Equitable remedy

Equitable remedy

In law, equitable remedies are the remedies developed and granted by the old courts of equity, such as the Court of Chancery in England, and still available today in common law jurisdictions. [See generally, Meagher and Gummow, "Equity, Doctrines and Remedies", 3rd ed.] Equity is said to operate on the conscience of the defendant, so an equitable remedy is always directed at a particular person, and his knowledge, state of mind and motives may be relevant to whether a remedy should be granted or not.

Equitable remedies are distinguished from "legal" remedies (which are available to a successful claimant as of right) by the discretion of the court to grant them. In common law jurisdictions, there are a variety of equitable remedies, but the principal remedies are:
# injunction [In English law, see generally "American Cyanimid Co v Ethicon" [1975] AC 396]
# specific performance
# Account of profits
# rescission
# rectification
# estoppel
# certain proprietary remedies, such as constructive trusts or tracing [See generally, Oakley, "Constructive Trusts", 2nd ed.]
# subrogation
# in very specific circumstances, an equitable lien

The two main equitable remedies are injunctions and specific performance, and in casual legal parlance references to equitable remedies are often expressed as referring to those two remedies alone. Injunctions may be mandatory (requiring a person to do something) or prohibitory (stopping them doing something). Specific performance requires a party to perform a contract, for example by transferring a piece of land to the claimant.

An account of profits is usually ordered where payment of damages would still leave the wrongdoer unjustly enriched at the expense of the wronged party. However, orders for an account are not normally available as of right, and only arise in certain circumstances. [Goff & Jones, "The Law of Restitution", 4th ed.]

Rescission and rectification are remedies in relation to contracts (or, exceptionally, deeds) which may become available.

Constructive trusts and tracing remedies are usually used where the claimant asserts that property has been wrongly appropriated from them, and then either (i) the property has increased in value, and thus they should have an interest in the increase in value which occurred at their expense, or (ii) the property has been transferred by the wrongdoer to an innocent third party, and the original owner should be able to claim a right to the property as against the innocent third party.

Equitable liens normally only arise in very specific factual circumstances, such as unpaid vendor's lien.

Equitable principles can also limit the granting of equitable remedies. This includes "he who comes to equity must come with clean hands" (ie the court will not assist a claimant who is himself in the wrong or acting for improper motives), laches (equitable remedies will not be granted if the claimant has delayed unduly in seeking them), "equity will not assist a volunteer" (meaning that a person cannot litigate against a settlor without providing the appropriate consideration e.g. Money) and that equitable remedies will not normally be granted where damages would be an adequate remedy. The most important limitation relating to equitable remedies is that an equitable remedy will not lie against a bona fide purchaser for value without notice.

Interestingly, damages can also be awarded in "equity" as opposed to "at law", ["Mcgregor on Damages", 17th rev ed.] and in some legal systems, by historical accident, interest on damages can be awarded on a compound basis only on equitable damages, but not on damages awarded at law. ["Westdeutsche v Islington BC" [1996] AC 669] However, most jurisdictions either have ended this anachronism, or evinced an intention to do so, by modernising legislation.

See also

* Equity (law)
* Legal remedy

Footnotes


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем решить контрольную работу

Look at other dictionaries:

  • equitable remedy — Court ordered action that directs parties to do or not to do something; such remedies include injunctive relief and specific performance. Alternatively, a non monetary remedy, such as an injunction or specific performance, obtained when a legal… …   Law dictionary

  • equitable remedy — solution according to equity laws …   English contemporary dictionary

  • equitable — eq·ui·ta·ble / e kwi tə bəl/ adj 1: having or exhibiting equity: dealing fairly and equally shall allocate...appropriations in an equitable manner U.S. Code 2: existing or valid in equity or as a matter of equity as distinguished from law an… …   Law dictionary

  • remedy — rem·e·dy 1 n pl dies: the means to enforce a right or to prevent or obtain redress for a wrong: the relief (as damages, restitution, specific performance, or an injunction) that may be given or ordered by a court or other tribunal for a wrong if… …   Law dictionary

  • Equitable — Companies*Scottish Equitable, is an investment company located in Edinburgh *Equitable PCI Bank *Equitable Resos *The Equitable Life Assurance Society, life insurance company in the United Kingdom *AXA Equitable Life Insurance Company, formerly… …   Wikipedia

  • equitable easements — A term frequently applied to covenants running with the land. Werner v Graham, 181 Cal 174, 183 P 945. Restrictive covenants as to the use of land or the location or character of buildings or other structures thereon are primary examples. 20 Am… …   Ballentine's law dictionary

  • Equitable interest — An equitable interest is an interest held by virtue of an equitable title (a title that indicates a beneficial interest in property and that gives the holder the right to acquire formal legal title) or claimed on equitable grounds, such as the… …   Wikipedia

  • remedy — The means by which a right is enforced or the violation of a right is prevented, redressed, or compensated. Long Leaf Lumber, Inc. v. Svolos, La.App., 258 So.2d 121, 124. The means employed to enforce a right or redress an injury, as… …   Black's law dictionary

  • equitable action — One seeking an equitable remedy or relief; though in the federal and most state courts, with the procedural merger of law and equity, there is now procedurally only one type of action a civil action. Fed.R. Civil P. 2 …   Black's law dictionary

  • equitable action — One seeking an equitable remedy or relief; though in the federal and most state courts, with the procedural merger of law and equity, there is now procedurally only one type of action a civil action. Fed.R. Civil P. 2 …   Black's law dictionary

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
… Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”