Gene-environment correlation

Genetic factors influence exposure to many features of the environment. This comes about because people actively shape their experiences according to their personality and behavior, which are heritable. A consequence is that the relationship between environmental exposure and disease may be confounded by genotype. This has implications for attempts to cut disease by reducing exposure to environmental risk.

Definition

The tendency for individuals to experience environments that are correlated with their genotype is known as gene-environment correlation (or genotype-environment correlation). Gene-environment correlations can arise by both causal and non-causal mechanisms. cite journal |author = Jaffee SR and Price TS |journal= Molecular Psychiatry |title= Gene-environment correlations: a review of the evidence and implications for prevention of mental illness. |year= 2007 |volume= 12 |issue= 5 |pages= 432–442 |pmid= 17453060 |doi= 10.1038/sj.mp.4001950 ] Of principal interest are the causal mechanisms, which indicate genetic control over environmental exposure. Genetic variants influence environmental exposure indirectly via behavior. Three causal mechanisms giving rise to gene-environment correlations have been described. [cite journal |author = Plomin R, DeFries JC, and Loehlin JC. |journal= Psychological Bulletin |volume= 84 |issue= 2 |pages= 309–322 |year= 1977 |title= Genotype-environment interaction and correlation in the analysis of human behavior |pmid = 557211 |doi= 10.1037/0033-2909.84.2.309]

: (i) Passive gene-environment correlation refers to the association between the genotype a child inherits from her parents and the environment in which the child is raised. Parents create a home environment that is influenced by their own heritable characteristics. Biological parents also pass on genetic material to their children. When the children's genotype also influences their behavioral or cognitive outcomes, the result can be a spurious relationship between environment and outcome. For example, because parents who have histories of antisocial behavior (which is moderately heritable) are at elevated risk of abusing their children, a case can be made for saying that maltreatment may be a marker for genetic risk that parents transmit to children rather than a causal risk factor for children’s conduct problems. [cite journal |author = DiLalla LF and Gottesman II. |journal= Psychological Bulletin |volume= 109 |issue= 1 |pages= 125–129 |year= 1991 |title= Biological and genetic contributions to violence: Widom’s untold tale |pmid = 2006224 |doi= 10.1037/0033-2909.109.1.125]

: (ii) Evocative (or reactive) gene-environment correlation happens when an individual's (heritable) behavior evokes an environmental response. For example, the association between marital conflict and depression may reflect the tensions that arise when engaging with a depressed spouse rather than a causal effect of marital conflict on risk for depression.

: (iii) Active gene-environment correlation occurs when an individual possesses a heritable propensity to select environmental exposure. For example, individuals who are characteristically extroverted may seek out very different social environments than those who are shy and withdrawn.

Gene-environment correlation can also arise from non-causal mechanisms, including evolutionary processes and behavioral 'contamination' of the environmental measure. Evolutionary processes, such as genetic drift and natural selection, can cause allele frequencies to differ between populations. For example, exposure to malaria-bearing mosquitoes over many generations may have caused the higher allele frequency among certain ethnic groups for the sickle hemoglobin (HbS) allele, a recessive mutation that causes sickle-cell disease but confers resistance against malaria. [cite journal |author = Aidoo M, Terlouw DJ, Kolczak MS, McElroy PD, ter Kuile FO, Kariuki S, Nahlen BL, Lal AA and Udhayakumar V |journal= Lancet |volume= 359 |issue= 9314 |pages= 1311–1312 |year= 2002 |title= Protective effects of the sickle cell gene against malaria morbidity and mortality |pmid = 11965279 |doi= 10.1016/S0140-6736(02)08273-9] In this way, HbS genotype has become associated with the malarial environment.

Evidence

Quantitative genetic studies

Twin and adoption studies have provided much of the evidence for gene-environment correlations by demonstrating that putative environmental measures are heritable. [cite journal |author = Kendler KS and Baker JH |journal= Psychological Medicine |volume= 37 |issue= 5 |pages= 615–626 |year= 2007 |title= Genetic influences on measures of the environment: a systematic review |pmid = 17176502 |doi= 10.1017/S0033291706009524] For example, studies of adult twins have shown that desirable and undesirable life events are moderately heritable as are specific life events and life circumstances, including divorce, the propensity to marry, marital quality and social support. Studies in which researchers have measured child-specific aspects of the environment have also shown that putative environmental factors, such as parental discipline or warmth, are moderately heritable. Television viewing, peer group orientations and social attitudes have all been shown to be moderately heritable. There is also a growing literature on the genetic factors influencing behaviors that constitute a risk to health, such as the consumption of alcohol, tobacco and illegal drugs, and risk-taking behaviors. Like parental discipline, these health related behaviors are genetically influenced, but are thought to have environmentally mediated effects on disease. To the extent that researchers have attempted to determine why genes and environments are correlated, most evidence has pointed to the intervening effects of personality and behavioral characteristics.

Environments are heritable because genotype influences the behaviours that evoke, select, and modify features of the environment. Thus, environments less amenable to behavioural modification tend to be less heritable. For example, negative life events that are beyond the control of the individual (e.g., the death of a loved one, losing one’s home in a natural disaster) have lower heritability than negative life events that may be dependent on an individual’s behaviour (e.g., getting a divorce, getting fired from a job). Similarly, personal life events (i.e., events that occur directly to an individual) are more highly heritable than network life events (i.e., events that occur to someone within an individual’s social network, thus affecting the individual indirectly).

Molecular genetic studies

Evidence for the existence of gene-environment correlations has recently started to accrue from molecular genetic investigations. The Collaborative Studies on Genetics of Alcoholism (COGA) group has reported that a single-nucleotide polymorphism in intron 7 of the gamma-aminobutyric acid A a2 receptor (rs279871; GABRA2) was associated with alcohol dependence and marital status. Individuals who had the high-risk GABRA2 variant (i.e., the variant associated with alcohol dependence) were less likely to be married, in part because they were at higher risk for antisocial personality disorder and were less likely to be motivated by a desire to please others. [cite journal |author = Dick DM, Agrawal A, Schuckit MA, Bierut L, Hinrichs A, Fox L, Mullaney J, Cloninger CR, Hesselbrock V, Nurnberger JI Jr, Almasy L, Foroud T, Porjesz B, Edenberg H and Begleiter H |journal= J Stud Alcohol |volume= 67 |issue= 2 |pages= 185–194 |year= 2006 |title= Marital status, alcohol dependence, and GABRA2: evidence for gene-environment correlation and interaction |pmid= 16562401] There is also molecular evidence for passive gene-environment correlation. A recent study found that children were almost 2.5 times more likely to be diagnosed with attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) if their mothers were divorced, separated, or never married. In this sample, however, mothers possessing the short allele of the dopamine receptor gene DRD2 were more likely to be divorced, separated, or never married. Moreover, their children were more likely to have ADHD. Therefore, part of the association between parental marital status and ADHD diagnosis among children in this sample is due to the confounding variable of maternal DRD2 genotype. [cite journal |author = Waldman ID |journal= Development and Psychopathology |volume= 19 |pages= 1117–1128 |year= 2007 |title= Gene–environment interactions reexamined: Does mother’s marital stability interact with the dopamine receptor D2 gene in the etiology of childhood attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder? |doi = 10.1017/S0954579407000570] Both of these studies also found evidence for gene-environment interaction.

Significance

Doctors want to know whether exposure to environmental risk causes disease. The fact that environmental exposures are heritable means that the relationship between environmental exposure and disease may be confounded by genotype. That is, the relationship may be spurious (not causal) because the same genetic factors influence both exposure to environmental risk and disease. If so then reducing environmental exposure will not reduce the risk for disease.

For example, a study of children born to twin sisters investigated whether the relationship between parental divorce and offspring alcohol and emotional problems was causal or confounded by parental genotype. [cite journal | author= D'Onofrio BM, Turkheimer E, Emery RE, Maes HH, Silberg J, Eaves LJ | title= A children of twins study of parental divorce and offspring psychopathology | journal= Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry | year= 2007 | volume= 48 | pages= 667-675 | doi = 10.1111/j.1469-7610.2007.01741.x] The study found that the offspring of twin sisters who were discordant for divorce had equally high levels of emotional problems, suggesting that genetic factors which made twin siblings divorce-prone also increased their children’s risk for depression and anxiety. This finding suggests that preventing the parents’ divorce would have had little impact on offspring risk for emotional problems (although the findings for alcohol problems were consistent with a causal role for divorce).

References

ee also

* Nature versus nurture
* Gene-environment interaction