- Michael A. Smith
Michael Andrew Smith (born in Melbourne, Australia on 23 July 1954) is an Australian philosopher who teaches at Princeton University (since September 2004). He taught previously at the University of Oxford, Monash University, and was a member of the Philosophy Program at the Research School of Social Sciences, Australian National University. He is the author of several essays in ethics and moral philosophy.
Smith earned his B.A. and M.A. in philosophy at Monash University, while his BPhil and DPhil were acquired at Oxford University under the direction of Simon Blackburn. He has held teaching appointments at various universities, including Wadham College, Oxford (1984), Monash (1984-5; 1989-94), Princeton (1985-9), and the Research School of Social Sciences, ANU (1995-2004).
In 2000, Smith's book The Moral Problem (1994) received The American Philosophical Association's first APA Book Prize for excellence in scholarship. Smith is considered to be one of the most important philosophers working in meta-ethics, and is one of the main proponents of a Neo-Humean approach to practical reason.
The moral problem
In The Moral Problem Smith diagnoses a longstanding tension between the apparent objectivity and practicality of moral judgments. The idea of moral objectivity is that "it is a distinctive feature of engaging in moral practice that the participants are concerned to get the answers to moral questions right." (1994 p. 5) Moral judgments are thought to be practical because they are thought to motivate those who accept them. But according to the Humean theory of motivation, a theory that Smith defends in chapter 4, it is not possible for a belief (a judgement about a matter of fact) to motivate someone without the presence of some antecedently held desire. Thus, if moral judgments are beliefs that motivate, they can only be beliefs about how to get something that we already want. But moral judgments, such as the judgment that murder is wrong, are not judgments about how to get something that we already want. Therefore, either they are not beliefs at all (and therefore not objective) or they cannot motivate us.
Hume famously claimed that reason is, and ought to be, only the slave of the passions. Humeans or Neo-Humeans do not typically hold strictly to Hume's views because, for one thing, they do not think of the passions in the same way that Hume did. Nonetheless, Humeans take their inspiration from Hume in claiming that reason alone is insufficient to motivate us to act. Often this claim is expressed in terms of beliefs and desires, and it is claimed that beliefs are mental states that are insufficient for motivation. Smith gives an analysis of action whereby in order for anything to count as an action at all, it must be explicable in terms of a belief-desire pair. He defends this account against objections by appeal to a dispositional conception of desire.
Smith later goes on to give an anti-Humean account of normative reasons. He thus claims to solve the moral problem by giving an account of moral judgments in terms of what one would desire if one were fully rational. As such, he attempts to maintain a form of moral realism whilst accounting for the motivational force of moral judgments.
A partial list of publications by Smith:
- The Moral Problem (1994), Wiley-Blackwell.
- Ethics and the A Priori: Selected Essays on Moral Psychology and Meta-Ethics (2004), Cambridge University Press.
Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.
Look at other dictionaries:
Michael W. Smith 2 — Studio album by Michael W. Smith Released February 23, 1984 … Wikipedia
Michael W. Smith — Michael Whitaker Smith (* 7. Oktober 1957 in Kenova, West Virginia) ist ein US amerikanischer Sänger und Songwriter mit christlicher Ausrichtung. Er ist verheiratet und Vater von fünf Kindern … Deutsch Wikipedia
Michael Whitaker Smith — Michael W. Smith Michael Whitaker Smith (* 7. Oktober 1957 in Kenova, West Virginia, USA) ist ein US amerikanischer Sänger und Songwriter mit christlicher Ausrichtung. Er ist verheiratet und Vater von fünf Kindern. Inhalts … Deutsch Wikipedia
Michael Bell-Smith — (b. East Corinth, Maine, 1978) is a contemporary artist who lives and works in Brooklyn, New York. Bell Smith s work utilizes digital forms to explore the use of popular technologies in contemporary visual culture. Bell Smith received a Bachelor… … Wikipedia
Michael W Smith — Michael W. Smith Michael W. Smith Michael Whitaker Smith (né le 7 octobre 1957, de Paul et Barbara Smith à Kenova, Virginie Occidentale), est un chanteur américain chrétien, compositeur, pianiste et guitariste. Il a également une sœur prénommée… … Wikipédia en Français
Michael W. Smith — Michael Whitaker Smith (né le 7 octobre 1957, de Paul et Barbara Smith à Kenova, Virginie Occidentale), est un chanteur américain chrétien, compositeur, pianiste et guitariste. Il a également une sœur prénommée Kim … Wikipédia en Français
Michael Hoke Smith — (* 2. September 1855 in Newton, Catawba County, North Carolina; † 27. November 1931) war ein US amerikanischer Politiker, Innenminister der Vereinigten Staaten von 1893 bis 1896 und zweimal Gouverneur von Georgia … Deutsch Wikipedia
Michael Keith Smith — (1953 – 3 July 2010, Portchester, Fareham, Hampshire), commonly known as Mike Smith, had been founder chairman of the Conservative Democratic Alliance, a British right wing pressure group. He was also the successful claimant in Keith Smith… … Wikipedia
Michael Wesley Smith — (* 2. Dezember 1983 in Wellington, Neuseeland; eigentlich Michael Thomas Wesley Smith) ist ein neuseeländischer Schauspieler. Bekannt wurde er durch die neuseeländische Science Fiction Jugendserie The Tribe, die inzwischen zur weltweiten Jugend… … Deutsch Wikipedia
Michael Buffalo Smith — (b. June 24, 1957, Spartanburg, South Carolina) is a writer and musician who has been called The Ambassdor of Southern Rock .He began his career in music at the age of 21. Prior to that, he had always maintained an interest in music, and plunked… … Wikipedia
Michael Wesley-Smith — Born Michael Thomas Wesley Smith 2 December 1983 (1983 12 02) (age 27) New Zealand Years active 1998 present Michael Thomas Wesley Smith (born 2 December 1983) is a New Zealand television actor. He is best known for his portrayal of the… … Wikipedia