An Experimental Enquiry Concerning the Source of the Heat which is Excited by Friction


An Experimental Enquiry Concerning the Source of the Heat which is Excited by Friction

.

Background

Rumford was an opponent of the caloric theory of heat which held that heat was a fluid that could be neither created nor destroyed. He had further developed the view that all gases and liquids were absolute non-conductors of heat. His views were out of step with the accepted science of the time and the latter theory had particularly been attacked by John Daltonref|JD and John Leslieref|JL.

Rumford was heavily influenced by the theological argument from designref|R1 and it is likely that he wished to grant water a privileged and providential status in the regulation of human liferef|C1.

Though Rumford was to come to associate heat with motion, there is no evidence that he was committed to the kinetic theory or the principle of "vis viva".

Experiments

Rumford had observed the frictional heat generated by boring cannon at the arsenal in Munich. Rumford immersed a cannon barrel in water and arranged for a specially blunted boring tool. He showed that the water could be boiled within roughly two and a half hours and that the supply of frictional heat was seemingly inexhaustible. Rumford confirmed that no physical change had taken place in the material of the cannon by comparing the specific heats of the material machined away and that remaining were the same.

Rumford argued that the seemingly indefinite generation of heat was incompatible with the caloric theory. He contended that the only thing communicated to the barrel was motion.

Rumford made no attempt to further quantify the heat generated or to measure the mechanical equivalent of heat.

Reception

Most established scientists, such as William Henryref|WH and Thomas Thomsonref|TT, believed that there was enough uncertainty in the caloric theory to allow its adaptation to account for the new results. It had certainly proved robust and adaptable up to that time.

Furthermore, Thomsonref|TT2, Jöns Jakob Berzelius and Antoine César Becquerel observed that electricity could be indefinitely generated by friction. No educated scientist of the time was willing to hold that electricity was not a fluid.

Ultimately, Rumford's claim of the "inexhaustible" supply of heat was a reckless extrapolation from the study. Charles Haldat made some penetrating criticisms of the reproducibility of Rumford's resultsref|CH and it is possible to see the whole experiment as somewhat tendentiousref|C2.

However, the experiment inspired the work of James Prescott Joule in the 1840s. Joule's more exact measurements were pivotal in establishing the kinetic theory at the expense of caloric.

Notes

#Cardwell (1971) "p."99
#cite book | author=Leslie, J. | title=An Experimental Enquiry into the Nature and Propagation of Heat | publisher=London | year=1804 | id=
#Rumford (1804) "An enquiry concerning the nature of heat and the mode of its communication" "Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society" "p."77
#Cardwell (1971) "pp"99-100
#Henry, W. (1802) "A review of some experiments which have been supposed to disprove the materiality of heat", "Manchester Memoirs" "v", "p."603
#Thomson, T. "Caloric", Supplement on Chemistry, "Encyclopædia Britannica", 3rd ed.
#"Ibid"
#Haldat, C.N.A (1810) "Inquiries concerning the heat produced by friction", "Journal de Physique" lxv, "p."213
#Cardwell (1971) "p."102

Bibliography

*cite book | author=Cardwell, D.S.L. | title=From Watt to Clausius: The Rise of Thermodynamics in the Early Industrial Age | location=Heinemann | publisher=London | year=1971 | id=ISBN 0-435-54150-1


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Mechanical equivalent of heat — For other uses, see Conservation of energy. In the history of science, the mechanical equivalent of heat was a concept that had an important part in the development and acceptance of the conservation of energy and the establishment of the science …   Wikipedia

  • Caloric theory — The caloric theory is an obsolete scientific theory that heat consists of a fluid called caloric that flows from hotter to colder bodies. Caloric was also thought of as a weightless gas that could pass in and out of pores in solids and liquids.… …   Wikipedia

  • 1798 in science — The year 1798 in science and technology involved some significant events.Chemistry* The element beryllium is discovered by Louis Vauquelin as the oxide in beryl and in emeralds. Friedrich Wöhler and A. A. Bussy independently isolated the metal in …   Wikipedia

  • List of important publications in physics — Optics Book of Optics *Ibn al Haytham (Alhacen)Description: The Book of Optics (Arabic: Kitab al Manazir , Latin: De Aspectibus ) is a seven volume treatise on optics and physics, written by the Iraqi Arab Muslim scientist Ibn al Haytham… …   Wikipedia

  • Benjamin Thompson — For other people named Benjamin Thompson, see Benjamin Thompson (disambiguation). Benjamin Thompson Born March 26, 1753 …   Wikipedia

  • Charles Haldat — Charles Nicolas Alexandre Haldat du Lys (1770–1852) was a French physicist who performed experimental work in hydrostatics.[1] He was a critic of the reliability of Benjamin Thompson s researches on the generation of heat, An Experimental Enquiry …   Wikipedia

  • Thompson, Sir Benjamin, Count Von Rumford — ▪ American British physicist born March 26, 1753, Woburn, Mass. [U.S.] died Aug. 21, 1814, Auteuil, France       American born British physicist, government administrator, and a founder of the Royal Institution of Great Britain, London. His… …   Universalium

  • Rumford , Benjamin Thompson, Count — (1753–1814) American–British physicist Benjamin Thompson was the son of a farmer from Woburn, Massachusetts. He started his career apprenticed to a merchant but was injured in a fireworks accident and moved to Boston. In 1772 he married a rich… …   Scientists


Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.