R v Smith (Thomas Joseph)

R v Smith (Thomas Joseph)

R. v. Smith (Thomas Joseph) [1959] 2 QB 35, [1959] A.C. is an English criminal law case, dealing with causation and homicide. The court ruled that negligence of medical staff does not break the chain of causation in murder cases

The victim was stabbed, but the attending doctor did not realise the full extent of his injuries, causing death.

The court said that the stabbing was still the 'operating' cause of death, and therefore the defendant is guilty.

Case Brief

Facts: Smith stabbed the victim who died 2 hours later; Smith had dropped the stab victim on the way to the hospital to get treatment. Once in emergency care, there was no blood transfusion. The victim was given saline solution (which, medically, is a gross error), and used artificial respiration - not knowing that the victim was suffering from a pierced lung). It was stated that with proper treatment, chances of the victim's survival was about 75%.

Issue: Did Smith cause the death of the stab victim?

Defence: argued that death was not the sole and natural consequence of wound, and hence, did not flow directly from it.

Court: "Essence of causation test" – is that if at the time of death, the wound is still an operating and substantial cause, then death is caused by the wound, even though another operating cause may be present. This is often referred to as the chain of causation. If the original wound is merely a setting in which another cause operates, then it cannot be said that death resulted from the stab wound. Is the second cause so overwhelming so as to make the first wound merely part of the history?

One question to ask is: Can you show a new cause which disturbs the sequence of events?

Held: The Court looked to particular facts of the case, and Smith was convicted, as he satisfied the "Essence of causation test". If the stabbed soldier had received proper treatment while in emergency care, he would have had a good chance of a complete recovery. Smith was consequently convicted of manslaughter because the wound was in fact the “operating and substantial cause of death”. Third party's inadvertent contribution was a major factor of this decision. However, later on in the contraversial case of R v James, the Court of Appeal held that the privy Council's decision on provocation as a partial defence to murder in R v Holley effectively overruled the earlier decision of the House of Lords in R v Smith. The Privy Council in exceptional circumstances overrule previous precedents of The House of Lords.

ee also

R v Cheshire (1991)


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем сделать НИР

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Thomas Joseph Meskill — 82nd Governor of Connecticut In office January 6, 1971 – January 8, 1975 Lieutenant T. Clark Hull Peter L. Cashman Preceded by John N. Dempsey …   Wikipedia

  • Thomas Joseph Meskill — (* 30. Januar 1928 in New Britain, Connecticut; † 29. Oktober 2007 in Delray Beach, Florida) war ein US amerikanischer Jurist und Politiker (Republikanische Partei). Er war Gouverneur des Bunde …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Thomas Joseph Kelly — Horseracing personalities infobox name = Tommy Kelly caption = occupation = Trainer birthplace = Baltimore, Maryland, United States birth date = September 19, 1919 death date = career wins = Not found race = Arlington Classic (1961, 1972) Saranac …   Wikipedia

  • Joseph Smith, Jr. — Joseph Smith, Jr. (December 23, 1805 – June 27, 1844) was the founder of the Latter Day Saint movement, also known as Mormonism, and an important religious and political figure in the United States during the 1830s and 1840s. In 1827, Smith began …   Wikipedia

  • Joseph Smith, Jr — Joseph Smith Pour les articles homonymes, voir Joseph Smith (homonymie). Joseph Smith Joseph Smith, fils (23 décembre  …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Joseph Smith, Jr. — Joseph Smith Pour les articles homonymes, voir Joseph Smith (homonymie). Joseph Smith Joseph Smith, fils (23 décembre  …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Joseph Smith Jr — Joseph Smith Pour les articles homonymes, voir Joseph Smith (homonymie). Joseph Smith Joseph Smith, fils (23 décembre  …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Joseph Smith (hijo) — Joseph Smith, Jr. Nacimiento …   Wikipedia Español

  • Joseph Wright of Derby — Autoportrait 1780 Naissance 3 septembre 1734 …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Thomas et Ann Borrow — Thomas Borrow, 1762 3 …   Wikipédia en Français

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”