Rules of Go


Rules of Go

This is an in-depth discussion of the rules of go.

There has been a certain amount of variation in the rules of go over time, and from place to place. This article discusses those sets of rules broadly similar to the ones currently in use in East Asia. (Traditional Himalayan variants, including Tibetan go, differ more markedly and are discussed instead in the article Go variants.) Even among these, there is a degree of variation.

Notably, Chinese and Japanese rules differ in a number of respects. The most significant of these is the scoring method, together with attendant differences in the manner of ending the game. [ [http://homepages.cwi.nl/~tromp/go.html Commentary] on the Tromp-Taylor rules by Bill Taylor]

While differences between sets of rules may have moderate strategic consequences on occasion, they do not change the character of the game. The different sets of rules usually lead to the same game result, [ [http://www.britgo.org/intro/intro2 How to play Go] , British Go Association] so long as the players make minor adjustments near the end of the game.

This article first presents a simple set of rules which are, except for wording, identical to those usually referred to as the Tromp-Taylor Rules, [ [http://www.britgo.org/rules/compare Comparison of Some Go Rules] , British Go Association] themselves close in most essential respects to the Chinese rules. These rules are then discussed at length, in a way that does not assume prior knowledge of go on the part of the reader. The discussion is for the most part applicable to all sets of rules, with exceptions noted. Later sections of the article address major areas of variation in the rules of go, and individual sets of rules.

Basic rules

A set of rules suitable for beginners is presented here. In some respects, these differ from the rules most commonly used. However, the basic rules are simply stated, and provide a convenient basis on which to discuss differences in rule sets. The rules are studied more fully in #Explanation of the basic rules below.

Two statements of the same basic rules, differing only in wording, are given here. The first is a concise one due to James Davies. The second is a formulation of the basic rules used for expository purposes in this article.

Except for terminology, the basic rules are identical to the [http://homepages.cwi.nl/~tromp/go.html Logical Rules] first proposed in their current form in September 1996 by John Tromp and Bill Taylor. [ [http://home.snafu.de/jasiek/superko.html Super Ko] , Robert Jasiek] [ [http://home.snafu.de/jasiek/intro.html Commentary on Tromp-Taylor Rules] , Robert Jasiek] They are also quite close to the [http://home.snafu.de/jasiek/siming.html Simplified Ing Rules] of the European Go Federation, the only exception being the method of ending the game.

Concise statement

These rules appear in "The Rules and Elements of Go" by James Davies. [ [http://home.snafu.de/jasiek/element.html Elementary Rules] of James Davies] They assume familiarity with the equipment used to play go, for which one may refer to #Elements of the game below.

"Notes:" The words "move" and "territory" are used differently here than elsewhere in this article; "play" and "area", respectively, are used instead. A clarification to Rule 5 is added in parentheses.

# The board is empty at the outset of the game.
# Black makes the first move, after which he and White alternate.
# A move consists of placing one stone of one's own color on an empty intersection on the board.
# A player may pass his turn at any time.
# A stone or solidly connected group of stones of one color is captured and removed from the board when all the intersections directly adjacent to it are occupied by the enemy. (Capture of the enemy takes precedence over self-capture.)
# No stone may be played so as to recreate a former board position.
# Two consecutive passes end the game.
# A player's territory consists of all the points he has either occupied or surrounded.
# The player with more territory wins.

These rules rely on common sense to make notions such as "connected group" and "surround" precise. What is here called a "solidly connected group of stones" is also called a "chain".

Reference statement

The basic rules are here formulated in a more detailed way in order to ease their presentation in the section Explanation of the basic rules below.

An optional rule prohibiting suicide is included as Rule 7A.

* Rule 1. [ [http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~wjh/go/rules/AGA.html Official AGA Rules of Go] , Rule 1: "The two sides [are] known as "Black" and "White" [...] "] Go is a game between two players, called Black and White.
* Rule 2. [ [http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~wjh/go/rules/AGA.html Official AGA Rules of Go] , Rule 1: "Go is a game of strategy between two sides usually played on a 19x19 grid (the "board")."] Go is played on a "board". A board is a plane grid of 19 horizontal and 19 vertical lines.:* Definition. [ [http://homepages.ihug.co.nz/~barryp/rules.htm New Zealand Go Society Rules of Go] : "Adjacent" intersections are those intersections connected by lines of the grid, with no intervening intersections."] A point on the grid where a horizontal line meets a vertical line is called an "intersection". Two intersections are said to be "adjacent" if they are distinct and connected by a horizontal or vertical line with no other intersections between them.
* Rule 3. [ [http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~wjh/go/rules/AGA.html Official AGA Rules of Go] , Rule 1: "The two sides, known as "Black" and "White", are each provided with an adequate supply of playing tokens, known as "stones", of the appropriate color."] Go is played with playing tokens known as "stones". Black has at his disposal an adequate supply of black stones, and White an adequate supply of white stones.
* Rule 4. [ [http://homepages.cwi.nl/~tromp/go.html Tromp-Taylor rules of go] : "Each point on the grid may be colored black, white or empty."] At any time in the game, each intersection on the board is in one and only one of the following three states: 1) empty; 2) occupied by a black stone; or 3) occupied by a white stone. :* Definition. [ [http://home.snafu.de/jasiek/siming.html Simplified Ing Rules] of the EGF: "The position is the distribution of black, white, and no stones on all the unique intersections of the grid. For a play, this is given after all its removals."] A "position" consists of an indication, for each intersection, of whether it is empty, occupied by a black stone, or occupied by a white stone.:* Definition. [ [http://home.snafu.de/jasiek/siming.html Simplified Ing Rules] of the EGF: "Stones of the same colour are connected if they are adjacent or if there is a chain of adjacent stones of their colour between them. Likewise, empty intersections are connected if they are adjacent or if there is a chain of adjacent empty intersections between them."] In a given position, two distinct stones of the same color are said to be "connected" if it is possible to pass from one to the other by a succession of stones of that color, each one other than the first being adjacent to the one before it. Similarly, empty intersections are "connected" if it is possible to pass from one to the other by a succession of adjacent empty intersections.:* Definition. [ [http://homepages.ihug.co.nz/~barryp/rules.htm New Zealand Go Society Rules of Go] : "A "liberty" of a stone is an unoccupied intersection adjacent to that stone or to any stone connected to that stone."] In a given position, a "liberty" of a stone is an empty intersection adjacent to that stone or to at least one stone to which that stone is connected.
* Rule 5. [ [http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~wjh/go/rules/AGA.html Official AGA Rules of Go] , Rule 1: "The board is initially vacant [...] "] At the beginning of the game, the board is empty.
* Rule 6. [ [http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~wjh/go/rules/AGA.html Official AGA Rules of Go] , Rule 2: "The players alternate in moving, with Black playing first."] Black moves first. The players alternate thereafter.
* Rule 7. [ [http://homepages.ihug.co.nz/~barryp/rules.htm New Zealand Go Society Rules of Go] : "A "play" consists of placing a stone (of that player's own colour) on an unoccupied intersection, then removing any of the opponent's stones that then have no liberties (if any), and then removing any of that player's own stones that then have no liberties (if any). A "move" consists of 1. making a play [...] or 2. saying 'pass'."] On his turn, a player may either "pass" (by announcing "pass" and performing no action) or "play". A play consists of the following steps, performed by the player in the prescribed order::* Step 1. Placing a stone of his color on an empty intersection (chosen subject to Rule 8 and, if it is in effect, to Optional Rule 7A).:* Step 2. Removing from the board any stones of his opponent's color that have no liberties. (this is referred to as "capture").:* Step 3. Removing from the board any stones of his own color that have no liberties. (this is referred to as "self-capture" or "suicide").
* "Optional Rule 7A." [ [http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~wjh/go/rules/AGA.html Official AGA Rules of Go] , Rule 5: "It is "illegal" for a player to move so as to create a string of his or her own stones which is completely surrounded (without liberties) after any surrounded opposing stones are captured."] "A play is illegal if one or more stones would be removed in Step 3 of that play. (Prohibiting suicide)"
* Rule 8. [ [http://home.snafu.de/jasiek/siming.html Simplified Ing Rules] of the EGF: "A play may not recreate a previous position from the game."] A play is illegal if it would have the effect, after application of Steps 1, 2 and 3 of that play, of creating a position that has occurred previously in the game.
* Rule 9. [ [http://home.snafu.de/jasiek/element.html Elementary Rules] of James Davies: "Two consecutive passes end the game."] The game ends when both players have passed consecutively. The "final position" is the position on the board at the time the players pass consecutively.:* Definition. [ [http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~wjh/go/rules/AGA.html Official AGA Rules of Go] , Rule 12: "Territory: Those empty points on the board which are entirely surrounded by live stones of a single color are considered the "territory" of the player of that color."] [Though the Simplified Ing Rules use the word "territory" differently, they describe what is here defined to be a player's territory as consisting of "the empty regions that are adjacent only to intersections with stones of his colour." The Commentary to the rules further specifies: "During scoring an empty region does not provide any points if a) it is adjacent to at least one black intersection and adjacent to at least one white intersection or b) the whole board is empty."] In the final position, an empty intersection is said to belong to a player's "territory" if 1) all stones adjacent to it or an empty intersection connected to it are of his color; and 2) there is at least one such stone.:* Definition. [ [http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~wjh/go/rules/AGA.html Official AGA Rules of Go] , Rule 12: "Area: All live stones of a player's color left on the board together with any points of territory surrounded by a player constitute that player's "area"."] In the final position, an intersection is said to belong to a player's "area" if either: 1) it belongs to that player's territory; or 2) it is occupied by a stone of that player's color.:* Definition. [ [http://home.snafu.de/jasiek/siming.html Simplified Ing Rules] of the EGF: "The "score" of each player is the number of all intersections a) with stones of his colour, and b) of the empty regions that are adjacent only to intersections with stones of his colour."] A player's "score" is the number of intersections in his area in the final position.
* Rule 10. [ [http://home.snafu.de/jasiek/siming.html Simplified Ing Rules] of the EGF: "For the final position, either the scores are unequal and the winner is the player with the greater score or the scores are equal and the game is a tie."] If one player has a higher score than the other, then that player wins. Otherwise, the game is drawn.

Comparative features of the basic rules

The essential features of these basic rules relative to other rule sets are summarized here. Each of the differences is discussed in greater detail in a later section of the article.

What variation exists among rule sets concerns primarily Rules 7A, 8, 9 and 10.

* The basic rules use "area scoring", as in China and Taiwan, and as in the official rules of many Western countries. The main alternative is "territory scoring". Though territory scoring is the system used in Japan and Korea, and is customarily used in the West, it is not possible to use territory scoring unless Rule 9 is replaced by a much more complex end-of-game rule. The goal of these basic rules is to present a simple system first. See the section "Scoring systems" below.

* The basic rules require the players to "play the game out" entirely. Virtually all rule sets used in practice provide some mechanism that allows players to begin scoring the game before the final position (the one used to score the game) has been reached. In some cases, this is merely a convenience intended to save time. In others, it may be an essential feature of the game. In any case, explaining these rules might obscure the nature of the game somewhat for a person unfamiliar with it. See the section "Counting phase" below.

* The basic rules allow "suicide" (or "self-capture"). This is unusual outside of Taiwan and New Zealand. Inclusion of Optional Rule 7A is in line with practice elsewhere. See the section "Suicide" below.

* The basic rules apply the rule of "positional superko". This, or a similar rule, is common in official Western rule sets, but not in East Asia. See the section "Repetition" below.

* The basic rules do not contain any special exceptions for territory in a "seki". This agrees with most practice outside Japan and Korea. See the section "Seki" below.

* The basic rules do not have a "komi". This is now unusual in even-strength games, but was common practice until the mid-twentieth century. A "komi" is a number of points, usually five to eight, awarded to White in compensation for moving second. See the section "Komi" below.

* The basic rules make no provision for the use of "handicap stones". See the section "Handicaps" below.

* The basic rules do not specify a "counting system". A counting system is a conventional method for calculating the difference in score between the players (hence determining the winner). It may incorporate various devices, such as filling in one's territory after the game, or shifting stones on the board into patterns, which allow quicker calculation of the difference in scores.

Explanation of the basic rules

The object of the game of go is, in rough terms, to control more territory at the end of the game than one's opponent does.

Elements of the game

Players

Rule 1. Go is a game between two players, called Black and White.

The choice of black or white is traditionally done by chance between players of even strength. The method of selection is called "nigiri". One player, let's call him/her Player A, takes a handful of stones; Player B then places either one or two stones on the board, indicating "even" or "odd." Player A counts the number stones in his/her hand to determine whether there is an odd or even number. If the number stones matches the other player's selection of "even" or "odd," Player A will play the black stones; if not, he/she will take the white stones.

When players are of different strengths, the weaker player takes black. Black may also pre-place several handicap stones before play begins, to compensate for the difference in strength (see below).

Board

Rule 2. Go is played on a "board". A board is a plane grid of 19 horizontal and 19 vertical lines.

Definition: A point on the grid where a horizontal line meets a vertical line is called an "intersection". Two intersections are said to be "adjacent" if they are are distinct and connected by a horizontal or vertical line with no other intersections between them.

The condition that the intersections be "distinct" is included to ensure that an intersection is not considered to be adjacent to itself.

Intersections are also called "points".

There are 361 points on a regular 19 × 19 board.

For simplicity, we will illustrate the rules mostly using 5 × 5 boards.

Each of the following diagrams shows two points on a 5 × 5 board:

Numbers are often used, as here, to indicate new moves in printed diagrams.

Once a stone has been played, it remains on the board, in the same location, until the end of the game or until it is captured (removed from the board as part of Step 2 or Step 3 of a play).

Capture

Step 2 of a play. (After playing his stone) a player removes from the board any stones of his opponent's color that have no liberties.

We say that the stones removed from the board have been "captured" by the player moving.

We now give some examples in which the capture rule is applied.

The diagrams below show the capture of a white stone by Black. To begin with, the white stone has a single liberty at "a". By playing a stone at "a", Black removes the last remaining liberty of the white stone. It is subsequently removed from the board.

Black captures the marked white chain at the edge of the board by playing at "a". Then White captures the black stone in the corner by playing at "b".

The previous example shows that it is important that Step 2 of a play (capture) precedes Step 3 (self-capture). If the order were reversed, then self-capture would occur here.

It is not difficult to convince oneself that if a play results in the capture of opposing stones, self-capture does not occur.

We now present some examples of plays in which self-capture occurs. These moves would be illegal under the optional rule prohibiting suicide.

In this example, if Black plays at "a", then the stone played by him is removed immediately. This move has the same effect on the position as a pass, though it would not allow White to end the game by passing next (Rule 9). The move is in any event illegal by Rule 8. (This is the positional superko rule. This move might be legal under other versions of the superko rule. See "Repetition" below.)

Another example of ko follows. Here, Black 3 is illegal by the ko rule.

The next example is typical of real games. It shows how the ko rule can sometimes be circumvented by first playing elsewhere on the board.

The first diagram below shows the position after Black 1. White can capture the marked black stone by playing at "a". The second diagram shows the resulting position. Black cannot immediately recapture at "b" because of the ko rule. So he instead plays 3 in the third diagram. For reasons that will become clear, Black 3 is called a "ko threat."

End

Rule 9. The game ends when both players have passed consecutively. The "final position" (the position later used to score the game) is the position on the board at the time the players pass consecutively.

Since the position on the board at the time of the first two consecutive passes is the one used to score the game, Rule 9 can be said to require the players to "play the game out."

Rule 9 differs significantly from the various systems for ending the game used in practice, which are discussed in the section "Counting phase" below. These generally allow the game to end as soon as it is obvious to the players which stones would remain on the board if the game continued. The precise means of achieving this varies widely by rule set, and in some cases has strategic implications. These systems often use passing in a way that is incompatible with Rule 9.

Under Chinese rules, and more generally under any using the area scoring system of these basic rules, a player who played the game out as if Rule 9 were in effect would not be committing any strategic errors by doing so. He would, however, likely be viewed as unsportsmanlike for prolonging the game unnecessarily. On the other hand, under a territory scoring system like that of the Japanese rules, playing the game out in this way would in many cases be a strategic mistake.

Territory

Definition. In the final position, an empty intersection is said to belong to a player's "territory" if 1) all stones adjacent to it or an empty intersection connected to it are of his color; and 2) there is at least one such stone.

"Note:" Unless the entire board is empty, the second condition - that there be at least one stone of the kind required - is always satisfied and can be ignored.

A point can never belong to both players' territories.

On the other hand, it may well happen that an empty intersection belongs to neither player's territory. In that case the point is said to be "neutral territory". There are rarely any more than a handful of neutral points at the end of a game; in the majority of cases, there are none at all.

Japanese and Korean rules count some points as neutral where the basic rules, like Chinese rules, would not. For more on this, see the section "Seki".

In order to understand the definition of territory, it is instructive to apply it first to a position of a kind that might arise before the end of a game. Let us assume that a game has ended in the position below [Example game taken from the go rules of the First World Mind Sports Games. [http://www.intergofed.org/wmsg/members_documents/2008_July_16/WMSG-GoRule-Appendix1_Revised.pdf] ] (even though it would not normally occur as a final position between skilled players).Goban 9x9|= a b c d e f g h i 1| | |b|I|b|E| |D|C|= 2| |b|H|b|w| | |w| |= 3| |b|b|w|w| | | |w|= 4| | |b|b|w| |w|w|b|= 5| | |b|w| | |w|b|b|= 6| |X|X|B|w|w|b|J|b|= 7| |X|b| |w|b|b|b|b|= 8| |X|b|w|w|w|b|F|w|= 9| |X|A|b|G|w|b|w|K|= a b c d e f g h i|=
24|u=u|d=d|l=l|r=r

The point "a" is adjacent to a black stone. Therefore "a" does not belong to White's territory. However, "a" is connected to "b" (by the path shown in the diagram, among others), which is adjacent to a white stone. Therefore "a" does not belong to Black's territory either. In conclusion, "a" is neutral territory.

The point "c" is connected to "d", which is adjacent to a white stone. But "c" is also connected to "e", which is adjacent to a black stone. Therefore "c" is neutral territory.

Similarly, the points "f" and "g" are neutral territory.

On the other hand, "h" is adjacent only to black stones and is not connected to any other points. Therefore, "h" is black territory. For the same reason, "i" and "j" are black territory, and "k" is white territory.

In the previous position, White might play 1 in the next diagram. If the game ended in this position, the marked intersections would become White's territory, since they would no longer be connected to an empty intersection adjacent to a black stone. Goban 9x9|= a b c d e f g h i 1| | |b| |b|w1|X|X|X|= 2| |b| |b|w| X|X|w|X|= 3| |b|b|w|w| X|X|X|w|= 4| | |b|b|w| X|w|w|b|= 5| | |b|w|X| X|w|b|b|= 6| | | | |w| w|b| |b|= 7| | |b| |w| b|b|b|b|= 8| | |b|w|w| w|b| |w|= 9| | | |b| | w|b|w| |= a b c d e f g h i|=
24|u=u|d=d|l=l|r=r

The game might end with the moves shown below. In the final position, the points marked "a" are black territory and the points marked "b" are white territory. The point marked "c" is the only neutral territory left.Goban 9x9|= a b c d e f g h i 1|A| A| b|b1| b|w|B|B|B|= 2|A| b| A| b| w|B|B|w|B|= 3|A| b| b| w| w|B|B|B|w|= 4|A| A| b| b| w|B|w|w|b|= 5|A| A| b| w| B|B|w|b|b|= 6|A|b3|w2|w4| w|w|b|A|b|= 7|A| A| b|w6| w|b|b|b|b|= 8|A| A| b| w| w|w|b|C|w|= 9|A| A|b5| b|b7|w|b|w|B|= a b c d e f g h i|=
24|u=u|d=d|l=l|r=r

The point in the lower right corner and the point marked "a" on the right side of the board would fall under the "seki" exception of Japanese and Korean rules, in which they would be considered neutral territory. (See the section "Seki" below.)

Area

Definition. In the final position, an intersection is said to belong to a player's "area" if either: 1) it belongs to that player's territory; or 2) it is occupied by a stone of that player's color.

Consider once again the final position shown in the last diagram of the section "Territory." The following diagram illustrates the area of each player in that position. Points in a player's area are occupied by a stone of the corresponding color. The lone neutral point does not belong to either player's area. Goban 9x9|= a b c d e f g h i 1|b|b|b|b|b|w|w|w|w|= 2|b|b|b|b|w|w|w|w|w|= 3|b|b|b|w|w|w|w|w|w|= 4|b|b|b|b|w|w|w|w|b|= 5|b|b|b|w|w|w|w|b|b|= 6|b|b|w|w|w|w|b|b|b|= 7|b|b|b|w|w|b|b|b|b|= 8|b|b|b|w|w|w|b| |w|= 9|b|b|b|b|b|w|b|w|w|= a b c d e f g h i|=
24|u=u|d=d|l=l|r=r

Score

Definition. A player's "score" is the number of intersections in his area in the final position.

For example, if a game ended as in the last diagram in the section "Territory," the score would be: Black 44, White 36. The players' scores add to 80. The difference between this and the 81 intersections on a 9 × 9 board is accounted for by the one point of neutral territory. The scoring system described here is known as "area scoring", and is the one used in the Chinese rules. Different scoring systems exist. These determine the same winner in most instances. See the "Scoring systems" section below.

Winner

Rule 10. If one player has a higher score than the other, then that player wins. Otherwise, the game is drawn.

In the previous example, Black wins by eight points.

Margin of victory does not matter; winning by one point is as good as winning by 100 points.

Scoring systems

The most prominent difference between rulesets is the scoring method. There are two main scoring systems: territory scoring (the traditional Japanese method) and stone or area scoring (the Chinese method). Care should be taken to distinguish between "scoring" systems and "counting" methods. Only two scoring systems are in wide use, but there are two ways of counting using "area" scoring.

Territory scoring

In territory scoring (including Japanese and Korean rules) a player's score is determined by the number of empty locations that player has surrounded minus the number of stones their opponent has captured.

Furthermore, Japanese and Korean rules have special provisions in cases of "seki", though this is not a necessary part of a territory scoring system. (See "Seki" below.)

Typically, counting is done by having each player place the prisoners they have taken into the opponent's territory and rearranging the remaining territory into easy-to-count shapes.

Stone or area scoring

In stone or area scoring (including Chinese rules), a player's score is determined by the number of stones that player has on the board plus the empty area surrounded by that player's stones.

There are several common ways in which to count the score (all these ways will always result in the same winner):

* The oldest counting method is as follows: At the end of the game, all white stones are removed from the board, and the players use black stones to fill the entirety of the black territory. Score is determined by counting the black stones. Since the board contains 361 intersections, black must have 181 or more stones to win. This method is still widely used in mainland of China.
* Around 1975, Taiwanese player and industrialist Ing Chang-ki invented a method of counting now known as Ing counting. Each player begins the game with exactly 180 stones (Mr. Ing also invented special stone containers that count each player's stones). At the end, all stones are placed on the board. One vacant intersection will remain, appearing in the winner's area; the number of stones of one color in the other color's area will indicate the margin of victory.

Attempts at reconciling the two scoring systems

If the game ends with both players having passed the same number of times, then the score will be identical no matter which method is used. [http://www.usgo.org/resources/downloads/completerules.pdf AGA rules] call for a player to give the opponent a stone when passing. This "passing stone" ensures a correct result under any counting method.

Counting phase

Customarily, when players agree that there are no useful moves left (most often by passing in succession), they attempt to agree which groups are alive and which are dead. If disagreement arises, then under Chinese rules the players simply play on.

However, under Japanese rules, the game is already considered to have ended. The players attempt to ascertain which groups of stones would remain if both players played perfectly from that point on. (These groups are said to be "alive".) In addition, this play is done under rules in which kos are treated differently from ordinary play. If the players reach an incorrect conclusion, then they both lose.

Unlike most other rule sets, the Japanese rules contain lengthy definitions of when groups are considered alive and when they are dead. In fact, these definitions do not cover every situation that may arise. Some difficult cases not entirely determined by the rules and existing precedent must be adjudicated by a go tribunal.

The need for the Japanese rules to address the definition of life and death follows from the fact that in the Japanese rules, scores are calculated by territory rather than by area. The rules cannot simply require a player to play on in order to prove that an opponent's group is dead, since playing in his own territory to do this would reduce his score. Therefore, the game is divided into a phase of ordinary play, and a phase of determination of life and death (which according to the Japanese rules is not technically part of the game).

Optional rules

Compensation

To allow players of different skills to compete fairly, handicaps and "komi" are used. These are considered a part of the game and, unlike in many other games, they do not distort the nature of the game. Players at all levels employ handicaps to make the game more balanced.

Komi

In an "even", or non-handicap game, Black's initial advantage of moving first can be offset by "komi" (compensation points): a fixed number of points, agreed before the game, added to White's score at the end of the game. The correct value of komi (to properly compensate for Black's advantage) is controversial, but common values are 5.5, 6.5 or 7.5 -- the fractional value avoids a tied game. In a handicap game, komi is usually set to 0.5 (i.e. White wins if the game is tied). A handicap game with a handicap of 1 starts like an even game, but White receives only 0.5 komi (i.e. a White player who is stronger by one rank is handicapped only by Black's first-move advantage).

There was no komi system before the 20th century. When the great Shusaku was once asked how an important game came out, he said simply, "I had Black," implying that victory was inevitable. As more people become aware of the significance of Black having the first move, komi was introduced. The amount of komi has been increased periodically based on analysis of game results indicated >50% wins for Black; each time, after a period of adjustment Black has again begun winning >50% of games. When it was introduced in Japanese Professional games, it was 4.5 points. However, Black still had better chance to win, so komi was increased to 5.5 points in 1974. In 2002, the Japanese Go Association again increased the komi value to 6.5.

Handicap

Handicaps are given by allowing the weaker player to take Black, and declaring White's first few moves as mandatory "pass" moves. In practice, this means that Black's first move is to place a set number of stones (usually the number is equal to the difference in the players' ranks) on the board before allowing White to play. Traditionally, the hoshi ("star points") -- strategically-important intersections marked with small dots -- are used to place these handicap stones. On the 19 × 19 board, there are nine star points: at the four 4-4 points in the corners, at the four 4-10 points along the sides, and one at the 10-10 point (the centre of the board, or "tengen" in Japanese). Smaller boards such as the 13 × 13 and 9 × 9 also have star points. The 13 × 13 has 9 at the 4-4 points, 4-7 points, and the center. The 9 × 9 board has only 5 points: the 3-3 points and the center.

When Black is only one rank weaker (also known as one "stone" weaker, due to the close relationship between ranks and the handicap system) he or she is given the advantage of playing Black, perhaps without komi, but without any mandatory White passes. For rank differences from two through nine stones, the appropriate number of handicap stones is used. Beyond nine stones, the difference in strength between the players is usually considered great enough that the game is more a lesson, with White teaching Black, so nine stones is the nominal upper limit on handicap stones regardless of the difference in rank (though higher numbers of stones, up to 41 stones in some cases, can be given if the teacher wants more of a challenge).

Thinking times

See the Time control section of the main Go article.

Variations

Go was already an ancient game before its rules were codified, and therefore, although the basic rules and strategy are universal, there are regional variations in some aspects of the rules.

Seki

To define this notion, we must begin with two definitions:

"Terminology:"
* An "eye' is a connected group of one (or more) empty intersections entirely surrounded by a chain or chains of stones of one color.

* A chain of one color is "independently alive" if it is (or can be made to be) adjacent to two eyes.

These definitions are given only loosely, since a number of complications arise when attempts are made to formalize the notion of life and death.

A group of stones of one color is said to be "alive by seki" (or "in seki") if it is not independently alive, yet cannot be captured by the opponent.

Go board 5x5|=
w| w| b| b| b|=
w| w| b| b| b|=
w| | w| b| r|=
w| w| w| b| b|=
w| w|dc| b| b|24

For example, in the diagram above, the black and white groups each have only one eye. Hence they are not independently alive. However, if either Black or White were to play at the circled point, the other side would then capture their group by playing in its eye. In this case both the black and white groups are alive by seki.

In the diagram above, the circled point is not surrounded by stones of a single color, and accordingly is not counted as territory for either side (irrespective of rule set). In more complex cases, as here, [Diagram taken from Robert Jasiek [http://home.snafu.de/jasiek/diffasts.html] ] Go board 5x5|=
w| u| b|uc| b|=
l| w| b| b| b|=
b| b| w| w| w|=
lc| b| w| | w|=
b| b| w| w|dr|24
a vacant point may be surrounded by a group of a single color which is in seki. According to Japanese and Korean rules, such a point is nonetheless treated as neutral territory for scoring purposes. Generally, the Japanese and Korean rules only count a vacant point as territory for one color if it is surrounded by a group or groups of that color that are independently alive.

Repetition

The major division in rules to prevent repetition is between the simple ko rule and the super ko rule: the simple ko rule (typically part of the Japanese ruleset) prevents repetition of the "last" previous board position; while the superko rule (typically part of Chinese derived rule sets, including those of the AGA and the New Zealand Go Society) prevents repetition of "any" previous position. In both cases, the rule does not however prohibit passing.

The super ko rule is differentiated into situational super ko (SSK, in which the "position" that cannot be recreated includes knowledge of whose turn it is) and positional super ko (PSK, which ignores whose turn it is). Natural situational super ko (NSSK) is a variant in which what matters is not whose turn it is, but who created the position (i. e., who made the last move other than a pass.)

The Ing rules feature a complicated distinction between "fighting" and "disturbing" ko.

Situations other than ko which could lead to an endlessly repeating position are rare enough that many frequent players never encounter them; their treatment depends on what rule set is being used. The simple ko rule generally requires the inclusion of additional rules to handle other undesirable repetitions (e.g. long cycles which can lead to "no result" where the game must be replayed).

The first position below is an example of a "triple ko", taken, with minor changes, from Ikeda Toshio's "On the Rules of Go". [ [http://gobase.org/studying/rules/ikeda/?sec=e2030601] ]

Without a superko rule, this position would lead to an endless cycle, and hence "no result", a draw, or some other outcome determined by the rules.

We now discuss the position using the superko rule. For simplicity, we assume that the last move placed a stone in a position unoccupied since the beginning of the game, and away from the ko. Under positional and situational super ko, Black captures the white group. This is also the case with natural situational super ko if it is Black's turn. If it is White's turn however, then NSSK exhibits odd behavior. White can get a seki by passing, but only at the cost of allowing Black unlimited moves away from the ko. If White insists on saving his group, the final position might look like the second diagram. On the other hand, with the first move (which should be a pass), White wins by two points in the third position using NSSK (assuming area scoring). Black's best response, in terms of maximizing his score, is a pass.

Suicide

Currently most major rule sets forbid playing such that a play results in that player's own stones being removed from the board, however some rule sets (notably, New Zealand derived rules and Ing rules) allow suicide of more than one stone. This hardly ever occurs in real games, but in certain circumstances a suicidal move may threaten the opponent's eye shape, yielding a ko threat.

Compensation

The major rulesets differ in how handicap stones are placed on the board: free placement (Chinese), where stones can be placed anywhere (as if the player's turn repeated); and fixed placement(Japanese), where tradition dictates the stone placement (according to the handicap). Area scoring rules and territory scoring rules also differ in the compensation given for each handicap stone (since each handicap stone would count under area scoring). Komi (compensation for going first) also varies, ranging from several fixed values (commonly 5.5, 6.5, or 7.5) to various "meta-games" to determine a value (notably Auction Komi).

Board sizes

Most Go is played on a 19 × 19 board, but 13 × 13 and 9 × 9 are also popular sizes. Historically other board sizes were commonly used (notably 17 × 17, a predecessor of the 19 × 19 board in ancient China). Go is also sometimes played on various "novelty" sized boards as small as 5 × 5 and larger than 19 × 19. All board sizes have an odd number of lines to ensure that there is a center point, possibly to make mirror go a less attractive strategy. Generally all rules apply to all board sizes, with the exception of handicaps and compensation (whose placement and values vary according to board size).

Issues

In general, there are three closely related issues which have to be addressed by each variation of the rules.

First, how to ensure that the game comes to an end. Players must be able to settle unsettled situations rather than going around in circles. And neither player should be able to drag the game out indefinitely either to avoid losing or to irritate the other player. Possible methods include: the super-ko rule, time control, or placing an upper bound on the number of moves. This is also affected by the scoring method used since territory scoring penalizes extended play after the boundaries of the territories have been settled.

Second, how to decide which player won the game; and should draws (jigo) be allowed. Possible terms to include in the score are: komi, prisoners captured during the game, stones in dead groups on the board at the end of the game, points of territory controlled by a player but not occupied by his stones, his living stones, the number of passes, and the number of disjoint living groups on the board.

Third, how to determine whether a group of stones is alive or dead at the end of the game, and whether protective plays are necessary e.g. connecting a group which would be in atari if all dame were filled. If the players are unable to agree, some rules provide for arbitration using virtual attempts to capture the group. Others allow play to resume until the group is captured or clearly immortal.

Rule sets

There are many official rule sets for playing Go. These vary in significant ways, such as the method used to count the final score, and in very small ways, such as whether the two kinds of "bent four in the corner" positions result in removal of the dead stones automatically at the end of the game or whether the position must be played out, and whether the players must start the game with a fixed number of stones or with an unbounded number.

Rule sets include [http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~wjh/go/rules/Japanese.html Japanese] , [http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~wjh/go/rules/Chinese.html Chinese] , [http://www.usgo.org/resources/downloads/completerules.pdf AGA] (American Go Association), [http://www.usgo.org/resources/downloads/IngRules2006.pdf Ing] , and [http://go.org.nz/index.php?title=Rules_of_the_game New Zealand] .

Further detailed information may be found at the following external links.

Japanese rules

These are rules used in Japan and, with some minor differences, in Korea. They are in wide use throughout the West, sometimes known as "territory" rules. The scoring is based on territory and captured stones. At the end of the game, prisoners are placed in the opponent's territory and players rearrange the board so that territories are easy to count, leaving a visual image resembling the game, which some players find aesthetically pleasing. There is no superko (the triple ko leads to an undecided game.) Suicide is always forbidden. Komi is 6.5.

Disagreements about whether certain groups are alive or dead, and about the counting of territory, are resolved in a notoriously complex manner (see "Counting phase," above).

Japanese rules count vacant points in a seki as neutral, even if they are entirely surrounded by stones of a single color.

World Amateur Go Championship Rules

The rules of the World Amateur Go Championship are based on the Japanese rules, with some differences. [ [http://home.snafu.de/jasiek/rules.html] ] These rules are sanctioned by the International Go Federation.

Chinese rules

This is the other major set of rules in widespread use, also known as "area" rules. At the end, one player (usually Black) fills in all of his/her captured territory, and the other (White) stones are removed from the board. Prisoners do not count. Black stones are then arranged in groups of ten -- eighteen such groups, plus half the komi, plus at least one additional stone = victory for Black. So for example with a komidashi of 7.5 points, under Chinese rules Black needs at least 185 stones on the board at the end to win. Komidashi is usually 7.5 points.

In the Chinese rules, there is no penalty for playing within one's territory at the end of the game, for example to kill and remove dead enemy groups. Thus passing to signal that one believes that there are no more useful moves may be conceived as simply being a convenient device to accelerate the end of the game - assuming one is not mistaken. The result will always be the same as if the game had been played out entirely.

The fact that disagreements can be resolved by playing on means that Chinese-style rules can be implemented easily without the need for the rules to define what is meant by "living" and "dead" groups.

World Mind Sports Games Rules

The rules of the First World Mind Sports Games, to be held in Beijing in October 2008, are based on the Chinese rules, but are simpler than they are, and also represent a compromise with the Japanese and Korean rules. [ [http://www.usgo.org/resources/downloads/2008IGFrpt.pdf AGA report on IGF conference] ] [ [http://www.intergofed.org/wmsg/wmsg_members_documents.html International Go Federation webpage on the WMSG] ] These rules are sanctioned by the International Go Federation.

These rules use area scoring, and have a komi of 6.5. Black has one further point deducted in the event that White was the first player to pass in the game. This last feature is a compromise with Japanese and Korean rules in that it is similar, in terms of its strategic consequences, to territory scoring. Unlike the Chinese rules, this rule will generally impose a penalty for an additional move at the end of the game within one's territory. In particular, the result of the game may differ by up to a point from what it would have been had both players played it out.

The game normally ends after two consecutive passes, but in the event of disagreement about the score, play resumes in the original order. Once this resumption has occurred, then when two consecutive passes do eventually occur again, play stops and all stones left on the board are deemed alive. Thus after a single disagreement, the players are required to play the game out entirely. (By this point in the game, there is no longer any penalty for making "useless" plays within one's territory to kill dead enemy groups, since the one-point advantage for passing first has already been attributed to one player or the other by the first set of consecutive passes.)

Suicide is forbidden in these rules. Unlike the Chinese rules, the WMSG rules apply superko (specifically, positional superko).

AGA rules

These are used by the American Go Association and the Federation Francaise de Go. Some special rules (like giving the opponent a prisoner when passing) are added, which make the area scoring and territory scoring equal.

The British Go Association adopted the AGA rules, with some minor departures, in April 2008. [ [http://www.britgo.org/rules/aga] ]

Ing rules

The scoring is basically the same as area scoring, but is done with a special technique involving "Ing bowls". Both players must start with exactly 180 stones; the Ing Foundation makes special bowls that allow players to count their stones easily. Prisoners come back to the owner. After the game finishes, both players fill their empty territory with their stones. The one that gets rid of all of them is the winner. White pays Black eight points (komi) by placing four white stones in Black's territory at the beginning of the counting phase. As Black wins ties it is 7.5 in effect. The ko rule makes a distinction between "fighting" and "disturbing" ko. Multi-stone suicide is allowed. This ruleset was invented and promoted by Ing Chang-ki.

Differences

In most cases the differences between the rule sets are negligible. The choice of rule set rarely results in a difference in score of more than one point, and the strategy and tactics of the game are mostly unaffected by the rule set used.

References

See also

*Go (board game)
*Go concepts
*Go strategy and tactics

External links

;Rules comparisons
* [http://senseis.xmp.net/?RulesOfGo A listing of rules pages]
* [http://www.usgo.org/resources/internet.asp#Rules Another listing of rules pages]
* [http://www.britgo.org/rules/compare.html Comparison of some go rules] summarized in a table
* [http://home.snafu.de/jasiek/rules.html Go (Weiqi, Baduk) rules]
* [http://wwwhomes.uni-bielefeld.de/achim/go_rule_philo.html Go rule dialects]

;Specific rule sets
* [http://www.usgo.org/resources/downloads/completerules.pdf Official American Go Association rules]
* [http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~wjh/go/rules/Japanese.html Official Japanese rules as amended in 1989]
* [http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~wjh/go/rules/Chinese.html Official Chinese rules]
* [http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~wjh/go/rules/SST.html Ing's SST laws of Goe]
* [http://www.cwi.nl/~tromp/go.html "Logical" rules] (Tromp-Taylor ruleset)
* [http://www.brooklyngoclub.org/jc/rulesgo.html "Mathematical Rules"] of Go by Jean-Claude Chetrit
* [http://home.snafu.de/jasiek/simple.html "Simple" rules]
* [http://www.usgo.org/resources/internet.html#Rules A collection of essays] assessing and comparing the various rule sets
* [http://gobase.org/studying/rules/ikeda/?sec=e_rules Ikeda's rule sets for Go]


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • rules — index code, mode, protocol (etiquette) Burton s Legal Thesaurus. William C. Burton. 2006 …   Law dictionary

  • Rules — Filmdaten Deutscher Titel Rules – Sekunden Der Entscheidung Originaltitel Rules of Engagement …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Rules — (as used in expressions) Australian Rules football Kirchhoff s circuit rules rules of order Queensberry rules * * * …   Universalium

  • Rules — The Certificate of Incorporation, By Laws, rules, interpretations, orders, resolutions and similar directives of the exchange and CME, if applicable. The trading of all futures and options on futures contracts in the market operated by the… …   Financial and business terms

  • Rules — /rulz/ (say roohlz) noun Colloquial → Australian Rules …   Australian English dictionary

  • rules — taisyklės statusas T sritis automatika atitikmenys: angl. laws; rules vok. Regeln, f rus. правила, n pranc. règlement, m; règles, f …   Automatikos terminų žodynas

  • rules — reglamentas statusas T sritis Standartizacija ir metrologija apibrėžtis Technologinio proceso techninių dokumentų rinkinys. atitikmenys: angl. order; regulations; rules vok. Ordnung, f; Regeln, f; Vollzugsordnung, f rus. регламент, m pranc.… …   Penkiakalbis aiškinamasis metrologijos terminų žodynas

  • rules — reglamentas statusas T sritis chemija apibrėžtis Technologinio proceso techninių dokumentų rinkinys. atitikmenys: angl. order; regulations; rules rus. регламент …   Chemijos terminų aiškinamasis žodynas

  • rules — taisyklė statusas T sritis Kūno kultūra ir sportas apibrėžtis Norma, labai tvirtais loginiais argumentais ir faktiniais įrodymais pagrįstas teiginys, kuriuo negalima abejoti neturint naujų duomenų, įrodymų. atitikmenys: angl. rule; rules vok.… …   Sporto terminų žodynas

  • rules — taisyklė statusas T sritis Kūno kultūra ir sportas apibrėžtis Visuma instrukcijų, teisių, pareigų, draudimų, nustatančių sportininko, trenerio, kitų sportinės kovos (varžybų) dalyvių statusą, varžybų erdvę, įrangą, įrankius. atitikmenys: angl.… …   Sporto terminų žodynas


Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.