the 2004 premiere of " The Day After Tomorrow". [cite web | last=Booth | first=William | title=Al Gore, Sundance's Leading Man | work=Washington Post | date=2006-01-26 | url=http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/01/25/AR2006012502230.html ] Inspired, they met with director Davis Guggenheimabout the possibility of making the slide show into a movie. Guggenheim, who was skeptical at first, later saw the presentation for himself, stating that he was "blown away," and "left after an hour and a half thinking that global warming [was] the most important issue. . . . I had no idea how you’d make a film out of it, but I wanted to try," he said. [cite web
title=Interview: David Guggenheim and "An Inconvenient Truth"
date= May 4, 2006
The film opened in
New York Cityand Los Angeleson May 24, 2006. On Memorial Dayweekend, it grossed an average of $91,447 per theater, the highest of any movie that weekend and a record for a documentary, though it was only playing on four screens at the time. [ [http://imdb.com/news/sb/2006-05-30/ 'Last Stand' delivers] "IMDb", 2006-05-30, accessed 2007-01-10]
At the 2006
Sundance Film Festival, the movie received three standing ovations. It was also screened at the 2006 Cannes Film Festivaland was the opening night film at the 27th Durban International Film Festivalon June 14, 2006."An Inconvenient Truth" was the most popular documentary at the 2006 Brisbane International Film Festival. [ [http://web.archive.org/web/20070218082019/http://www.biff.com.au/general/libraryattachment.aspx?code=101 BIFF EXCEEDS ALL EXPECTATIONS (Adobe Reader format)] accessed 2007-01-10]
The film has grossed over $24 million in the U.S. and over $49 million worldwide as of June 3, 2007, making it the fourth-highest-grossing documentary in the U.S. to date (after "
Fahrenheit 9/11", " March of the Penguins" and " Sicko"). [ [http://boxofficemojo.com/genres/chart/?id=documentary.htm Documentary Movies] "Box Office Mojo", accessed 2007-06-09]
Al Gore has stated, "Tipper and I are devoting 100 percent of the profits from the book and the movie to a new bipartisan educational campaign to further spread the message about global warming." [ [http://www.chron.com/CDA/archives/archive.mpl?id=2006_4128989 Housewife addresses climate conference] "Flanders News", dated
2006-11-16, accessed 2007-01-10] Paramount Classicsis committing 5% of their domestic theatrical gross for the film to a new bipartisan climate action group, Alliance for Climate Protection, dedicated to awareness and grassroots organizing. [ [http://web.archive.org/web/20070329055319/http://www.allianceforclimateprotection.org/bios.php Governing Council] "The Alliance for Climate Protection", accessed 2007-01-10]
The film received a generally positive reaction from critics. It garnered a "certified fresh" 93% rating at
Rotten Tomatoes(as of May 21, 2007), with a 94% rating from the "Cream of the Crop" reviewers. Film critics Roger Ebertand Richard Roepergave the film "two thumbs up". Ebert wrote: "In 39 years, I have never written these words in a movie review, but here they are: You owe it to yourself to see this film. If you do not, and you have grandchildren, you should explain to them why you decided not to." [ Roger Ebert[http://rogerebert.suntimes.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20060601/REVIEWS/60517002 "An Inconvenient Truth"] "Chicago Sunday Times", accessed 2007-01-10]
Ronald Baileyargued in the libertarianmagazine "Reason" that although "Gore gets [the science] more right than wrong," he exaggerates the risks. [Ronald Bailey [http://www.reason.com/rb/rb061606.shtml Gore as climate exaggerator] "Reason", dated 2006-06-16, accessed 2007-01-10]
Critic Jayson Harsin [Jayson Harsin [http://www.brightlightsfilm.com/53/gore.htm Eco-apocalypse and the Powerpoint film] "Bright Lights Film Journal", dated
August 2006, accessed 2008-8-10] emphasized the film's groundbreaking aesthetic qualities, as a new genre of "Powerpoint" film. In addition Harsin drew attention to its persuasive or rhetorical nature (instead of only its scientific claims), including the use of emotion in analogies to the danger of tobacco and to the universal identification with the fate of our children. He notes that the film's persuasive choices very likely fail in the end with what should be the film's target audience.
The film has received a number of awards worldwide.
* The film won the 2007
Academy Award for Documentary Featurecite news
title= Hudson wins supporting actress Oscar
date=February 25, 207] and Best Original Song for
Melissa Etheridge's " I Need to Wake Up". [cite web
title=Oscar Night: Winner: Music (Song)
publisher=Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Science
date=February 25, 2007] It is the first documentary to win a best original song Oscar [cite web | url=http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/08022/851177-331.stm | title=80th Annual Academy Awards Oscar Quiz | date=
2008-01-22| accessdate=2008-04-30 | publisher= Pittsburgh Post-Gazette] [cite web | url=http://theenvelope.latimes.com/awards/oscars/2007/env-oscarwinners-25feb25,0,2802194.story | title='The Departed' arrives | date=2007-02-25 | first=Brian | last=Hanrahan | publisher= Los Angeles Times| accessdate=2008-04-30 ] .
*It has often been erroneously reported by many members within the various news and entertainment media outlets that Al Gore himself had won the Oscar for "An Inconvenient Truth" but it was actually
Davis Guggenheimwho was the "Nominee" and "Recipient" of the Academy Award.
* The film received special recognition from the
Humanitas Prize, the first time the organization had handed out a Special Award in over 10 years.cite web
url = http://www.humanitasprize.org/pdf/2006%20HUMANITAS%20Winners.pdf
title = 2006 HUMANITAS Prize Winners
accessdate = 16 January
accessyear = 2007
date = 2006-06-28
publisher = the HUMANITAS prize
* 2007 Stanley Kramer Award - The Producers Guild of America; recognizes "work that dramatically illustrates provocative social issues".cite web
url = http://www.variety.com/article/VR1117957742.html?categoryid=2474&cs=1
title = Stanley Kramer Award: "An Inconvenient Truth"
accessdate = 18 January
accessyear = 2007
date = 2007-01-18
publisher = Variety.com]
* The President’s Award 2007 - The
Society for Technical Communication"for demonstrating that effective and understandable technical communication, when coupled with passion and vision, has the power to educate—and change—the world."cite web
url = http://www.stc.org/recog/awards01_President_winners.asp
title = President’s Award
accessdate = 18 July
accessyear = 2007
date = 2007-07-18
publisher = stc.com]
* For his wide-reaching efforts to draw the world’s attention to the dangers of global warming including "An Inconvenient Truth", Al Gore, along with the
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change(IPCC), has won the 2007 Nobel Peace Prize.cite web
url = http://nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/peace/laureates/2007/
title = 2007 Nobel Peace Prize Laureates
accessdate = 11 October
accessyear = 2007|]
Best Documentary: [ [http://movies.yahoo.com/movie/1809257809/awards "An Inconvenient Truth" - Awards and Nominations]
Yahoo, accessed February 10, 2007]
* Academy Awards (The Oscars) 2007 February 25, 2007
* Chicago Film Critics Association [cite web | url=http://www.chicagofilmcritics.org/ | title=Winners Announced for the 2006 Chicago Film Critics Awards | date=
2006-12-28| accessdate=2007-06-01 | publisher= Chicago Film Critics Association] - 2006-12-28
* Dallas-Fort Worth Film Critics Association [cite web
Dallas-Fort Worth Film Critics Association
accessdate=2007-06-01] [cite web | url=http://www.imdb.com/Sections/Awards/Dallas-Fort_Worth_Film_Critics_Association_Awards/2006 | title=Dallas-Fort Worth Film Critics Association Awards: 2006 | publisher=
IMDb| date= 2006-12-18| accessdate=2007-06-01 ] - 2006-12-18
* Florida Film Critics 2006 -
title =Florida Film Critics Circle Awards - 2006
accessdate =2007-10-08 ]
* Kansas City Film Critics Awards 2006 [cite web
title =Film Critic's Circle of Kansas City
accessdate =2007-10-08 ] January 2, 2006
* Las Vegas Film Critics Society 2006 [cite web
title=LVFCS Sierra Award winners:
publisher=Las Vegas Film Critics Society 2006] -
* National Board of Review [cite web
title=NBR page on "An Inconvenient Truth"
publisher=National Board of Review of Motion Pictures] -
* New York Film Critics Online [cite web
title=New York Film Critics Online
publisher=Movie City News
2006-12-10] - 2006-12-10
* New York Film Critics Society -
* Ohio Film Critics Awards 2006 [ [http://www.cofca.org/awards.php?year=2006 Central Ohio Film Critics Association (COFCA) - Awards ] ] -
* Oklahoma Film Critics Circle Awards 2006 [cite web
title =Oklahoma Film Critics Circle: Oklahoma Film Critics Circle Announces 2006 Awards
* Online Film Critics Society 2006 [cite web
title =Online Film Critics Society Awards - 2006
* Phoenix Film Critics Circle 2006 [cite web
title =Phoenix Film Critics Circle Awards - 2006
* Satellite Awards 2006 "(Nominated)" [cite web
title =11th Annual SATELLITE Awards - 2006
accessdate =2007-10-30] December 18, 2006
* St. Louis Film Critics Awards 2006 [cite web
title =St. Louis Gateway Film Critics Association
accessdate =2007-10-30] January 07, 2007
* Toronto Film Critics Association Awards 2006 "(Nominated)" [cite web
title =Toronto Film Critics Association Awards 2006
accessdate =2007-10-30] December 19, 2006
* Utah Film Critics Awards 2006 [cite web
title =Utah Film Critics Awards 2006
accessdate =2007-10-30] December 28, 2006
* Washington D.C. Film Critics Association 2006 [cite web
title =Washington D.C. Film Critics Association 2006
accessdate =2007-10-30] December 10, 2007
* National Society of Film Critics [cite web | url=http://www.indiewire.com/movies/2007/01/the_critics_hav.html | title=The Critics Have Spoken (Again); National Society Chooses "Pan's Labyrinth" As Best Film of 2006 | first=Eugene | last=Hernandez | date=
2007-01-06| accessdate=2007-06-01 ] - 2007-01-06
The documentary has been generally well-received politically in many parts of the world and is credited for raising further awareness of global warming internationally, prompting calls for more government action in regard to the climate. Several colleges and high schools have begun to use the film in science curricula, [cite news
title=Gore's "Inconvenient Truth" required classroom viewing?
date=May 19, 2007 ] though at least one US school district put temporary restrictions on its use in the classroom.
* President Bush, when asked whether he would watch the film, responded: "Doubt it." He later stated that "And in my judgment we need to set aside whether or not greenhouse gases have been caused by mankind or because of natural effects, and focus on the technologies that will enable us to live better lives and at the same time protect the environment."cite web | title=Bush gives thumbs down to Gore's new movie | date=
2006-05-24| url=http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/12930351/ | publisher= Associated Press| accessdate=2007-05-31] Gore responded that "The entire global scientific community has a consensus on the question that human beings are responsible for global warming and he [Bush] has today again expressed personal doubt that that is true." White House deputy press secretary Dana Perino stated that “The president noted in 2001 the increase in temperatures over the past 100 years and that the increase in greenhouse gases was due to certain extent to human activity”.
*In September 2006, Gore traveled to
Sydney, Australiato promote the film. Then-Australian Prime Minister, John Howardsaid he would not meet with Gore or agree to Kyoto because of the movie: "I don't take policy advice from films." Former Opposition Leader Kim Beazleyjoined Gore for a viewing and other MPs attended a special screening at Parliament House earlier in the week. [cite web | title=Howard isolated on climate change: Gore |url=http://news.ninemsn.com.au/article.aspx?id=143315 | date= 2006-09-11| accessdate=2007-05-31 | publisher= Nine Network] After winning the general election a year later, Prime Minister Kevin Ruddratified Kyoto in his first week of office making the United States the only industrialized nation in the world not to have signed the treaty. [cite web | url=http://news.ninemsn.com.au/article.aspx?id=143315 | date= 2006-09-11| accessdate=2007-05-31 | publisher= Nine Network]
* In the
United Kingdom, Conservative Leader of the Opposition David Cameronurged people to see the film in order to understand climate change. [ [http://politics.guardian.co.uk/conservativepartyconference2006/story/0,,1887540,00.html Full text of David Cameron's speech to the Conservative Party conference] , "Guardian Unlimited", 4 October 2006, accessed 25 November 2006]
Belgium, Margaretha Guidonepersuaded the entire Belgian government to see the film. [cite web | title=Spitzenpolitiker sehen Gore-Film | url=http://www2.vrtnieuws.net/cm/flanderninfo.be/Nachrichten/1.22085 | date= 2006-10-31| accessdate=2007-05-31 | publisher=Flanderninfo.be ]
Costa Rica, Al Gore met with president Oscar Arias, and was well received by other politicians and the local media.Fact|date=August 2007
Germany, German Environment Minister Sigmar Gabriel bought 6,000 DVDs of "An Inconvenient Truth" to make it available to German schools. [ [http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/0,1518,511325,00.html Inconvenient Truth to Continue Airing in Schools] , "Spiegel Online", 13 October 2007.]
Spain, after a meeting with Gore, prime minister José Luis Rodríguez Zapaterosaid the government will make "An Inconvenient Truth" available to schools. Gore has received this year's Prince of Asturias Prizefor international cooperation [ [http://www.fundacionprincipedeasturias.org/ing/04/premiados/trayectorias/trayectoria815.html Al Gore - The Prince of Asturias Foundation ] ] [ [http://www.expatica.com/actual/article.asp?subchannel_id=81&story_id=36238 Gore climate documentary to be shown in schools] , "Expatica", 7 February 2007, accessed 11 February 2007] .
* In Burlington,
Ontario, Canada, the Halton District School Boardhas made "An Inconvenient Truth" available at schools and as an educational resource. [cite pressrelease
title=Screening of "An Inconvenient Truth" set to educate students on climate change
publisher=Halton District School Board
* The film has also been made available as an educational resource in
Argentinaand other Latin American countries.
*The film will be science curriculum for fourth and sixth-year students in
Scotland, as a joint initiative between Learning and Teaching Scotlandand ScottishPower. [cite news
title=All secondary schools to see Gore climate film
date=January 17, 2007
*In August 2006, the
Wall Street Journalcite web | title=Where did that video spoofing Gore's film come from? | url=http://online.wsj.com/public/article/SB115457177198425388-0TpYE6bU6EGvfSqtP8_hHjJJ77I_20060810.html | date=2006-08-03 | publisher= Wall Street Journal| accessdate=2007-06-01 ] [cite web | title=Slick lobbying is behind penguin spoof of Al Gore | url=http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/us_and_americas/article700813.ece | publisher= The Times| date=2006-08-05 | accessdate=2007-06-01 ] revealed that a YouTubevideo lampooning Gore and the movie, titled " Al Gore's Penguin Army", appeared to be astroturfingby DCI Group, a Washington PR firm.
The Dimmock case
As part of a nationwide "Sustainable Schools Year of Action" launched in late 2006, the
UK Government, Welsh Assembly Governmentand Scottish Executiveannounced between January-March 2007 that copies of "An Inconvenient Truth" would be sent to all secondary schools in England, Walesand Scotland. The UK Government's distribution of the film was challenged in May 2007 in the High Court of Justiceby a group of global warming skeptics, notably Viscount Monckton. [cite news | url=http://www.glennbeck.com/content/articles/article/196/6783/ | title=Glenn talks with Lord Monckton | publisher=Glenn Beck | date=2008-03-04] The plaintiffs sought an injunctionpreventing the screening of the film in English schools. They argued that schools are legally forbidden to promote partisan political views in the teaching of any subject in school and, when dealing with political issues, are required to provide a balanced presentation of opposing views.
On 10 October 2007, Mr Justice Burton, after explaining that the requirement for a balanced presentation does not warrant that equal weight be given to alternative views of a mainstream view, ruled that it was clear that the film was substantially founded upon scientific research and fact, albeit that the science is used, in the hands of a talented politician and communicator, to make a political statement and to support a political program.cite web
title= Stuart Dimmock v Secretary of State for Education & Skills  EWHC 2288
2007-10-10] The film could then, on that basis, be shown, provided an accompanying explanation was given of its scientific errors, in order to prevent political indoctrination. [ [http://www.telegraph.co.uk/earth/main.jhtml?xml=/earth/2007/10/11/scigore111.xml Al Gore's 'nine Inconvenient Untruths' - Telegraph ] ]
The judge concluded "I have no doubt that Dr Stott, the Defendant's expert, is right when he says that: 'Al Gore's presentation of the causes and likely effects of climate change in the film was broadly accurate.'" On the basis of testimony from
Robert M. Carterand the arguments put forth by the claimant's lawyers, the judge also pointed to nine 'errors', i.e. statements that he found to depart from the mainstream. He also found that some of these 'errors' arose in the context of alarmism and exaggeration in support of Al Gore's political thesis. Since the government had already accepted to amend the guidance notes to address these 'errors' along with other points in a fashion that the judge found satisfactory, no order was made on the application.
The Minister of Children, Young People and Families, Kevin Brennan, declared the outcome a victory for the government, stating: "We have updated the accompanying guidance, as requested by the judge to make it clearer for teachers as to the stated Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change position on a number of scientific points raised in the film. [cite web
title=Climate change film to stay in the classroom
date=October 10, 2007
accessdate =2007-12-14 ] Stewart Dimmock also declared victory but expressed dissatisfaction at the verdict, saying that "no amount of turgid guidance" could change his view that the film was unsuitable for the classroom. [cite web
title=Schools must warn of Gore climate film bias
date=October 3, 2007
accessdate=2007-12-14 ] A spokesman for Gore said: "Of the thousands of facts in the film, the judge only took issue with just a handful. And of that handful, we have the studies to back those pieces up." [cite news
title=U.K. Judge Finds Problems in Gore Film
date=October 12, 2007
In the United States
In the United States, 50,000 free copies of "An Inconvenient Truth" were offered to the
National Science Teachers Association(NSTA), which declined to take them. Laurie David, one of the film's producers, provided an email correspondence from the NSTA detailing that their reasoning was that the DVDs would place "unnecessary risk upon the [NSTA] capital campaign, especially certain targeted supporters," and that they saw "little, if any, benefit to NSTA or its members" in accepting the free DVDs. [cite news
title=Conversation: Al Gore/An Inconvenient Truth
date=October 12, 2006
publisher=The Huffington Post
accessdate=2007-11-04|format=PDF] [cite news
title=Science a la Joe Camel
date=November 26, 2006
publisher=The Washington Post
accessdate=2006-11-26] In public, the NSTA argued that distributing this film to its members would have been contrary to a long-standing NSTA policy against distributing unsolicited materials to its members. The NSTA also said that they had offered several other options for distributing the film but ultimately " [it] appears that these alternative distribution mechanisms were unsatisfactory." [cite news
title=NSTA Statement on November 26 Washington Post Op-ed "Science à la Joe Camel"
date=November 28, 2006
National Science Teachers Association
accessdate=2007-01-09] Laurie David has stated that NSTA Executive Director Gerry Wheeler promised in a telephone conversation to explore alternatives with NSTA's board for advertising the film but she had not yet received an alternative offer at the time of NSTA's public claim. She also said that she rejected their subsequent offers because they were nothing more than offers to sell their "commercially available member mailing list" and advertising space in their magazine and newsletter, which are available to anyone. She noted that in the past, NSTA had shipped out 20,000 copies of a 10-part video produced by Wheeler with funding provided by ConocoPhillips in 2003. NSTA indicated that they retained editorial control over the content, which David questioned based on the point of view portrayed in the global warming section of the video. [cite news
title=Crooked Curriculum: Oil Company Money Scandal at Nat'l Science Teachers Association Deepens
date=December 8, 2006
The Huffington Post
American Association for the Advancement of Sciencepublication "ScienceNOW" published an assessment discussing both sides of the NSTA decision in which it was reported that "David says NSTA's imprimatur [i.e. endorsement or sanction] was essential and that buying a mailing list is a nonstarter. 'You don't want to send out a cold letter, and it costs a lot of money,' she says. 'There are a thousand reasons why that wouldn't work.'." [cite news
title=An Inconvenient DVD
date=November 30, 2006
publisher=ScienceNOW Daily News
In January 2007, the Federal Way (Washington State) School Board voted to require an approval by the principal and the superintendent for teachers to show the film to students and that the teachers must include the presentation of an approved "opposing view".cite news
title=Federal Way schools restrict Gore film
author=Robert McClure & Lisa Stiffler
date=January 11, 2007
accessdate=2007-01-11] The moratorium was repealed after broad public condemnation at the subsequent meeting on January 23. cite news
title =Federal Way School Board lifts brief moratorium on Gore film
date=January 24, 2007
Shortly thereafter, the school board in
Yakima, Washington, calling the film a "controversial issue", prevented the Environmental Club of Eisenhower High School from showing it, pending review by the school board, teachers, principal, and parents. [cite news
title=School Delays Viewing of Global Warming Documentary
date=January 24, 2007
accessdate=2007-01-24] It lifted the stay a month later, upon the approval by a review panel. [cite web | title=Wash. high school club cleared to watch Gore film | publisher=
Associated Press| date=February 3, 2007 | accessdate=2007-10-12 | url=http://www.firstamendmentcenter.org/%5Cnews.aspx?id=18089 ]
Richard S. Lindzenwrote in a June 26, 2006 op-ed in the "Wall Street Journal" that Gore was using a biased presentation to exploit the fears of the public for his own political gain. [Richard S. Lindzen [http://online.wsj.com/article_print/SB115127582141890238.html There Is No 'Consensus' On Global Warming] "Wall Street Journal", accessed 2007-01-10] Roy Spencer wrote an open letter to Gore criticizing his presentation of climate science in the film, asserting that the Arctic had a similar temperature in the 1930s before the mass emissions of carbon dioxide began. [ [http://www.tcsdaily.com/article.aspx?id=052506C Questions for Al Gore by Roy Spencer] "TCS Daily - Questions for Al Gore", 2006-05-25, accessed 2007-03-13] Timothy F. Ballrejected Gore’s claim that there has been a sharp drop-off in the thickness of the Arctic ice cap since 1970, stating that the data was taken only from an isolated area of the Arctic and during a specific cooling period. [ [http://www.epw.senate.gov/pressitem.cfm?party=rep&id=257909 U.S. Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works ] ]
William Gray said of the movie: "We're brainwashing our children. They're going to the Gore movie "An Inconvenient Truth" and being fed all this. It's ridiculous." [cite news | last=Lytte | first=Steve | title=Gore gets a cold shoulder | newspaper=Sydney Morning Herald | year=2007 | date=2007-10-14 | url=http://www.smh.com.au/news/environment/gore-gets-a-cold-shoulder/2007/10/13/1191696238792.html ] While discussing the companion book to the movie Gray said, "This is a slick propaganda book. The pictures are very good. But there are factual errors." [cite news | title=The Skeptic | first=Alan | last=Prendergast | date=
2006-06-29| url=http://www.westword.com/2006-06-29/news/the-skeptic/full | publisher= Denver Westwood News]
A March 13, 2007 article in "
The New York Times" reported on concerns among some scientists about the tone and the accuracy of the film, noting that they "argue that some of Mr. Gore’s central points are exaggerated and erroneous." Gore's discussion of a rise in sea level of up to 20 feet, while not stating a timeframe, appears in contrast with a report from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change(IPCC), which predicts a maximum rise of 23 inches this century, excluding non-linear effects on ice sheets; although that too discusses the possibilities of higher rises if the ice sheets melt. The article also states that "a report last June by the National Academies seemed to contradict Mr. Gore’s portrayal of recent temperatures as the highest in the past millennium."cite news
The New York Times
title=From a Rapt Audience, a Call to Cool the Hype
2007-03-13] [cite web
title=Don't believe the Hype
accessdate=2007-05-31] The article quotes both defenders and critics of the film; Gore responds that scientists may disagree with him on some details, "but we do agree on the fundamentals."
documentary film" The Great Global Warming Swindle", broadcast on Channel 4in the UK in 2007, brought together skeptical scientists and others who disagree with the IPCCposition regarding human-caused global warming. The film claims that Gore misrepresented the data in "An Inconvenient Truth", and contends that the actual relationship between carbon dioxide and the temperature is the other way round (that is, rise in temperature preceded an increase in carbon dioxide in the ice coresamples and therefore does so today). The claim that CO2 increases lag temperature increases in the historical ice core record is not disputed, but the inference that the same relationship holds today, and several other of "The Great Global Warming Swindle"'s claims, have been disputed by scientists and scientific bodies such as John T. Houghton,cite web | last = Houghton| first = John| coauthors = | title = The Great Global Warming Swindle| publisher = The John Ray Initiative| date = | url = http://www.jri.org.uk/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=137&Itemid=83 | format = | doi = | accessdate = 2007-03-12] the British Antarctic Survey, [ [http://www.antarctica.ac.uk/about_bas/news/news_story.php?id=178 BAS Statement about Channel 4 programme on Global Warming] ] Eigil Friis-Christensen, [ [http://folk.uio.no/nathan/web/statement.html NR+EFC Statement ] ] and the Royal Society. [cite web|title = The Royal Society’s response to the documentary "The Great Global Warming Swindle"| url=http://www.royalsoc.ac.uk/news.asp?id=6089 | publisher = Royal Society| date= 2007-03-11 | accessdate = 2007-04-03] The UK media regulator OfComhas since upheld some complaints against the programme (while rejecting others and declining to investigate the majority). [ [http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/7517509.stm Climate documentary 'broke rules'] ]
Influences on popular culture
* Prior to "An Inconvenient Truth" being released, Al Gore was parodied in the "
South Park" episode “ Manbearpig,” which ends with Al Gore exclaiming his intention to make a film starring himself in which he will try to save the world from the manbearpig, a "half man, half bear, half pig". Gore laughed off this sensationalized depiction of him, saying "Their comic sensibility is aimed at a different demographic than the one I inhabit, but I still find a lot of what they do hilarious." [ cite news | url = http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_qn4155/is_20060505/ai_n16358218 | title = Gore promotes his 'ultimate action movie' | publisher = Chicago Sun-Times | date = 5 May 2006 ] Gore makes a second appearance on "South Park" in the episode " Imaginationland Episode III", where he argues that the American government must nuke Imaginationland (where all the imaginary characters live) in order to destroy Manbearpig.
* During the movie, Al Gore shows a clip from the "
Futurama" episode " Crimes of the Hot" dealing with global warming; Al Gore was a guest star in that episode (though not present in the clip.) While not the credited author of this episode, his daughter, Kristin Gore Cusack, was on the " Futurama" writing staff and worked as a story editor. In addition, Gore stars in a faux trailer made by the "Futurama" cast and crew titled, "A Terrifying Message from Al Gore". [ cite web | url = http://www.ifilm.com/video/2748863 | publisher = www.ifilm.com | title = A Terrifying Message from Al Gore ]
Stephen Colbert, on " The Colbert Report", also parodied "the critics" of "An Inconvenient Truth" on 19 July 2006. Entitled "The Convenientest Truth", Colbert created his own presentation that argued for the positive effects of global warming, using his signature humor tactics to satirize the conservative response to Gore's presentation. [cite web | url = http://www.comedycentral.com/colbertreport/videos.jhtml?videoId=71953 | publisher = ComedyCentral.com | title = The Convenientest Truth ]
* In "
The Simpsons Movie", "An Inconvenient Truth" is parodied when Lisa Simpson, presenting dangers of the pollution of Lake Springfield to Springfield's residents in a style similar to Gore, fails to properly operate a scissor lift intended to lift her up in order to show a spike of data on a projected graph regarding global warming. The title of her presentation is "An Irritating Truth". Mayor Quimby's initial response was to buy a new scissor lift until Lisa revealed that she put the polluted lake water in the audience's drinking glasses, convincing them to immediately fix the pollution problems.
* The phrase “an inconvenient truth,” or variations thereof, has become a common descriptive expression in the English vernacular since the film's title was announced, appearing in journalism [ cite news | url = http://edition.cnn.com/2008/POLITICS/01/13/raw.politics.foreman/index.html | title= Analysis: Candidates won't risk votes as troops risk lives | publisher = CNN | date = 13 January 2008 ] , blogs [cite web | url = http://www.democrats.com/ron-paul-shocks-gop-with-inconvenient-truth-about-islamic-terrorism | title = Ron Paul Shocks GOP With the 'Inconvenient Truth' About Islamic Terrorism | publisher = Bob Fertik | date = 16 May 2007 ] , and elsewhere.
* In an episode of "The Replacements", when an evil villain realizes that his plot to melt Antarctica will eventually backfire, Riley asks him if "the truth is too inconvenient".
* The episode of the TV shows "Scrubs" "
My Inconvenient Truth" parodies the title. Also the character The Janitor is inspired, after being shown the movie by lawyer Ted Buckland, to be more environmentally friendly.
* An episode of "Dexter" is named "An Inconvenient Lie".
List of documentaries
* "The 11th Hour", a film regarding the same subject
The Great Global Warming Swindle
Timeline of environmental events
United Kingdom Climate Change Bill
* [http://www.hokeg.dyndns.org/AITruth.htm Unofficial Transcript] Review: "Eco-Apocalypse and the Powerpoint Film"http://www.brightlightsfilm.com/53/gore.htm
Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.
Look at other dictionaries:
An Inconvenient Truth — Une vérité qui dérange Une vérité qui dérange (An Inconvenient Truth, titre en anglais) est un film documentaire américain traitant du changement climatique, spécialement du réchauffement planétaire, réalisé par Davis Guggenheim. Al Gore, ancien… … Wikipédia en Français
An inconvenient truth — Une vérité qui dérange Une vérité qui dérange (An Inconvenient Truth, titre en anglais) est un film documentaire américain traitant du changement climatique, spécialement du réchauffement planétaire, réalisé par Davis Guggenheim. Al Gore, ancien… … Wikipédia en Français
My Inconvenient Truth — Scrubs episode Episode no. Season 7 Episode 3 Directed by Bill Lawrence Written by … Wikipedia
An Inconvenient Truth — Filmdaten Deutscher Titel: Eine unbequeme Wahrheit Originaltitel: An Inconvenient Truth Produktionsland: USA Erscheinungsjahr: 2006 Länge: 94 Minuten Originalsprache: Englisch … Deutsch Wikipedia
An inconvenient truth — Filmdaten Deutscher Titel: Eine unbequeme Wahrheit Originaltitel: An Inconvenient Truth Produktionsland: USA Erscheinungsjahr: 2006 Länge: 94 Minuten Originalsprache: Englisch … Deutsch Wikipedia
inconvenient — UK US /ˌɪnkənˈviːniənt/ adjective ► causing problems or difficulties: inconvenient hour/moment/time »They rescheduled the meeting for a very inconvenient time. »I can call back later if it s inconvenient. »an inconvenient detail/fact/truth … Financial and business terms
An Inconvenient Book — Infobox Book | name = An Inconvenient Book: Real Solutions to the World’s Biggest Problems image caption = The cover of An Inconvenient Book author = Glenn Beck illustrator = Paul Nunn cover artist = George Lange country = United States of… … Wikipedia
Une vérité qui dérange — (An Inconvenient Truth, titre en anglais) est un documentaire américain traitant du changement climatique, spécialement du réchauffement planétaire, réalisé par Davis Guggenheim. Al Gore, ancien vice président des États Unis et prix Nobel de la… … Wikipédia en Français
Une Vérité qui dérange — (An Inconvenient Truth, titre en anglais) est un film documentaire américain traitant du changement climatique, spécialement du réchauffement planétaire, réalisé par Davis Guggenheim. Al Gore, ancien vice président des États Unis d Amérique et… … Wikipédia en Français
Une verite qui derange — Une vérité qui dérange Une vérité qui dérange (An Inconvenient Truth, titre en anglais) est un film documentaire américain traitant du changement climatique, spécialement du réchauffement planétaire, réalisé par Davis Guggenheim. Al Gore, ancien… … Wikipédia en Français