# Empty product

﻿
Empty product

In mathematics, an empty product, or nullary product, is the result of multiplying no factors. It is equal to the multiplicative identity 1, given that it exists for the multiplication operation in question, just as the empty sum—the result of adding no numbers—is zero, or the additive identity.[1][2][3]

When a mathematical recipe says "multiply all the numbers in this list", and the list contains, say, 2, 3, 2 and 4, we multiply first the first number by the second, then the result by the third, and so on until the end of the list, so the product of (2,3,2,4) would be 48. If the list contains only one number, so that we cannot multiply first by second, common convention holds that the 'product of all' is that same number, and if the list has no numbers at all, the 'product of all' is 1. This value is necessary to be consistent with the recursive definition of what a product over a sequence (or set, given commutativity) means. For example,

\begin{align} \text{prod}((2,3,5)) & = \text{prod}((2,3)) \times 5 = \text{prod}((2)) \times 3 \times 5 \\ & = \text{prod}(()) \times 2 \times 3 \times 5 = 1 \times 2 \times 3 \times 5. \end{align}

In general, we define

$\text{prod}(()) = 1\text{ and }\text{prod}((a_i)_{i \le n}) = \text{prod}((a_i)_{i \le n-1}) \times a_n.$

The empty product is used in discrete mathematics, algebra, the study of power series, and computer programs.

The term "empty product" is most often used in the above sense when discussing arithmetic operations. However, the term is sometimes employed when discussing set-theoretic intersections, categorical products, and products in computer programming; these are discussed below.

## Nullary arithmetic product

### Intuitive justification

Imagine a calculator that can only multiply. It has an "ENTER" key and a "CLEAR" key. One would wish that, for example, if one presses "CLEAR", 7 "ENTER", 3 "ENTER", 4 "ENTER", then the display reads 84, because 7 × 3 × 4 = 84. More precisely, we specify:

• A number is displayed just after "CLEAR" is pressed;
• When a number is displayed and one enters another number, the product is displayed;
• When "CLEAR" is pressed and then some numbers are entered, their product is displayed.

Then the starting value after pressing "CLEAR" has to be 1. After one has pressed "clear" and done nothing else, the number of factors one has entered is zero. Therefore the product of zero numbers is 1.

### Frequent examples

Two often-seen instances are a0 = 1 (any number raised to the zeroth power is one) and 0! = 1 (the factorial of zero is one).

More examples of the use of the empty product in mathematics may be found in the binomial theorem, factorial, fundamental theorem of arithmetic, birthday paradox, Stirling number, König's theorem, binomial type, difference operator, Pochhammer symbol, proof that e is irrational, prime factor,[4][5] binomial series, and multiset.

### Logarithms

The definition of an empty product can be based on that of the empty sum:

The sum of two logarithms is equal to the logarithm of the product of their operands, i.e. for any base b > 0:

$\log_b n + \log_b m = \log_b (nm) \,$

and

$b^{\log_b n + \log_b m} = nm$

and more generally

$\prod_i x_i = b^{\sum_i \log_b x_i}$

i.e., multiplication across all elements of a set is b to the power of the sum of all logarithms of the set's elements.

Using this property as definition, and extending this to the empty product, the right-hand side of this equation evaluates to b0 for the empty set, because the empty sum is defined to be zero, and therefore the empty product must equal one.

## 0 raised to the 0th power

In set theory and combinatorics, the cardinal number nm is the size of the set of functions from a set of size m into a set of size n. If m is positive and n is zero, then there are no such functions, because there are no elements in the latter set to map those of the former set into. Thus 0m = 0 when m is positive. However, if both sets are empty (have size 0), then there is exactly one such function — the empty function. For this reason, authors in combinatorics and set theory frequently define 00 to be 1 when it represents an empty product.

## Nullary conjunction and intersection

Conjunctions of the arguments in parentheses: The conjunction of no argument is the tautology.

For similar reasons, the logical conjunction of no argument is the tautology. Accordingly the intersection of no set is conventionally equal to the universe. See nullary intersection for more information.

## Nullary Cartesian product

Consider the general definition of the Cartesian product:

$\prod_{i \in I} X_i = \{ g : I \to \bigcup_{i \in I} X_i\ |\ \forall i\ g(i) \in X_i \}.$

If I is empty, the only satisfying g is the empty function $f_\varnothing$:

$\prod_\varnothing{} = \{ f_\varnothing: \varnothing \to \varnothing \}.$

Thus, the cardinality of the Cartesian product of no sets is 1.

Under the perhaps more familiar n-tuple interpretation,

$\prod_\varnothing{} = \{ ( ) \},$

that is, the singleton set containing the empty tuple. Note that in both representations the empty product has cardinality 1.

### Nullary Cartesian product of functions

The empty Cartesian product of functions is again the empty function.

## Nullary categorical product

In any category, the product of an empty family is a terminal object of that category. This can be demonstrated by using the limit definition of the product. An n-fold categorical product can be defined as the limit with respect to a diagram given by the discrete category with n objects. An empty product is then given by the limit with respect to the empty category, which is the terminal object of the category if it exists. This definition specializes to give results as above. For example, in the category of sets the categorical product is the usual Cartesian product, and the terminal object is a singleton set. In the category of groups the categorical product is the Cartesian product of groups, and the terminal object is a trivial group with one element. To obtain the usual arithmetic definition of the empty product we must take the decategorification of the empty product in the category of finite sets.

Dually, the coproduct of an empty family is an initial object. Nullary categorical products or coproducts may not exist in a given category; e.g. in the category of fields, neither exists.

## In computer programming

Many programming languages, such as Python, allow the direct expression of lists of numbers, and even functions that allow an arbitrary number of parameters. If such a language has a function that returns the product of all the numbers in a list, it usually works like this:

   listprod( [2,3,5] ) --> 30
listprod( [2,3] )   --> 6
listprod( [2] )     --> 2
listprod( [] )      --> 1


This convention sometimes helps avoid having to code special cases like "if length of list is 1" or "if length of list is zero" as special cases.

Many programming languages do not permit the direct expression of the empty product, because they do not allow expressing lists. Multiplication is taken to be an infix operator and therefore a binary operator. (A programmer may, of course, implement it.) Languages implementing variadic functions are the exception. For example, the fully parenthesized prefix notation of Lisp languages gives rise to a natural notation for nullary functions:

(* 2 2 2)   ; evaluates to 8
(* 2 2)     ; evaluates to 4
(* 2)       ; evaluates to 2
(*)         ; evaluates to 1


## References

1. ^ Jaroslav Nešetřil, Jiří Matoušek (1998). Invitation to Discrete Mathematics. Oxford University Press. pp. 12. ISBN 0-198-50207-9.
2. ^ A.E. Ingham and R C Vaughan (1990). The Distribution of Prime Numbers. Cambridge University Press. pp. 1. ISBN 0-521-39789-8.
3. ^ Page 9 of Lang, Serge (2002), Algebra, Graduate Texts in Mathematics, 211 (Revised third ed.), New York: Springer-Verlag, ISBN 978-0-387-95385-4, MR1878556
4. ^ Edsger Wybe Dijkstra (1990-03-04). "How Computing Science created a new mathematical style". EWD. Retrieved 2010-01-20. "Hardy and Wright: “Every positive integer, except 1, is a product of primes”, Harold M. Stark: “If n is an integer greater than 1, then either n is prime or n is a finite product of primes.”. These examples —which I owe to A.J.M. van Gasteren— both reject the empty product, the last one also rejects the product with a single factor."
5. ^ Edsger Wybe Dijkstra (1986-11-14). "The nature of my research and why I do it.". EWD. Retrieved 2010-07-03. "But also 0 is certainly finite and by defining the product of 0 factors —how else?— to be equal to 1 we can do away with the exception: "If n is a positive integer, then n is a finite product of primes.""

Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

### Look at other dictionaries:

• empty product — noun The result of multiplying no numbers (defined in order to be able to extend certain mathematical concepts, such as the product of n numbers, to the case where n = 0) …   Wiktionary

• Empty sum — Not to be confused with Zero sum. In mathematics, an empty sum, or nullary sum, is a summation involving no terms at all. The value of any empty sum of numbers is conventionally taken to be zero. For summations defined in terms of addition of… …   Wikipedia

• Empty set — ∅ redirects here. For similar looking symbols, see Ø (disambiguation). The empty set is the set containing no elements. In mathematics, and more specifically set theory, the empty set is the unique set having no elements; its size or cardinality… …   Wikipedia

• Product (category theory) — In category theory, the product of two (or more) objects in a category is a notion designed to capture the essence behind constructions in other areas of mathematics such as the cartesian product of sets, the direct product of groups, the direct… …   Wikipedia

• Product (mathematics) — In mathematics, a product is the result of multiplying, or an expression that identifies factors to be multiplied. The order in which real or complex numbers are multiplied has no bearing on the product; this is known as the commutative law of… …   Wikipedia

• Product topology — In topology and related areas of mathematics, a product space is the cartesian product of a family of topological spaces equipped with a natural topology called the product topology. This topology differs from another, perhaps more obvious,… …   Wikipedia

• Empty function — In mathematics, an empty function is a function whose domain is the empty set. For each set A , there is exactly one such empty function :f A: varnothing ightarrow A.The graph of an empty function is a subset of the Cartesian product empty;… …   Wikipedia

• Empty vessel — The phrase empty vessel literally means a container with nothing inside. It has additional significance in various areas.In literatureThe quotation, As empty vessels make the loudest sound, so they that have the least wit are the greatest… …   Wikipedia

• Cartesian product — Cartesian square redirects here. For Cartesian squares in category theory, see Cartesian square (category theory). In mathematics, a Cartesian product (or product set) is a construction to build a new set out of a number of given sets. Each… …   Wikipedia

• Wick product — In probability theory, the Wick product:langle X 1,dots,X k angle,named after physicist Gian Carlo Wick, is a sort of product of the random variables, X 1, ..., X k , defined recursively as follows::langle angle = 1,(i.e. the empty product… …   Wikipedia