Ramsey problem

Ramsey problem

The Ramsey problem or Ramsey-Boiteux pricing, is a policy rule concerning what price a monopolist should set, in order to maximize social welfare, subject to a constraint on profit. A closely related problem arises in relation to optimal taxation of commodities.
For any monopoly, the price markup should be inverse to the price elasticity of demand: the more elastic demand for the product, the smaller the price markup. This was stated by J. Robinson (1933) but it has been recognized later that Frank Ramsey has found the result before (1927) in another context (taxation). The rule was later applied by Marcel Boiteux (1956) to natural monopolies (decreasing mean cost): a natural monopoly experiences profit losses if it is forced to fix its output price at the marginal cost. Hence the Ramsey-Boiteux pricing consists into maximizing the total welfare under the condition of non-negative profit, that is, zero profit. In the Ramsey-Boiteux pricing, the markup of each commodity is also inversely proportional to the elasticities of demand but it is smaller as the inverse elasticity of demand is multiplied by a constant lower than 1.
It is applicable to public utilities or regulation of natural monopolies, such as telecom firms.

Practical issues exist with attempts to use Ramsey pricing for setting utility prices. It may be difficult to obtain data on different price elasticities for different customer groups. Also, some customers with relatively inelastic demands may acquire a strong incentive to seek alternatives if charged higher markups, thus undermining the approach. Politically speaking, customers with relatively inelastic demands may also be viewed as those for whom the service is more necessary or vital; charging them higher markups can be challenged as unfair.

Formal presentation and solution

Consider the problem of a regulator seeking to set prices left(p_{1},...p_{N} ight) for a multi-product monopolist with costs Cleft(z_{1},z_{2}....,z_{N} ight) =Cleft( mathbf{z} ight) where z_{n} isthe output of good "n" and p_{n} is the price. Suppose that theproducts are sold in separate markets (this is commonly the case) so demandsare independent, and demand for good "n" is z_{n}left( p_{n} ight) , with inverse demand function p_{n}left( z ight) . Total revenue is

Rleft( mathbf{p,z} ight) =sum_{n}p_{n}z_{n}left( p_{n} ight)

Total surplus is given by

Wleft( mathbf{p,z} ight) =sum_{n}left( intlimits_{0}^{z_{n}left(p_{n} ight) }p_{n}left( z ight) dz ight) -Cleft( mathbf{z} ight)

The problem is to maximize Wleft( mathbf{p,z} ight) subject to therequirement that profit Pi = R-C should be equal to some fixed value Pi^* . Typically, the fixed value is zero to guarantee that the profit losses are eliminated.

Rleft( mathbf{p,z} ight) -Cleft( mathbf{z} ight) =Pi ^*

This problem may be solved using the Langrange multiplier technique to yieldthe optimal output values, and backing out the optimal prices. The first order conditions on mathbf{z} are

p_{n}-C_{n}left( mathbf{z} ight) =lambda left( frac{partial R}{partial z_{n-C_{n}left( mathbf{z} ight) ight)

= lambda left( p_{n}left( 1+frac{z_{n{p_{nfrac{partial p_{n{partial z_{n ight)-C_{n}left( mathbf{z} ight) ight)

where lambda is a Lagrange multiplier and Cn(z) is the partial derivative of C(z) with respect to zn, evaluated at z.

Dividing by p_{n} and rearranging yields

frac{p_{n}-C_{n}left( mathbf{z} ight) }{p_{n=-frac{k}{varepsilon _{n

where k=frac{lambda }{1+lambda } is lower than 1 and varepsilon _{n}=frac{partialz_{n{partial p_{nfrac{p_{n{z_{n is the elasticity of demand forgood n. That is, the price markup over marginal cost for good n is againinversely proportional to the elasticity of demand but it is smaller. The monopoly is in a second-best equilibrium, between ordinary monopoly and perfect competition.

Ramsey Condition

An easier way to solve this problem in a two-output context is the Ramsey condition. According to Ramsey, as to minimise deadweight losses, one must increase prices to rigid and elastic demands in the same proportion, in relation to the prices that would be charged at the first-best solution (price equal to marginal cost).


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужен реферат?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Ramsey — may refer to:In places in the United Kingdom: * Ramsey, Cambridgeshire, a small market town in England * Ramsey Abbey, historic ecclesiastical centre near Ramsey, Cambridgeshire * Ramsey Island, off the coast of the St David s peninsula in… …   Wikipedia

  • Ramsey-Preise — (nach Frank Plumpton Ramsey) zielt die zweitbeste (second best) Lösung bei der Regulierung eines natürlichen Monopols an. Natürliche Monopole entstehen in erster Linie dann, wenn hohe Fixkosten, aber vergleichsweise geringe variable Kosten für… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Ramsey-Preis — Ramsey Preise (nach Frank Plumpton Ramsey) zielen die zweitbeste (second best) Lösung bei der Regulierung eines natürlichen Monopols an. Natürliche Monopole entstehen in erster Linie dann, wenn hohe Fixkosten, aber vergleichsweise geringe… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Ramsey's theorem — This article goes into technical details quite quickly. For a slightly gentler introduction see Ramsey theory. In combinatorics, Ramsey s theorem states that in any colouring of the edges of a sufficiently large complete graph (that is, a simple… …   Wikipedia

  • Ramsey growth model — The Ramsey growth model is a neo classical model of economic growth based primarily on the work of the economist and mathematician Frank Ramsey. The Solow growth model is similar to the Ramsey growth model, however without incorporating an… …   Wikipedia

  • Problem of induction — The problem of induction is the philosophical question of whether inductive reasoning is valid. That is, what is the justification for either:# generalizing about the properties of a class of objects based on some number of observations of… …   Wikipedia

  • Frank P. Ramsey — Infobox Philosopher region = United Kingdom era = 20th century color = #B0C4DE image size = 200px image caption = name = Frank P. Ramsey birth = 22 February 1903 death = 19 January 1930 school tradition = Analytic philosophy main interests =… …   Wikipedia

  • Frank P. Ramsey — Frank Plumpton Ramsey (* 22. Februar 1903 in Cambridge; † 19. Januar 1930) war ein britischer Mathematiker und Logiker. Inhaltsverzeichnis 1 Leben und Wirken 2 Werke (Auswahl) 3 Literatur …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Frank Plumpton Ramsey — (* 22. Februar 1903 in Cambridge; † 19. Januar 1930) war ein britischer Mathematiker und Logiker. Inhaltsverzeichnis 1 Leben und Wirken 2 Werke (Auswahl) 3 Literatur …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Teoría de Ramsey — Según la teoría de Ramsey, del total de estrellas del cielo nocturno, siempre podemos seleccionar un subconjunto de ellas para dibujar diferentes objetos como: un triángulo, un cuadrilátero, un paraguas o un pulpo. La teoría de Ramsey, llamada… …   Wikipedia Español

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”