Arles portrait bust


Arles portrait bust

In the Rhone River near Arles, southern France, divers from the French Department of Subaquatic Archaeological Research, headed by Michel L'Hour, discovered in September-October 2007 a life-sized marble bust showing an aging man with wrinkles, deep naso-labial creases and hollows in his face. [During the same campaign, divers also recovered smaller statues of Marsyas in Hellenistic style and a life-size marble sculpture of Neptune dating, from its style, to the third century CE. ] The uncompromising realism of the portrait places it in the tradition of late Republican portrait and genre sculptures. The immediate reaction was that this was a portrait of Julius Caesar and that it should be given a date range of about 46 BC/BCE.

After Caesar's assassination in 44 BCE, portraits of him would have been discreetly disposed of, as politically dangerous possessions. ["I suspect the bust was thrown in the river after he was assassinated because it would not have been good at that time to be considered a follower of his," said French archaeologist Luc Long, quoted by Agence France Presse at the time the discovery was revealed ( [http://www.cbc.ca/arts/artdesign/story/2008/05/14/bust-caesar.html Bust from riverbed reveals face of Julius Caesar: archeologist] ).]

France's Minister of Culture Christine Albanel reported on May 13, 2008, that the bust would be the oldest representation of Caesar known today. [ [http://www.culture.gouv.fr/culture/actualites/communiq/albanel/cesarles08.htm Original communique] (May 13, 2008); [http://www.culture.gouv.fr/culture/actualites/communiq/albanel/arles200508.htm second communique] (May 20, 2008); [http://www.culture.gouv.fr/culture/actualites/index-com.html report] (May 20, 2008)]

Reactions

The story was picked up by all larger media. [E.g. [http://www.cnn.com/2008/WORLD/europe/05/14/caesar.bust.ap/index.html, "Divers find marble bust of Caesar that may date to 46 B.C."] , CNN-Online "et al."; [http://programmes.france3.fr/des-racines-et-des-ailes/index-fr.php?page=emission&id_article=89 Video (QuickTime)] on the archaeological find (France 3)]

The identification as Caesar was immediately disputed, apparently on the basis of photographs, by Mary Beard in the "Times Literary Supplement". [ [http://timesonline.typepad.com/dons_life/2008/05/the-face-of-jul.html Mary Beard, "The face of Julius Caesar? Come off it!", "TLS" 14 May 2008, on-line] ] Other historians and archaeologists not affiliated with the French administration, among them the archaeologist and expert on Caesar and Augustus Paul Zanker, were also quick to deny that the portrait bust is of Caesar. [Paul Zanker, [http://www.sueddeutsche.de/,ra16m1/wissen/special/67/174544/index.html/wissen/artikel/74/176540/article.html "Der Echte war energischer, distanzierter, ironischer"] , "Sueddeutsche Zeitung", May 25, 2008, on-line; Nathan T. Elkins, [http://coinarchaeology.blogspot.com/2008/05/oldest-bust-of-julius-caesar-found-in.html 'Oldest Bust' of Julius Caesar found in France?] , May 14, 2008, on-line] Many noted the lack of resemblances to Caesar's likenesses issued on coins during the last years of the dictator's life, and to the "Tusculum bust" of Caesar, [ [http://www.aeria.phil.uni-erlangen.de/photo_html/portraet/roemisch/republik/benannt/caesar/caesar5.jpgthe "Tusculan bust"] : image at the "AERIA" library.] which depicts Julius Caesar in his lifetime, either as a so-called "zeitgesicht" or as a direct portrait. After a further stylistic assessment Zanker dated the Arles bust to the Augustan period. Elkins pointed out the third century CE as the outside "terminus post quem" for the deposition of the statues, thereby refuting the claim that the bust was thrown away due to feared repercussions from Caesar's assassination in 44 BCE. [A different approach was presented by Mary Beard in that members of a military Caesarian colony would not have discarded portraits of Caesar, whom they worshipped as god, although statues were in fact destroyed by the Anti-Caesarians in the city of Rome after Caesar's assassination (Appian, "BC" III.1.9).]

The argument by the French archaeologists that Caesar had founded the colony in 46 BCE shows to be incorrect, as the colony was founded by Caesar's former quaestor Tiberius Claudius Nero on the dictator's orders in his absence. [Konrat Ziegler and Walther Sontheimer (eds.), "Arelate", in "Der Kleine Pauly: Lexikon der Antike", Vol. 1, col. 525, Munich 1979; in 46 BCE Caesar himself was campaigning in Africa, before returning to Rome.]

Mary Beard has accused the persons involved in the find to have wilfully invented their claims for publicity reasons. The French ministry of culture has not yet responded to the criticism and negative reviews.

Notes


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Arles — This article is about the city in France. For the medieval kingdom, see Kingdom of Arles. For the village in Ireland, see Arless. For the village in England, see Arle, Gloucestershire. Arles …   Wikipedia

  • Julius Caesar — For other uses, see Julius Caesar (disambiguation). Gaius Julius Caesar Dictator of the Roman Republic …   Wikipedia

  • César, le Rhône pour mémoire — Buste de Jules César, sculpté de son vivant ( 46) César, le Rhône pour mémoire est une exposition qui s est déroulée au musée de l Arles antique, dit musée bleu, du 24 octobre 2009 au 2 janvier 2011. Son but a été …   Wikipédia en Français

  • History of the English penny (c. 600-1066) — After Rome: prelude to the Anglo Saxon coinageAt the end of the fourth century, the Roman provinces of Britain were still part of a vibrant and quite efficient economic and monetary system that stretched over the whole Roman world. Precious metal …   Wikipedia

  • Drawings, water-colours and prints by Vincent van Gogh — Drawings and water colours and prints by Vincent van Gogh is an incomplete list of works on paper and other works by the Dutch artist Vincent van Gogh (1853–1890) that form an important part of Vincent van Gogh s complete body of work. Contents 1 …   Wikipedia

  • Western sculpture — ▪ art Introduction       three dimensional artistic forms produced in what is now Europe and later in non European areas dominated by European culture (such as North America) from the Metal Ages (Europe, history of) to the present.       Like… …   Universalium

  • Constantine the Great — This article is about Constantine as an Emperor. For Constantine as a Saint, see Constantine I and Christianity. Constantine I redirects here. For other uses, see Constantine I (disambiguation). Constantine I 57th Emperor of the Roman Empire …   Wikipedia

  • Lost artworks — are original pieces of art that cannot be accounted for in museums, private collections, or known to have been destroyed or neglected through ignorance and lack of connoisseurship.For lost literary works, see Lost work.Works are listed… …   Wikipedia

  • Art, Antiques, and Collections — ▪ 2003 Introduction       In 2002 major exhibitions such as Documenta 11 reflected the diverse nature of contemporary art: artists from a variety of cultures received widespread recognition for work ranging from installation to video to painting …   Universalium

  • Ancient Rome — For the modern day city, see Rome. For Other uses, see Ancient Rome (disambiguation). The Roman Forum, the political, economic, cultural, and religious center of the city during the Republic and later Empire, now lies in ruins in modern day Rome …   Wikipedia


Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.