Earnings quality

Earnings quality

Earnings quality, in accounting, refers to the overall reasonableness of reported earnings. It is an assessment criterion for how "repeatable, controllable and bankable"McClure, Ben. (n.d.) "Earnings: Quality Means Everything". Retrieved June 29, 2008, from http://www.investopedia.com/articles/02/103002.asp] a firm's earnings are, amongst other factors. It recognizes the fact that the economic impact of a given transaction will vary across firms as a function of their fundamental business characteristics Financial Education. (n.d.) "What is Earnings Quality?". Retrieved June 29, 2008, from http://financial-education.com/2007/02/22/what-is-earnings-quality/] , and has variously been defined as the degree to which earnings reflect underlying economic effects, are better estimates of cash flows, are conservative, or are predictable.



The concept of earnings quality has roots in the judgmental nature of accounting, which can be seen in the fact the different parties may interpret the economics underlying a transaction differently, and different firms may have different business characteristics. Earnings quality is the inverse of earnings management; that is, more earnings management results in less earnings quality.

Interpretation of underlying economics

The interpretation of the economics underlying a transaction and even the wording of the accounting standards can vary between firms. This, along with the fact that a firm's financial statements are the responsibility of the firm's management, allows management to structure transactions to achieve desired accounting results Knechel, W Robert, Salterio, Steven E, Ballou, Brian (2007), "Auditing: Assurance & Risk, 3e". Canada, Thompson South-Western.] , by choosing an interpretation of the economics underlying ther transactions that may be different from another party's. This use of judgment by management thus increases the chances that the earnings presented in a firm's financial statements may have been manipulated.

Differing business characteristics

Furthermore, the fact that firms have different fundamental business characteristics increases the possibility of error in or manipulation of presented earniings. For example, companies that operate in different industries may use a given machine for entirely different purposes or wear out a given machine at dramatically different rates, which makes it appropriate to allow management to choose between alternative depreciation methods and useful lives to be applied to the use of the machine. This discretion, however, increases the possibility for firms to make both honest mistakes, such as the accidental use of a wrong useful life, or to manipulate earnings.

Earnings quality and ways to lower it

The above factors lead to investors needing to assess the extent to which a firm's reported earnings are free from mistake or manipulation, i.e. the quality of the firm's earnings.

Other ways accounting choices can lower a firm's earnings quality include
*Recording revenue too soon or of questionable quality,
*Recording fictitious revenue,
*Boosting income with one-time gains,
*Shifting current expense to a different period,
*Railing to record or improperly reducing liabilities,
*Shifting current revenue to a later period, and
*Shifting future expenses to the current period as a special charge

Assessing earnings quality

While the criteria for earnings to be considered high-quality differs between authors, sustainability of earnings may be the underlying concept.

Conservative accounting policies

Earnings quality has usually been associated with the use of conservative accounting policies. It has, however, been noted that conservatism in the current financial periods may allow aggressiveness in future financial periods. For example, choosing an "accelerated" depreciation method, or one that allocates a large amount of depreciation expense at the beginning of an asset's useful life, allows the firm to present abnormally high expenses for a given financial period and abnormally low expenses for future financial periods: conservatism, followed by aggressiveness. In other words, conservative decisions by management in a single period should not be used as sole proof of earnings quality.

Other factors

An assessment of earnings quality would therefore be based on other factors, such as
#A correlation between reported earnings and underlying economic activity,
#The permanence and sustainability of reported earnings,
#The relationship between reported earnings and market valuation,
#The extent and impact of discretionary accruals,
#The transparency and completeness of disclosures,
#The impact of low reported earnings on corporate image,
#The handling of “bad” news , and
#The degree to which earnings are good estimates of cash flows.

ustainability of earnings

It has even been claimedRevsine, Collins, Johnson. (2005) "Financial Reporting and Analysis, 3e". Pearson-Prentice Hall.] , simply, that earnings are considered to be of high quality when they are sustainable.

Methods of assessment as conflicting

It should also be noted that the different definitions of earning quality and hence the different methods of assessment sometimes lead to contradictions between methods. For example, using only the criteria of correlation between reported earnings and underlying economic activity, accelerated depreciation may give rise to higher-quality earnings than straight-line depreciation, while the converse is true if one uses only the criteria of predictability of earnings.

ee also

*Accounting ethics
*Creative accounting


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • earnings quality — UK US noun [U] (also quality of earnings) ACCOUNTING ► the degree to which a company s accounts accurately show income for that period, for example, by only including real sales made during that period, and not including income that may not be… …   Financial and business terms

  • Quality investing — is an investment strategy based on clearly defined fundamental factors that seeks to identify companies with outstanding quality characteristics. The quality assessment is made based on soft (e.g. management credibility) and hard criteria (e.g.… …   Wikipedia

  • Earnings — Net income for the company during the period. The New York Times Financial Glossary * * * earnings earn‧ings [ˈɜːnɪŋz ǁ ˈɜːr ] noun [plural] 1. FINANCE the money that a person receives for the work they do in a particular period of time: • He… …   Financial and business terms

  • earnings — net income for the company during a period. Bloomberg Financial Dictionary Often a general phrase, meaning profits . It does however have a very specific definition in the context of earnings per share. Here, it is defined as profit after tax,… …   Financial and business terms

  • Quality Of Earnings — The amount of earnings attributable to higher sales or lower costs rather than artificial profits created by accounting anomalies such as inflation of inventory. Quality of earnings is considered poor during times of high inflation. Also,… …   Investment dictionary

  • Earnings Per Share - EPS — The portion of a company s profit allocated to each outstanding share of common stock. Earnings per share serves as an indicator of a company s profitability. Calculated as: When calculating, it is more accurate to use a weighted average number… …   Investment dictionary

  • Quality-of-Life Index — The Economist Intelligence Unit’s quality of life index is based on a unique methodology that links the results of subjective life satisfaction surveys to the objective determinants of quality of life across countries. The index was calculated in …   Wikipedia

  • quality of earnings — The extent to which *net income reflects and portrays underlying economic circumstances. External auditors review the quality of earnings of *auditees, to obtain evidence that *financial statements have not been distorted by *creative accounting… …   Auditor's dictionary

  • quality of earnings — Increased earnings due to increased sales and cost controls, as compared to artificial profits created by inflation of inventory or other asset prices. Bloomberg Financial Dictionary …   Financial and business terms

  • quality of earnings — The degree to which the net profit of an organization reflects accurately its operating performance; it is particularly important to ensure that creative accounting has not taken place and that no events have occurred to distort the profit figure …   Accounting dictionary