- Pluralism (political philosophy)
Pluralism is, in the general sense, the acknowledgment of diversity. The concept is used, often in different ways, in a wide range of issues. In
politics, pluralism is often considered by proponents of modern democracy to be in the interests of its citizens, and so political pluralism is one of its most important features.
The term pluralism is also used to denote a theoretical standpoint on state and power - which to varying degrees suggest that pluralism is an adequate model of how power is distributed in societies. For information on the political theory of pluralism see
Pluralism (political theory).
politics, pluralism is a guiding principlewhich permits the peaceful coexistence of different interests, convictions and lifestyles. In this context it has normative connotations absent from its use to denote a theoretical standpoint. Unlike totalitarianismor particularism, pluralism "acknowledges" the "diversity" of interests and considers it imperative that members of society accommodate their differences by engaging in good-faith negotiation.
One of the earliest arguments for pluralism came from
James Madisonin The Federalist Papers10. Madison feared that factionalism would lead to in-fighting in the new American republic and devotes this paper to questioning how best to avoid such an occurrence. He posits that to avoid factionalism, it is best to allow many competing factions to prevent any one dominating the political system. This relies, to a degree, on a series of disturbances changing the influences of groups so as to avoid institutional dominance and ensure competition.
Pluralism and the common good
Pluralism is connected with the hope that this process of
conflictand dialoguewill lead to a definition and subsequent realization of the " common good" that is best for all members of society. This implies that in a pluralistic framework, the common good is not given "a priori". Instead, the scope and content of the common good can only be found out in and after the process of negotiation ( a posteriori).
Consequently, the common good does not, according to pluralists, coincide with the position of any one cohesive group or organization. However, a necessary outcome of this philosophy is that the beliefs of any particular group cannot represent absolute truth. Therefore any group with a philosophy that purports to hold both absolute truth and identify the common good necessarily rejects pluralism- their belief system does not consider as valid the opinions of others who do not hold to their given beliefs.
Still, one group may eventually manage to establish its own view as the generally accepted view, but only as the result of the negotiation process within the pluralistic framework. This implies that, as a general rule, the "operator" of a truly pluralistic framework, i.e. the state in a pluralistic society, must not be "
biased": it may not take sides with any one group, give undue privileges to one group and discriminate against another one.
Proponents of pluralism argue that this negotiation process is the best way to achieve the common good: since everyone can participate in power and decision-making (and can claim part of the ownership of the results of exercising power) there can also be widespread participation and a greater feeling of commitment from society members, and therefore better outcomes. By contrast, an authoritarian or oligarchic society, where power is concentrated and decisions are made by few members, forestalls this possibility. Fact|date=November 2007
Proponents in contemporary political philosophy of such a view include
Isaiah Berlin, Stuart Hampshireand Bernard Williams. An earlier version of political pluralism was a strong current in the formation of modern social democracy, with theorists such as Harold Laskiand G. D. H. Cole, as well as other leading members of the British Fabian Society. Horace Kallencoined the term cultural pluralismto express the condition of a democratic nation which sustained, and was sustained by, many cultural traditions.
Note, however, that political philosophers such as
Charles Blattberghave argued that negotiation can at best compromise rather than realise the common good. Doing the latter is said to require engaging in "conversation" instead, room for which is made within what Blattberg calls a patriotic, as distinct from pluralist, politics.
Conditions for pluralism
For pluralism to function and to be successful in defining the common good, all groups have to agree to a minimal consensus regarding shared values, which tie the different groups to society, and shared rules for
conflict resolutionbetween the groups:
The most important value is that of mutual
respectand tolerance, so that different groups can coexist and interact without anyone being forced to assimilate to anyone else's position in conflicts that will naturally arise out of diverging interests and positions. These conflicts can only be resolved durably by dialoguewhich leads to compromiseand to mutual understanding.
Examples of misapplied pluralism include
cultural relativism, anarcho-capitalism, and post-modernism. Pluralism's tolerance for difference, its fostering of diversity, its promotion of different individuals' pursuit of variable modes of life and their expression of different cultural values does not conflate all cultures as more or less equal (multiculturalism), nor is it indifferent to some cultural differences that are unacceptable to social standards of decency, e.g., genital mutilation (cultural relativism), nor is it without cognizance of the need for social institutions to provide "space" for diversity to meet minimum standards of decency and order (anarcho-capitalism), nor is it silent or uncritical of inferior standards and values (post-modernism), but engages different social and personal values in a critical, but respectful, dialectic of reciprocal evaluation. Coercive action is used only when another mode of life or cultural expression causes harm, otherwise it engages in a dialogue of critical evaluation of different modes and expressions through persuasion. Unlike many of the misapplications, pluralism's tolerance is intolerant of intolerance (which is self-defeating and anti-pluralistic).
To illustrate, anarcho-capitalism takes
self-ownershipas a shared "a priori" value. Derived from this come the principles of non-aggression and private property. To resolve conflicts over the use of property, both-benefit voluntary trade is conducted according to subjective theory of value. From the single shared value of self-ownership, voluntary trade thus enables individuals with differing values to resolve conflicts without resorting to violence.
Pluralism and subsidiarity
However, the necessary consensus on rules and values should not unnecessarily limit different groups and individuals within society in their value decisions. According to the principle of
subsidiarity, everything that need not be regulated within the general framework should be left to decide for subordinate groups and, in turn, to individuals so as to guarantee them a maximum amount of freedom.
In ultimate consequence, pluralism thus also implies the right for individuals to determine
valuesand truths for themselves instead of being forced to follow the whole of society or, indeed, their own group.
List of democracy and elections-related topics
* The political theory of pluralism
Global Centre for Pluralism
* "A Pluralistic Universe", James, William (1909).
political philosophyand ethics:
* "Morality and Conflict",
* "From Pluralist to Patriotic Politics", Blattberg, Charles (2000).
* "Liberty", Berlin, Isaiah (2002).
* "In the Beginning Was the Deed",
* "In Pursuit of Justice",
Skillen, James W.(2006).
* On legal pluralism and communities, see:
Gad Barzilai, Communities and Law: Politics and Cultures of Legal Identities. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 2003.
* [http://www.pluralism.ca Global Centre for Pluralism]
* [http://www.pluralism.org/ The Pluralism Project at Harvard University]
Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.
Look at other dictionaries:
Pluralism (political theory) — This article is about a political theory called pluralism . For the idea of pluralism in politics as acknowledgment of diversity, see Pluralism (political philosophy). For other uses, see Pluralism (disambiguation). Classical pluralism is the… … Wikipedia
Political philosophy — Part of the Politics series Politics List of political topics Politics by country … Wikipedia
List of topics in social and political philosophy — * And theory of conservatism * A Conflict of Visions * A Few Words on Non Intervention * A Vindication of the Rights of Men * Accountability * Action theory * Actual Idealism * Adam Müller * Adamites * Agency (philosophy) * Aggravation of class… … Wikipedia
Pluralism — is used, often in different ways, across a wide range of topics to denote a diversity of views, and stands in opposition to one single approach or method of interpretation: *Scientific pluralism, the view that some phenomena observed in science… … Wikipedia
Political ideologies in the United States — vary considerably. Persons in the U.S. generally classify themselves either as adhering to American liberalism, American conservatism or as moderates. American liberalism aims at the preservation and extension of human, social and civil rights as … Wikipedia
Philosophy of social science — considers the nature of confirmation and explanation in the social (or human) sciences, such as history, economics, and sociology. Philosophers of social science are often concerned with the differences and similarities between the social and the … Wikipedia
philosophy, Western — Introduction history of Western philosophy from its development among the ancient Greeks to the present. This article has three basic purposes: (1) to provide an overview of the history of philosophy in the West, (2) to relate… … Universalium
Pluralism (philosophy) — This article is about the term pluralism in branches of philosophy. For the ancient Greek school of thought, see Pluralist school. Pluralism is a term used in philosophy, meaning doctrine of multiplicity , often used in opposition to monism (… … Wikipedia
Political science — For the Randy Newman song of the same name, see Political Science (song). Part of the Politics series Politics … Wikipedia
PHILOSOPHY, JEWISH — This article is arranged according to the following outline: WHAT IS JEWISH PHILOSOPHY? recent histories of jewish philosophy biblical and rabbinic antecedents bible rabbinic literature hellenistic jewish philosophy philo of alexandria biblical… … Encyclopedia of Judaism