Margarine Reference

Margarine Reference
Margarine Reference
Supreme Court of Canada.jpg

Supreme Court of Canada

Hearing: October 5-8, 1948
Judgment: December 14, 1948
Full case name: Reference as to the Validity of Section 5(A) of the Dairy Industry Act
Citations: [1949] S.C.R. 1
Court membership

Chief Justice: Thibaudeau Rinfret
Puisne Justices: Patrick Kerwin, Robert Taschereau, Ivan Rand, Roy Kellock, James Wilfred Estey, Charles Holland Locke

Reasons given

Majority by: Rand J.
Concurrence by: Tascherau J.
Concurrence by: Kellock J.
Concurrence by: Locke J.
Dissent by: Kerwin J.
Joined by: Kerwin J.

Reference re Validity of Section 5(a) of the Dairy Industry Act (1949), also known as the Margarine Reference[1] or as Can. Federation of Agriculture v. A.-G. Que.,[1] is a leading opinion of the Supreme Court of Canada on determining if a law is within the authority of the federal government under the Parliament's powers to legislate criminal law. In this particular case, the Court found that a regulation made by Parliament was ultra vires. It contained sufficient punitive sanctions; however, the subject matter was not the kind that served a public purpose.

At this time, the Supreme Court of Canada was not the supreme authority on Canadian law. However, the decision, by Rand J., was upheld by the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council (JCPC) in 1951. The case has been cited in federalism disputes many times since.[2]

Contents

Background

Under section 91(27) of the Constitution Act, 1867 (or, at the time of this case, the British North America Act, 1867), Parliament receives exclusive powers to legislate in regard to the criminal law. The precise meaning of the criminal law power, however, had proved controversial. In Board of Commerce (1922), the JCPC seemingly chose to define criminal law power as limited to prohibiting only what was criminal in 1867, the year of Canadian Confederation.[1] This was overturned in Proprietary Articles Trade Assn. v. A.-G. Can. (1931), in which it was found criminal law means Parliament could legitimately prohibit any act "with penal consequences." The problem with the latter decision was that it gave Parliament an excuse to legislate in regard to many matters.[1]

The matter came before the courts again with the Margarine Reference, and a compromise was attempted. In this case, Parliament had legislated against the production and trade of margarine, in order to give dairy businesses assurances that margarine would not threaten their existence.[3] This legislation actually dated back to 1886, and it was claimed in the law that the real purpose was to target a product that was "injurious to health."[3] While this, if true, would have made margarine a fair target for criminal law, the federal government admitted before the courts that this assessment was simply false.[3]

Decision

Justice Rand, for the Majority, struck down the prohibition on production of margarine on the grounds that it was not valid criminal law, the prohibition on importation of margarine, however, was upheld under the federal Trade and Commerce power.

Rand outlined a test to determine if a law falls under the criminal law.

A crime is an act which the law, with appropriate penal sanctions, forbids; but as prohibitions are not enacted in a vacuum, we can properly look for some evil or injurious or undesirable effect upon the public against which the law is directed. That effect may be in relation to social, economic or political interests; and the legislature has had in mind to suppress the evil or the safeguard the interest threatened.

From this, two requirements must be met for a law to be criminal in nature.

  1. the law must be a prohibition with a penal sanction; and
  2. the law must be directed towards a public purpose.

Rand also listed a few objectives that would qualify as legitimate public purposes, namely "Public peace, order, security, health, morality."

The JCPC, in upholding Rand's decision, agreed that in pith and substance, the law was primarily related to property and civil rights, a provincial power.

See also

References

  1. ^ a b c d Hogg, Peter W. Constitutional Law of Canada. 2003 Student Ed. (Scarborough, Ontario: Thomson Canada Limited, 2003), p. 462.
  2. ^ Hogg, p. 463.
  3. ^ a b c Hogg, 465.

External links


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем сделать НИР

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Margarine — in a tub Margarine (  /ˈ …   Wikipedia

  • Reference re Firearms Act — SCCInfoBox case name=Reference re Firearms Act (Can.) full case name=Reference re Firearms Act (Can.) heard date=February 21, 22, 2000 decided date=June 15, 2000 citations= [2000] 1 S.C.R. 783, 2000 SCC 31 history= none (Reference question)… …   Wikipedia

  • Criminal law in Canada — is under the exclusive jurisdiction of the federal government. The power to enact criminal law is derived from section 91(27) of the Constitution Act, 1867 . Most criminal laws have been codified in the Criminal Code of Canada , as well as the… …   Wikipedia

  • Proprietary Articles Trade Association v. Attorney General of Canada — [1931] A.C. 310 is a famous Canadian constitutional decision of the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council on the Constitution s criminal law power under section 91(27). Lord Atkin, writing for the Council, rejected the previous interpretation …   Wikipedia

  • Criminal law of Canada — The criminal law of Canada is under the exclusive legislative jurisdiction of the federal government. The power to enact criminal law is derived from section 91(27) of the Constitution Act, 1867. Most criminal laws have been codified in the… …   Wikipedia

  • Canadian federalism — For the political ideology that favours Quebec remaining within the Canadian federation rather than pursuing independence, see Quebec federalist ideology. Canada This article is part of the series: Politics and government of Canada …   Wikipedia

  • Nova Scotia Board of Censors v. McNeil — Supreme Court of Canada Hearing: May 24, 25, 1977 Judgment: January 19, 1978 Full case name …   Wikipedia

  • Criminal law under the Constitution Act, 1867 — In Canadian Constitutional law, the Constitution Act, 1867 provides the government with the authority to legislate on matters of criminal law and quasi criminal law. The primary criminal law power is granted to the federal government under… …   Wikipedia

  • Trans fat — Types of fats in food Unsaturated fat Monounsaturated fat Polyunsaturated fat Trans fat Cis fat Omega fatty acids: ω−3 ω−6 ω−9 Saturated fat Interesterified fat See also Fatty acid …   Wikipedia

  • Cooking oil — Plant oils Olive oil Types Vegetable fats (list) Macerated (list) Uses …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”