Palm Beach County Canvassing Board v. Harris (Harris I)


Palm Beach County Canvassing Board v. Harris (Harris I)

Palm Beach County Canvassing Board v. Harris (Harris I) was a lawsuit pertaining to the 2000 Presidential Election.

There were two main issues:
* Whether the county canvassing boards' authority to conduct manual recounts to correct "errors in the vote tabulation" extended to efforts to remedy situations where machines, though perhaps correctly functioning to detect properly marked ballots, did not count votes on certain ballots on which votes might be found under a manual inspection with an "intent of the voter" standard (Harris had ruled that it did not); and
* How such recounts in the case at hand could be made to fit into the statutory scheme, which as Harris interpreted it contemplated a quick certification followed, if necessary, by an election contest during which a court (rather than the canvassing boards) would be empowered to correct errors

Regarding the first issue, the court ruled that, while Harris was generally entitled to deference in her interpretation of state laws, in this case the interpretation "contravene [d] the plain meaning" of the phrase "error in the vote tabulation" and so must be overturned.

Regarding the second issue, the court ruled that the statutory scheme must be interpreted in light of the Florida state constitution's declaration that "all political power is inherent in the people," with any ambiguities therefore construed "liberally." Preventing the canvassing boards from continuing to conduct recounts beyond the seven-day timeframe (specified in the law, but with ambiguity as to how firm it was intended to be), would "summarily disenfranchise innocent electors [voters] " and could not be allowed except unless the recounts continued for so long as to "compromise the integrity of the electoral process." The court ordered counties to submit returns by November 26, until which time the stay of certification would stand.


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Gore v. Harris (Harris II) — Gore v. Harris, 772 So.2d 1243 (2000), was a Florida Supreme Court case heard on 2000 12 08. The parties to the case were Al Gore and Katherine Harris.Gore s appeal cited several instances claimed to involve the rejection of legal votes or the… …   Wikipedia

  • Bush v. Gore — Supreme Court of the United States Argued December 11, 2000 Decided December 12, 2000 …   Wikipedia

  • United States presidential election, 2000 — 1996 ← November 7, 2000 → 2004 …   Wikipedia

  • Al Gore presidential campaign, 2000 — Al Gore Gore in Manchester, New Hampshire campaigning for President of the United States in 1999 Democratic candidate for President of the United States …   Wikipedia

  • Jeb Bush — 43rd Governor of Florida In office January 5, 1999 – January 2, 2007 Lieutenant Frank Brogan Toni Jennings …   Wikipedia

  • David McReynolds — at the 2009 Left Forum in New York City Personal details Born January 10, 1929 (1929 25 10) (age 81) Los Angeles, Calif …   Wikipedia

  • Al Gore — This article is about the former U.S. Vice President. For his father, who was also a U.S. Senator, see Albert Gore, Sr. Al Gore …   Wikipedia

  • Dan Quayle — 44th Vice President of the United States In office January 20, 1989 – January 20, 1993 President George …   Wikipedia

  • Elizabeth Dole — United States Senator from North Carolina In office January 3, 2003 – January 3, 2009 Preceded by …   Wikipedia

  • George W. Bush — This article is about the 43rd U.S. president. For his father, the 41st U.S. president, see George H. W. Bush. For other persons of the same name, see George Bush. George W. Bush …   Wikipedia


Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.