State immunity


State immunity

The rules of state immunity concern the protection which a state is given from being sued in the courts of other states. The rules relate to legal proceedings in the courts of another state, not in a state's own courts. The rules developed at a time when it was thought to be an infringement of a state's sovereignty to bring proceedings against it or its officials in a foreign country. But there are now substantial exceptions to the rule of immunity; in particular, a state can be sued when the dispute arises from a commercial transaction entered into by a state or some other non-sovereign activity of a state. The new United Nations Convention on Jurisdictional Immunities of States and their Property, which is not yet in force, formulates the rules and the exceptions to them. It does not cover criminal proceedings, and it does not allow civil actions for human rights abuses against state agents where the abuse has occurred in another country.

Immunity against civil proceedings for serious human rights abuses

It is not obvious why states should have immunity in cases relating to serious human rights abuses. The argument is made that fundamental human rights such as the right to life and the prohibition against torture should take precedence over rules of state immunity. The argument goes that these rights have a higher ranking and importance (in lawyer-speak they constitute norms of "jus cogens") than a rule of state immunity, and that the recent focus on ending impunity for serious human rights abuses should ensure that the law develops to allow states to be sued.

The argument on the other side is that immunity should be ended, but other ways exist to accomplish this. Ending immunity should not be at the expense of proper conduct of relations between states; one country's perception of abuse may not be another’s; civil actions for a state agent's atrocities should be brought in the courts of that state, not in a foreign court; prosecution of crime lies in the hands of the state, whereas civil proceedings are brought by individuals for their own ends; civil actions brought by disgruntled individuals in one country against another state can have grave political and economic repercussions for both states; and civil proceedings can raise difficult issues of enforcement and extra-territorial jurisdiction. The arguments on both sides reflect different perceptions of how to strike a balance between protection of state interests and protection of the human rights of individuals.

European Convention on State Immunity

The European Convention on State Immunity was signed in Basle on May 16, 1972 and currently has 46 signatories — that is every member of the Council of Europe.

United Nations Convention on Jurisdictional Immunities of States and Their Property

The United Nations Convention on Jurisdictional Immunities of States and Their Property was adopted by the General Assembly on 2 December 2004. The Convention is open for signature by all States until 17 January 2007 and will enter into force on the thirtieth day following the date of deposit of the thirtieth instrument of ratification, acceptance, approval or accession. As of 16 May 2007, there are 28 signatories to the Convention and 4 instruments of ratification have been deposited.

ee also

*Command responsibility
*Human rights abuse
*International humanitarian law
*Sovereign immunity

References

*Based on the May 2005 international law programme from speakers Joanne Foakes and Elizabeth Wilmshurst, Chatham House [http://www.chathamhouse.org.uk/pdf/research/il/BPstateimmunity.pdf]
*cite|author=Hazel Fox|title=The Law of State Immunity|publisher=Oxford University Press|date=2002

External links

* [http://conventions.coe.int/Treaty/en/Treaties/Html/074.htm Text of European Convention on State Immunity]
* [http://untreaty.un.org/ilc/texts/instruments/english/conventions/4_1_2004.pdf Text of United Nations Convention on Jurisdictional Immunities of States and Their Property]


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • state immunity — the general principle that one state does not impose civil or criminal liability on another. Thus the head of state or former head of state of a country is normally free from prosecution in another country. However, where a crime is… …   Law dictionary

  • state immunity — суверенный иммунитет, иммунитет государства, не позволяющий подавать против него иски в суды и арбитражи и приводить в исполнение судебные и арбитражные решения. В литературе выделяют абсолютный и функциональный иммунитеты, см. iure imperii, iure …   Glossary of international commercial arbitration

  • State Immunity Act 1978 — The State Immunity Act 1978 is an Act made by the Parliament of the United Kingdom in order to implement the European Convention on State Immunity of 1972 into British law. The doctrine of absolute state immunity was changed to one of restricted… …   Wikipedia

  • European Convention on State Immunity and an Additional Protocol — USA European Convention on State Immunity and an Additional Protocol, Also known as the EU Convention. Open for signature by the member countries of the Council of Europe in 1972 and effective in 1976, the European Convention on State Immunity… …   Law dictionary

  • Immunity from prosecution (international law) — Immunity from prosecution is a doctrine of international law that allows an accused to avoid prosecution for criminal offences. Immunities are of two types. The first is functional immunity, or immunity ratione materiae . This is an immunity… …   Wikipedia

  • immunity — im·mu·ni·ty /i myü nə tē/ n pl ties [Latin immunitas, from immunis exempt from public service, exempt, from in non + munis (from munia services)] 1: exemption from a duty or liability that is granted by law to a person or class of persons a… …   Law dictionary

  • State of Palestine — This article is about the political entity proclaimed in 1988. For other uses, see Palestine (disambiguation). State of Palestine[1][i] دولة فلسطين …   Wikipedia

  • Immunity — • An exemption from a legal obligation (munus), imposed on a person or his property by law, custom, or the order of a superior Catholic Encyclopedia. Kevin Knight. 2006. Immunity     Immunity …   Catholic encyclopedia

  • Immunity (medical) — Immunity is a biological term that describes a state of having sufficient biological defenses to avoid infection, disease, or other unwanted biological invasion. Immunity involves both specific and non specific components. The non specific… …   Wikipedia

  • State Defense Forces — (SDF) (also known as State Guards, State Military Reserves, or State Militias) in the United States are military units that operate under the sole authority of a state government, although they are regulated by the National Guard Bureau through… …   Wikipedia