Pan-nationalism


Pan-nationalism

Pan-nationalism is a form of nationalism distinguished by the large scale of the claimed national territory, and because it often defines the nation on the basis of a ‘’cluster’’ of cultures and ethnic groups. It shares the general nationalist ideology, that the nation is a fundamental unit of human social life, that it is the only legitimate basis for the state. Some pan-nationalisms, such as pan-Germanism, were mono-ethnic, like standard nationalism. The prefix ‘pan-’ was used, because the ethnic Germans were dispersed over much of Central Europe. In other cases pan-nationalists speak of the ‘peoples’ (for instance ‘the Turkic peoples’), whereas classic nation-states have one ethnicity, culture and language.

Pan-nationalism implies that the ‘national group’ is dispersed over several existing states. It is not identical to irredentism - nationalist claims on adjoining territories on the grounds that they from part of the national homeland. Scale is a factor here, however. Greater Albania, even in the largest version, would still be a small country. An irredentist Greater Germany, even if it is limited to contiguous German-speaking regions, would have about 100 million inhabitants. Such a state would probably be called pan-German. Pan-nationalism is not the same as diaspora nationalism, such as Zionism, which implies the concentration of a dispersed group on an ancestral homeland. Colonies (other than settler colonies) fall outside most definitions of a nation, since both coloniser and colonised recognise that they share no ethnicity, culture, and language.

Nationalist movements in large nations, such as the German and Russian nations, are therefore difficult to distinguish from pan-nationalist movements, and often there are explicitly pan-nationalist elements. Aside from these cases, however, most pan-nationalist movements failed. Specifically pan-national states are rare. Yugoslavia attempted to unify a category of South Slavs, the prefix ‘’jugo’’ means south. After 1945, it did recognise separate internal nations, with their own governments. That probably accelerated its disintegration in the 1990s.

Other large states are difficult to classify as pan-national. Around 1942 Nazi Germany controlled a vast collection of annexed territories, German-administered civilian entities, puppet states, collaborationist states, and front-line areas run by the military. The conquests were partly inspired by the idea of Lebensraum, but that is not in itself a pan-nationalist concept. The Soviet Union had a Soviet identity, but no ‘Soviet’ ethnicity, culture, or language. It was influenced by pan-Russian ideas, but also by other geopolitical ideals which implied a large territory. China has a long tradition of cultural and administrative unity. (The fact that both China and India annexed territories, does not necessarily make the state pan-national in character).

The general failure of the pan-nationalist movements is illustrated by several examples, which had a clear idea of their ideal state, but never got anywhere near achieving it. Modern Turkey is the former core area of the Ottoman Empire. The present state is closely modelled on the classic European nation state, and was a deliberate break with that empire. Beside the very strong Turkish nationalism there are three pan-nationalisms. In ascending order of scale: pan-Turkism, a sometimes distinct pan-Turkic ideology referring to the Turkic peoples, and pan-Turanism, which covers most of central Asia and even Finland and Hungary. As in Turkey, pan-nationalist movements often operate on the margin of a more limited ‘standard-nationalist’ movement, in the existing core area of the claimed mega-state.

Pan-Slavism is another notable example of an influential ideal that never resulted in the corresponding mega-state - if Russian territory was included, it would extend from the Baltic to the Pacific (west to east) and right down to central asia and the caucasus in the south.

Pan-Americanism as an ideal was influential around the time of the independence movements in Latin America. However, the new nation-states soon diverged in policy and interests, and no federation emerged. The term acquired another meaning, namely U.S.-led co-operation among the separate nation-states, with a connotation of U.S. hegemony. That is why there is a pan-latin-americanism which proposes inter-americanism with the United States. An important exponent of this philosophy is Víctor Raúl Haya de la Torre, from Peru, while Bolivarianism represents a current variation on the theme.

Examples

;Ethnic, or Cultural
*Pan-Arabism
*Pan-Asianism
*Pan-Celticism
*Pan-Iranism
*Pan-Serbism
*Pan-Slavism
*Pan-Turkism
*Assyrianism
*Turanism
*Iberism

*Expansionism
**Großdeutschland
**Greater Albania
**Greater Israel
**Greater Netherlands
**Greater Romania
**Greater Serbia
**Greater Hungary
**Greater Ukraine

Religious
*Pan-Islamism

;Continental
*Pan-europeanism
**International Paneuropean Union
*Pan-Africanism
*Pan-Americanism
**Bolivarianism

ee also

*Ethnic nationalism
*Empire
*Colonialism
*Imperialism
*Diaspora
*Ummah
*Caliphate


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Hui pan-nationalism — refers to the post 1949 (the foundation of the People s Republic of China) phenomenon of a sense of common nationhood kindled among diverse communities of Chinese speaking Muslims (typically members of the Hui ethnic cultural group), due to the… …   Wikipedia

  • Pan-Turkism — is a political movement aiming to unite the various Turkic peoples into a modern political state, a confederation, or an economic union closely resembling that of the European Union.NameIn the research literature, the term Pan Turkism is used to… …   Wikipedia

  • Pan-Americanism — is a movement which, through diplomatic, political, economic and social means, seeks to create, encourage and organize relationships, associations and cooperation between the states of the Americas in common interests.HistoryThe struggle for… …   Wikipedia

  • Nationalism — Part of a series on Nationalism …   Wikipedia

  • Pan-European nationalism — This article is about those who claim that Europe is, or should be, a single nation. For the history and ideology of nationalism in Europe, see Nationalism. For the practice of viewing the world from a European perspective, see Eurocentrism. For… …   Wikipedia

  • Pan-Germanism — ( de. Pangermanismus or Alldeutsche Bewegung) was a political movement of the 19th century aiming for unity of the German speaking peoples of Europe. Origins Pan Germanism s origins began in the early 1800s following the Napoleonic Wars. The wars …   Wikipedia

  • Pan-Arabism — is a movement for unification among the peoples and countries of the Arab World, from the Atlantic Ocean to the Arabian Sea. It is closely connected to Arab nationalism which asserts that the Arabs constitute a single nation. Pan Arabism has… …   Wikipedia

  • Pan-Islamism — (اتّحاد الاسلام) is a political movement advocating the unity of Muslims under one Islamic state or a Caliphate. [Ottomanism, Pan Islamism,and the Caliphate; Discourse at the Turn of the 20th Century, American University in Cairo,The Middle East… …   Wikipedia

  • Pan-Iranism — is an ideology that advocates solidarity and reunification of Iranian peoples living in the Iranian continent and Iranian plateau ( Falāte Īrān ), including Ossetians, Kurds, Armenians, Persians (including the Tajiks and Qizilbash), Hazaras,… …   Wikipedia

  • Pan-Asianism — is an ideology that Asian countries and peoples share similar values and similar histories and should be united politically or culturally. OriginsPan Asianism in JapanPan Asian thought in Japan began to develop in the late nineteenth century and… …   Wikipedia


Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.