Pre-Greek substrate
- Pre-Greek substrate
The term Pre-Greek substrate refers to an unknown language that is conjectured to have been spoken in prehistoric Greece before the settlement of Greek-speakers in the area. It is believed by some linguists that Greek took over a large number of words and proper names from such a language (its substrate), because a large proportion of the vocabulary of Greek does not have demonstrable Indo-European roots.
Non-Indo-European words
Including the following:
# Terms of insult and pejorative vocabulary
# Maritime terms, words for the sea, shipping (e.g. θάλασσα (thálassa), "sea")
# Words relating to Mediterranean agriculture, (e.g. elaia, "olive" etc.)
# Words regarding rulers, given by the populace (e.g. Tyrannos)
# Building technology (e.g. pyrgos "tower"
# Words relating to Non-Indo-European divinities (e.g. Athena)
# Placenames (e.g. Athens; those placenames that include -inth-: Corinth (Korinthos), Zacinthos (Zakynthos); those placenames that include -ss-: Knossos (Knossos), Halicarnassus (Halikarnassos), and Parnassus (Parnassos); and those placenames that include -tt-: Atticaubstratum theories
Various explanations have been put forward to explain these substrate features. All have weaknesses. Some of these explanations include:
Luwian substratum
A
Luwian substratum was proposed by Leonard Palmer and others, on the basis of -ss- placenames being widespread in Western Anatolia, and of the widespread Anatolian presence of "Grey Minyan Ware" formerly associated with the coming of the Greeks.:Counterargument 1. - there is nothing to prevent the Grey Minyan incursions into Anatolia being of pre-Greek speaking Indo-Europeans. The Greek language shows close affinities to Armenian, and these Anatolian people may have been speakers of a proto-Armenian tongue.:Counterargument 2. - It may be that the -ss- and -inth- presence in Luwian language placenames may be due to the substrate languages of this area, with both the Aegean and West Anatolian people speaking related languages (this is the view ofJames Mellaart ).Tyrrhenian substratum
On the basis of statements in
Thucydides that Tyrrhenian was a former language of Athens and that the Tyrrhenians had been expelled toLemnos , it has been suggested that the substrate language was related to Lemnian, and thus by association to Etruscan.:Counterargument 1: There is nothing historically to suggest that Tyrrhenian was more widespread in the Aegean than the northeast and adjacent areas ofAsia Minor . :Counterargument 2: Nothing in Greek substrate terminology seems similar to the reconstructed vocabularies for Etruscan.Minoan substratum
The existence of a
Minoan (Eteocretan ) substratum is the view ofArthur Evans who assumed widespread Minoan colonisation of the Aegean, policed by a Minoanthalassocracy .:Counterargument 1: Theories of a Minoan "thalassocracy" have in modern times been dismissed as the product of a late Victorian fantasy of an earlier civilisation which like Britain "ruled the waves".:Counterargument 2: Archaeologically, the Cretan civilisation seems to have been a development of the island of Crete, having only indirect cultural impacts upon either theCyclades or earlyHelladic cultures, which seem to have developed independently of MinoanCrete .Pelasgian substratum
Suggests that there was an indigenous non-Indo-European "
Pelasgian " language in the Aegean area before the emergence of the Indo-European Proto-Greeks.:Counterargument: The word Pelasgian has been used in a variety of ways by both ancient and modern writers to mean different things.Egyptian-Semitic substratum
Martin Bernal suggests, based on theargument s of his book "Black Athena " that the substratum languages for the pre-Greek language of the Aegean was a mixture of Egyptian andSemitic languages.:Counter argument 1: Whilst modern scholars are taking greater account of the Egyptian and Semitic influence upon Greek civilisation, they reject Bernal's use of "mass comparisons" based upon random phonetic similarities.:Counter argument 2: Concrete evidence of a mass transfer of population from Egypt or the Levant before 2,000 BCE is absent, which puts a great burden of proof upon Bernal's thesis.References
*Alfred Heubeck, "Praegraeca: sprachliche Untersuchungen zum vorgriechisch-indogermanischen Substrat", Erlangen (1961); review: A. J. Beattie, The Classical Review (1963).
ee also
*
Proto-Greek language
*Substratum in Vedic Sanskrit
*Tyrrhenian languages
*Eteocretan
*Eteocypriot
Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.
Look at other dictionaries:
Pre-Indo-European — may refer to various languages or linguistic hypotheses depending on the context: *pre Proto Indo European: for internal reconstruction aiming at the recovery of a stage earlier than the Proto Indo European language *Old European culture: for pre … Wikipedia
Germanic substrate hypothesis — The Germanic substrate hypothesis is an attempt to explain the distinctive nature of the Germanic languages within the context of the Indo European language family. It postulates that the elements of the common Germanic vocabulary and syntactical … Wikipedia
Modern Greek phonology — For assistance with IPA transcriptions of Greek for Wikipedia articles, see WP:IPA for Greek. This page presents a sketch of the phonology of Standard Modern Greek. Contents 1 Consonants 1.1 Phonetic realisation 1.2 Sandhi rules … Wikipedia
Ancient Greek philosophy — Raphael s School of Athens, depicting an array of ancient Greek philosophers engaged in discussion. Ancient Greek philosophy arose in the 6th century BCE and continued through the Hellenistic period, at which point Ancient Greece was incorporated … Wikipedia
Cretan Greek — History of the Greek language (see also: Greek alphabet) Proto Greek (c. 3000–1600 BC) Mycenaean (c. 1600–1100 BC) Ancient G … Wikipedia
Chalkidiki Greek — History of the Greek language (see also: Greek alphabet) Proto Greek (c. 3000–1600 BC) Mycenaean (c. 1600–1100 BC) Ancient … Wikipedia
Demotic Greek — Not to be confused with Demotic (Egyptian). History of the Greek language (see also: Greek alphabet) Proto Greek (c. 3000–1600 BC) Mycenaean … Wikipedia
Mycenaean Greek — This article is about Achaean Greek. For the later dialect used in Achaea and the Peloponnese, see Achaean Doric Greek. Mycenaean Greek Spoken in southern Balkans/Crete Extinct 12th century BC Language family … Wikipedia
English words of Greek origin — The Greek language has contributed to the English vocabulary in three ways: #directly as an immediate donor, #indirectly through other intermediate language(s), as an original donor (mainly through Latin and French), and #with modern coinages or… … Wikipedia
Proto-Greek language — The Proto Greek language is the assumed last common ancestor of all known varieties of Greek, including Mycenaean, the classical Greek dialects (Attic Ionic, Aeolic, Doric and Northwest Greek), and ultimately Koine, Byzantine and modern Greek.… … Wikipedia