Nelson's Pillar

Nelson's Pillar

Nelson's Pillar ca 1830

The Nelson Pillar (Irish: Colún Nelson), known locally as Nelson's Pillar or simply The Pillar, was a large granite pillar topped by a statue of Horatio Nelson in the middle of O'Connell Street, Dublin. It was built in 1808 and destroyed by a bomb planted by Irish republicans in 1966.^[1]

Description

The pillar was a Doric column that rose 121 feet (36.9 m) from the ground and was topped by a 13 feet (4.0 m) tall statue in Portland stone by Cork sculptor Thomas Kirk, RHA (1781–1845), giving it a total height of 134 feet (40.8 m) – some 35 feet (10.7 m) shorter than Nelson's Column in London. The diameter of the column was 13 feet (4.0 m) at the bottom and 10 feet (3.0 m) at the top.^[2]

All the outer and visible parts of the pillar were of granite, from the quarry of Gold Hill, Kilbride, County Wicklow. The interior was of black limestone.^[2] A contemporary account of the pillar described it in the following terms:

"In Sackville Street is a very noble monument to the memory of the immortal Nelson: it consists of a pedestal, column, and capital of the Tuscan order, the whole being surmounted by a well executed statue of the hero, leaning on the capstan of his ship."^[3]

History

The Lord Mayor of Dublin, James Vance, is credited with first coming up with the idea of honouring Lord Nelson and the Battle of Trafalgar with a monument, in 1805. After consultation with the British Lord Lieutenant of Ireland, the Duke of Richmond, a meeting with leading citizens was held and a committee of 21 duly appointed, containing, as well as the Mayor, John La Touche, M.P., Robert Shaw, M.P., Hans Hamilton, M.P., Arthur Guinness, and the Chief Secretary, Charles Long. A subscription was opened, with the banks leading the way in forwarding funds. However, it took over two years for the finances to get close to the projected budget of over £5,000.^[4]

The original plans for the Pillar were submitted to the organising committee by William Wilkins (1778–1839), a London architect, Fellow of Caius College, Cambridge, and accepted by them in 1808. However, for some reason, the committee wrote later that they were incapable of "executing his design precisely as he had given it." Francis Johnston (1760–1829), the architect who built the General Post Office (to the left in the picture above) was brought in to execute the design, and "afforded the necessary assistance with his acknowledged ability, which...he did with the utmost cheerfulness."^[5] He made several drawings of his own, one of which met the approval of the committee sufficiently for construction to start.^[6] Johnston and later architects laid out Sackville Street (now O'Connell Street) so that the buildings, the GPO, and the Pillar were in scale to the size and length of the street and to each other.^[7]

Construction of the Pillar was started with the laying of the foundation stone on 15 February 1808. It was inaugurated with a procession of dignitaries including the Fellows and Provost of Trinity College and the Lord Lieutenant and his wife.^[8] Notably, the Pillar was finished long before the similar Nelson's Column was erected in Trafalgar Square in London in 1849. The pillar became both a tram terminus and a common meeting place for Dubliners and offered the city's best public viewing platform, reached by a spiral stairway inside the column.^[2] The original entrance to the pillar was underground but, G. P. Baxter designed a porch in 1894 which was added to allow direct access from the street. The adult public paid sixpence (children under 12 were half-price) to climb the 168 spiral steps to a platform which gave a bird's-eye view of the city.^[9]

Criticism

Nelson's Pillar's viewing platform afforded views over Dublin, as this 1964 photograph of O'Connell Street attests.

The building of Nelson's Pillar had been, from the outset, controversial. As early as September 1809 a paragraph appeared in Watty Cox's Irish Magazine, stating: "The statue of Nelson records the glory of a mistress and the transformation of our state into a discount office".^[10] Until 1922 most of the criticisms were due to aesthetic considerations or because it was considered an impediment to traffic. In May 1876 a letter to the editor expressed its author's feelings in verse:

“

In the centre of our city Where the lines of traffic meet - In the very path of commerce, Blocking up a noble street - As a figure in a picture Disproportionately tall Seems to make its right surroundings Quite ridiculously small.[11]

”

In 1876 Dublin Corporation took up the question of removal, but found it did not have the power to remove it. In 1879 the Corporation argued that it should be removed as it was "an ugly traffic hazard".^[12] It tried again in 1891, causing much debate in the city and in Parliament, but did not succeed due to financial considerations. A writer on Dublin's history in 1909, Dillon Cosgrave, acknowledged the temporary nature of the Pillar, remarking that "For a very long time, the project of removing the Pillar, which many condemn as an obstruction to traffic, has been mooted, but it has never taken definite shape".^[13]

In 1923, the debate was renewed when famous Irish poet William Butler Yeats called for the pillar to be removed on aesthetic grounds, saying "It's not a beautiful object". The debate was renewed again in 1926 and again in 1928. Several attempts were made subsequently to have it removed, including by Taoiseach Seán Lemass, in 1960. He said "[Nelson] has no place in the centre of our capital city overshadowing our principal national monument, which is the GPO".^[12] There were proposals to keep the pillar but to replace the statue of Nelson with other statues.

On 7 April 1954, the Dublin Brigade Irish Republican Army (IRA) sent a letter to Dublin Corporation, asking that it "seek legislation for the removal of the Nelson Pillar".^[12]

Politician and former SIPTU president Des Geraghty argued that, by the 1960s, "not many people wanted Nelson there...he was a relic of the Empire".^[12] Independent Dublin TD Frank Sherwin said: "Although I view Nelson as a great Englishman ... I hold that there should be a great historic Irishman put in his place".^[12]

1955 attack

On 29 October 1955, a group of nine University College Dublin students locked themselves inside the pillar and tried to melt the statue with flamethrowers. From the top they hung a poster of Kevin Barry—a Dublin Irish Republican Army (IRA) volunteer who was executed by the British during the Irish War of Independence. A crowd gathered below and began to sing the well-known Irish rebel song "Kevin Barry". Gardaí forced their way inside with sledgehammers. They took the students' names and addresses and brought them downstairs. As a Garda van arrived it was attacked by the sympathetic crowd. Rather than arrest the students, the Gardaí merely confiscated their equipment and told everyone to leave quietly. None were ever charged.^[12]

Destruction

Nelson's Pillar after being destroyed

At 02:00 on 8 March 1966, a group of former Irish Republican Army (IRA) volunteers, including Joe Christle,^[14] planted a bomb that destroyed the upper half of the pillar, throwing the statue of Nelson into the street and causing large chunks of stone to be thrown around. Christle, dismissed ten years earlier from the IRA for unauthorised actions, was a qualified barrister and saw himself as a socialist revolutionary. It is thought that the bombers acted when they did to commemorate the 50th anniversary of the Easter Rising.

No one was hurt by the explosion. The closest bystander was a 19-year-old taxi driver, Steve Maughan, whose taxi was blasted to pieces.

Six days after the original damage, on the morning of Monday 14 March 1966, Irish Army engineers blew up the rest of the pillar after judging the vestigial structure to be too unsafe to restore. This planned demolition caused more destruction on O'Connell Street than the original blast, breaking many windows.^[15]

The rubble from the monument was taken to the East Wall dump and the lettering from the plinth moved to the gardens of Butler House, Kilkenny.

Ken Dolan and six other students^[9] from the National College of Art and Design stole the statue's head on St. Patrick's Day from a storage shed in Clanbrassil Street as a fund-raising prank to pay off a Student Union's debt. They leased the head for £200 a month to an antiques dealer in London for his shop window. It also appeared in a women's stocking commercial, shot on Killiney beach, and on the stage of the Olympia Theatre with The Dubliners. The students finally gave the head to the Lady Nelson of the day about six months after taking it, and it was later housed in the Civic Museum in Dublin. It now resides in the Gilbert Library, in Pearse Street.

The Nelson's Pillar Act was passed in 1969,^[16][17] transferring responsibility for the site of the monument from the Nelson Pillar Trustees to Dublin Corporation. The site was simply paved over by the authorities until the Spire of Dublin was erected there in 2003. In 2001, whilst the site was being excavated to prepare for the foundations of the spire, The Irish Times announced the discovery of a 200-year-old time capsule.^[18] This, in fact, turned out to be a dedication plaque commemorating Nelson's achievements.^[19]

On 23 April 2000, Liam Sutcliff, from the suburb of Walkinston, claimed^[20] on the RTÉ radio programme Voices of the 20th Century that he was responsible for blowing up the monument. Sutcliffe is a republican supporter who has been linked in the past to the Official Sinn Féin movement. He maintained that in Operation Humpty Dumpty, the explosive used was a mixture of gelignite and ammonal. He declined to confirm his remarks when he received a visit at home from Garda Special Branch detectives four months after his radio interview in August. Then, on the morning of 21 September, he was arrested under Section 30 of the Offences Against the State Act and invited to repeat his allegations at Store Street Garda Station. His reluctance to do so, while in custody, resulted in his release without charge that night. The Gardaí prepared a file for review by the Director of Public Prosecutions to decide if the matter should be pursued further.

The identity of the bombers has been a source of speculation and conflicting claims of responsibility.

Songs about the explosion

Within a matter of days of the blowing up of the pillar, a group of Belfast school teachers: Gerry Burns, Finbar Carrolan, John Sullivan and Eamonn McGirr, known as The Go Lucky Four, reached the top of the Irish music charts with "Up Went Nelson", a popular folk song set to the tune of "The Battle Hymn of the Republic" which maintained the number one spot for eight consecutive weeks.

Other songs were:

• "Good Lord Nelson" by Tommy Makem
• "Nelson's Goodbye" by Joe Dolan, released as "Nelson's Farewell" by The Dubliners on their album Finnegan Wakes and as a single "Nelson's Farewell / The Foggy Dew", both in 1966

See also

• Dublin statues and their nicknames
• Nelson's Column, Montreal
• Nelson Monument, Edinburgh
• Britannia Monument

References

1. ^ Craig, Maurice (1969). Dublin 1660–1860. Dublin: Allen Figgis. p. 287. 
2. ^ ^{a b c} Henchy, Patrick (1949). Nelson's Pillar. Dublin Historical Record, Volume X, no. 2. p. 57. 
3. ^ An Accurate Observer, "Reminiscences of Half a Century", published in London(1838).
4. ^ Henchy, Patrick (1949). Nelson's Pillar. Dublin Historical Record, Volume X, no. 2. p. 54. 
5. ^ Henchy, Patrick (1949). Nelson's Pillar. Dublin Historical Record, Volume X, no. 2. p. 58. 
6. ^ Johnston Robb, Colin (1946). The Irish Builder (trade journal). Dublin: Irish Builder. 
7. ^ Peter, A. (1927). Dublin Fragments: Social and Historic. Dublin: Hodges Figgis & Co.. pp. 39–44. 
8. ^ Somerville-Large, Peter (1988). Dublin, the first thousand years. Belfast: Appletree Press. p. 221. 
9. ^ ^{a b} Nelson's Pillar – Irish Independent, 12 March 2006.
10. ^ Henchy, Patrick (1949). Nelson's Pillar. Dublin Historical Record, Volume X, no. 2. pp. 59–60. 
11. ^ Henchy, Patrick (1949). Nelson's Pillar. Dublin Historical Record, Volume X, no. 2. p. 60. 
12. ^ ^{a b c d e f} Nelson's Pillar: The day they blew it up. Raidió Teilifís Éireann (RTÉ), 2010.
13. ^ Henchy, Patrick (1949). Nelson's Pillar. Dublin Historical Record, Volume X, no. 2. p. 55. 
14. ^ Armed Struggle: The History of the IRA – Richard English, Oxford University Press, 2003 ISBN 0-19-516605-1
15. ^ Hopkins, Frank (2002). Rare Old Dublin. Dublin: Marino Books. p. 65. ISBN 1860231500. 
16. ^ [1] The Nelson Pillar Bill
17. ^ [2] Dáil debate on Nelson Pillar Bill, 1969: Second and Subsequent Stages
18. ^ Curiosity surrounds untimely find of capsule at Nelson's Pillar site – The Irish Times, 4 October 2001.
19. ^ Dedication Plaque Dedication plaque found in the foundation stone of Nelson's Pillar, O'Connell Street, Dublin – Margaret Gowen & Co Ltd., 4 October 2001.
20. ^ Irish Independent, 22 September 2000

Coordinates: 53°20′59″N 6°15′37″W / 53.34972°N 6.26028°W / 53.34972; -6.26028

External links

• RTÉ – Scannal – Nelson's Pillar: The Day They Blew It Up