Political settlement


Political settlement

Political Settlement: Concept in political theory linked to Elite theory, States, and State-building. Joel Migdal has suggested that the concept of political settlements has a pedigree going back to the work of Barrington Moore. Political settlements are the frameworks for governing a state established by elites, either through formal processes or informally over time. Attempts to clearly define the concept are relatively recent and the political scientist Alan Whaites has suggested that

Political settlements are the deeper, often unarticulated, understandings between elites that bring about the conditions to end conflict, but which also in most states prevent violent conflict from occurring. Political settlements happen because of self interest (hope of greater benefit from a common state-building project) or due to a strong sense of shared ethos (such as religious or ideological conviction).
He goes on to suggest that many political settlements contain the seed of their own eventual failure through inherent inflexibility.
Most political settlements now have an explicit articulation (enshrined in an evolvingdocument – usually a constitution). Ultimately, however, no political settlement canafford to be static. For a political settlement to endure it must absorb socialchange, for example settlements formed by elites that exclude a growingmiddle class usually become subject to a step change; a `Great Reform Act,’suffragettes struggle or people’s movement. It has been suggested that in moststates constitutional reform has become the metaphor for the renegotiation ofpower.

Whaites offers categories for different types of political settlements, including `engineered' and imposed. http://www.dfid.gov.uk/pubs/files/State-in-Development-Wkg-Paper.pdf

Verena Fritz and Alina Rocha Menocal published a paper in 2007 arguing that political settlements are a `domain' at the heart of all state processe. They relate the concept to broader state theory (including the issues of elections and legitimacy). They stress that political settlements are not one-off events but evolve over time. See http://www.odi.org.uk/pppg/politics_and_governance/publications/ODI_state_building_paper.pdf.

Important contributions on the establishing of political settlements in modern (particularly newly democratic) states have also been made by Tom Carothers and Marina Ottaway of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. http://www.carnegieendowment.org Also of note is JC Scott's work `Seeing Like a State' which explores the routes through which political settlements in medieval Europe begain to consolidate formal state structures.

It is important to note that in political science the concept of `political settlements' is distinct from short-term processes aimed at elite agreements, such as a `peace process' or `peace agreement.' Peace negotiations and agreements may be part of the process of achieving a political settlement, but the settlement itself is the period of time for which an elite agreement holds, which could last for days or centuries.

Controversially the political scientist Patrick Chabal has suggested that the concept of political settlements is often less useful than that of `political sedimentation,' the residue of elite accommodation that is left after a period of contestation or explict conflict, (quoted from Whaites above) see also www.dfid.gov.uk/pubs/files/Expert-feedback.pdf

References

Fritz, V and Rocha Menocal A, Understanding state-building from a political economy perspective, ODI, London 2007

Migdal Joel, State in Society, CUP, 2001

Moore, B, `Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy,' Beacon Press 1993

Scott, JC, `Seeing Like a State,' Yale University Press, 1999

Whaites, A, States in Development, DFID, London 2008


= Headline text =


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • political settlement — settlement due to political beliefs, settlement established for political reasons …   English contemporary dictionary

  • Political positions of John McCain — U.S. Senator John McCain (R AZ), a member of the U.S. Congress since 1983, a two time U.S. presidential candidate, and the nominee of the Republican Party in the 2008 U.S. Presidential election, has taken positions on many political issues… …   Wikipedia

  • Political positions of Joe Biden — Joe Biden is the senior senator from the U.S. state of Delaware. He has served in the Senate since 1973 and made his second run for president in 2008 election as a Democrat. Biden was announced as presidential nominee Barack Obama s running mate… …   Wikipedia

  • Political migration — is any migration motivated primarily by political interests. Typically, political migration is in one of two classes, private or government, depending on who encourages the migration.Political migrations differ from other migrations by attempting …   Wikipedia

  • Political repression — is the persecution of an individual or group for political reasons, particularly for the purpose of restricting or preventing their ability to take part in the political life of society. Political repression may be represented by discriminatory… …   Wikipedia

  • Settlement movement (Israel) — Settlement movement ( he. תנועת מיישבות) is a term used in Israel to describe national umbrella organisations for kibbutzim, moshavim, moshavim shitufiim, and communal settlements. It is not related to the term Israeli settlement, which denotes… …   Wikipedia

  • Political and military events in Scotland during the reign of David I — are the events which took place in Scotland during David I of Scotland s reign as King of Scots, from 1124 to 1153. When his brother Alexander I of Scotland died in 1124, David chose, with the backing of Henry I of England, to take the Kingdom of …   Wikipedia

  • POLITICAL LIFE AND PARTIES — Introduction It was largely due to the existence of the pre state political parties, which had conducted intensive political activities for almost half a century within the framework of the yishuv , under the British Mandate for Palestine, that… …   Encyclopedia of Judaism

  • Political parties —    Israel s political parties, many with roots in late 19th and early 20th century Europe, fall into several distinct categories, many with cross cutting ideological and denominational lines. These categories of parties include secular… …   Historical Dictionary of Israel

  • political system — Introduction       the set of formal legal institutions that constitute a “government” or a “ state.” This is the definition adopted by many studies of the legal or constitutional arrangements of advanced political orders. More broadly defined,… …   Universalium